|
Crystal International Group Limited is an apparel manufacturing company founded in 1970. The company produces lifestyle wear, denim, intimate apparel, sweaters, sportswear, and outdoor apparel. It operates self-managed manufacturing facilities across five countries and serves global apparel brands through a co-creation business model. The group includes the subsidiary Crystal SL Global Pte. Ltd. and partners with Schneider Electric for renewable energy and energy efficiency initiatives. Summarised from the company's own disclosures, fiscal year ended Apr 2026 |
Industry Apparel Manufacturing | Homepage crystalgroup.com |
| Sector Consumer Cyclical | IR page ir.crystalgroup.com/en/global/home.php | |
|
Tags
apparel manufacturing, denim, sportswear, outdoor apparel, sweaters, intimate apparel, lifestyle wear, co-creation model, contract manufacturing, Crystal SL Global Pte. Ltd.
|
Press page crystalgroup.com/news |
Metrics
| Valuation | |
|---|---|
| Market cap | HK$ 23B |
| Market cap (USD) | $ 2.931B |
| P/E | 13.13 |
| PEG | 1.45 |
| P/BV | 1.79 |
| P/S | 1.19 |
| P/OCF | 10.72 |
| P/FCF | — |
| Dividend yield | 5.3% |
| Turnover / mcap | 0.08% |
| Returns | |
|---|---|
| ROE | 14.3% |
| ROI | 13.9% |
| ROIC | 13.9% |
| Profit margin | — |
| Growth | |
|---|---|
| Revenue growing | No |
| Profits growing | Yes |
| Revenue up 3y | No |
| Revenue up 5y | No |
| Earnings growth 3y (net profit CAGR) | 9.1% |
| Quality | |
|---|---|
| Profitable | Yes |
| Margin expanding | Yes |
| Buying back stock | No |
| Diluting (TTM) | No |
| Debt/Equity | 1.1% |
| Podcast bulls (TTM) | Sign up |
| Podcast bears (TTM) | Sign up |
| Podcast sentiment (TTM) | Sign up |
| Podcast sentiment % (TTM) | Sign up |
| News sentiment (TTM) | 0 |
| Quality score | 6.3% |
| Insiders | |
|---|---|
| Buys, 1w | Sign up |
| Buys, 1m | Sign up |
| Buys, 1y | Sign up |
| Sells, 1w | Sign up |
| Sells, 1m | Sign up |
| Sells, 1y | Sign up |
Podcast Mentions
Announcements and reports published on HKEXnews, newest first, monthly and next-day returns, proxy forms and board-meeting notices included. The link opens the announcement on HKEXnews. Press releases from the company's own website, newest first.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Contents
2 4 6
About This Sustainability Report
CEO Message
About Crystal International
10
Our Sustainability Vision and Approach
14
Stakeholder Engagement
18
Regenerating Nature
44
Driving Innovative Manufacturing
52
Product Responsibility
56
Supply Chain Management
62
Resourcing People
80
Revitalising Community
82
Awards and Recognition
85
Glossary
88
Content Index for ESG Reporting Code and Reference Standards
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
01
About This Sustainability Report This Sustainability Report 2025 (the “Report”) has been prepared in full compliance with the Environmental, Social and Governance (“ESG”) Reporting Code set out in Appendix C2 to the Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (the “Stock Exchange”), and with reference to the Global Reporting Initiative (“GRI”) Standards and the International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”) S1 General Requirements for Disclosure of Sustainability-related Financial Information and S2 Climate-related Disclosures issued by the International Sustainability Standards Board (“ISSB”), to align our reporting with globally recognised frameworks.
I would like to express my heartfelt appreciation for the tremendous support of our top management, whose confidence in our sustainability efforts continues to drive us forward; and for the motivation and teamwork of our global employees, whose dedication remains the driving force behind our exemplary progress. None of the accomplishments would have been possible without the collaborative efforts.
This marks the seventeenth sustainability report published by Crystal International Group Limited (“Crystal” or “Crystal International” or the “Company” or “we” or “our” or “us”) (Stock code: 2232), covering our sustainability performance for the calendar year from 1 January to 31 December 2025.
Catherine Chiu Vice President Corporate Quality and Sustainability
We welcome your valuable feedback on this Report regarding our sustainability performance, initiatives and policies. For any related enquiries, please contact us at [email protected].
During the reporting year, Crystal sustained our operational growth and business expansion. The reporting boundary of this Report, in line with our Annual Report 2025, encompasses all our manufacturing facilities spanning Vietnam, China, Cambodia, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka – unless otherwise specified. This Report highlights positive strides towards our ambitious transition to Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 and ultimately a net-zero fashion future, addressing material sustainability topics and navigating increasingly complex challenges in the global landscape. During the year, we progressed our net zero commitment by intensifying decarbonisation initiatives devised in our net zero roadmap with global factories, while navigating operational challenges associated with regional policies, infrastructure and technology availability. Meanwhile, we optimised our circularity efforts through stepping up waste reduction strategies by solidifying the Corporate Waste Management Framework and forging new partnerships to close material loops. In addition, we deepened our commitment to women empowerment by joining Reimagining Industry to Support Equality (“RISE” or “SERI” in Vietnam) as a member, which enabled more female employees to achieve personal and professional advancement. Our highly rated vision screening programme also scaled significantly, helping improve the wellbeing and productivity of workers in all operating countries. Our sustainability achievements continued to earn accolades from global brand customers and international organisations. In particular, we are the only garment manufacturer and Hong Kong company being scored A-list in CDP Climate for three consecutive years. The awards affirm our ongoing commitment to excellence, innovation, and credibility as we work to embed sustainability across every facet of our business.
02
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
03
CEO Message 2025 was a year shaped by shifting global business landscape, where we stayed steadfast in our long-standing commitment to responsible growth and sustainable value creation. Volatile macroeconomic conditions, evolving regulatory expectations, and accelerated climate impacts brought new complexities to the apparel industry. Yet amid these changes, one constant remained: our customers remained strong momentum in their sustainability commitments, responsible manufacturing, resilience, and innovation across their supply chains.
Striving to Outperform Guided by our Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030, we are delighted by our ability to consistently excel and exceed our ambitious sustainability targets. Our commitment to sustainability remains firmly embedded in our culture, governance, and day-to-day operations. This also enables us to make long-term decisions, deliver measurable progress, create enduring impact towards a net-zero future.
Gearing Up for Productivity Enhancement We strengthened productivity and operational efficiency through streamlining operations and accelerating transition to smart manufacturing. By integrating automation, digitalisation, and data-driven management systems, we elevated production performance and focused on tasks that add value while reducing resource consumption. As one of our decarbonisation strategies, productivity enhancement sets us up well to realise our Net Zero 2050 vision, while being vital and foundational to fostering business competitiveness. Smart manufacturing will remain a central role as we scale pioneer low-carbon solutions and future-ready strategy across our global operations.
Collaboration is crucial for a successful journey towards advancing circular model and wider sustainable transformation in the global apparel sector. We call upon our ardent customers, like-minded innovators, passionate partners and suppliers, to jointly create a circular and net-zero fashion industry, balancing environmental stewardship with shared economic and social progress. As we move forward, we will exert every effort to push boundaries, outperform our targets, and take bold actions that shape a more inspiring, regenerative apparel industry. I profoundly thank my extraordinary teams for their strenuous support and contributions over the past year. I‘m optimistic about our potential, we will do our utmost to collectively weave a trend-setting future – one where sustainability, innovation, and partnership unlock impactful possibilities for generations to come.
Andrew Lo Chief Executive Officer
Investing in People to Sustain Production Capacity Our competitive strengths have been fuelled by our loyal and dedicated talents. To ensure consistent production capacity and enable future business growth, we invested in human resources and put unwavering focus on achieving greater workforce stability. To sharpen our worker retention, we strengthened our wellness programmes to further support physical, mental, and social wellbeing of global workers in a more holistic, inclusive way. The extended steps bolster organisational commitment and empower our people – the backbone of our operations – to grow with us as we chart the next phase of strategic expansion.
Deepening Climate and Operational Resilience Looking ahead, climate change persists as one of the most pressing challenges for fashion industry. Severe cyclones affecting production countries including Vietnam and Sri Lanka in 2025 underscored the urgency of building operational resilience. In response to the significant impact brought by global climate threats and continued extreme weather events, we are undertaking in-depth climate risk scenario analysis to optimise our climate-related risk management framework and reinforce the robustness of our resilience planning. Taking international standards into account, we actively integrated climate considerations into governance, operations, and financial planning against the plausible climate events.
04
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
05
About Crystal International As a global apparel manufacturer, Crystal International has established itself as a sustainability pioneer. Founded in 1970 and headquartered in Hong Kong, the Company and its subsidiaries (collectively, the “Group”) have a diverse product portfolio spanning six categories where the Group holds a leading position: Lifestyle wear, Denim, Intimate, Sportswear and outdoor apparel, Sweater, and Fabrics. The Group operates a multi-country manufacturing platform, with production facilities comprising garment factories and fabric mills spanning five countries: Vietnam, China, Cambodia, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka.
Mission To be the most profitable company in the industry, customer choice, and employee choice.
Corporate Values Integrity
Delight our customer
Respect for people
Live quality
Embrace innovation
Deliver bottom line results
Energise others
Boundaryless enterprise
Geographical Markets and Multi-Country Production Facilities
Product Categories
Denim Europe 19.4% Sportswear and outdoor apparel
Asia Pacific 40.1%
Others 3.1%
China
Lifestyle wear
North America 37.4%
Vietnam
Bangladesh
Cambodia
Sri Lanka
Fabrics Intimate
06
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Sweater
Garment Factories %: Sales by geographical region
Fabric Mills
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
07
About Crystal International
Corporate Governance
Sustainability Governance
Crystal International is the embodiment of exemplary corporate governance, with practices that are not only in compliance with all relevant rules and regulations, including the Corporate Governance Code (“CG Code”), but also intricately aligned with the organisation’s goals and strategies. Crystal recognises the integral role that robust governance plays in achieving long-term success and is unequivocally committed to maintaining high standards that are crucial to the sustainable growth of the Group.
Our Board provides a high level of sustainability governance, retaining overall responsibility for Crystal’s sustainability strategic direction, policies, and annual reporting. The role of the Board involves steering and supervising sustainability strategies to ensure their effectiveness and relevance in response to emerging issues.
To ensure that the governance framework remains effective and responsive to the evolving needs of the business, Crystal’s board of directors (“Board”) undertakes regular reviews and is proactive in establishing relevant Board committees as necessary. This dynamic governance structure is designed to facilitate strategic objectives and enhance overall performance. The composition of Crystal’s Board is thoughtfully diversified, featuring a substantial number of female Board members as well as members with expertise in management of different industries, banking and finance, technology, and manufacturing. This diversity strategically reflects Crystal’s commitment to staying at the forefront of manufacturing innovation and efficiency. Such a varied Board composition is instrumental in steering Crystal towards the vision of excellence in manufacturing capabilities. Understanding the critical nature of board development, Crystal invests in the continuous development of our Board members. Seminars, forums and factory visits to our operational countries are organised, providing Board members with deeper insights into the Company’s business environment, risk management, operations, and sustainability-related issues. These visits are more than informational excursions; they are integral to ensuring that Board members are well-informed and equipped to thoroughly understand the business landscape in which Crystal navigates. Our consistent application of and adherence to advanced corporate governance standards underlines our belief that such practices are not mere formalities but are vital to driving forward Crystal’s vision and long-term success. The Board comprises five executive Directors (including the Chairman, a Vice Chairman and a Vice Chairman who also serves as the Chief Executive Officer), two non-executive Directors and four independent non-executive Directors. The Board has established the following committees to oversee specific aspects of Crystal’s affairs and to assist in the discharge of its responsibilities. • • •
Audit Committee Nomination Committee Remuneration Committee
• •
People Committee Sustainability Committee
The roles and responsibilities of each committee and details of our corporate governance framework are available in Crystal’s Annual Report 2025. The Board places significant emphasis on the oversight of the Group’s risk management and internal control processes, delegating this responsibility to the Audit Committee. This ensures a focused approach to identifying and mitigating risks. The Audit Committee, supported by the Internal Audit Department, actively assesses the effectiveness of these processes, regularly monitors the status of risk mitigation, and provides updates to the Board. Additionally, other Board committees manage risks pertinent to their areas, ensuring alignment with the Group’s overall strategy. To maintain high standards of corporate governance, the Board conducts regular evaluations of its performance, reinforcing its commitment to effective risk management and sustainable growth in a dynamic business environment. Remuneration packages for executive Directors and senior management are explicitly structured to align with both individual and Group performance, in accordance with our prevailing policies, including the remuneration policy. As climate vision and sustainability strategy are core strategic priorities, achievement of climate-related objectives is directly linked to the Group’s performance metrics and is therefore a key factor in determining remuneration outcomes. This ensures that progress on climate goals is an integral component of our reward framework.
08
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Underpinned by a robust governance structure to manage our sustainability approach, the Board-level Sustainability Committee, which is comprised of our CEO and two non-executive Directors, endorses our sustainability vision and commitments, oversees the formulation of integrated strategies and management approach, and provides recommendations on the Group’s sustainability framework and policies, to ensure their effectiveness and alignment with the Group’s business strategies. Our Board and Sustainability Committee members have industry-specific experience in sustainability-related issues, ensuring our ability to address emerging challenges and identify opportunities that support our long-term strategic goals. The Sustainability Committee also reviews the annual reporting, group-wide sustainability performance, material sustainability issues, and related risks and opportunities, in addition to making recommendations and reporting to the Board on a regular basis. The sustainability performance and progress towards our targets are reported quarterly to the Executive Committee (“Execo”) members and twice a year to the Sustainability Committee for review and evaluation.
Sustainability Risk Management The Group applies group-wide risk management and internal control systems to identify, assess, prioritise and monitor sustainability-related risks and opportunities in our operations, and across the value chain where relevant. These processes include reviewing regulatory and market developments, stakeholder engagement and scenario analysis aligned with the Task Force on Climate-related Financial Disclosures (“TCFD”). Identified risks are evaluated using the mechanism of group risk management and internal control systems, considering likelihood, impact and imminence. Material sustainability-related risks and opportunities, and the status of response actions, are prioritised and monitored through regular management reviews to support effective and timely oversight. An internal communication mechanism and a reporting model are in place to keep Sustainability Committee and Execo members informed in a timely manner. We have started climate-related disclosures since 2022 with reference to the recommendations of the TCFD under the four core pillars of Governance, Strategy, Risk Management, and Metrics and Targets. To further enhance climate-related risk management, we are now mapping and integrating the applicable requirements of International Financial Reporting Standards (“IFRS”) S2 into our established climate-related disclosures. All key sustainability and climate-related risks and opportunities, and their potential impact on the Group, are reported to the Sustainability Committee on a half-yearly basis. Authorised by the Board and led by an Executive Director, the Corporate Quality and Sustainability Department (“CQS”) is delegated to develop sustainability strategies and policies, work with business units to embed sustainability into operations, implement relevant initiatives, assess the Group’s sustainability performance, identify improvement areas, and lead sustainability reporting. The CQS and sustainability departments of our factories are responsible for executing projects, evaluating results, monitoring potential risks, and reporting on performance to senior management. Please refer to our Annual Report 2025 for more about Crystal’s risk management process and the “Stakeholder Engagement” section of this Report for the process used to evaluate, prioritise, and manage material sustainability-related issues.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
09
Our Sustainability Vision and Approach Renewable electricity
United Nations Global Compact
Global NGO partnership Provide aid to individuals living in poverty and projects partnered with global NGOs
Since 2021, we have joined the United Nations Global Compact and continued to support its 10 universal principles covering human rights, labour, environment, and anti-corruption. By joining hands with nearly 26,000 other participating companies and organisations worldwide, we remain committed to integrating these principles into our strategy, culture, and daily operations and to engaging with our industry peers through partnerships that drive progress towards shared goals.
Maximise the use of renewable electricity
Anti-poverty
Science-aligned target
Provide aid to individuals living in poverty and projects partnered with global NGOs
Achieve science-aligned target •35% absolute reduction (base year 2022)
nt & e m ge rship a e g En ar tn P
R
Co
Employe e Ergageme nt
Impact for Better
re
ng
Equal opportunities
Eq
No coal-fired units in •Wholly-owned factories, mills, and new investments by 2025 •Core suppliers by 2030
Waste diversion Strive to divert 100% production waste from landfill
uit te
r
y
Embrace diversity and inclusion in employee recruitment, compensation, and promotion
CSV2030
in n erat g N atu
- Support a precautionary approach to environmental challenges.
- Undertake initiatives to promote greater environmental responsibility.
- Encourage the development and diffusion of environmentally friendly technologies.
Coal phase-out
ge
Continue empowering our female employees and advancing gender equity
Re
Women empowerment
ng lisi y a t i nit ev mu m
i ur c R e s o pl e Peo
- Uphold the freedom of association and the effective recognition of the right to collective bargaining.
- Uphold the elimination of all forms of forced and compulsory labour.
- Uphold the effective abolition of child labour.
- Uphold the elimination of discrimination in respect of employment and occupation.
Ensure climate-related risks are effectively managed and disclosed referencing to CDP and TCFD framework
e
Apply worker voice programmes to engage for employee communication
Climate-related risk management
im at
- Support and respect the protection of internationally proclaimed human rights.
- Make sure that they are not complicit in human rights abuses.
Cl
rit y
Employee communication
cula
Businesses should:
C ir
The Ten Principles of the United Nations Global Compact
a W
- Work against corruption in all its forms, including extortion and bribery.
Social wellness
Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 – Impact for Better
We ll n
ess
r sit Bio d iv e
Freshwater intensity
y
Reduce freshwater intensity by 20% per production unit (base year 2022)
Engage our employees to participate in social services
Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 underpins our overarching sustainability strategy and serves as a blueprint to take sustainable fashion to the new heights. Aligned with the UN Sustainable Development Goals (“SDGs”), Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 consists of eight impact areas across environmental, people, and community dimensions, as well as relevant goals associated with each impact area, aiming to tackle wider sustainability challenges and pressing threats. “Impact for better” accentuates our ambition and driving force behind Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030. It also illustrates our aspiration to create a positive impact for our nature, people, and communities to weave a better future.
Physical and mental health •Provide a workplace of excellent health and safety •Launch wellness programmes to promote physical and mental heath
Assessment and strategy Identify material impacts on biodiversity, and implement focused strategies
Since embarking on this new journey in 2024, we have devised the action agenda and implemented tailored actionable items across all eight impact areas at our production facilities. During the past year, we worked relentlessly with all facilities to formulate strategies and monitor progress towards achieving this vision.
10
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
11
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
12
Our Sustainability Vision and Approach
Stakeholder Engagement Highlights in 2025
77,000+
group-wide solar PV
women empowered since 2016
planted in 2025
34,000+
4 factories achieved zero operational waste to landfill
We continued to adopt the double materiality approach for our materiality assessment, referencing the European Sustainability Reporting Standards (“ESRS”) by the European Financial Reporting Advisory Group.
Announcements Direct mails Focus groups Interviews Intranet and external websites Meetings (virtual and in-person)
• • • • •
Press releases Site visits Sustainability reporting Surveys Social media
It is crucial to regularly engage with internal and external stakeholders in order to balance their significant viewpoints and identify issues related to the environment, society, and governance that are relevant to us and our stakeholders.
With the double materiality approach, we assessed business sustainability from both financial and impact perspectives. In addition to assessing material topics that reflect positive or negative impacts on the environment, society and governance, we evaluated the impact of material topics on our business. This up-to-date assessment enables us to better review the integration of sustainability within our business, ensuring our sustainability strategy is purpose-aligned and adaptable in an ever-changing business landscape. Through survey analysis, interviews, and evaluation of the opinions we collected from internal and external stakeholders, such as senior management, employees, NGOs, and business partners, we built a materiality matrix.
Materiality Matrix 2025 1
Stakeholder Groups
40% renewable
for workers
To maintain strong connections with our stakeholders, it is essential to leverage diverse communication channels and nurture robust relationships. We actively and openly engage with different stakeholder groups on a continuous basis, facilitating transparent two-way communication to understand their expectations, interests, and needs. Our communication channels include: • • • • • •
525,000 trees
Free vision screening
Double Materiality Assessment
energy across all factories
200+
Supported families for home rebuilding after Typhoon Yagi
Customers
Employees
Communities
Governments
Suppliers
Shareholders
Investors
Media
NGOs
Institutions
Impact on Environment and Society
23MW
We foster timely and meaningful communication with our stakeholders, aiming to address their concerns and build lasting trust. We identify relevant stakeholders affected by our decisions, activities, and outcomes, prioritising those with whom we frequently interact to gather feedback in alignment with the reporting principles of materiality and inclusiveness.
Follow Us on Social Media
1 2 3
4 5
2
7
3 11
6
8
12
9 17 10
z
14 13 15 16
Business Impact
9,600+
No coal-fired units in
Material Issues under Our Spotlight
volunteering hours benefitting
wholly-owned factories
The following topics were identified as material:
62,000+ individuals Regenerating Nature
Resourcing People
YouTube
Environment
Social
Governance and Operations
Circularity and waste management Climate change Freshwater use Health and safety
These identified material topics were validated and endorsed by the Sustainability Committee and will be prioritised in our strategic planning for greater sustainability. Please refer to sections “Crystal Net Zero 2050”, “Water Conservation”, “Waste Management” and “Safeguarding Employee Health and Safety” for our strategised actions.
Revitalising Community
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
• • • •
4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17
Climate change Circularity and waste management Sustainable materials and product development Freshwater use Chemical and wastewater management Biodiversity Health and safety Employee wellness People empowerment and engagement Equity Human rights Community engagement Product responsibility Ethical business practices Manufacturing excellence and innovation Operational resilience Supply chain sustainability
13
14
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
15
Stakeholder Engagement
Global Partnerships on Sustainability Signatory
Disclosing Company (Climate Change, Water Security)
Member
Member
Participant
Partner Member
Member
Signatory Manufacturer
Silver Member
Corporate Member
Recognition from Customers Certificate of North Star, by adidas
Commitment to Advancing Gender Equality Through the SERI program (2024 – 2025), by Victoria’s Secret & Co.
Real Good Award, by American Eagle Outfitters
Sustainable Performance Award, by adidas
Founding Member
16
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
17
Regenerating Nature Our Environmental Policy and Management System
Recognition and Certifications
Overseen by our Sustainability Committee, our Corporate Environmental Policy outlines the guiding principles that reflect our commitment to environmental compliance and continuous improvement. It guides our actions on climate change mitigation, natural resources conservation, pollutant discharge management, waste and circularity, sustainable material utilisation, and employee awareness. To bring the principles of our Environmental Policy to effective implementation in our factories, we have our Environmental Management System Guidelines in place, which lays the foundation for our factories to establish and implement robust environmental management system. In 2025, 10 of our factories were certified to international standards: the ISO 14001 Environmental Management System, ISO 50001 Energy Management System, and/or the WWF-HK’s Low Carbon Manufacturing Programme (“LCMP”).
Three-time CDP Climate A List
In 2025, all of our factories operated in line with the principles laid out in the Corporate Environmental Policy and complied with all related legal requirements. At the Group level, the Corporate Quality and Sustainability Department (“CQS”) oversees the environmental performance of all factories, including emissions, effluents, waste resource consumption, and compliance status with legal and customer requirements.
For the third consecutive year, the accolade reflected our robust climate governance, environmental transparency, and climate risk management across our operations and value chain. This continued recognition also signifies our consistent leadership among the top 4% of global companies.
Second Year on CDP Supplier Engagement Assessment A List Earning CDP’s Supplier Engagement Assessment A List for the second consecutive year underscores our strong governance and clear targets, strengthening value chain engagement to accelerate sustainable supply chain transformation.
Water Security A- on First Disclosure Going beyond climate, we received A- in our first CDP Water Security disclosure, demonstrating our commitment and continued efforts to responsible water stewardship.
ISO 14064-Verified Carbon Inventory Our Group’s carbon emissions inventory has been verified in accordance with ISO 140641 since 2022, covering Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions, as well as major Scope 3 categories – Category 1: Purchased Goods and Services, which represents over 90% of our total Scope 3 emissions. The reliable and credible dataset provides a strong foundation for our carbon management and enables us to track and demonstrate meaningful progress in our decarbonisation journey.
Environmental awareness mural at our lifestyle factory in Bangladesh.
18
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
19
Regenerating Nature
Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
Scenario Analysis and Financial Impact Assessment
Since 2021, we have prepared climate-related disclosures with reference to the Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (“TCFD”) framework, through which we identify and assess climate-related risks across our operations and broader value chain. The identified risks have been incorporated into the Group’s key risk management system to support consistent identification, prioritisation and monitoring.
Among the climate scenarios that we have assessed, we considered RCP4.5 for physical risks and the NGFS Current Policies pathway for transition risks as our primary basis for climate risk management. These scenarios are better reflecting the climate science projections and prevailing global decarbonisation policies. Recognising the inherent uncertainty of long-term climate scenarios, we placed emphasis on short to medium term impacts that are most relevant to our strategic planning and operational decision making.
To further inform operational strategy, capital allocation and resilience planning under a range of plausible future climate conditions, we partnered with an external consultant in 2025 to complete a climate scenario analysis, advancing to quantitative assessments.
With respect to climate-related opportunities, as we remain committed to progressing towards Net Zero 2050, we reference the NGFS Net Zero 2050 pathway to identify and harness market and technological opportunities that may emerge as global decarbonisation efforts intensify. The potential financial impacts of our focused climate scenarios and time horizons are summarised in the table below.
Climate Scenario Analysis The climate scenario analysis identified potential physical and transition risks and opportunities affecting our operations and value chain, including scenarios aligned with the Paris Agreement as an international climate agreement. We referenced Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (“IPCC”) Representative Concentration Pathway (“RCP”) scenarios for physical risks; and the Network for Greening the Financial System (“NGFS”) pathways for transition risks. These scenarios were selected for their credibility, industry relevance and alignment with regulatory and market expectations. The analysis incorporated high-level assumptions from the IPCC and NGFS scenarios, covering anticipated climate policies, macroeconomic trends, national and regional climate variables, future energy-mix shifts, and technological advancement. Drawing on recognised global climate datasets alongside our operational information, the analysis provided an indicative view of how different climate futures may affect our asset resilience, continuity of our business and value chain.
Climate Scenario Analysis & Financial Impact Physical Risk1 RCP 4.52 Short Term3 Medium Term3
Scenario Time horizon Sea level rise: damage to owned property and assets Heatwave: reduced worker productivity and increased energy cost Climate events: supply chain disruption and increased material cost
Low Low Low
Low Low Low
Transition Risk4 We assessed possible impacts in the short (0-2 years), medium (3-5 years) and long term (>5 years) for all operational locations and value chain. The time horizons are aligned with our Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 and net-zero target. We retain the capacity to adjust our strategies in response to the evolving climate-related conditions, strengthening our overall climate resilience.
Carbon pricing regulations: compliance cost Low-carbon technologies: capital expenditure Increased material cost from market transition
To assess potential physical and transition impacts under a range of plausible climate futures, we applied a suite of IPCC and NGFS climate-related scenarios. The scenario set includes: • •
RCP 2.6, RCP 4.5, and RCP 8.5 NGFS Net Zero 2050, NGFS Delayed Transition, and NGFS Current Policies
Current Policies5 Short Term3 Medium Term3
Scenario Time horizon
Low Low Low
Opportunity6 Scenario Time horizon Sustainable products: Increased revenue from emerging sustainable product market Green manufacturing: Increased revenue from customers’ sourcing by fulfilling climate targets
1 2
3 4 5
6 7
20
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Low Low Medium
Net Zero 20507 Short Term Medium Term
Low
Medium
Low
Medium
Analysis result indicates that ~30% of our manufacturing facilities face exposure to physical risks including flooding and heat stress. “RCP 4.5” is a Representative Concentration Pathway climate scenario developed by the IPCC, associated with approximately 2–3°C of global warming by 2100. Risk levels are categorised based on the estimated financial impact or the exposure respective to the nature of risks. All our manufacturing facilities are exposed to transition risks driven by evolving climate policies, market expectations and technology development. “Current Policies” is a climate transition scenario developed by the NGFS, which reflects only existing policies and leads to significantly higher warming (around 3°C or more by 2100). All our facilities face opportunities arising from growing demand for sustainable products and the shift toward green manufacturing practices. “Net Zero 2050” is a climate transition scenario developed by the NGFS, which reflects an ambitious 1.5°C pathway. SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
21
Regenerating Nature
The identified material climate-related risks and opportunities were monitored and reviewed regularly through our Group risk management system, evaluating likelihood, impact and imminence. These insights inform flexible resource allocation, resilience planning, and the development of preventive and adaptive measures.
Crystal Net Zero 2050
In response to climate-related risks, we placed particular emphasis on protecting employee health arising from heat stress. We implemented a multi-faceted approach to address immediate workforce wellbeing, the measures included:
We embarked on our net zero commitment in 2022 – to achieve net zero by 2050 and 35% absolute carbon reduction by 2030 as a science-aligned interim target, encompassing the operations of all our garment factories and fabric mills.
• • •
Extending air conditioning coverage in workshops Enhancing hydration and nutrition support through improved canteen offerings Providing wellness supplements
In addition, we are also advancing longer term opportunities aligned with a lower-carbon and more circular future by: • • •
Monitoring sustainable material availability and market developments Progressing research into textile-to-textile recycling and material innovations Partnering with customers to realise scalable circularity
Advancing Our Net Zero Transition
Our 2050 net zero target was validated by the Science Based Targets initiative (“SBTi”), and is also aligned with Paris Agreement to reduce absolute Scopes 1, 2, and 3 greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions8 by 90% by 2050, against the base year 2022. The Scope 3 includes emissions from purchased goods and services, upstream transportation and distribution, and the end-of-life treatment of sold product. The structured progression of our net-zero roadmap has driven a 14% reduction in carbon intensity at our garment factories since 2022, while the absolute emissions, as projected, increased by 12% amid business growth. Per our roadmap, we will expedite renewable energy adoption, strengthen energy management, and deploy application innovations towards our targets.
Together, these actions help manage near-term operational needs while positioning the Group to capture strategic climate-related opportunities and build long-term business resilience.
Factory-level Carbon Management
Please refer to sections “Crystal Net Zero 2050”, “Water Conservation”, “Sustainable Materials”, “Managing Environmental and Social Risks along Supply Chain”, “Safeguarding Employee Health and Safety” in this Report for our strategies and actions addressing these risks and opportunities.
Building on the Group’s overall targets, and tailoring to individual factory circumstances, we set specific carbon intensity targets for each garment factory starting from 2025. The targets strengthened governance, enabled factories to take proactive ownership, and catalysed cross-factory exchange on effective management practices and saving measures.
8
22
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
The target covers all seven types of GHG stipulated under the Kyoto Protocol, including Carbon dioxide (CO2), Methane (CH4), Nitrous oxide (N2O), Hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), Perfluorocarbons (PFCs), Sulphur hexafluoride (SF6), and Nitrogen trifluoride (NF3). Our net-zero target is based on achieving 90% actual emissions reduction measured in tonnes of carbon dioxide equivalent (tCO2e) and addressing the remaining 10% through certified removals and offsets sourced from internationally recognised third-party programmes that ensure high project integrity and permanence.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
23
Regenerating Nature
Net Zero Strategy
ISO 50001 Energy Management System
Underpinning the progress toward our targets, our net-zero roadmap serves as our climate transition plan. In addition to actions and milestones, the plan sets out resources required, assumptions and dependencies, which are reviewed annually to reflect evolving climate science, regulations, technologies, and business strategy.
Energy Efficiency Since 2022, our factories have identified more than 200 energy efficiency measures for implementation by 2028, comprehensively covering: • • • •
Production equipment efficiency Operation of associated facilities and utilities, e.g., chillers, air compressors Waste heat recovery Energy monitoring
These measures are prioritised for short-, medium-, and long-term adoption based on their payback periods and reduction potential, hence we have not yet applied an internal carbon pricing in our decision-making processes. We will continue to review the necessity of internal carbon pricing timely. Investment for energy efficiency measures was primarily through internal operational and capital budgets. As of the end of 2025, 125 measures have been completed, resulting in an annual carbon reduction of over 40,000 tCO2e.
125 measures completed
40,000
Our intimate factory in Vietnam was certified with ISO 50001, as the second factory at Crystal. This is attributable to its advanced building management system (“BMS”), along with 61 smart meters, which enables 24/7 real-time energy analysis, optimises operational parameters and load-based power allocation across major consuming units and the wastewater treatment plant.
Renewable Energy Group-wide Solar PV According to our group-wide solar plan, our rooftop solar photovoltaic (“PV”) capacity has surged from 0.6 MW to 22.9 MW from 2020 to the present, and will continue to allocate internal capital budget to grow towards 2030. The existing rooftop PV systems at our factories generate approximately 26,100 MWh of renewable electricity annually, equivalent to around 15% of electricity for the factories with solar installation.
Growth of Installed Solar PV Capacity MW
tonnes carbon reduced annually
Air-Conditioning Energy Performance Benchmark Air-conditioning (“AC”) and ventilation systems provide our workers with a comfortable workspace in response to the growing heat stress, yet they typically account for around 15% of a factory’s total energy consumption. To ensure that our facilities adopt energy-efficient cooling solutions with equipment selection and system design, we are engaging Schneider Electric to develop a set of AC energy performance benchmarks. These benchmarks incorporated key considerations such as local climate conditions, cooling load requirements of different workshops, and the best-available technologies in the market for our factories when planning AC expansions or renovations. This also supports both operational needs and sustainability outcomes – enhancing thermal comfort for workers while delivering low-carbon solutions.
24
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
0.6MW
22.9MW
2020
2025
2030
To maximise the Group’s solar installation potential, we are conducting a study with Schneider Electric on developing a robust solar roadmap to govern installable capacities per factory by year towards 2030. The study holistically examined all available factory areas and technical factors, such as roof condition, structural characteristics and best-in-class PV technologies. By fully unlocking our potential with an actionable roadmap, we aim to accelerate clean energy deployment systematically.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
25
Regenerating Nature
Purchasing Renewable Electricity
Unlocking Solar Power Utilisation
Procuring traceable and certified green electricity and renewable energy attributes from the market is a feasible way for factories to reduce carbon emissions while also supporting the development of regional renewable energy markets.
Vietnam – Regulating Device for Solar Generation Our denim factory installed 2.09 MW solar system with a regulating device to better utilise the surplus solar electricity that cannot be exported to the grid. The device monitors the overall site power demand and allocates electricity proportionally across workshops. This prioritised solar generation for onsite consumption and further curtailed reliance on grid electricity.
China – Battery Energy Storage Our lifestyle wear factory has adopted a 1.29 MWh battery energy storage system. The system is charged by surplus solar generation partly and by off-peak grid power hours with a lower tariff, with the stored energy used to power the 228 automated-guided vehicles (“AGV”). By leveraging the peak-shaving and load-shifting capabilities of energy storage, the factory reduced 30% of electricity cost of the AGVs and raised overall solar self-consumption rate.
Sri Lanka – New Solar PV Connection Scheme Our intimate factory has expanded its rooftop solar installation beyond the contract demand to fully utilise the available rooftop space according to a new local connection scheme. By exporting more solar power to offset grid consumption, the facility not only reduces electricity costs but also receives additional income.
Our knits factories in China procured 4,360 MWh of green electricity in 2025. Combining the onsite rooftop PV, the proportion of renewable electricity used by the factories reached approximately 26%. Three of our intimate factories and lifestyle wear factories in Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Vietnam purchased International Renewable Energy Certificate (“I-REC”) that matched the grid electricity volume, resulting in 100% renewable electricity coverage on a market-based GHG accounting basis.
Industry Carbon Programmes UN Fashion Industry Charter for Climate Action We have joined the Fashion Industry Charter for Climate Action for six years. Through participating in the Charter’s initiatives, we collaborated with around 70 other signatories, including brands and suppliers, to collectively drive carbon reduction actions and industry progress. We attended the Charter’s annual meeting in Bonn, Germany in November to share our climate-related risk analysis from the manufacturer’s perspective. Pursuant to our participation in the Charter, we are a member of the Race to Zero campaign. We contribute to this collective effort by strengthening our decarbonisation strategy, advancing credible emissions-reduction pathways, and helping build momentum across the industry.
Decarbonisation Programmes in Cambodia Our sportswear factory in Cambodia participated in the International Finance Corporation (“IFC”)’s Cambodia Decarbonization Project (“CaDP”) and the German Agency for International Cooperation (“GIZ”)’s Project Development Programme (“PDP”). With the detailed feasibility assessment conducted in 2025, the factory has made active implementation planning on 12 energy and water saving initiatives identified, including switching to biomass boilers, air compressor replacement and automation of fabric cutting.
26
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
27
Regenerating Nature
Carbon Leadership Program
Key achievements of solar streetlights and clean water projects from these initiatives are as follows:
Our intimate factory in Sri Lanka joined the Best Practice Action Plan under Carbon Leadership Program jointly organised by the Apparel Impact Institute (“Aii”) and a consultant, RESET Carbon. Through desktop assessment and interview process, the factory established its carbon and water baselines, developed a best practice action plan, and enhanced internal capacity for carbon management.
Solar Streetlights Projects
Collaborative Initiatives with Customers Vietnam Renewable Energy Cohort Our Vietnam sportswear factory was invited by a customer to join a Vietnam Renewable Energy Cohort, a collaborative initiative bringing together around 10 manufacturers in Vietnam to jointly explore renewable energy opportunities and accelerate the cleaner electricity transition.
1,459 Sets
44.37 Kilometers
285.14 Tonnes
224,000 People
Solar Streetlights Installed
Mileage with Solar Streetlights
Annual Carbon Emissions Saving
Project Beneficiaries
Clean Water Projects
The factory is expected to receive expert insight in renewable energy strategy, tailored recommendations on procurement, and valuable insights into Vietnam’s evolving renewable energy landscape.
RE:Spark – Supply Chain Decarbonisation Programme Our intimate factories in Vietnam, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka have participated in the RE:Spark, a global supply chain decarbonisation initiative by a customer in collaboration with Schneider Electric. Our involvement helps strengthen our concerted efforts with the customer on clean energy options, including onsite renewable energies, energy attribute certificates, green tariffs, and power purchase agreements (“PPAs”).
Crystal Climate Charity Foundation The Crystal Climate Charity Foundation (the “Climate Charity Foundation”), a Hong Kong charitable trust established in 2022 by our Chairman, Mr. Kenneth Lo, is dedicated to advancing climate change education and alleviating poverty caused by environmental changes. Working closely with Crystal, the Climate Charity Foundation has spearheaded impactful sustainability and educational initiatives in affected regions, including Bangladesh, Cambodia, China, Sri Lanka, and Vietnam. As part of its climate poverty relief initiatives, the Climate Charity Foundation periodically installs solar streetlights, solar PV panels, and water filtration systems in local communities and institutions – such as schools, community centres, orphanages, and clinics – located near the Group’s factories. These projects aim to enhance the livelihoods of underserved populations in a sustainable manner, while addressing the adverse effects of climate change on vulnerable regions.
28
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
11 Sets
8 Organisations
1,928 People
Water Machines Installed
Benefited Organisations
Project Beneficiaries
Empowering Communities through Solar Streetlights In 2025, Climate Charity Foundation, together with Crystal, continued to drive positive change by expanding our solar streetlight initiatives across Asia. This year marked the launch of our first projects in Bangladesh and China, where the China project was delivered in partnership with Yuk Ching Charity Trust, alongside ongoing installations in Cambodia and Vietnam. Through these collaborative efforts, 863 solar streetlights were installed in 2025 alone, illuminating an additional 26.49 kilometres of roads and transforming night-time safety and accessibility for local communities. As of the end of 2025, a total of 1,459 solar streetlights have been installed, delivering reliable, sustainable lighting solutions that contribute to an annual carbon reduction of approximately 285 tonnes. Most importantly, these projects have improved the quality of life for over 224,000 beneficiaries, fostering safer environments, supporting economic activity, and advancing our commitment to sustainable development in every region we serve.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
29
Regenerating Nature
Community Solar PV Panel Projects in Cambodian School and Orphanage In October 2025, Crystal and Climate Charity Foundation, in partnership with our denim factory in Cambodia, launched Cambodia’s first Solar PV Panel Project, installing off-grid solar systems at five schools and an orphanage. This initiative delivered clean energy, reduced costs and emissions, and improved the learning environment for over 1,300 children, while serving as a practical model for climate poverty relief and climate education in local communities.
Water Conservation WWF Water Risk Filter Freshwater is a material resource for our operations, particularly our factories with wet processing, which could be affected by risks such as regional water depletion, drought and associated costs from short to long term. None of our factories are located in regions with the highest risk of water depletion, as indicated by the WWF Water Risk Filter. When planning to establish new factories, we also assess the relevant risks in the area, including water depletion, flooding, and drought. Our factories obtained freshwater from locally available sources in line with regulations and permits concerning freshwater withdrawal. In addition to water risks, we monitor freshwater consumption by tracking flow meters and water bills to reflect the effectiveness of water measures to reduce consumption and associated expenditure, mainly freshwater purchase.
Stewarding Water Efficiency As water conservation is one of the targets in our Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030, our factories have implemented multiple water-saving initiatives to unlock near- and mid-term opportunities for reducing freshwater dependency and upgrading water-smart technologies and processes, ultimately to save freshwater consumption responsibly.
Advancing Climate Education: Perpetual Scholarships at University of Toronto Apart from our existing undergraduate sustainability scholarship for City University of Hong Kong and Hong Kong Metropolitan University, Climate Charity Foundation has established the “Crystal Climate Charity Foundation Awards in Sustainability” at University of Toronto, marking its first postgraduate scholarship programme. This perpetual endowed scholarship supports outstanding PhD students in the Faculty of Arts & Science and Faculty of Applied Science & Engineering, empowering them to pursue high-impact sustainability research. By investing in climate education and supporting innovative research on climate resilience and net-zero solutions, the Climate Charity Foundation is helping to cultivate future leaders who will drive meaningful progress towards a more sustainable and resilient world.
Driving Circularity: Local Paper Recycling Loop Crystal has strengthened its commitment to circular economy principles through a strategic collaboration with the Climate Charity Foundation and a Hong Kong recycler, Mil Mill. This initiative establishes a closed-loop system by collecting used paper from the Hong Kong office via secure, floor-by-floor post-boxes equipped with designated green and red bags for general and confidential documents. The collected paper is processed by Mil Mill through its secure recycling service, pulped, and transformed into recycled paper products such as A4 and A3 paper and paper hand towels. These products are then procured for use within Crystal’s operations, creating a sustainable cycle that reduces waste, promotes responsible sourcing, and minimises environmental impact. By embedding this circular approach into daily practices, Crystal demonstrates leadership in resource efficiency and reinforces its ESG commitments.
30
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
We balanced investment and operating costs against longer-term water security and operational resilience, prioritising measures that strengthen water security and cost resilience, while securing production needs. Investments for water-efficient and recycling measures were primarily through internal operational and capital budgets. Across our garment factories with washing operations and diverse product types, our average freshwater consumption intensity was around 31 m3 per washing tonne in 2025. Our lifestyle wear factory in Vietnam has adopted a multi-pronged approach to significantly reduce freshwater use through water-efficient processes and wastewater recycling. In addition, the factory has also advanced its water efficiency through adoption of various water-saving technologies in its production in the past decade. • •
Brongo auto-washing: applied for over 90% of washing products, achieved around 30% water saving. E-soft washing: water spraying washing, resulted in 95% water reduction compared with the traditional washing.
With all the collective efforts of factories, our per product freshwater intensities of factories have decreased by almost 8% against 2022 level.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
31
Regenerating Nature
Holistic Water Conservation Efficient Freshwater Management of Our Denim Factory in Vietnam Piloting New Auto-Washing Machine In 2025, the factory introduced a pilot auto-washing machine. This new machine requires only 15 to 20 litres of water per kilogram of garments, compared with 25 litres per kilogram needed by conventional belly washers, demonstrating a 20–30% reduction in water consumption and marking an important step toward wider adoption.
Solar Heating
Dormitory Flushing
Municipal Sewage System
10% MUNICIPAL WATER Advanced eco-washing process, ozone bleaching, laser technologies and certified green chemicials
Smart Laundry & Production Use
45% RECYCLED WATER
Wastewater Treatment 9,400m3/day
Smarter Washing for Denim Our denim operations continued to advance water efficiency by optimising washing processes and adopting water-saving measures. One key measure is increasing the loading capacity of bulk washing machines, where technically feasible, with careful adjustment of load size while maintaining washing performance and product quality. This measure contributed to 10% water intensity reduction in 2025. Our denim factories also prioritised the use of waterless enzyme washing processes whenever product requirements allow. In 2025, our denim factories doubled the share of washing processes carried out using the waterless enzyme technique to around 50%, replacing conventional methods to achieve significant water savings. Compared with traditional wet-processing, while maintaining the desired washing effects, waterless enzyme treatments:
Greening
30%
15% REUSE
SAVE 60% Water Consumption
40%
RIVER WATER
Discharge River Water Treatment
%: Percentage of water sources
Full compliance with national standards and ZDHC Wastewater Guidelines
Solar Heating
Municipal Water
River Water
Recycled/ Treated Water
Waste Water
Collective Actions on Water Management WWF Greater Mekong Programme
• • • •
Saved overall process water demand by up to 20% Halved the process time Consumed no steam Reduced wastewater and sludge
Our denim factory in Cambodia participated in the WWF Cambodia Water Audit under the broader SML – Greater Mekong Programme, demonstrating our commitment to collaborative responsible water stewardship in the region. Funded by the Swiss Agency for Development and Cooperation (“SDC”), the programme strengthened management of water resources and wastewater of joining factories across Great Mekong region, while contributing to the region’s long-term water security and ecological resilience. WWF’s technical team analysed the factory’s data to contextualise the water efficiency performance and to set basis for evaluating future water-efficiency investments.
Supply Chain Water Assessment Our lifestyle wear factory in China took part in a third-party water assessment as part of a broader supply chain water-saving initiative led by one of our customers. With our comprehensive water metering system and existing reduction plans, the assessment revealed the excellent performance of our factory in industrial water use, with water management practices that exceed the industry average. On the other hand, our factory gained actionable insights to further shape the continued water-efficiency actions.
32
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
33
Regenerating Nature
Air Emissions Control
Carbon, Energy, and Water Data 2025
All of our factories regularly monitor and test air emission sources, including boilers and generators, according to the local legal requirements. In 2025, all of our factories fully complied with the relevant legal standards.
Product Footprints
Adoption of Cleaner Fuels We have promoted the adoption of cleaner fuels for combustion equipment, which is associated with a wide range of control measures for flue gas treatment and indoor air quality improvement. Our factories in China have been using natural gas as boiler fuel. Our lifestyle wear and sweater factories in China purchased direct steam supply to replace onsite steam generation by the boiler to further minimise the impacts on the environment. All of these initiatives have served the purpose of achieving better air quality in local communities. Our major emission sources are boilers, generators, kitchen facilities, printing facilities, vehicles, and forklifts. In 2025, our factories emitted about 485.1 tonnes of nitrogen oxide (“NOx”), 12.2 tonnes of sulphur dioxide (“SO2”), and 53.4 tonnes of particulate matter (“PM”).
0.20
Carbon intensity
Energy intensity
0.64
(kgCO2e/equivalent piece)
(kWh/equivalent piece)
Notes: • Carbon intensities are calculated by dividing the total greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions of Scope 1 and Scope 2 by the total equivalent pieces of garments. • The scope of the product footprint calculation only includes our garment factories.
Greenhouse Gas Emissions
57,789
Scope 1
108,715
Scope 2
111,434
20.8%
(tCO2e)
39.1%
(tCO2e)
40.1%
Biogenic emissions (tCO2)
Notes: • Operational control approach is adopted for our emissions accounting during the reporting period. • Scope 1 included direct emissions from fuel combustion of stationary sources (e.g. boilers, generators, kitchens), motor vehicles, wastewater treatment facilities, and septic tanks. • Scope 2 included indirect emissions from purchased energy. The market-based Scope 2 emissions were 108,715 tCO2e; and the location-based Scope 2 emissions were 126,859 tCO2e. • GHG emissions are accounted for and reported with reference to the GHG Protocol Corporate Accounting and Reporting Standard. The GHG emission factors from the UK Department for Environment, Food & Rural Affairs (“DEFRA”) and the International Energy Agency (“IEA”) were applied.
Energy Consumption
882,040 31.2%
Purchased energy
693,838 24.5%
(GJ)
Direct energy
1,251,563
(GJ)
44.3%
Renewable energy (GJ)
Notes: • Purchased energy includes grid electricity and steam. • Direct energy includes the combustion of fossil fuels and non-renewable alternative fuels. • Renewable energy includes biogenic fuel, onsite solar power, purchased green electricity and renewable electricity attributes • Based on our records such as fuel purchases, electricity bills, and energy meters, the energy consumption was calculated using the conversion factors published by the UK Government’s Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy, and the DEFRA.
Water Consumption for Production Use
5,396,709 71.6%
Freshwater 3
(m )
2,137,720 28.4%
Recycled water (m3)
Notes: • Municipal water, river water, and groundwater accounted for 25%, 33%, and 42% of the total quantity of freshwater consumed, respectively. • Water was consumed in full compliance with water quality or quantity permits and standards.
34
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
35
Regenerating Nature
Waste Management Corporate Waste Management System
Packaging Materials 2025
In support of achieving the Group’s 2030 vision on zero production waste to landfill, we launched the Corporate Waste Management System Framework this year in order to standardise waste management practices across all factories gradually, unleashing ongoing opportunities to realise potential environmental and financial benefits of waste in short to medium term. The Framework is built on four pillars: • • • •
Governance: Cross-functional teams, transparent contractor selection Operations: Waste classification, prevention, onsite sorting & storage, contractor evaluation & traceability Monitoring: Waste inventory, onsite inspections, corporate audits Education & Awareness: Training programmes, awareness campaigns
15.2 kilotonnes
4.8 kilotonnes
Paper products and carton boxes
Plastics
Scaling Zero Production Waste to Landfill Our factories strictly implement the waste management hierarchy stipulated in the Framework, including source classification and collaboration with qualified waste contractors and recyclers, to realise the dual economic and environmental value of waste. In 2025, our sweater factory in China achieved zero production waste to landfill, bringing the total to four factories now and serving as exemplary models for gradual expansion.
4
factories achieved zero production waste to landfill
Within the Framework, we applied a waste management hierarchy that considered trade-offs among different disposal pathways and prioritised reduction at sources, recycling and energy recovery. Where preferred pathways are available locally, factories also assess financial and operation factors.
Total Waste Management at Our Sweater Factory in China The Framework implementation in all factories also mitigates compliance risks in short to medium term by meeting evolving customer expectations and local policies on waste reduction, recycling and traceability.
Sorting & Segregation
Waste Data 2025
Chemical related and contaminated waste
32.8 kilotonnes Non-hazardous waste (Mainly fabric waste and domestic waste)
Waste chemical drums and packaging
Total
7.6 kilotonnes
40.4 kilotonnes
8.6 kilotonnes
Waste recycled
Waste recovered to energy
Notes: • The disposal of hazardous waste was handled by licensed contractors. • Recyclable waste is sorted in factories and then collected by or delivered to various recyclers. • Apart from recycling and energy recovery, other non-hazardous waste was taken to local landfills and/or incineration facilities. • Waste-related expenses mainly comprised licensed waste contractor fees, while income was generated from selling recyclables.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Hazardous
Waste
19.9 kilotonnes
Waste to energy
Waste industrial oil
Hazardous waste (Mainly chemical waste from production processes and sludge from waste treatment)
Waste Recycling and Energy Recovery
36
End Products
Non-hazardous
Waste cartridges Fluorescent light bulbs
Treated by qualified waste contractors
Paper products
Recycled paper
Plastics
Recycled plastics
Sludge
Bricks
Waste yarn
Regenerated yarn
Food waste
Animal feed
Waste cooking oil
Biodiesel
General refuse
Waste to energy
Waste to energy Waste to recycling
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
37
Regenerating Nature
CirClimate – Sustainable Denim Product Innovation
Digitalised Waste Traceability via Reverse Resources
Inspired by “Design to Disappear” concept, the revolutionary sustainable collection, CirClimate. incorporates 100% cellulosic fibres, 100% cotton threads, removable shank buttons, and compostable packaging, greatly reducing waste and promoting fashion circularity.
Seven of our factories onboarded onto Reverse Resources’ software-as-aservice platform that formalises the textile waste supply chains by digitally connecting manufacturers, waste handlers, and recyclers. Our factories mapped the material flows, identified recycling outlets, and enabled a more collaborative and data-driven approach to waste reduction. This supported us to build verifiable transparency for transitioning to circular models.
Unlike traditional synthetic performance fabrics, CirClimate is entirely made of biodegradable materials, leaving no trace behind on our waste footprints. The collection showcases our ability to translate circularity principles into commercially scalable, consumer relevant solutions.
Industry Waste Programmes Circular Fashion Partnership in Cambodia Our sportswear factory in Cambodia has participated in the Global Fashion Agenda (“GFA”) Circular Fashion Partnership, a cross sectoral initiative that aims to advance circular fashion systems in key textile, garment, and footwear manufacturing regions. Our factory underwent a detailed Textile Waste Management Assessment, which formed the foundation for an effective waste management system with accurate data collection, clear waste stream segregation and tracing. An implementation plan will be developed to improve waste reduction and recycling practices.
Support for HKRITA Research on Innovative Industry Solution We supported The Hong Kong Research Institute of Textiles and Apparel (“HKRITA”) in its research project on direct extraction of cotton fibres from polyester-cotton blended fabrics in mechanical recycling.
The project explores the application of dry separation technology to help separate polyester from blended materials during mechanical recycling and increase the purity of cotton content in recycled denim fibre. As a supporting party, we will be supporting the research team to test and validate the new approach under real industry conditions.
Local Textile-to-Textile Circular Model As invited by a brand customer, our lifestyle factory in Vietnam piloted a local textile-to-textile cotton waste recycling project in collaboration with tier 1 to 4 supply chain peers. Our factory initiated waste traceability, classification and collection with proper colour and fibre composition sorting. The sorted cotton cutting waste was sent to mechanically recycling into cotton fibre, which is then spun into recycled yarn and woven into recycled fabric. This model unlocked strong potential for closed-loop textile products and built a robust local recycling network.
38
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
39
Regenerating Nature
Sustainable Materials
Chemical and Wastewater Management
Over 90% of our factories have received sustainable material certifications, offering an extensive array of recognised sustainable options tailored for different customers. In our diverse range of product categories, we have showcased extensive application of sustainable materials.
Corporate Chemical Management Guidelines We are committed to eliminating the use of hazardous chemicals in our operations and products. Our Corporate Chemical Management Guidelines provide a comprehensive framework for chemical management, from input, process, to output control.
Input
Across our garment factories, around 40% of the two major fibre materials – cotton and polyester – that we sourced in 2025 was sustainable materials9.
• •
At our denim division
Group Manufacturing Restricted Substances List (“MRSL”) Green chemical procurement and screening
Process
• •
Chemical management system Assessment and training
Output
•
Regular testing according to Zero Discharge of Hazardous Chemicals (“ZDHC”) Wastewater Guidelines and legal requirements
At our fabric mills
85%
80%
cotton sourced with sustainability attributes
yarn carried sustainability attributes
Joining Textile Exchange to Scale Sustainable Textile We became a Partner Member of Textile Exchange in 2025, strengthening our efforts to scale preferred fibres and materials in our operations and across value chain. Through collaboration with Textile Exchange and its global member network, we are accelerating the adoption of lower-impact materials, advancing innovative fibre solutions aligned with the Preferred Fiber & Materials Matrix, and enhancing circular practices through structured waste management, improved traceability, and textile-to-textile recycling initiatives.
Group Restricted Substances List In 2025, we updated our Group Product & Manufacturing Restricted Substances List (“RSL”) in alignment with the latest customer requirements, industry initiatives, and international standards. All factories are required to comply with the revised limits and requirements. As the key foundation of our chemical governance, the RSL compliance has been incorporated into the annual corporate chemical audit by the CQS for facilities using production chemistries.
Green Chemistry Controlling inputs and procuring green chemicals is a crucial step in eliminating hazardous chemicals. We use online chemical inventory management (“CIM”) tools and the Zero Discharge of Hazardous Chemicals (“ZDHC”) InCheck Report to monitor, track, and report the conformance status of production chemicals, such as those used in washing and printing, against the ZDHC MRSL.
81% of chemicals conformed to the highest level 3 of the ZDHC MRSL
9
40
Materials procurement records for materials with sustainability attributes, including recycled content, organic cotton, and Better Cotton, are categorised as sustainable.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
41
Regenerating Nature
Automated Chemical Dosing in Fabric Mills
Higg Index
The new dyeing machines in our fabric mills in Vietnam and Bangladesh are equipped with an automatic chemical dosing system, which ensured chemicals are used efficiently and responsibly.
Facility Environmental Module and Facility Data Manager
The automated dispenser delivers precise quantities of dyes and auxiliaries, reducing overuse, spillage, and human error, resulting in: • • •
40% reduction in chemical usage Enhanced batch-to-batch continuity, product quality while reducing defects and reprocessing Enhanced workspace safety by minimising direct contact with dyes and chemicals
All our factories continued to adopt the latest version of the industry environmental performance assessment tool – Higg Facility Environmental Module (“FEM”) 4.0. During the 2025 cycle, 100% of our factories completed core verification by third parties10. In line with customer requirements for standardised and transparent environmental data reporting, 10 of our factories reported and shared the required 2025 data through a common platform, the Higg Facility Data Manager (“FDM”).
Supplier Performance Tracking and Training In addition to our own factories, we also used the Higg FEM to understand and track our suppliers’ environmental performance, thereby identifying environmental risks in the supply chain and assisting in the calculation of Scope 3 emissions. In the last cycle, 47 upstream suppliers shared their completed FEM with us. To further build up our suppliers’ capacity, our denim division engaged with their suppliers in Vietnam to join the To the Finish Line program for Higg FEM 4.0 deep dive training, and provided them a Learning for Action community.
ZDHC Wastewater Guidelines Our factories conducted biannual tests in accordance with the industry standard, ZDHC Wastewater Guidelines. The latest version 2.2, launched in September 2024, outlines requirements for testing wastewater parameters, sludge leachate, and declaring sludge disposal pathways. In 2025, all of our factories regularly monitored and tested wastewater, and complied with relevant local legal standards and requirements. Our operations treated 8.3 million m³ of wastewater.
10
42
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
During the current transition of verification methodology, the core verification scores of Higg FEM 4.0 are not allowed to be communicated publicly at this moment per related guidelines.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
43
Driving Innovative Manufacturing Our commitment to manufacturing excellence enables us to boost efficiency and productivity, anticipate and exceed evolving customer expectations, and elevate our environmental, health and safety performance. This integrated approach strengthens our competitive advantage and positions us for sustained success in an increasingly demanding industry landscape. Progress on the journey towards transforming our facilities into smart factories has been underway since 2018, when a digitally enabled manufacturing model was first envisioned – one built around a central computer system and strengthened by advanced technologies such as data analytics and visualisation, robotics, artificial intelligence, interconnected machinery, and integrated product management platforms.
Transforming to FLAP and FLOCK Our knits division defined our production logic models in 2023 – FLAP 11 for garment factories and FLOCK for fabric mills. These models establish the foundation for our smart factory vision, where materials move seamlessly through each manufacturing stage with the support of robotic arms, automated-guided vehicles (“AGV”), autonomous mobile robots (“AMR”), and a wide range of advanced automated machinery. The entire material flow is orchestrated by an integrated digital system comprising multiple interconnected software applications, enabling a highly autonomous and efficient production environment.
11
44
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
FLAP represents the Finishing Centre, Logistics Centre, Assembly Centre, and Parts Manufacturing Centre, while FLOCK refers to the Finishing Centre, Logistics Centre, Colouration Centre, and Knitting Centre. These two models serve as our production logic frameworks for garment factories and fabric mills respectively.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
45
Driving Innovative Manufacturing
Progressing FLAP across Vietnam and China
Building a More Integrated and Automated Operation
Our FLAP rollout continued to gain momentum in Vietnam and China.
The Modernisation Centre of the knits division continued to accelerate our automation journey by applying and piloting an extensive range of new automation, manufacturing-excellence, and robotic solutions across pre-production, production, and finishing processes.
At our knits factory in Vietnam, implementation remained firmly on track with its five-year FLAP vision, with the central cutting workshop in the Logistic Centre fully established and parts of the sewing-focused Assembly Centre already in use. In China, the knits factory in Dongguan introduced an intelligent hanger system in the Assembly Centre. The construction of the new Logistics Centre building was also completed, with the central cutting area partially operational, while development of the automated storage and retrieval systems (“AS/RS”)-enabled smart warehouse progressed towards its scheduled readiness in early 2026.
In addition, the centre re-engineered several finishing and packaging workflows to create the conditions necessary for deeper automation adoption and to support the transition towards fully integrated, centre-to-centre material flow. Together, these initiatives catalysed progress towards a more synchronised and efficient smart-manufacturing ecosystem across our knits operations.
Gearing Up for Greater Output with FLOCK Our fabric mill in Vietnam continued its large scale reconfiguration to advance the FLOCK manufacturing model. The year saw the successful installation and commissioning of new machines in the relocated knitting area, marking a major step forward in optimising process flow and strengthening the mill’s capacity for future output growth. The AS/RS in the greige warehouse also commenced operation, delivering significant benefits: increased storage volume, doubled utilisation capacity, a four-fold improvement in work-in-progress levels through just-in-time movement, enhanced data visibility through dashboards, high inventory accuracy, strict first in, first out compliance, and preventive maintenance capabilities. The mill is now developing an AS/RS for the yarn warehouse and planning to expand the use of AGVs from the dyeing plant to the finishing processes.
46
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
47
Driving Innovative Manufacturing
Towards a Fully Smart Denim Operation Our denim factory in Vietnam continued to advance its smart manufacturing transformation, a journey guided by four strategic pillars: • • • •
Smart Warehouse Management System Smart AGV System Smart Cutting System Intelligent Production Lines
Building on the previous progress made, the factory made notable strides in 2025. The newly launched AS/RS enabled accessory warehouse marked a major step forward, replacing manual sorting and record keeping with automated storage allocation and real-time inventory capture. This system design also reduced floor space requirements by 60%, without compromising storage capacity. In parallel, the cutting workshop shifted its focus from individual automation tools to deeper process integration. AI vision technologies were expanded to enhance data acquisition and automated decision making, helping close the gaps between previously isolated automated processes. Several of these innovations were further adopted by our sister factory in Cambodia, reinforcing cross-factory learning.
Enterprise Resources Integration System Integrated Process Planning & Scheduling Kanban & Logistics System
Manufacturing Execution System Machinery Management System
Smart Laundry
Smart Sewing
AGV System
Scan & Pack System RFID
Automatic Sewing Operation
Smart AGV deployment also progressed on multiple fronts. AGVs now operate reliably between the warehouse and cutting area, and another fleet manages transport between sewing workshop and the washing laundry. Planning for an inter-workshop AGV system is underway, with implementation targeted for 2026. Complementing these developments, the factory continued to roll out intelligent production lines across multiple processes, underpinned by RFID-enabled tracking that enhances visibility over the production status and movement of semi-finished products. With the washing hanger line already in operation and additional smart lines completing assessments, the factory was well positioned to advance wider-scale adoption of intelligent production lines. Together, these upgrades support the factory’s roadmap to complete its smart transformation by 2026 and strengthen its readiness for a significant capacity increase expected by 2029.
Smart Marker System
Auto Cutting
AGV System
Auto Planning System
Smart Warehouse
48
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Warehouse Management System Shade Blanket & Shrinkage System
Smart Warehouse
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
49
Driving Innovative Manufacturing
Inno:D – Innovative Design Process Crystal Denim embraces smart design and product creation through its innovative design process (“Inno:D”), which integrates AI and digital tools at every stage. This approach breaks traditional barriers and delivers reliable, fully vertical services – from product strategy to decision making support – for customers.
Integrating insights from these platforms enabled the design team to respond swiftly and bring the right products to market at the right time. This data-driven approach not only enhanced decision-making process but also minimised the risk of overproduction during sampling and ensured closer alignment between our output and actual consumer demand.
Research
Create
Share
Make
Achieve
AI Market Intelligence
AI-Enabled Generative Design
Digital Communication Board
Digital Product Creation
AI-Powered Presentation Design
Our Artificial Intelligence Market Intelligence system (“A.I.M.I.”) strengthened the team’s capabilities in trend forecasting and product strategy for brand customers. By leveraging three complementary digital platforms, A.I.M.I. delivered faster, more comprehensive and precise market insights than traditional research approaches: • • •
Crystal Big Data – In-house analytics platform that tracks and evaluates data from our denim products, uncovering long-term shifts and patterns in historical trends Runway Analysis – Monitoring of upcoming runway trends to anticipate emerging fashion influences and translate them into actionable design directions Social Media Trend Forecast – Real-time review of global social media content, analysing millions of posts each day and using AI-based visual recognition to identify current style movements and predict future trends
Partnering with HKUST and HKRITA on AI Integration Crystal is joining forces with The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology (“HKUST”) and the Hong Kong Research Institute of Textiles and Apparel (“HKRITA”) to accelerate AI-driven smart manufacturing in the textile industry. The collaboration will develop Textile-GPT, a large language model to enhance intelligent design, optimise production process, streamline supply chain management, automate quality inspections, and foster innovation in smart wearables. The partnership also includes establishing a Textile AI Innovation Hub, promoting AI-as-a-Service (“AlaaS”), and nurturing “AI + Textiles” talent to support industry-wide transformation.
50
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
51
Product Responsibility Quality Management System In accordance with our corporate mission and our value of “Live Quality”, our Quality Policy contributes to sustainable and profitable growth by guiding the delivery of products and services that delight customers, underpinned by our Group quality management system (“QMS”) based on legal and customer requirements, recognised best practices, and requirements related to product labelling, safety, and environment. Our concept of quality covers the totality of our operations, through which we deliver the right goods and services to our customers at the right time and at the right cost. To achieve “Right First Time” and “Quality Managed at Source”, we implement quality standards throughout our operations holistically. From product design through raw material sourcing, production and packaging, to inventory storage and delivery, we ensure compliance with the quality standards and specifications of our company, customers, and the supply chain.
Digitalised Quality Management We launched the Group QMS digitalisation project to build a standardised, end-to-end digital quality assurance platform across all operations. This initiative aims to replace manual inspections and paper-based records, unify fragmented inspection data, and incorporate flexibility for different customer requirements. The digital QMS will provide real-time data visibility, faster responses to issues, better insights, and seamless integration with other group-wide systems. At the factory level, our knits factory in China advanced its own quality-digitalisation efforts. The Manufacturing Execution System (“MES”) was rolled out to enable end-to-end digitalisation of QA inspections – from cutting and value-added processes (“VAP”) to sewing, washing, and finishing. With connected data now readily accessible, the factory can leverage advanced analytics to support more informed decisions and more effective problem solving.
Our QMS, in line with international standards, applies the concept of PDCA – Plan, Do, Check, Act, focusing on prevention rather than detection or correction. This enables us to drive process effectiveness and continuous improvement, and to manage and deliver quality products systematically. 12 of our factories are certified with ISO 9001 Quality Management System certification. We will continue to extend this globally recognised standard certification to more Group operations.
Everyone Plays a Part in Quality At our sportswear factory in Vietnam, quality was strengthened through shared ownership across all levels. Top Management at the Production Line Regular top-management audits – led by the factory general manager, regional QA general manager – brought leadership directly onto the production floor to review processes, product workmanship, and compliance. Complementing this, cross-functional gemba walks united teams from production, product development, and technical service support to observe real-time operations and identify early risks. Building End-User Awareness across All Functions To broaden this shared responsibility beyond the production lines, employees from a wide range of departments took part in the “We Are Consumers” programme and retail store visits. By experiencing products from an end-user’s perspective and evaluating the quality of both our own products and those of industry peers, colleagues from production planning, merchandising, finishing, and even equipment maintenance gained a deeper appreciation of how their individual roles influence the final product on the rack. Empowering Frontline Teams through Recognition and Knowledge Quarterly Quality Days further reinforced collective ownership of quality by celebrating the best sewing lines and spotlighting the contributions of frontline workers, with winning teams sharing proven practices for others to learn from. Together, these efforts underscored that quality excellence is not confined to a single department – it is a mindset embraced by everyone, from the production floor to supporting functions.
52
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
53
Product Responsibility
Our Quality Performance
Handling Product Complaints and Recalls
We have a corporate quality scorecard with targets to demonstrate our quality performance in achieving customers’ expectations.
A complaint is defined as any written or verbal statement made by our customers that indicates their dissatisfaction with our product quality. Such complaints may include product recalls, in which customers request to return, exchange, or replace products when defects are identified that could:
Customer Final Inspection Pass Rate (“CFIR”) Group target: ≥ 99.5% 2025 result: 99.9%
• • •
Hinder performance Incur product safety issues Lead to legal consequences
Observed Quality Level (“OQL”) Group target: ≤ 2.5% 2025 result: 0.84%
Quality Claim Group target: ≤ 0.1% to sales turnover 2025 result: 0.087%
Any compliant received is handled according to our complaint-handling procedure. Line management reviews and validates the complaint, while the relevant factory and sales teams investigate the case, identify root causes, and take corrective actions. The Corporate Quality and Sustainability Department (“CQS”) and factory teams then monitor these corrections, and a designated department such as Sales or factory Quality Assurance, is responsible for timely communication with the customer until the case is fully resolved and the customer is satisfied.
Product Safety
The CQS logs all valid complaints, including any product recalls, and reports them to the Executive Committee (“Execo”) twice a year as part of the Group’s key risk management system. In 2025, there were no valid product quality complaints or product recalls.
Our Product Safety Guidelines, embedded with customer and legal safety requirements, include preventive measures starting from product development and throughout the production processes, to ensure that our products are physically and chemically safe.
Intellectual Property Rights
In addition, we review the Corporate Product Restricted Substances List (“RSL”) annually and update it where appropriate, to ensure that our supply chain partners use compliant chemicals only during manufacturing processes, with no unsafe chemicals in final products. In 2025, 469 million pieces of products were shipped, with no product recalled due to safety or health reasons.
We acknowledge the importance of intellectual property (“IP”) rights, and work to protect and promote IP assets, such as patents, trademarks, and copyrights. We implement control measures including patent and trademark registration, as well as regular monitoring of IP registration. We promote awareness among employees of our responsibility to make IP an integral part of our daily operations. By implementing the control measures, physical and information technology security management is adopted to protect IP rights and company equity. Our Execo is also informed of the status of IP registration monitoring and any infringement cases biannually, as a part of our key risk management system.
Note: • Product advertising is not material to our garment and textile manufacturing business.
54
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
55
Supply Chain Management Supply Chain Sustainability Management Strategy Supply chain partners are a vital component in achieving the Group’s sustainability targets. We have applied meticulous diligence during supplier selection, and have designated the following indicators as key criteria for supplier qualification assessment. • Cost • Quality performance
• Delivery • Social and environmental sustainability performance
In 2025, our material procurement involved fabrics and trims sourced from 20 key suppliers, each accounting for no less than 1% of our total material expenditure. Geographically, all of these suppliers were headquartered within the Asia Pacific region.
Deploying Traceability Solutions Blockchain Platforms and Tracer Technologies We continued collaborating with our customers to implement both fibre-forward and garment-backward traceability programmes, utilising a range of solutions such as blockchain platforms, tracer technologies, and DNA testing. Across these programmes, we identified opportunities for improvement, while our teams also contributed practical feedback aimed at streamlining operational processes.
Embedding Fibre Integrity into Production Workflow Our denim division has begun supporting a customer’s material traceability programme through the use of FibreTrace, a real-time solution that verifies fibre integrity. As a garment vendor, our factories performed inbound fabric inspections and outbound checks on finished garments using FibreTrace handheld scanners. The scanners read the unique infrared signature of pigments embedded in the fibre at the raw material stage, allowing immediate confirmation of fibre identity and origin. Building on the initial implementation during the year, the use of FibreTrace physical verification is expected to expand to about 60% of this customer’s orders in 2026.
Material Traceability We play an important role to support our customers’ traceability programmes, which are fundamental to product authenticity, sustainability, and transparency. As a tier-one supplier, we serve as a key link that connects brand customers with upstream suppliers, enabling effective collaboration across the value chain. Leading by a dedicated corporate team, we‘ve built a fully traceable journey from raw materials to finished products. Our traceability initiatives include:
Maintaining material origins records
56
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Auditing suppliers
Monitoring regulatory and market updates
Communicating with stakeholders
Proactive Stakeholder Communications We actively engaged with solution providers to stay informed about emerging traceability technologies and tools, while continually monitored customer expectations and regulatory developments across our markets and operating countries. These updates were regularly communicated to suppliers through training and audits, and were shared internally with relevant teams, including Sales and Merchandising. This ongoing exchange reinforced the preparedness of both our company and value chain to adapt effectively to rapidly evolving traceability requirements.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
57
Supply Chain Management
Corporate Supply Chain Management Procedure
Managing Environmental and Social Risks along Supply Chain
To provide a standardised guideline for supplier management process across our operations, we have established the Corporate Supply Chain Management Procedure. The Procedure covers a structured approach for screening and onboarding potential suppliers, and defines the roles and responsibilities of management and relevant staff throughout the supplier management process. It also outlines the nature and frequency of supplier reviews, as well as the consequences arising from suppliers’ non-compliance with our requirements.
Environmental and social risks in our supply chain refer to any practices that deviate from our established compliance framework or incidents that may adversely impact workers’ wellbeing, including: • • • •
We regularly monitor and evaluate risks to identify and mitigate significant environmental and social impacts in our supply chain through methods including:
Through these measures, the Procedure not only mitigates risks and supports product quality and regulatory compliance, but also strengthens our supply chain resilience and advances the Group’s overall strategic objectives. Designated staff from line companies and factories have received training on the Procedure and its implementation to promote consistent application across the Group.
Governing Policies and Requirements to Suppliers Based on the requirements stipulated in the above-mentioned Procedure, we only approve suppliers which are able to meet the Group’s minimum requirements on social and environmental compliance, including: • • • •
Violations of local regulatory requirements Non-compliance with our Code of Conduct or internal policies Failure to meet the minimum requirements outlined in the Corporate Supply Chain Management Procedure Incidents that impair workers’ human rights, health and safety, or result in labour disputes
• • • •
Questionnaires Onsite visits Suppliers’ self-assessments or third-party audit reports NGO platforms
At the corporate level, the key risk management system oversees the identification and mitigation of supply chain risks. All identified risks are managed by designated corporate functions to develop and implement appropriate mitigation measures, and to review their measure effectiveness and risk exposure on an ongoing basis. Our reporting framework ensures that environmental and social performance, along with associated risks, is communicated to management on a regular basis, and immediately in significant cases such as work stoppages, severe injuries, or fatalities. Significant risks are also reported to the Executive Committee (“Execo”) in a timely manner.
Prohibition of child labour Prohibition of forced labour Adherence to local minimum wage standards Compliance with local environmental regulations
For the Group’s key suppliers, adherence to the aforementioned requirements and local regulatory standards is complemented by our ongoing close communication. This ensures they are kept closely aligned with and fully compliant with the following Crystal’s policies as part of our supplier relationship management: • • • •
Code of Conduct Environmental Policy Restricted Substances List (“RSL”) Brand Protection Policy
• • • •
Social Compliance Policy Anti-Corruption Policy Quality Policy Customer-specific requirements
We oversee and support our suppliers in achieving quality, social, and environmental compliance, thereby reinforcing the sustainability and operational reliability of our supply chain. Through collaborative partnerships, we engaged with suppliers to explore new development opportunities in line with customer needs, market dynamics, and technological progress. To further strengthen supplier capabilities, we also conduct training, audits, and risk evaluations.
58
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Supply Chain Management
Green Supply Chain
Supply Chain Engagement
To advance an environmentally responsible supply chain, our Corporate Supply Chain Management Procedure outlines clear environmental criteria for evaluating and selecting suppliers. Preference is given to suppliers who minimise negative environmental impacts by adopting good environmental practices such as:
Establishing carbon and water reduction targets
Committing to low-carbon and energy-efficient manufacturing
Implementing water-efficient practices
Diverting waste from landfill
Obtaining certification for sustainable materials or products
Adopting green chemistries
Developing environmental management systems (e.g. ISO 14001)
Conducting regular wastewater testing per industry standard ZDHC
The Corporate Quality and Sustainability Department (“CQS”), line companies, and factories are responsible for tracking and monitoring supplier performance according to the above criteria.
IPE Environmental Supervision for Suppliers As a platform based in China, Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs (“IPE”) serves as one of our key tools for monitoring environmental compliance and performance of suppliers. By reviewing the information disclosed on the platform, we can identify any environmental incidents occurring within our supply chain in China. In the event of violations, we follow up with the concerned supplier immediately. In 2025, no environmental violations were reported on IPE.
Empowering Supplier Data Management Building on our comprehensive environmental data management system, we shared our expertise with suppliers and encouraged them to establish their own environmental databases. This has strengthened their ability to monitor and track performance, enabling them to meet the customer requirements of various data platforms, such as comMIT, EMeReT, and SpheraCloud Corporate Sustainability.
Climate Outreach Program To drive decarbonisation across our value chain, three of Crystal Denim’s subcontractor facilities participated in the Climate Outreach Program, jointly initiated by the Apparel Impact Institute (“Aii”) and one of our brand customers. The Carbon Target Assessment (“CTA”) and Carbon Target Setting (“CTS”) of the programme helped the facilities to measure baseline carbon footprints, establish reduction targets, and develop actionable decarbonisation plans. Each participating facility formed a project committee team for continuous engagement and maintaining transparent communications. Their active involvement not only strengthened their emissions-reduction roadmaps but also contributed to collective climate actions across our broader supply chain.
Participation in Biodiversity Training To strengthen our supply chain’s understanding of nature-related risks, five of our subcontractor facilities participated in a biodiversity risk analysis and a training organised by one of our customers in 2025. The training provided foundational knowledge on biodiversity and its relevance to business, helping participants understand how industrial operations interact with ecosystems and importance of biodiversity for long-term sustainability, regulatory readiness, and risk management. By engaging our subcontractors alongside our own factories, the programme enhanced the collective capability to address nature-related risks and environmental stewardship across the broader supply chain network.
60
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
61
Resourcing People “Respect for people” is one of our corporate values. At Crystal, we respect, protect, and promote human rights, provide a workplace that is healthy, safe, equitable, inclusive, and diverse, where every employee feels a sense of belonging and warmth.
Labour Standards We adopt a zero-tolerance policy against child and forced labour, and strictly adhere to the International Labour Organization (“ILO”) conventions. In line with ILO guidelines, we have established group-wide policies, and we conduct unannounced spot checks to monitor compliance. In 2025, there were no instances of child labour in our factories or within our supply chain.
Preventing Child Labour Our recruitment teams receive regular training on identifying potential child labour cases, ensuring they are equipped with the necessary knowledge to recognise and address related risks. Clear remediation measures are activated immediately should any instance of child labour be identified. The measures include: • • • • •
Immediate removal from the workplace Full payment of earned wages Arrangement of a free medical examination and treatment if required Safe return to the custody of the guardian Launch of an internal investigation and timely remediation of system gaps
Eliminating Forced Labour We strictly prohibit all forms of forced labour in our operations, including bonded, indentured, prison, and slave labour, and enforce this commitment through clear policies, internal assessment procedures, and regular monitoring.
Code of Conduct and Social Compliance Policies
To uphold transparency and fairness in compensation, all employee wages are paid directly and exclusively via bank transfer to their personal accounts. This direct payment system protects employees’ rights, prevents unauthorised deductions, and ensures they receive the full wages they have earned.
Our Code of Conduct, Social Compliance Policies, and Master Policies articulate our commitment to operating not only in full compliance with local laws, but also in alignment with the high standards of social responsibility, environmental protection, and ethical business conduct. These policies are built upon the following core criteria:
Risk Monitoring and Reporting Channels
• • • • • •
No child or forced labour No discrimination, harassment, or abuse Equal opportunity and fair compensation Reasonable working hours and adequate rest A healthy and safe workplace Employee wellbeing and welfare
The Corporate Quality and Sustainability Department (“CQS”) conducts annual internal risk assessments across all factories to identify potential child and forced labour risks. When risks or violations are identified, we prioritise remediating affected parties and implementing corrective actions to eliminate or mitigate these risks. In addition, all of our factories provide multiple reporting channels – including smartphone apps, HR and factory general manager hotlines, unions, and worker representatives – for workers to report potential human rights violations. All reported cases are thoroughly investigated by factory management and escalated to CQS when necessary.
To maintain compliance, our factories undertake regular internal assessment to systematically verify compliance with the above mentioned Code of Conduct and policies.
62
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
63
Resourcing People
Supply Chain Compliance We hold our suppliers to the same stringent standards, where any form of child labour or forced labour is unacceptable. Our zero-tolerance policy is clearly communicated to suppliers from the very beginning of our engagement. Additionally, the CQS may conduct unannounced audit of the suppliers. If any violation is identified, it will be immediately escalated to the management and may trigger the initiation of a supplier exit process.
Social and Labor Convergence Program As a signatory manufacturer of the Social and Labor Convergence Program (“SLCP”), we adopted the Converged Assessment Framework (“CAF”) Data Collection Tool to streamline our social compliance assessments. Through this initiative, we shared our SLCP verification reports via the accredited host – the Higg Facility Social and Labor Module (“FSLM”). This industry-aligned approach reduces the burden of repetitive social audits by customers or third parties, and enables us to dedicate more resources towards improving working conditions and strengthening supply chain transparency.
Better Work High Performance Factory
Safeguarding Employee Health and Safety A healthy, safe, and comfortable working environment is fundamental for employees to work effectively and feel fulfilled. Our Group Code of Conduct, Master Policy, and Social Compliance Policy clearly stipulates requirements for workplace safety, while the Corporate Social Compliance Manual provides detailed guidance on specific safety indicators for factory implementation. Every factory within our Group has established an occupational health and safety (“OHS”) management system to ensure compliance with local regulations, customer standards, and industry benchmarks. A robust OHS management system not only mitigates the risk of operational disruption from lost workdays, but also creates opportunities to enhance worker efficiency, wellbeing, and operational resilience of all factories in the long run. For effective system implementation, each factory has designated personnel, whose duties include: • • • • • •
Developing OHS policies and procedures Creating and implementing action plans Formulating emergency preparedness Providing training and capacity building Conducting risk assessments Monitoring performance and implementing improvements
As a globally recognised standard, ISO 45001 represents a benchmark of excellence in OHS management system. As of 2025, seven of our factories have achieved ISO 45001 certification. The implementation has strengthened our factories’ ability to identify, assess, and control workplace hazards, thereby reducing the risk of accidents and occupational illnesses. It has also enhanced operational discipline through clear roles, documented procedures, and continuous monitoring. We remain dedicated to extending this certification to more factories.
Four of our garment factories in Vietnam were recognised as Better Work High Performance Factories for consistently demonstrating their: • • • •
64
High level of compliance with publicly reported issues Mature level of social dialogue Effective management systems to sustain changes Commitment to learning for sustainable development
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
65
Resourcing People
Rate of Fatalities and Work Injuries
Dietary Support for Hydration
Injury cases are defined as cases that have been reported to local governments with medical and insurance claims, and that resulted in at least four lost days each. These data were tracked by our factories with the use of injury and investigation logs. In 2025, 0.01% of the total working person-days across the Group’s operations were lost as leave taken by employees owing to work injuries. There were a total of 150 work injury cases, accounting for 2,835 lost workdays. Work-related fatality refers to death arising from exposure to hazards at work or commuting incidents where transportation is provided by the Company. During the reporting year, we recorded zero work-related fatalities. Year
2025
2024
2023
Number of work-related fatalities Rate of work-related fatalities
0 0.0%
1 0.001%
0 0.0%
As part of our dietary support during hot months, the canteen in our Vietnam knits factory refreshed its menus with hydrating dishes and prepared iced beverages to help employees stay comfortable. Meanwhile in Bangladesh, our factories provided employees with a cooling traditional jaggery lemonade that is nourishing, digestion-aiding, and naturally energising.
Structural, Fire, and Electrical Safety Driven by a shared commitment to upholding worker wellness across global supply chains, structural, fire, and electrical safety have been an increasing concern of our customers and stakeholders. As an integral part of our operational integrity and social responsibility, our Corporate Construction and Facilities Department (“CFD”), staffed with licensed experts, oversees and ensures compliance in structural, fire, and electrical safety across all our factories. •
Our factories in Vietnam and Cambodia actively participate in the Life and Building Safety (“LABS”) Initiative, an industry-led programme the dedicated to advancing workplace safety in apparel and footwear supply chains. In early 2026, our sportswear factory in Cambodia graduated from the LABS Initiative after completing a series of assessments and upgrades to its building structures, electrical systems, and fire safety systems.
•
In Bangladesh, our factories engage with the Ready-Made Garments Sustainability Council (“RSC”) to systematically enhance structural, fire, and electrical safety standards.
•
For our factories in China, we take part in functionally similar programmes such as Critical Life and Safety (“CLS”), a proprietary safety initiative led by one of our key customers.
Protecting Employees from Heat Stress To safeguard employees from rising heat stress, our factories implemented a range of measures to improve employees’ physical wellness during the hottest months.
Worker Comfort through Air-Conditioning In Vietnam, our knits factory continued expanding its air-conditioning coverage across multiple production blocks, installing high-efficiency water-cooled chillers with inverter controls, fresh-air optimisation, and condensate-based pre-cooling features that delivered cooling for workers in a low-carbon way. This investment is expected to support worker productivity and workforce stability. To complement these upgrades, employees were encouraged to dress lightly during hot periods.
These initiatives are in common conducting comprehensive safety assessments by qualified engineers to evaluate both hardware (e.g. building structure, electrical systems, fire safety equipment) and software (e.g. safety procedures, emergency protocols) setup. Each programme also includes training and capacity-building components for relevant personnel. By the end of 2025, the majority of our factories enrolled in these initiatives have completed all identified improvements, earning strong recognition from our customers and stakeholders.
Our intimate factories in Vietnam distributed vitamin C effervescent tablets to all employees to prevent heat-related illnesses.
Through these structured, programme-driven efforts, we have built robust protection for our employees. This multi-faceted approach not only mitigated risks but also fostered a culture of safety, reinforced operational resilience, and aligned our operations with internationally recognised best practices. Fire prevention and fighting drill at our denim factory in Vietnam.
66
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
67
Resourcing People
Gender Equality, Maternity and Parenting Support Our work to promote gender equality and provide maternity and parenting support continued throughout the year. We remained committed to cultivating a workplace culture grounded in equal opportunity, mutual respect, and healthy work-life balance. As the status of women is set to improve in many of our operating countries, our factories took proactive measures to further advance gender equality. We delivered a range of programmes – from cervical cancer screenings and contraception counselling to menopause awareness sessions and gender-based violence campaigns. These initiatives empowered our female employees and contributed to their overall wellness.
Advancing Gender Equality and Women Empowerment W e deepened partnerships and expanded impactful training across our operations. We became a member of the Reimagining Industry to Support Equality (“RISE”) initiative – joining a global movement dedicated to advancing equitable workplaces throughout global garment supply chain. A key milestone in this journey was the rollout of the RISE Respect programme – locally known as SERI Respect – at our intimate factory in Vietnam. The first cohort of 190 trained Change Makers completed a comprehensive genderequality curriculum and actively participated in dialogue sessions to address workplace gender issues. The factory also established a formal Anti-Sexual Harassment Committee that was supported by expert-led training on preventing and handling sexual harassment cases, reinforcing a safer and more respectful work environment for all employees. Our factories in Vietnam, China, and Cambodia sustained strong momentum in Gap Inc.’s P.A.C.E. programme. Hundreds of women completed modules covering communication, problem-solving, health and self-confidence, benefitting from supportive learning environments that encouraged personal growth and leadership.
68
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Nurturing New Life, Supporting Every Family Caring for Expectant Moms Across our operations, we remained focused on enhancing the wellness of pregnant workers. A strong demonstration was seen in our knits and intimate factories in China, where the long-running Caring for Expectant Moms campaign provided expert-led workshops by local hospitals, practical pregnancy knowledge sharing, and psychological consultations. These activities offered emotional reassurance and created a warm, community-centred experience for mothers-to-be. Providing Comprehensive Prenatal-to-Postnatal Guidance Another meaningful effort was implemented in our denim factory in Cambodia, where maternal-health initiatives fostered an engaging learning environment. Pregnant workers actively discussed nutrition, prenatal care and newborn health, turning these sessions into empowering platforms that strengthened their confidence in caring for themselves and their babies. From free gynaecological examinations and reproductive health consultations in Vietnam, to infant-feeding awareness sessions during World Breastfeeding Week in Bangladesh, and pregnancy health talks on safety and nutrition in Cambodia, our operations helped nurture a caring and supportive ecosystem for women and families.
Creating Meaningful Parent-Child Experiences through “Family Day” Beyond maternity care, we also extended support to working parents by fostering family connection. Our sportswear factories in Vietnam and Cambodia celebrated Family Day with a brand customer, inviting employees’ children to visit the workplace and participate in engaging parent-child activities. The events strengthened family bonds, nurtured pride among workers, and showcased our commitment to creating a supportive environment for every family within Crystal.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
69
Resourcing People
Employee Wellness
Mental
Physical
Ensuring our employees’ mental wellness is equally important to achieving our sustainability goals. We support our workforce in managing everyday stresses and strive to create a workplace where every individual feels a strong sense of belonging and connection to the team.
To encourage an active lifestyle, we established sports centres or sports grounds across our operations, providing employees with convenient access to recreational facilities. In addition, we regularly organised wellness initiatives such as health assessments, enabling employees to identify potential health concerns early and seek timely treatment.
Fostering Mental Wellness through Virtual Engagement Our intimate factories in Vietnam boosted employees’ mental wellness through two online engagement activities. One activity invited employees to complete seven daily positivity challenges – such as sharing gratitude, reflecting on proud moments, and capturing happy experiences – via the factories’ social media page, generating meaningful stories and uplifting interactions. The other activity guided employees to reflect on kindness through a video and quiz on the selfdeveloped CARE mobile application.
Bringing Clarity Back to Vision 10 of our garment factories and fabric mills in Vietnam, Bangladesh and Cambodia partnered with nonprofits such as VisionSpring and The Fred Hollows Foundation to offer free vision screenings for employees. Over 34,000 workers received onsite vision checks conducted by eye-care professionals, and nearly 11,700 who were diagnosed with refractive errors received quality eyeglasses free of charge, making a meaningful difference for those who had long experienced compromised vision.
With close to 5,000 interactions, these activities fostered positive morale and encouraged supportive exchanges among colleagues.
Talent Acquisition We aim to be an employer of choice that attracts and retains the most engaged and talented individuals. All our employees are treated with respect and have equal opportunities to succeed, contributing to the continuous improvement of the Company. We have established Master Policies on Human Resources that cover organisational development, recruitment, promotion, compensation, benefits, performance management, human resources development, and disciplinary and grievance procedures. The aim of these policies is to: • • • • •
70
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Improve recruitment quality and efficiency Identify and develop employees with high potential Establish reward strategies Ensure internal equity and improve retention Promote a work environment that values open communication, accountability, trust, and mutual respect
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
71
Resourcing People
Workforce Breakdown
Monthly Average Employee Turnover Rate
Crystal had approximately 81,000 employees at the close of 2025, of which 31.7% were male and 68.3% were female.
Our monthly average employee turnover rate (voluntary) was 2.5%, with voluntary turnover referring to employees who resign of their own accord, excluding dismissals and retirements. This rate is calculated by dividing the number of employees who willingly left employment in 2025 by the total year-end number of employees, then averaging over 12 months.
Notes: • The workforce figures include all garment and textile manufacturing facilities across five operating countries, our headquarters and offices in Asia. • Our workforce comprises full-time employees, except for four part-time staff. • All employees meet the minimum working age required by the customers and applicable local laws and regulations.
By Gender
2.9% Male By Region and Gender Country
%
Male
Female
Vietnam China Cambodia Bangladesh Sri Lanka Hong Kong and other offices in Asia
52.8% 15.4% 13.1% 12.5% 5.7% 0.5%
32.0% 31.8% 20.7% 44.0% 26.6% 40.6%
68.0% 68.2% 79.3% 56.0% 73.4% 59.4%
Total
100%
31.7%
68.3%
2.3% Female By Region Vietnam China Cambodia Bangladesh Sri Lanka Hong Kong and other offices in Asia
2.8% 2.0% 1.2% 1.9% 4.3% 0.6%
By Age Group
By Age Group 1.0%
55 46–55 9.5%
18–25
18–25 26–35 36–45 46–55
55
3.9% 2.5% 1.7% 1.2% 1.0%
19.3%
31.4%
Peer Support for Settling in New Joiners
Age % 39.0%
36–45 26–35
E arly employment stage is crucial to engagement and retention. Our denim factory in Vietnam and knits factory in Bangladesh introduced peer-mentoring approaches to better support newly joined workers. In Bangladesh, experienced workers acted as buddies who guided newcomers through daily tasks and helped them settle smoothly into the workplace. In Vietnam, a similar network of volunteer mentors regularly checked in on new colleagues, offering encouragement, supportive listening, and timely assistance during their adjustment period. By fostering early connections and a sense of belonging, these people-focused initiatives contributed to a more engaged and stable workforce over time.
72
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
73
Resourcing People
Talent Grooming Our Master Policies on Human Resources provides clear guidelines to support employee development and build a culture of continuous professional development. Through training, education, and development activities, we strive to develop a skills base and intellectual capital in the Group to ensure qualified personnel for our present and future needs.
Programmed Training Breakdown By Gender Gender
% Trained
Average Training Hours
Female Male
73.6% 75.3%
16.1 23.1
Total
74.2%
18.6
% Trained
Average Training Hours
Executive Manager Officer General Staff Worker
82.4% 89.4% 82.6% 73.3% 73.3%
11.0 20.4 12.9 8.4 19.8
Total
74.2%
18.6
By Job Level Grade
Training Data In 2025, a total of 9,790,781 hours of training were provided, including: • •
8,104,409 hours of customer-requirement training 1,686,372 hours of programmed training
Each of our current and former employees received an average of 80.3 hours of training. Customer-requirement training consists mainly of worker-oriented morning briefings, on-the-job training, and refresher briefings on customer requirements and quality standards. Programmed training includes structured and classroom training activities in management and leadership skills, technical skills, communication skills, female empowerment, talent development, and compliance. The percentage of employees who received programmed training by gender and job level is tabulated below. However, the breakdown information does not reflect customer-requirement training due to the unavailability of relevant data.
74
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
75
Resourcing People
Learning and Development Recognising the strategic importance of leadership and talent development, we continued to invest resources to help our people grow and strengthen our talent pipeline. Our group-wide training programme covered all our employees at different levels for their personal and career growth. Targets
Examples of training programme
Workers
• CARE • Production • Language • Labour practices • Financial literacy • Assistant Supervisor Programme
Structuring Learning and Development for Employee Growth To nurture a resilient and future-ready workforce, we continued to invest in building the capabilities of our right-level managers – supporting them in leveraging their strengths, expanding their skillsets, and confidently taking on new challenges. • Crystal Manager Training Curriculum: A total of 72 management training workshops were delivered across Vietnam, China, Cambodia, and Bangladesh. • Crystal Officer Training Curriculum: 84 skill-based workshops were organised to empower our officers. This newly rollout strengthened our efforts to attract, engage, and retain young talent and supported equitable development.
Crystal Associate Programme and Talent Programme
Supervisors and line leaders
• Supervisory and management skill
Officer-grade staff
• Crystal Officer Training Curriculum
The Associate Programme and Talent Programme are integral to our Learning and Development strategy, supporting both mid- and long-term succession planning. We systematically identify potential successors and develop them through targeted training, job rotations, and exposure with regular mentoring and review, ensuring a steady pipeline of talent ready for key roles.
Managerial-grade staff
• Crystal Manager Training Curriculum • Talent Acceleration Programme
In 2025, our focus was on engaging and empowering younger talent, encouraging them to actively shape their careers and contribute to our organisational success.
Executives
• Action Learning Project
Transforming Worker Potential into Leadership T he Assistant Supervisor Programme (“ASP”) in our knits division in Vietnam opened new pathways for workers to grow into bigger roles across more than 10 production processes, including cutting, sewing, linking, and packing. Through a structured six-month journey supported by over 40 internal trainers and cross-functional collaboration, the programme equipped participants with the technical and supervisory capabilities needed for their first leadership positions.
822
Learning hours for Talent Programme
6,652
Learning hours for Associate Programme
By the end of 2025, 130 high-potential workers completed the programme, and 102 of them were promoted – proudly “rising from the line” into Assistant Supervisor roles. Graduates shared how the programme helped them “gain confidence to lead” and “see a clearer future” at Crystal. ASP will continue to create meaningful advancement opportunities – transforming potential into leadership and strengthening our local talent pipeline.
76
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
77
Resourcing People
Employee Communications
Anti-Corruption
We treat our employees as part of the family, ensuring they are well informed and encouraged to communicate openly. Our operations maintain close connections with employees through a variety of channels, including regular worker representative meetings, informal gatherings, newsletters, mobile applications, and online social platforms.
To promote good business ethics and integrity across the Group, Crystal’s board of directors (“Board”) oversees a series of master policies, including the following, which have been established and are available on the corporate intranet for all staff with computer access:
Management connects with employees periodically through webcasts to share updates and strengthen dialogue. In addition, structured channels such as pulse surveys and anonymous grievance mechanisms allow workers to share their views in a secure and respectful manner.
New Counselling Space for Open Dialogue To provide a trusted channel for dialogue, our knits factory in Bangladesh introduced a new counselling room. The facility complements existing counselling areas on sewing floors available throughout the working day, while the newly added room near the canteen offers support during lunch hours for greater accessibility. Beyond ensuring privacy, the space strengthens trust, encourages open communication, and deepens worker-management relationships.
• • • • • •
Conflict of Interest Anti-Bribery Anti-Money Laundering Anti-Fraud Anti-Corruption (Vendor) Whistle-Blowing
The policies apply throughout the Group. Every director and employee is required to adhere to the policies as well as all applicable laws, rules, and regulations of the jurisdictions in which the Group operates. We adopt zero tolerance towards corruption and fraud. We carry out relevant corruption-prevention practices to maintain the highest standards of integrity, honesty, and fairness. Employees must avoid activities that conflict with the Group’s interests when performing their duties, and must not accept any form of bribery, reward, or inducement benefit, including payments, gifts, hospitality, or any improper personal, business, regulatory, and contractual advantage. In 2025, there were no legal cases regarding corrupt practices brought against the Company or our employees. We set up whistleblowing channels to allow employees and other relevant personnel to report corruption, fraud, dishonesty, or unlawful conduct confidentially. Upon receipt of a complaint, the Corporate Governance Office (“CGO”), headed by our Chairman of the Board, logs the case in a control register for tracking purposes. Where necessary, management or the CGO conducts independent investigations and takes follow-up actions. The control register is circulated to the Audit Committee for inspection on a quarterly basis, and a summary is submitted to the Board annually. Risks associated with corruption are assessed as part of the key risk management process. All whistleblowing cases received are treated in a confidential and sensitive manner. According to our non-retaliation principle, no whistle-blowers are victimised or disadvantaged for making a complaint.
Anti-Corruption and Code of Conduct Training It is our ongoing commitment to develop Crystal leaders who demonstrate strong ethical and compliance behaviours. In 2025, new executives and managers across our operating countries completed the mandated Anti-Corruption and Code of Conduct training, translating to a total of 403 training hours on related principles, including conflict of interest, anti-bribery, anti-money laundering, and whistleblowing.
78
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
79
Revitalising Community
Identifying Community Engagement Activities
Creating Shared Value with Communities
Recognising the unique needs of the communities where we operate, we support local government initiatives, uplift underprivileged groups, and contribute to environmental protection. We strive to balance these efforts while thoughtfully exploring new opportunities for community engagement.
Our business relies on the resources and infrastructure of the communities in which we operate. In return, we are committed to becoming an active and positive presence, contributing to their long-term wellbeing and shared prosperity. Through ongoing engagement with community members, local authorities, NGOs, and charitable organisations, we identify priority areas for our community initiatives. These include community activities, education, the environment, health and medical care, and community resilience. Each operation develops a local action plan to align its efforts with the specific needs of its surrounding community.
We work closely with local authorities, community organisations, and our customers to deliver meaningful and measurable contributions in our operating countries. To ensure responsible use of financial resources, our teams assess proposals and related investments before project implementation. We prioritise partnerships with like-minded organisations that share our commitment to building harmonious and resilient communities. While we aim to create lasting benefits through ongoing programmes, we also remain responsive to one-off initiatives that address urgent or specific societal needs. In 2025, our community contributions totalled approximately US$620,000 and over 9,600 person-hours, supporting initiatives that benefitted around 62,000 people.
Making a Difference in the Community A Heartfelt Day Connecting with Children in Care Our sportswear factory team in Cambodia, together with representatives from some of our customers, spent a heartfelt day at a local orphanage. They donated food items, household supplies, and educational materials to support the children’s daily needs and learning. The factory also shared practical life skills by teaching older children simple hand-sewing, mending, and basic garment-packing techniques. To bring joy and connection, the team organised fun games, reading and colouring activities, and prepared a warm, home-cooked meal for everyone.
Planting for the Future: Protecting Biodiversity and Restoring Landscapes In line with the Group’s target to plant two million trees by 2030, we have planted 525,000 trees across Vietnam, China, Cambodia, Bangladesh, and Sri Lanka. These efforts were implemented thoughtfully to ensure long-term benefits for local ecosystems and communities. Notably, our denim factory in Cambodia planted 30,000 mangrove saplings, helping protect coastal areas and enhance biodiversity. Other operations focused on native species planting and prioritised reforestation in areas damaged by extreme weather events, reinforcing the Group’s commitment to regenerating nature and climate resilience.
Collective Support for Flood-Affected Communities Advancing Health and Hygiene for Primary School Students Severe flooding during the year prompted coordinated relief efforts from our Vietnam operations. Employees from our knits division collectively raised around US$21,000, which was contributed through the Vietnam Fatherland Front Committee to support recovery for affected communities in the Central and Central Highlands regions. Our fabric mill also mobilised meaningful assistance by funding essential food and water supplies for families in need, delivered with the support of the Fire Prevention and Rescue Police team.
In collaboration with Crystal Climate Charity Foundation, our denim factory in Vietnam supported essential upgrades at a neighbouring primary school to improve students’ health and hygiene. The initiative delivered three advanced water purifiers with an 80L-per-hour capacity, ensuring reliable access to clean drinking water and reducing reliance on single-use plastic bottles. It also provided a new, well-ventilated washroom block and refurbished existing facilities to raise hygiene standards and safeguard the surrounding environment.
In Sri Lanka, cyclones brought torrential rains and landslides inundated one-fifth of the country. We provided immediate relief to 900 affected workers and their families, helping them regain stability during the crisis.
80
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
81
Awards and Recognition 10
17
12
10
11
Business Denim factory in Vietnam •
ESG Reporting and Sustainability
Business
Environment
Employee Care
Outstanding Business Awards, by the People’s Committee of Phu Tho Province
Community Service
Lifestyle wear factory in Vietnam •
Prestigious Export Enterprise Award 2024, by Ministry of Industry and Trade of Vietnam
Highlighted Awards and Recognition ESG Reporting and Sustainability
Environment Group
Group •
Hong Kong Sustainability Award 2025 – Distinction
•
Award (Large Organization Category), by the Hong
Commendation for the Best ESG Report – Mid-cap,
•
by Hong Kong ESG Reporting Awards 2025
Kong Management Association
•
Standard Chartered Corporate Achievement
•
Awards 2025 – Sustainable Corporate Leadership
Hong Kong Green Organisation, Wastewi$e Certificate and Energywi$e Certificate, by the Environmental Campaign Committee
•
Green Office and Eco-Healthy Workplace Awards Labelling Scheme, by the World Green Organisation
Commendation for the Carbon Neutral Award, by Hong Kong ESG Reporting Awards 2025
Award, by Standard Chartered
Lifestyle wear factory in China • •
•
2025 International ARC Awards: Silver Winner
•
Commendation for the Excellence in Environmental
– Specialized A.R.: Sustainability Report: Asia/
Positive Impact, by Hong Kong ESG Reporting
Pacific, by MerComm Inc.
Awards 2025
BOCHK Corporate Environmental Leadership Awards 2024: 10 Years+ EcoPioneer and EcoChallenger, by the Federation of Hong Kong Industries
2025 International ARC Awards: Bronze Winner – Interior Design: Sustainability Report: Asia/Pacific, by MerComm Inc.
Intimate factory in Bangladesh •
82
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
Low Carbon Manufacturing Programme – Gold Label by WWF Hong Kong
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
83
Awards and Recognition
Glossary Intimate factory in Vietnam •
National Energy Efficiency in Industry Award 2025 – Second Prize (Manufacturing Industry), with Special Prize for the Best Energy-saving Solution (Building Management System), by Steering Committee of the Vietnam National Energy Efficiency Programme under the Ministry of Industry and Trade (“MoIT”), the Vietnam Energy Conservation and Energy Efficiency Association (“VECEA”) and Deutsche Gesellschaft für Internationale Zusammenarbeit (“GIZ”)
Apparel Impact Institute (“Aii”)
The Aii is a nonprofit collective founded in 2017 by NGO and industry leaders. The organisation identifies, funds, and scales proven quality solutions to accelerate positive impact in the apparel and footwear industry.
Better Cotton
Better Cotton is a sustainability initiative that supports more responsible cotton farming. It enables the sourcing of cotton as a sustainable material through adopting sustainable farming practices, improving livelihoods and working conditions, protecting and restoring the environment.
Better Work
Better Work is a partnership between the International Labour Organization (“ILO”) and the International Finance Corporation (“IFC”). It brings together governments, employers’ and workers’ organisations, global brands, factory owners and workers to improve compliance with labour standards and promote competitiveness in global supply chains. The programme combines independent assessments with advisory and capacity building activities to support practical improvements in working conditions in supplier factories through workplace cooperation.
Biogenic emissions
Biogenic emissions are carbon dioxide emissions from the combustion or biodegradation of biomass.
CDP
Formerly the Carbon Disclosure Project, CDP is a global non-profit organisation that runs the world’s foremost environmental disclosure platform. It is one of the most recognised environmental reporting platforms, with a comprehensive dataset on corporate and city action, acknowledged by states and regions, cities, investors, and companies.
Converged Assessment Framework (“CAF”)
The CAF is a tool to measure working conditions in facilities developed by Social & Labor Convergence Program (“SLCP”) signatories. It consists of a data collection tool, verification methodology and guidance documents.
Crystal Advocates Respect and Engagement (“CARE”)
CARE is an employee wellbeing programme self-initiated by Crystal. It contains five levels to help employees build on their skills, promote a good work-life balance, strengthen their self-respect, enhance their sense of belonging and help them attain self-actualisation.
Customer final inspection pass rate (“CFIR”)
The CFIR is a measure of factory quality performance derived from analysing the first-time pass rate of a customer’s first-time final inspection.
Equivalent piece
Equivalent piece is a common unit to express our garments, produced and washed, by normalising the carbon emissions or water consumption respectively of our different product types.
Employee Care Crystal Headquarters, all factories and fabric mills in China and Vietnam, Singapore office •
Best Companies to Work for in Asia 2025, by HR Asia
Singapore office •
Employee Experience Awards 2025 Singapore – Most Innovative and Sustainable Office Design – Silver Award, by Human Resources Online
International Organization for Standardization (“ISO”) Certification •
ISO 9001 Quality Management System 12 factories in Vietnam, China, Cambodia, and Bangladesh
•
ISO 14001 Environmental Management System 9 factories in Vietnam and China
Facility Environmental Module (“FEM”)
The Higg FEM is one of the facility tools of the Higg Index that standardises how facilities measure and evaluate their environmental performance.
•
ISO 50001 Energy Management System 2 factories in Vietnam and China
Facility Social and Labor Module (“FSLM”)
•
ISO 45001 Occupational Health and Safety Management System 7 factories in Vietnam and China
The Higg FSLM is part of the Higg Index. It measures the social impact of manufacturing across areas such as wages, working hours, health and safety, and employee treatment.
Greenhouse gas (“GHG”)
GHGs are the gaseous constituents that absorb and hold heat in the atmosphere, that occur either naturally or due to human activities.
Higg Index
The Higg Index is a suite of tools developed by Cascale (formerly Sustainable Apparel Coalition) that enables brands, retailers and facilities to measure and score the sustainability performance of a company or product.
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate
IPCC is the United Nations body responsible for assessing the scientific,
Change (“IPCC”)
technical and socio-economic information related to climate change. IPCC synthesises research into authoritative assessments on climate impacts, risks, and pathways for mitigation and adaptation.
84
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
85
Glossary
International Renewable Energy
I-REC is a market-based instrument that certifies one megawatt-hour (MWh)
Certificate (“I-REC”)
of renewable electricity generation, which is used to substantiate renewable
Reimagining Industry to Support Equality (“RISE”)
RISE is a collaborative initiative aimed at advancing gender equality in global garment, footwear, and home textiles supply chains. It focuses on empowering women workers, integrating gender equality into business practices, and driving systemic change through innovative solutions and policy influence.
Science Based Targets initiative (“SBTi”)
The SBTi is a collaboration between CDP, the United Nations Global Compact (“UNGC”), World Resources Institute (“WRI”) and the World Wide Fund for Nature (“WWF”). The initiative defines and promotes best practices in emissions reductions and offers technical assistance to companies aiming to set science-based targets (“SBT”).
Scope 3 emissions
Scope 3 emissions are the result of activities from assets not owned or controlled by the reporting organisation, but that the organisation indirectly affects in its value chain. Scope 3 emissions include all sources not within an organisation’s Scope 1 and 2 boundary.
Smart factory and smart warehouse
In a smart factory, physical production processes and operations are combined with digital technology, smart computing, and big data to create a more opportunistic system. This represents a leap forward from traditional automation to a fully connected and flexible system. A smart warehouse provides efficient accessibility, timely delivery, and optimised order picking and storage through automation and a real-time management system, preventing human error while increasing safety and security in the workplace.
electricity consumption for Scope 2 greenhouse gas accounting. Institute of Public and Environmental Affairs (“IPE”)
The IPE is a non-profit environmental research organisation registered and based in Beijing, China, offering a pollution database to monitor corporate environmental performance.
Low Carbon Manufacturing Programme LCMP, hosted by WWF-Hong Kong, provides manufacturers with a carbon (“LCMP”) accounting and labelling system to help measure their effectiveness in carbon reduction and equip them with best practices. Manufacturing Restricted Substances MRSL is a list of chemical substances that are subject to a usage ban or List (“MRSL”) restrictions in manufacturing processes. Network for Greening the Financial
NGFS is a global network of central banks and financial supervisors that develops
System (“NGFS”)
climate scenarios, analytical frameworks and best-practice recommendations. NGFS scenarios provide an integrated framework that combines climate pathways, macroeconomic assumptions and policy responses.
Observed quality level (“OQL”)
OQL is a measure of factory quality performance that analyses the defect rate of the customer’s first-time final inspection.
Personal Advancement & Career Enhancement (“P.A.C.E.”)
Initiated by Gap Inc., P.A.C.E. is an innovative factory-based programme that aims to positively impact female garment workers. The programme provides foundational skills and support that help them advance in the workplace and in their personal lives, through life skills education and technical training.
Power Purchase Agreement (“PPA”)
PPA is a long-term contract for the purchase of electricity – typically from renewable sources – at agreed prices and volumes, enabling corporates to secure clean energy supply while supporting the financing of renewable energy projects.
Purchased Goods and Services
Purchased Goods and Services refers to Scope 3, Category 1 emissions, which include all upstream (i.e. cradle-to-gate) emissions from the production of products purchased or acquired by the reporting company in the reporting year. Products include both goods (tangible products) and services (intangible products).
Race to Zero
Social and Labor Convergence Program The SLCP is a non-profit multi-stakeholder initiative that aims to eliminate (“SLCP”) audit fatigue in global supply chains. The tools and system for generating highquality comparable data on working conditions can increase transparency in the supply chain. Task Force on Climate-Related Financial Disclosures (“TCFD”)
The TCFD was created in 2015 by the Financial Stability Board to develop consistent, climate-related financial risk disclosures for use by companies, banks, and investors in providing information to stakeholders.
United Nations Global Compact (“UNGC”)
The UNGC is a voluntary initiative based on CEO commitments to implement universal sustainability principles and to take steps to support UN goals.
UN Fashion Industry Charter for Climate Action (“UNFICCA”)
The UNFICCA is an industry-wide initiative, driven by the United Nations, to collectively address the climate impact of the fashion sector across its value chain.
United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (“UN SDGs”)
The UN SDGs are a collection of 17 global goals set by the United Nations General Assembly in 2015 for the year 2030. These goals provide a blueprint to achieve a more sustainable future and address global sustainability challenges.
WWF Water Risk Filter
The WWF Water Risk Filter is an online tool developed by the WWF and German finance institution DEG, which helps companies and financial institutions to explore, assess, value, and respond to water risks.
ZDHC InCheck
The ZDHC InCheck was developed by the ZDHC Foundation to enable suppliers to check their chemical inventory against the ZDHC MRSL Accepted Certification for better chemical management.
Zero Discharge of Hazardous Chemicals (“ZDHC”)
The ZDHC was formulated by a group of apparel and footwear brands and retailers working together to lead the industry towards zero discharge of hazardous chemicals.
Launched in 2019, Race to Zero is a global campaign, led by the UN Climate Change High Level Champions, rallying non-state actors – including companies, cities, regions, financial, educational, and healthcare institutions – to take immediate action to halve global emissions by 2030 and deliver a healthier, fairer zero carbon world.
Representative Concentration Pathway RCP is a set of climate change scenarios adopted by the IPCC that describe (“RCP”)
possible future pathways of GHG concentrations and radiative forcing in the atmosphere up to 2100. RCPs are labelled according to their radiative forcing levels (e.g. RCP2.6, RCP4.5, RCP6.0 and RCP8.5).
Restricted Substances List (“RSL”)
86
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
The RSL is a list of chemical substances restricted or banned from use in finished products.
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
87
Content Index for ESG Reporting Code and Reference Standards HKEX ESG Reporting Code
IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
HKEX ESG Reporting Code
IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Para. 13 Governance structure
IFRS S1 Para. 26–27 Governance
•
About Crystal International – Corporate Governance; Sustainability Governance
KPI A1.6 Waste handling, reduction targets and actions
IFRS S1 • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements
•
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking
•
KPI A2.1 IFRS S1 Energy consumption • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets types and data • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements
•
IFRS S2 Para. 5–7 Governance
Para. 14 Reporting principles
Para. 15 Reporting boundary
IFRS S1 • Para. 44(a)(vi) Risk management process change • Para. 59 Information about sources of guidance • Para. 66 Reporting consistency • Para. 78(b) Measurement uncertainty IFRS S2 • Para. 25(a)(vi) Changes in risk management • Para. 29(a)(iii) Measurement approach, inputs & assumptions for GHGs emissions • Para. 34 Target setting methodology IFRS S1 Para. 20 Reporting entity
2-9 Governance structure and composition • 2-12 Role of the highest governance body in overseeing the management of impacts • 2-13 Delegation of responsibility for managing impacts • 2-14 Role of the highest governance body in sustainability reporting 1 Reporting Principles
General disclosure
•
•
About Crystal International – Sustainability Governance Stakeholder Engagement – Double Materiality Assessment Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero, Carbon, Energy, and Water Data 2025
KPI A1.1 Emissions types and data KPI A1.3 Hazardous waste data KPI A1.4 Non-hazardous waste data KPI A1.5 Emission targets and actions
IFRS S1 Para. 51–53 Information about targets set
• •
• •
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
302-1 Energy consumption within the organisation 302-3 Energy intensity
Regenerating Nature – Carbon, Energy, and Water Data 2025
KPI A2.2 Water consumption data
303-5 Water consumption
Regenerating Nature – Carbon, Energy, and Water Data 2025
KPI A2.3 Energy use efficiency target(s) and actions
302-4 Reduction of energy consumption
•
•
•
• • •
•
Regenerating Nature
•
305-7 Nitrogen oxides Regenerating Nature – (NOx), sulfur oxides (SOx), Carbon, Energy, and Water and other significant air Data 2025 emissions • 306-3 Waste Regenerating Nature – generated Waste Management • 306-4 Waste diverted from disposal • 306-5 Waste directed to disposal
•
88
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
Regenerating Nature
KPI A2.4 Water sourcing issues, efficiency target(s) and actions
Emissions IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking IFRS S1 • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
About This Sustainability Report
Environment General disclosure
3-3 Management of Regenerating Nature – material topics Waste Management 306-2 Management of significant waste-related impacts
Use of resources
•
2-2 Entities included in the organisation’s sustainability reporting
•
Section or Feedback
3-3 Management of • material topics 303-2 Management of water discharge-related impacts 305-5 Reduction of GHG • emissions
Our Sustainability Vision and Approach – Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 – Impact for Better Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero 2050; Air Emissions Control; Waste Management; Chemical and Wastewater Management
KPI A2.5 Packaging material data
3-3 Management of • material topics 303-1 Interactions with water as a shared resource 303-2 Management of • water discharge-related impacts 303-3 Water withdrawal
–
Our Sustainability Vision and Approach – Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 – Impact for Better Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero 2050 Our Sustainability Vision and Approach – Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 – Impact for Better Regenerating Nature – Water Conservation
Regenerating Nature – Waste Management
Environment and natural resources General disclosure
–
• •
KPI A3.1 Significant environmental and natural resource impacts and managing actions
–
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
101-1 Policies to halt and reverse biodiversity loss
Regenerating Nature – Our Environmental Policy and Management System •
•
•
Our Sustainability Vision and Approach – Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 – Impact for Better Regenerating Nature – Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities Stakeholder Engagement – Double Materiality Assessment
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
89
Content Index for ESG Reporting Code and Reference Standards
HKEX ESG Reporting Code
IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking
•
•
IFRS S1 • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements
404-1 Average hours of training per year per employee
Social
Development and training
Employment
General disclosure
General disclosure
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking KPI B1.1 IFRS S1 Workforce • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets categories and data • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements KPI B1.2 Employee turnover rate
• •
• •
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
Resourcing People – Code of Conduct and Social Compliance Policies; Talent Acquisition
2-7 Employees 401-1 New employee hires and employee turnover
Resourcing People – Talent Acquisition
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
Resourcing People – Safeguarding Employee Health and Safety
KPI B3.1 Percentage of employees trained by category KPI B3.2 Employee training hours by category
Health and safety General disclosure
KPI B2.1 Work-related fatalities data KPI B2.2 Lost days due to work injury KPI B2.3 Occupational health and safety measures
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking IFRS S2 • Para. 10–12 Climate-related risks and opportunities • Para. 14 Climate-related strategy and decision-making IFRS S1 • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements IFRS S2 • Para. 27- 32 Climate-related metrics
• •
403-9 Work-related injuries
•
•
• • •
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
•
3-3 Management of material topics 403-1 Occupational health and safety management system 403-2 Hazard identification, risk assessment, and incident investigation 403-4 Worker participation, consultation, and communication on occupational health and safety 403-5 Worker training on occupational health and safety 403-6 Promotion of worker health 403-7 Prevention and mitigation of occupational health and safety impacts directly linked by business relationships
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments 404-2 Programs for upgrading employee skills and transition assistance programs
Supply Chain Management – Corporate Supply Chain Management Procedure • Resourcing People – Code of Conduct and Social Compliance Policies; Safeguarding Employee Health and Safety; Talent Grooming Resourcing People – Talent Grooming
Labour standards General disclosure
Resourcing People – Safeguarding Employee Health and Safety
•
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking KPI B4.1 IFRS S1 Employment practice • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets for child and forced • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable labour avoidance disclosure requirements KPI B4.2 Actions for discovered child and forced labour
• • •
•
• •
•
90
HKEX ESG Reporting Code
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
Resourcing People – Code of Conduct and Social Compliance Policies
408-1 Operations and suppliers at significant risk for incidents of child labour 409-1 Operations and suppliers at significant risk for incidents of forced or compulsory labour 2-25 Processes to remediate negative impacts
Resourcing People – Code of Conduct and Social Compliance Policies
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
Supply Chain Management
Supply chain management General disclosure
KPI B5.1 Suppliers by geographical region KPI B5.2 Supplier engagement
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking IFRS S1 • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements
• • – •
• KPI B5.3 Supply chain environmental and social risk management KPI B5.4 Green purchase practices
• •
Supply Chain Management – Supply Chain Sustainability Management Strategy 308-1 New suppliers Supply Chain Management that were screened – Corporate Supply Chain using environmental Management Procedure; criteria Governing Policies and 308-2 Negative Requirements to Suppliers environmental impacts Supply Chain Management in the supply chain and – Managing Environmental actions taken and Social Risks along 414-1 New suppliers Supply Chain; Green that were screened Supply Chain using social criteria Supply Chain Management 414-2 Negative social – Governing Policies impacts in the supply chain and actions taken and Requirements to Suppliers; Green Supply Chain
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
91
Content Index for ESG Reporting Code and Reference Standards
HKEX ESG Reporting Code
IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking KPI B6.1 IFRS S1 Percentage of • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets products recalled for • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable safety and health disclosure requirements reasons KPI B6.2 Number of products and service related complaints received and actions KPI B6.3 Intellectual property rights observation and protection practices KPI B6.4 Quality assurance process and recall procedures KPI B6.5 – Consumer data protection and privacy policies
• •
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
416-2 Incidents of noncompliance concerning the health and safety impacts of products and services
Product Responsibility
General disclosure
Product Responsibility – Product Safety
KPI B8.1 Focus areas of contribution KPI B8.2 Resources contributed
Product Responsibility – Handling Product Complaints and Recalls
Product Responsibility – Intellectual Property Rights
KPI B7.1 Concluded legal cases regarding corrupt practices KPI B7.2 Description of preventive measures and whistle-blowing procedures, and how they are implemented and monitored KPI B7.3 Description of anticorruption training provided to directors and staff
92
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking IFRS S1 • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements
–
Revitalising Community
–
Revitalising Community – Identifying Community Engagement Activities
HKEX ESG Reporting Code – Part D
IFRS S2 Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
Climate-related disclosures Governance
Product Responsibility – Quality Management System; Handling Product Complaints and Recalls Our core garment and textile manufacturing business does not involve ownership of consumer privacy in the context of networked data nor globalised corporate activities that might lead to risks of personal data leakage and misuse or unauthorised access.
–
Para. 19 Climate-related governance
Para. 5–7 Climate-related governance
• •
• •
2-9 Governance About Crystal International structure and – Corporate Governance; composition Sustainability Governance 2-12 Role of the highest governance body in overseeing the management of impacts 2-13 Delegation of responsibility for managing impacts 2-17 Collective knowledge of the highest governance body
Strategy Climate-related risks and opportunities
Anti-corruption General disclosure
IFRS Sustainability Disclosure Standards
Community investment
Product responsibility General disclosure
HKEX ESG Reporting Code
IFRS S1 • Para. 30 Sustainability-related risks and opportunities • Para. 33 Strategy and decisionmaking IFRS S1 • Para. 45–53 Metrics and targets • Para. 56–58 Identifying applicable disclosure requirements
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
•
2-23 Policy commitments 2-24 Embedding policy commitments
Resourcing People – AntiCorruption
205-3 Confirmed incidents of corruption and actions taken
Resourcing People – AntiCorruption
•
• •
2-25 Processes to remediate negative impacts 2-26 Mechanisms for seeking advice and raising concerns
205-2 Communication and training about anticorruption policies and procedures
Para. 20 Para. 10–12 Climate-related risks and Climate-related risks opportunities and opportunities
201-2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities due to climate change
Regenerating Nature – Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
201-2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities due to climate change
Regenerating Nature – Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
201-2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities due to climate change
•
Business model and value chain Para 21 Para. 13 Business model and value Business model and chain value chain
Strategy and decision-making Para. 22–23 Strategy and decision-making
Para. 14 Strategy and decision-making
•
Our Sustainability Vision and Approach – Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 – Impact for Better Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero 2050; Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
93
Content Index for ESG Reporting Code and Reference Standards
HKEX ESG Reporting Code – Part D
IFRS S2 Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
Financial position, financial performance and cash flows Para. 24(a) Current financial effect Para. 24(b) Material adjustment within next reporting period Para. 25(a)(i) Investment and disposal plans Para. 25(a)(ii) Planned funding sources for strategy Para. 25(a)(b) Anticipated financial effect across time horizons
Para. 16(a) Current financial effect
Para. 16(b) Material adjustment within next reporting period
HKEX ESG Reporting Code – Part D
IFRS S2 Sustainability Disclosure Standards
GRI Standards
Section or Feedback
201-2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities due to climate change
Regenerating Nature – Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
201-2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities due to climate change
Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero 2050
Para. 29(f) Internal carbon prices
–
Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero 2050
Para. 29(g)(i) Remuneration
•
Climate-related risks and opportunities 201-2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities due to climate change
Para. 16(c)(i) Investment and disposal plans
Regenerating Nature – Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities No factory is identified as requiring a material adjustment within the next reporting year. Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero 2050
Para. 16(c)(ii) Planned funding sources for strategy Para. 16(d)-21 Anticipated financial effect across time horizons
Regenerating Nature – Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
Para. 30 Assets or business activities vulnerable to climate-related transition risks Para. 31 Assets or business activities vulnerable to climate-related physical risks Para. 32 Assets or business activities aligned with to climate-related opportunities
Para. 29(b) Assets or business activities vulnerable to climate-related transition risks
Para. 29(c) Assets or business activities vulnerable to climate-related physical risks
Para. 29(d) Assets or business activities aligned with to climate-related opportunities
Capital deployment Climate resilience Para. 26 Climate resilience
Para. 22 Climate resilience
201-2 Financial implications and other risks and opportunities due to climate change
Regenerating Nature – Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
Para. 24–26 Climate-related risk management
Para. 29(e) Capital deployment towards climate-related risks and opportunities
Internal carbon prices
Risk management Para. 27 Climate-related risk management
Para. 33 Capital deployment towards climaterelated risks and opportunities
• •
3-1 Process to determine material topics 3-3 Management of material topics
•
•
About Crystal International – Sustainability Governance Regenerating Nature – Crystal Net Zero 2050; Climate-Related Risks and Opportunities
Para. 34 Internal carbon prices Renumeration Para. 35 Remuneration
•
2-19 Remuneration About Crystal International policies – Corporate Governance 2-20 Process to determine remuneration
Metrics and targets Greenhous gas emissions Para. 28–29 GHG emissions Scope 1,2 and 3
Para. 29(a) GHG emissions Scope 1,2 and 3
Industry-based metrics • • •
94
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
305-1 Direct (Scope
- GHG emissions 305-2 Energy indirect (Scope 2) GHG emissions 305-4 GHG emissions intensity
•
Regenerating Nature – Carbon, Energy, and Water Data 2025
Reasonable information relief was applied as the complete quantification of Scope 3 emissions is not yet available and will be provided in 2025 CDP disclosure.
Para. 36 Industry-based climate-related disclosures
Para. 32 Industry-based climate-related disclosures
–
Regenerating Nature – Sustainable Materials; Chemical and Wastewater Management
•
3-3 Management of Regenerating Nature – material topics Crystal Net Zero 2050; 305-5 Reduction of GHG Carbon, Energy, and Water emissions Data 2025
Climate-related targets Para. 37–40 Climate-related targets & performance
Para. 33–36 Climate-related targets & Performance
•
SUSTAINABILITY REPORT 2025
95
Adapted for English readers from the Chinese edition
All Rights Reserved © 2017 Crystal Knitters Ltd. Published & Printed in Hong Kong
Table of C onte nts
Table Of Contents Preface By Tadashi Yanai
7
Preface By Michael Chan Yue-kwong
8
Preface By Andrew Chan Chi-fai
10
Message From Co-editors
13
Foreword From Kenneth Lo Lok-fung, The Author
20
Chapter One
My Journey With Crystal
25
With integrity, wisdom, benevolence and courage, one can turn a setting sun to a bright rising sun. Chapter Two
Our Principles
77
Build core values for the Greater Good. Chapter Three Our Practice Of Learning From The Best
119
Professionalism is our focus and the pursuit of excellence is our lifelong goal. Chapter Four Our People
163
People come first in our corporate culture. We nurture talents through learning. Chapter Five
Our Operation Models
209
Begin with the end in mind. Chapter Six
Our SustainabilityMission
253
Respect clients as part of our sustainability mission.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter Seven Perpetual Enterprise
305
Let the capable take over for a sustainable enterprise. Appendices & Suppliers’ Impressions Postscript Business Partners’ Impressions
343 347
Employees’ Viewpoint
351
Thank You For Inspiring Me
357
Acknowledgement
361
Index
363
Pre face
Preface By: Tadashi Yanai Mr Yanai is the chief executive officer of Fast Retailing Company, Limited - a Japanese company operating the Uniqlo clothing brand.
I would like to start by congratulating Mr Kenneth Lo for publishing this wonderful book that presents to his readers his business philosophy. It is a book that will benefit not only those who work in the clothing industry, but also people in other lines of business. Hong Kong is in a unique economy and city where one can realise the dream of starting and then expanding a business. Mr Lo has demonstrated over all these years that such is indeed the case. He is a role model for all business people and has showcased the degree of success one can achieve. When I first met Mr Lo, I was struck by his philosophy of building and managing a business and discovered that his core principles echoed mine. I had never met anybody like him before. We share the same values of building trust and regard ‘keeping a promise’ of the utmost of importance. There is a strong chemistry between us and I find our time together to be very intellectually stimulating - hence we have maintained a relationship for years. I am convinced that this book will provide readers with inspiration and business insight. The book has been written to encourage young people who aspire to take on the challenges and opportunities available in Hong Kong, Asia and the world.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Preface By: Michael Chan Yue-kwong Dr Chan is the ex-chairman of Café de Coral Group, the honorary chairman of the Legacy Academy and a recipient of Businessweek Magazine’s “Stars of Asia” Award.
A Matter Of Destiny And Fortune There are not that many entrepreneurs like Mr Kenneth Lo who can boast of a lifetime of success. There are even fewer who are willing to share their formula of success as openly as Mr Lo. In my journey through life, I can perhaps best describe my acquaintance with Mr Lo as ‘a matter of destiny and fortune.’ The destiny was in that we met, even though we came from completely different backgrounds and worked in different industries. I had then the good fortune of seeing how Mr Lo and I shared many common challenges and experiences. In matters concerning developing corporate culture, team management and business development, we speak a common language and abide by the same philosophy. To hear Mr Lo describe in detail his first-hand account of the Crystal Group’s development is to see a mirror reflection of the corporate history of my own organisation. The rapport between the two of us is truly astounding. I have heard it said before: ‘A person’s insights develop as they progress through life.’ Mr Lo’s book is a chronicle of his self-driven struggle in building a business from scratch. In the process, he has learnt many lessons on management and life. Reading it through is like absorbing the essence of the writer’s wisdom that he has accumulated throughout a lifetime. The book requires the readers savor and digest each and every point that the author shares with them, be it the corporate culture of caring for the Greater Good, the people-oriented approach to personnel management, the integration of Chinese and Western concepts in corporate governance or the orderly ways of implementing a succession plan in a company. What Mr Lo has to say in this book about the business of ‘Becoming No. 1 in the World’ not only sheds light on his grand vision of turning a sunset industry to a world-
Pre face
class enterprise but also demonstrates his willingness to share the business wisdom that has been accrued over the years. He arrives at a set of core values that apply to the way we relate to our family, corporate work, employees, and the world at large. They are relevant to the shaping of our social culture as well. I am honoured to be invited to write a preface for this book. Struck by the similarities between his philosophy and mine, I hereby respectfully share my thoughts with the readers. I sincerely recommend this book to all and would like to express that readers can learn from the insights that Mr Lo has gained from his experience. In digesting this book, readers will discover details of Mr Lo’s personal life, his constant pursuit for excellence, his thoughtful handling of family relations, his habit of working for the interest of others as much as his own, his insistence in passing on his business ideal to the next generation and his ways of appointing people based on their capabilities. In the business world, people strive for the sustainability of their companies. Mr Lo’s selfless sharing makes it possible for readers to learn a thing or two about the work involved in the survival and success of a global enterprise, which in turn will help sustain businesses for the long term and deliver bright futures to greater industries in Hong Kong. It has never been easy to run a garment manufacturing business – harder still to run an industry that requires high concentration, talent and attention to detail. Mr Lo has now stepped on the stage to chronicle for us the extraordinary process of building a corporate culture and reveal the fact that the secret of human resources development lies in the care and nurturing of talents. He shares with readers his unique leadership style that combines Chinese and Western elements. This book is not just about the Crystal Group; it is a chapter of the history of Hong Kong’s entrepreneurship, and an extraordinary story of a classic self-made man. As someone who has gone through similar experiences, I regard this book as a mirror. As an entrepreneur, I use it for reference. As a Hong Kong person, I am proud of Mr Lo’s work.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Preface By: Andrew Chan Chi-fai Professor Chan teaches marketing at the Chinese University of Hong Kong. He is also the College Head of Shaw College and Director of the Executive MBA Programme.
A View Of Crystal’s Success From The Theories Of Left-Right Circles And The Five Phases Of Customer Acceptance Behaviour Mr Kenneth Lo is a much admired industrialist in Hong Kong. Recognising the importance of sustainable development, he utilises it as a competitive edge and discovers a new horizon for Hong Kong’s garment manufacturing industry. While business development on the one hand and environmental protection and social responsibility on the other may reach conflict at times, he demonstrates that through sustainability; even conflicts can be converted into benefits for all. In the context of my ‘left-right circles’ theory, Crystal’s success conforms exactly to the concept of the right circle meeting the demand of the left circle. The left circle is made up to support the needs of relevant stakeholders while the right circle represents the capability of an enterprise. Conceptually, the overlap of the two circles is where a business can meet customer or market needs within a specific timeframe. The bigger the overlap area , the greater the enterprise’s ability is to meet the demands. If the overlap area is small, then the enterprise will have to find ways to improve and to increase its competitiveness. The Crystal Group was founded in the era of the textile quota system. In those early years, the required quantity of product was predetermined by the quota given to a garment maker. Other factors such as pricing, product quality and the punctuality of delivery were of secondary importance. As a result, garment manufacturers would do all they could to acquire more quotas by buying them from the market or moving production to territories that either received favorable treatment from major importing countries or to territories that were not subject to the quota system. Crystal compares this act of chasing quotas to nomads looking for an oasis evident in moving factories to
Pre face
where quotas were available. This style of behaviour was a characteristic of the garment industry at the time - one that hampered the growth and scale of garment manufacturers. The abolition of the textile quota system brought intensified competition to the garment making world. Industry participants had to turn their attention from quotas to matters that really affect their competitive nature. The high quality, low price and fast react would definitely be a competitive advantage - but market demand of the garment industry in recent years has gone beyond these considerations. In the global arena, fashion brands have to meet corporate social responsibilities and related compliance obligations. While facing media, non-government organisations or local government, different stakeholders are paying close attention to the way international brands handle such issues such as the environment, labor relations and fair trade. These factors have caused great pressure to global brands. Sustainable development has since then been incorporated into the supply chain – manufacturing, delivery and retail. Such transition, from a state of protection under the quota system to one of embracing sustainable development cannot be achieved overnight. The process involves not only organisational restructuring or the formulation of related policies but also preparation of the workforce so that they can carry out sustainable development measures effectively. The Crystal Group has accomplished all this under Mr Lo’s leadership. He puts the Greater Good ahead of self-interests and dares to make changes by learning from outstanding management experts. The result is that Crystal has become a fertile ground for the establishment of a sustainable culture. In fact, even before the official launch of the sustainable development policy, Mr Lo had already integrated concepts and management models in consonance with sustainability, which made it easier for Crystal to transform itself into a sustainable organisation.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
When other garment makers are making their way towards sustainable development, Crystal is able to offer international fashion brands sustainable production methods that they seek. With Crystal’s tradition of maintaining high product quality and high production efficiency, brand name owners do not need to think twice before they enter into collaboration with Crystal. Collaborations of this kind represents the perfect union of the left and right circles, making Crystal a company with a strong competitive edge. To succeed in sustainable development, an organisation must first nurture a team that values the culture of sustainability. To inculcate such a culture, the organisation must be adept at managing changes, and its workforce must in turn go through five stages of acceptance. They must ‘know’ why change is necessary, ‘understand’ the essence of the change ‘take delight’ in effecting the change, then after implementing change, have to ‘make a habit’ of the change so that it becomes the very core of their behaviour. The key to Mr Lo’s success lies in putting into practice a corporate culture that exemplifies the five stages of acceptance outlined above, to such an extent that he is able to realise his ideals of the Greater Good and respect for the value of people. Through years of patient nurturing, he has succeeded in making his workforce aware of, understand, welcome, practice then finally make a habit of observing the culture of sustainability - which is now deeply embeded in the daily operation of the company. Mr Lo has also transformed Crystal into an organisation that focuses on education. From top to bottom, everybody in the company has learned to put aside short-term personal interests in exchange for the long-term benefits for all. This reason alone is why Crystal was able to emerge from the comfort of a business environment protected by the quota system to realise its full potentials. Corporate culture is indeed the cornerstone on which Crystal built its success. Crystal is truly an illustrative example of a local organisation that practices my management theories of the ‘left-right circles’ and the five phases of corporate behaviour.
Pre face
Message From Yim Kai-ming, co-editor Of The Chinese edition Mr Yim is the founder of Write4u.hk, an online platform providing services in writing, editing and translation. He is also the former chairman of Hong Kong Institute of Marketing.
Pleasant Surprises At Every Turn In the process of compiling this book for the Crystal Group, I had the good fortune of getting to know in great depth the transformation of a family-style business into a major corporation that employs tens of thousands of workers. I learnt how Mr Lo, starting with his own personal belief, rallied together his employees into a unified workforce that is pushing his company to the top spot of the world. Mr Lo believes that other people, like him, can also contribute to society and the cause of sustainability. An enterprise can influence the tens of thousands of employees working under it, then other companies and eventually, the entire industry and the world. The task that we originally set for ourselves was to ‘discover management principles that can serve as a reference for new entrants to business.’ Frankly, we thought at first that Crystal was a traditional company and luck must have, to a certain extent, played a part in its success. As we settled into to our task, however, we soon realised that Crystal is not just ahead of many enterprises but is in fact among the top of the world’s garment manufacturers. Crystal’s management shows foresight in strategy, demonstrates team spirit in action and stresses efficiency of cost in operation. These three features alone are worthy of emulation for many other enterprises. We were initially worried that it would be hard to find what we called ‘foundation for theories’ but elements of it turned up everywhere we looked. Very early on, we were able to summarise Crystal’s operational ideas or beliefs into seven major points:
- My Journey With Crystal: This term describes Mr Lo’s struggle for success, and the different strategies that he adopted in response to changing circumstances;
- Our Principles: summarises Mr Lo’s core management ideas, the inception of the
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Crystal corporate culture and the process of learning from practice; 3. Our Practice of Learning From The Best: depicts Crystal as an institute of continuous learning and identifies models of emulation and the benefits that result; 4. Our People: explains how to attract and develop talents as the next generation leaders for a highly effective team; 5. Our Operation Models: stresses the concept of beginning with the end in mind, a scientific approach to management, the amalgamation of the sales and production functions, the culture of product quality and sound financial management; 6. Our SustainabilityMission: chronicles Crystal’s commitment to corporate social responsibilities and sustainable development (both in concept and practice), through which the company establishes a competitive advantage in the industry; 7. Perpetual Enterprise: describes Mr Lo’s unique views on succession and his succession plan for the next two generations. These points are discussed in great length in different chapters which are further divided into subsections. With a total of about 30 of them – each touching on a different subject – the book is rich and comprehensive, elucidating the many management ideas that Mr Lo and his team adopt. Mr Lo believes that conflicts or contradictions abound in relationships, be they between society and the family, a company and its employees, a supervisor and the people working under him, husband and wife, father and son, siblings, or man and machine. Members of Crystal senior management team are no exception. At one point, they were far from convinced by Mr Lo’s corporate concepts and core values such as those regarding the Greater Good and people-oriented approach to management and paid only lip service to them. The book devotes quite a number of pages to explaining how Mr Lo succeeded in marshalling the entire workforce into a cohesive team who strive to put Crystal on the top of the world as an apparel maker. I trust that like me, readers will discover surprises at several turns when they read
Pre face
this book. In Chapter One alone, for example, they will read about: • How Mr Lo handled his first business failure at the age of 10; • How the first major order that Crystal recieved put the company in crisis; • How Crystal employees lived at its factory in Mauritius; • Who influenced Mr Lo in his decision to introduce enterprise management to a family-style business; • How Crystal passed the impossible test given by a Japanese client; • What the circumstances were surrounding Crystal’s loss of several hundred million dollars in war-torn Madagascar; • How Crystal entered the business of intimate wear; • How Mr Lo arrived at the grand vision of becoming the world’s No. 1 apparel maker. Other chapters focus more on Mr Lo’s management concepts; how they came about, why they were put into practice, the resistance they ran into during their implementation, how the resistance was overcome and the results of the adoption of these concepts. Reading this one book is equivalent to getting a thorough explanation of the ins and outs of dozens of management issues and solutions concepts. If you are a common reader, you shall be entranced by the success story of a worldclass enterprise. If you are a member of the management, your time will be well spent in absorbing and learning the concepts and wisdom described in the book, quite a few of which will not be what you expect. If you are in manufacturing or human resources management, you will discover that this is an uncommon textbook with high value. If you wish to promote sustainable development in your own company, invest in environmental protection facilities, or simply hand over the business to the next generation in due course, you will find in this book valuable experiences and inspirations that will save you from turning into the dead-end street of defeat. I am grateful to Mr Lo and his various colleagues for supporting us throughout
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
the write-up of the book. I would also like to take this opportunity to congratulates Crystal for numerous achievements over the past 46 years. I strongly recommend this book to everyone.
Pre face
Message From Davis Man Chun-kao, co-editor Of The Chinese edition Mr Man is the founder and director of Man Communications, Ltd.
Set Aside Self-interests And Touch Others With Kindness I have the good fortune of helping Mr Lo to write this book, which, to my great benefit, gave me an in-depth understanding of Mr Lo’s management concepts, his business philosophy and his way of life. In the past year, I visited the Crystal Group’s head office in Hong Kong and its production plants in Mainland China and Vietnam to meet and interview employees at all levels. The one comment that I heard repeatedly from Crystal employees that the “entire team must be people oriented.” What touched me most deeply is the principle behind the comment – care for the Greater Good. Crystal employees are most impressed by the deep love between Mr and Mrs Lo, the company’s co-founders, who never put on airs but treat people with sincerity and rather than haughtily dispensing orders, actively get themselves involved in getting things done. Caring for the Greater Good is but the concrete manifestation of Mr Lo’s business philosophy. Informing such an ideal is his kind heart. Mr Lo treats everyone, his family and the world with kindness. His magnanimity puts the interest of others before his own. He considers first not so much his personal interest as the welfare of the company, society or even the world as a whole. His every action is based on what he considers to be the best for all. And through example, he encourages people around him to do the same. In fact, having spent time with Mr Lo, I have fallen under his influence as well. When I make decisions these days, I also take into account others situations and the ‘bigger picture’. I also subscribe to his philosophy of treating my clients with respect and begin
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
a project with a clear goal in mind. I majored in Chinese language and literature in the university, and began my career at a local Chinese bank with almost 100 years of history. Having been exposed to traditional Chinese business thinking very early on, I therefore identify with the importance that Mr Lo attaches to integrity, concern for other people, respect for the customers and other similar business concepts. Indeed, without integrity, it is impossible to gain a foothold in the business world! Betraying one’s trust, if only once, can result in compromising one’s reputation. Breaking one’s promise or failing to meet one’s commitment can instantly ruin the goodwill that an organisation has cultivated for decades. I believe people working in public relations will understand this fully. In corporate communications, product promotion, image cultivation or crisis management, one must be true to the facts. Put a positive spin on things - yes, but fabrication of information or distortions of facts - never! Having worked in the field of communications for 25 years and having run my own company for 12, I have made the acquaintance of many chief executive officers. I have observed that the higher they are in the management, the humbler and more personable these executives are. Affable people seem to be able to get ahead, probably because others prefer to work with them. Or is it because policies and business plans eventuate only through the action of people, so much so that being approachable becomes an indispensable qualification for senior executives? Mr Lo practices the people-oriented philosophy of personnel management that he preaches, fosters harmony throughout the whole company, and influences others to do the same. It is truly amazing. Where there are people, conflicts are bound to arise. Over the years, I have come
Pre face
across many instances of politicking and power jockeying in the office. It is common to see people fighting fiercely to protect their own interests, to the point of making sacrificial lambs of others. Crystal, however, functions as one big congenial family undivided by territoriality. If something goes wrong, Crystal’s employees would try to resolve the issue by focusing on the matter itself and not the people involved. Crystal workers pull together with one mind, daring to try out new ideas to get the problem solved. They are accustomed to managing changes and make it their lifelong mission to continue to learn. I sincerely believe that the ‘secret’ behind this corporate spirit should be shared with other entrepreneurs. Throughout the writing process, the book has gone over a number of revisions but I was not the least frustrated. What a meaningful endeavor it is to make known to the world the mental progress of a successful entrepreneur and to promote his business principles that I also happen to uphold! I hope this book will encourage people in business to embrace the very goals of changing themselves, changing their enterprises and in turn, changing the world so that more will understand the merits of sustainable development. The ancients spoke of making accomplishments, cultivating virtues and leaving behind words of wisdom as three ways of attaining immortality. Having proven to be a distinguished businessman and an ethical and responsible individual, Mr Lo now turns to propound his wisdom in this book. I regard it as my honor to play a part in this worthy endeavor.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Foreword Kenneth Lo Lok-fung, The Author
Is Garment Making A Sunset Industry? Why do some say that garment making is a dying industry? Garment manufacturing was labeled a ‘sunset industry’ in the early 1980s. Back then, electronics were booming in Hong Kong and siphoned a lot of labour from the garment industry, which, moreover, was hamstrung by the textile quota system for it to develop in any significant way. Above all, garment making is labor-intensive. The industry was up against hard times. Even many leaders within the garment making industry was going downhill, a note of pessimism not heard in other industries. Was there indeed no future in my line of work? ◆
◆
◆
Personally, I believe that people who made this type of comments were blaming the industry, when, in reality, the simple fact was that they might not resolve the issues confronting them. Similarly, people these days seem to complain about the lack of opportunities in Hong Kong. They say that this is due to the government, the economy and the society we live and so on and so forth - without stopping to explore new ways that challenge today’s boundaries. To say that garment making is a dying industry really reflects more a psychological hang-up. Clothing, food, housing and transportation are but essential needs in our daily life: clothing, therefore, is a basic indispensable necessity. The garment industry’s market is as big as the entire world’s population. As long as we do our job well, keep in step with the changing times, look ahead with clear vision, and map out in details the
Pre face
road that will take us there, then even the ‘sunset’ can be turned to assume the glory of the noon-time sun. ◆
◆
◆
In this world, there is no ‘sunset industry,’ only ‘sunset management.’ If there is one motto that can be said to describe the Crystal Group’s management principle, it is ‘caring for the Greater Good,’ which any employee of the company, regardless of his position, will be able to tell you loud and clear. I have said the same to those around me as a way to motivate them. If only we keep our gaze at the bigger picture, and set aside our selfish interests for the benefits of the clientele, our fellow colleagues, the company, society, the country and the global environment, then the future will surely bring us the rewards we deserve. ◆
◆
◆
In my opinion, we can learn from water with its versatile properties. Water takes the shape of the container that it is put in. It turns into vapor when heated and solid ice when frozen. In the same way, one should adapt to the situation and stay flexible when different settings find us dealing with different problems and interacting with different people. If we can be as versatile as water, treat others with kindness and do not lose sight of the big picture, we shall be able to unite the team of people working around us to look for opportunities and solutions. ◆
◆
◆
In 1970, I was only about 20 years old. With the help of my wife, I made up my mind to start my own business. This was how Crystal came to being – with the two of us, about 70 employees, several sewing machines and knitting looms. Starting our business certainly was not easy. After 46 years of operation, The Crystal Group has now established a presence in about 20 locations across six different countries with a workforce of more than 60,000. Our annual production volume has been increasing from year to year. In 2014, we produced more than 300 million pieces of clothing. As we expanded in scale, we also rose in global industry ranking and our influences increased accordingly.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
At every stage of its development, a company is concerned with different things. At the beginning, it is a question of survival and gaining a steady foothold; later, the company considers how to stabilise business and sustain its growth. For me, in the last decade or so, my focus went beyond sustainable development to the consideration of perpetual operation – not just in terms of succession planning at the very top but also a continuous development of our operations as well as the long-term relationships with our various business partners. ◆
◆
◆
If an enterprise operates purely from the standpoint of profit, it will become a mere bean counter - mean and harsh. In the end, workers may find the pressure hard to bear and become passive in their work or simply quit. The suppliers may baulk at the harsh terms and terminate their relationship with the company, while clients may come to complain about the compromised quality of the merchandise or service. Worse still, in an attempt to control costs, the company may resort to illegal or unethical measures in deploying resources and disposing of pollutants that end up damaging the environment. One might be able to get away with things like these for a while, but when a business has come to be regarded as an unscrupulous employer or conscienceless corporation, it will lose all its allies. No one will step up to lend a helping hand in times of difficulties, with the result that the company might be forced to close down. Crystal is of course not such an enterprise. The question now is: how should we arrive at the state of perpetual enterprise? The hardship that I witnessed in my younger days taught me that in order to improve one’s life, one must first improve oneself. When one is capable of turning one’s life for the better, one should reach out to help others. With such a thought in my mind, I strove to pull myself out of poverty so that I could improve the livelihood of others. Garment manufacturing is a labor-intensive industry and stands to employ a lot of people. To enable people to work with dignity and become self-sufficient by offering them jobs thus became the ‘people-oriented’ philosophy of my company.
Pre face
To create more employment opportunities, Crystal has to increase its business volume. And as the company expands in scope, not only does it have to keep an eye on society with its changes, technological advancement, economic and political conditions and the livelihood of the people, it also has to adapt to the times, pay attention to new environmental policies and aim at sustainable development. ◆
◆
◆
These and other events brought new challenges and opportunities to the garment manufacturing industry: the People’s Republic of China’s entrance to the World Trade Organisation, the complete abolition of the textile quota system, the emergence of Africa as a clothing production base for European and American buyers, the coming of age of e-commerce, the increasing international call for carbon emission reduction, the report from International Performance Computing and Communications Conference (IPCCC) predicting the threat that global warming poses to the world, and the rising pressure from developed Western countries on their developing counterparts to care for environmental protection. In the face of the new challenges, I began by promulgating the company top management’s commitment to sustainable development as the major direction for the entire Crystal workforce to follow. We then set measurable targets and to have them realised step by step. Denim making is considered highly polluting compared to other types of garment manufacturing. To quell concerns from our management team that environmental protection and sustainability measures might detract from profitability, I deliberately selected our denim production in China to be a ‘model factory’. My thinking was that if our denim production could grow following all of the environmental and sustainability additions, then other factories would be more inspired to do a better job! We would then be able to replicate the success of one single factory in other sectors of the entire garment industry to the benefit of the environment. In time, I hope that this will become an example for other enterprises, the entire industry and even the whole world.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
◆
◆
◆
Crystal has matured along with the rest of the Hong Kong apparel making industry. We went through numerous ups and downs but are fortunate to become the business allies of many fashion brand names. For us, this process of growth and development is the story of the transformation of a small family-run manufacturer in a so-called ‘sunset industry’ into a multinational corporation with an annual turnover of several tens of billions Hong Kong dollars and a future as bright as the midday sun. In 2016, Fortune Magazine ranked Crystal 17th as part of the ‘Change the World Top 50 Companies,’ list where they scored the highest among companies from Asia. Fortune praised Crystal for environmentally friendly denim factories and female empowerment programs to enhance the lives and personal qualities of women in the workforce. The award proves that the principal of ‘to change oneself, their companies and then the world’ actually works! With global recognition, this motivated Crystal to further achieve in sustainable development work. All in all, this book describes my principles and the key to promulgating and implementing them. I sincerely hope that the book can do for the readers what its title says: to change oneself, their organisations and then the world!
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
Chapter One My Journey With Crystal With integrity, wisdom, benevolence and courage, one can turn a setting sun to a bright rising sun.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter One: My Journey With Crystal
- My Formative Years ◆
My First Run-in With Failure
◆
My Foray Into Business At Age 14
◆
An Easy-going Nature Wins Friends
◆
My Venture Into Sweater Manufacturing
- The Difficulties Of Starting A Business ◆
Starting My Business With My Wife’s Support
◆
Win Or Lose: Opportunity Has Its Price
◆
Yvonne Lo: Trust Is The Long-term Competitive Edge
◆
Days Of Chasing Quotas And Opening Factories
◆
Sherman Lau: The Three Musketeers In Mauritius
- Institutionalising Reforms ◆
Setting Up A Joint Venture In China With My Friend From US
◆
Towards Modern Enterprise Management
◆
Foray Into Japan: Getting Ready For A Rainy Day
◆
Dennis Wong: Learn Quality First From Japanese
- Setting The Scene To Become The World’s No. 1
◆
An Expensive Lesson
◆
Acquisition Of A British Intimates Company
◆
Lawrence Ward: Say ‘No’ To Marks & Spencer
◆
The Turning Point
27
41
52
64
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
- My Formative Years My First Run-in With Failure Times were hard but we were happy. Life was hard then but it instilled in me a fighting spirit. I owe my character to such hard times. Now I am not afraid to face difficulties. I also have the courage to take on challenges. My motto in life is: ‘let the Greater Good come first’. This is reflected in the way I run my company. The Crystal Group was formed several decades ago. Over the years, I have handled my business with integrity and have managed the company with wisdom. I have been kind in my dealings with people and bold in embarking on new adventures. I am glad to say that I have established a reputation for Crystal with efficiency in managing our operations and a right corporate culture for our people. At the end, our goal is to become the world’s No. 1 apparel maker. I believe that we should distinguish the difference between the Greater Good and the lesser personal good in our dealings. I always put the needs of others ahead of my own. In all of my relationships I seek harmony and do not bear a grudge as this does not help to resolve issues. Additionally, if one keeps sulking over how one has been treated unfairly, it will only make one feel bad. In an effort to improve the situation for all concerned, one should adopt a forgiving approach. This management style of mine has taken a long time to develop. It has also been tempered by the many mistakes I have made over the years. As for my life experiences, let me begin with the early days when I first arrived in Hong Kong . In the year 1950 when I was five or six years old, I moved to Hong Kong with my
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
father leaving behind my mother, younger brother and sister in Mainland China. Father and I started a farm in Ma Liu Shui near Shatin, the New Territories of Hong Kong. Life was hard. I did not go to school; my father taught me how to read and write. On most days, we worked on the farm. Once a month, father would walk to Taipo to buy the necessities. Only on that day, we could have meat for dinner, while on most days we just ate a simple meal of steamed rice with a dab of lard and soy sauce and sometimes with salted black beans and vegetables that we picked fresh from our farm. I was young then and did not think much of it. In fact, I rather enjoyed our rough and rugged way of life. An early memory of mine was when I had to make a certain shopping trip to Taipo by myself. From where we lived, I had to walk a long stretch of railroad track that passed through a long and dark tunnel. In those days, trains ran on steam engines that were fired by coal. When I came out of the tunnel, my face was completely black with soot. What’s more, when I was in the tunnel, I had to watch out for oncoming trains that came tearing through. Luckily, I was able to make it out in one piece. Thinking back, I must say I was a tough and gutsy little guy.
My First Failure: Raising Ducks When I was about eight or nine years old I planted chilies and raised 30 ducklings on two plots of land in our farm. I always tell people that I learn from failures - and my first failure came from raising that brood of ducklings! Each day, I took the ducklings to a nearby stream where they were able to search for food. It was fun watching them waddle along in a group. Unfortunately, only one out of 30 ever reached adulthood. Some of them got eaten by snakes, others wandered off unaccompanied and others simply died from various kinds of diseases. That was a complete failure for me at a very young age.
Meal Coupons And Free Schooling After about three years of working on the farm, my father decided to close it down. With the rest of the family arriving from Guangzhou, China we moved as a family of six
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
to a squatter hut on the slope of Shek Kip Mei, Kowloon Peninsula of Hong Kong. In the 1950s, there was a labour surplus in Hong Kong. One might be willing to work, but jobs were difficult to come by. It was hard to make a living and workers were in general treated poorly. Some jobs offered only a couple of meals per day however no actual salary. Even then, there were eager takers. The end of year bonus or double pay was unheard of in those days - some kindhearted employers would give a ‘little extra’ to workers so that they could have the money to get a haircut and buy new clothes for the Lunar New Year. That was pretty much it. Father used to work as a civil servant in Guangzhou, China before coming to Hong Kong. However, neither his education nor work experience was officially recognised in the British colony. Much as he tried to pull strings, he couldn’t land as lowly a job as the turnstile keeper on a city bus. His goal of starting a garment business also ended in failure. Taking outsourced odd jobs from outlets of various cottage industries in Hong Kong at the time was all he could manage. As life got tougher, our parents decided to send me and my younger brother and sister to live by ourselves in Rennie’s Mill (now better known as Tiu Keng Leng in Kowloon Peninsula of Hong Kong), an enclave of former Kuomintang soldiers. It was known as a ‘refugee camp’ at that time. Back then, the United Nations gave out relief items to dependents of these soldiers. With only a few dollars, we were able to buy a full month worth of meal coupons from a military family. Since we were still very young, the amount of food from a single meal coupon was enough to provide us with two solid meals per day. The shack we lived in had tarred paper for walls. Even though there was a door of sorts, the shack was actually open on all sides - and one could enter in and out from any direction. We had no kitchen, no desk, just a bed. Since we had nothing of great value, we did not have to worry about having things stolen from us. I still remember when a typhoon hit Hong Kong we would have to tie ropes in an effort hold down the roof so that it would not blow away.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
The four of us did not own a pair of shoes and we were forced to travel to school in bare feet. It was a Catholic school for the poor and we did not need to pay tuition fees. We even were provided with books and our stationery at no cost. Despite our harsh living conditions, we managed to get by. We learnt to watch out for one another and soon developed a strong sense of independence. As the eldest child however, I was the one responsible for taking care of the younger ones.
Periodic Borrowing And The Monthly Trek During those post-war days, the economy was in shambles and supplies were scarce. It was quite common for people to pawn their cotton-padded quilts for cash when they were in need of money. Our parents had to borrow from relatives to supplement their own income in order to support us. From time to time, they also had to pledge whatever ‘valuables’ they had at the pawn shop to make ends meet. Yet, even though we were poor, nobody ever looked down upon us as it was common for people to help one another. Once a month, I took the long and arduous trek from Rennie’s Mill to Shek Kip Mei to see my parents and receive our monthly stipend. I would hike across the hills to Lei Yue Mun, where I would then take a ferry to Sai Wan Ho of the Hong Kong Island. From there, I caught the tram and the ferry for Shum Shui Po of the Kowloon Peninsula, then walked from the pier to our parents home in Shek Kip Mei. The trip in total took six to seven hours. I literally had to traverse land and sea and tired myself out with the tremendous amount of walking, bus and boat rides. The weather would usually be clear and bright as we set out in the morning, by the time I returned however it would be seven or eight o’clock in the evening and dark out. There was no avoiding the trek across the hills as I was nearer to Rennie’s Mill. In the moonlight, the footpath was quiet except for the howling wind and the occasional barking from dogs. It was not unusual to find graves along the way. I was about 10 years old at the time, and my young mind could not help but to be filled with all sort of scary thoughts - I had no choice but to trudge along. Under these circumstances, we spent several years at Rennie’s Mill. I was not a
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
good student and therefore ended my education before finishing primary school. When I was a young teenager I then returned to live with my parents. Soon after, my fifth and sixth brothers were born.
A Fighting Spirit And A Sense Of Responsibility Life was hard then but it instilled in me a fighting spirit. I owe my character to such hard times. Now I am not afraid to face difficulties. I also have the courage to take on challenges. As young as I was, I understood that however hard things may get, I had to learn to cope for the Greater Good of the family. Our parents simply had no time to take care of us. If we had not moved away to Rennie’s Mill, we would have been in their way. As the oldest child, I could take care of my siblings. Why would I want to add to my parents’ burden?
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
My Foray Into Business At Age 14 Armed with my parents’ trust, I assumed the responsibility of operating a business. Thinking back to those early days, I experienced bone-crushing poverty at first hand. There were practically no social benefits of any kind in Hong Kong at that time. Living hand to mouth was by no means uncommon for many Hong Kong families. In time, there developed among the people a hard-working and resilient attitude. This indomitable spirit came to known as the ‘Lion’s Rock Spirit’, by which people took responsibilities for their own lives, and would not blame every little misfortune on other people or the community.
A Desire To Win And An Example Of Diligence I started to help our parents with their small business after turning 14. Hong Kong’s industrialisation was just taking off in the 1950s. To make a living, mother would bring home outsourced work from various factories and my entire family would be mobilised to work. It was mostly simple handiwork such as beading on gloves or tasks alike. Father was learned, capable, well-connected and had a way with words. As a result, he was a popular figure with his acquaintances. From childhood, he taught us the importance of making friends. Unlike parents around him, father treated us like ‘buddies’ and engaged in activities such as card playing during festivals. In our daily life, he encouraged us to be independent. While he would delegate duties, he was happy to leave to us to carry out the task at hand alone. ‘Micro-management’ in other words was not his style. What impressed me most about him however was his fearlessness. During our days on the farm, I saw him catch a snake with his bare hands once. He showed absolutely no fear. Father always spoke of his vision for ‘the Great Lo Clan.’ It was his firm belief that each one of the Lo’s were born to achieve and that we all had it in us to rise above whatever negativity life dished out. His encouragement helped us to develop self-confidence and a sense of ambition. As it turned out, all six of us were able to make a name for ourselves
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
in separate fields - we did not disappoint our father in this respect. Mother was well-educated. She was amiable and gracious. There was none of the country air about her that was expected of people from the Mainland. She was highly efficient with what she did. In addition to taking care of the family chores as a dutiful mother, she worked hard for the family business, sleeping only three to four hours day in day out. When mother would accept outsourced work from the glove factories, I would often tag along and quickly picked up her routine. After not long, I was the go-to person for when it came to dealing with other factory orders. The scale of our family business was quite small. We were able to maintain a steady income as long as we could get work from one or two factories. My parents never resorted to giving out direct orders or long-winded lectures when teaching us. Instead, they cheered us from the sideline and gave us the freedom to develop our potentials. From Father, I learned the desire to achieve; in Mother, I saw a shining example of diligence. I have both of them to thank for trusting me and giving me the chance to help them manage their business. These early attempts have exerted a strong influence on my future career.
Keep The Big Picture In Mind And Understand One’s Limitations At Christmas in 1953, a huge fire razed to the ground the Shek Kip Mei squatter area not sparing even the hut that my parents rented. As a temporary measure, the government put up a two-storey building to provide shelter for those who were left homeless, and our parents moved in. This was replaced eventually by several sevenstorey concrete blocks, which came to be known as the ‘resettlement estate’. These midrise buildings had no elevators. Cooking had to be done by the open verandah as there was no kitchen in individual units. Tenants also had to share public bathrooms on each floor. While living conditions were far from desirable, we had a roof over our head and were spared the brunt of the elements.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Thinking back to those early days, I experienced bone-crushing poverty at first hand. At that time, there were practically no social benefits of any kind in Hong Kong. Living hand to mouth was by no means uncommon for many local families. Among the people developed a hard-working and resilient attitude. This indomitable spirit came to be known as the ‘Lion’s Rock Spirit’ by which people took responsibility for their own lives and would not blame every little misfortune on other people or the community. From the squatter hut to the resettlement estate, our family managed to stay afloat on outsourced handicraft work from various factories. Under these trying circumstances, I learnt not to quibble over insignificant gains and losses. I also got into the habit of asking myself: “What can I do to do a better job?” When faced with a problem, my first thought was directed not to my personal interest, but to finding a solution and getting things done.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
An Easy-going Nature Wins Friends An extensive network provides the help I want. If you get along with people, you stand at an advantage wherever you are.
Being Helpful And Being Helped In business as in other things, if you enjoy good interpersonal relationships with others, your network will be extensive. Other people will come to your aid and you can achieve more with less effort. While my parents took care of the work, I was responsible for soliciting work orders. I was only 14 then and I never failed to bring back work for the family when I visited the factories. We were never short of work - only because I was good with people. Because I was easy-going and did not mind being taken advantage of, people working at the factories would ask me to get them snacks and sundry items whenever I showed up. I knew very well that these workers were not authorised to place work orders to people like me, but I was eager to develop a good relationship. As long as it made other people happy, I did not mind it at all. As a result, people liked me. They were happy to see that I would not haggle over every minor detail, In turn, they would go out of their way to help me and would place work orders for me. Soon, we did not have to worry about getting enough work orders. If you get along with people, you stand at an advantage wherever you are.
Outsourcing Work With Steady Growth Thanks to the strong relationship we had with our customers, orders we received increased and the volume of our work expanded gradually. We began to outsource work to others down the production line. Upon receiving work orders, we would complete the stage of work that we were responsible for, then delegate out the next phase of labourintensive work such as the sewing of beads and embroidery to the housewives.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Since our parents focused mainly on business development, the rest of the work fell on my shoulders. As business grew, so did the amount of work. Every day there was a new challenge. Of all the chores, transporting raw materials and finished products was physically the most taxing. Every time we received an order, I had to lug the raw materials from the client to our workshop at home. Although we already had paid workers to help out by then, deadlines were so tight and we often found ourselves so short-handed that I ended up doing all that coolie work by myself. If my memory serves me well, an order consisted usually of several hundred gloves, weighing over several dozen pounds. On top of this, there were baskets and baskets of spare parts such as beads and decorative sequins to be sewed onto the gloves. It was not at all easy for an adolescent like me to carry them from place to place. After we finished our stage of work at the workshop, I had to dispatch the gloves to the housewives we subcontracted downstream. I relied solely on a bicycle that was too tall for my height. The bike would wobble as I tried to steady myself on it. One time, I was stopped by the police for overloading the bike. Father had to come to the police station to bail me out. When I finally arrived at the homes of the subcontract workers, I had to haul the materials up flights of stairs again. When the workers lived in a roof-top shack or up a hill, the job became even more daunting. When there was a rush to fulfil orders, everyone worked around the clock. Once I had to collect finished products from a subcontract worker’s place in the early hours of 3am. On the way to their homes perched up on the hill, I often came across aggressive wild dogs. At first I was scared but then I thought of a way to send them away. I would take off my jacket and wave it wildly like a matador. The dogs would be confused and I would walk on unscathed. Our family business went from gloves to sweaters, starting with sewing pieces of sweaters together, then running them through the pre-shrink laundry process; ironing, and so on. Observing how our business had stabilised and that we had had perfected our
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
skills, Father decided to start a factory that specialised in sweaters. In those days, many import-export firms helped foreign wholesalers or retailers to locate merchandise in Hong Kong. We focused on serving the smaller of the exporters.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
My Venture Into Sweater Manufacturing I met the love of my life, who helped me overcome many difficulties. Just being willing to pay doesn’t mean others would complete the job to your satisfaction. Give it a human touch, reach out as a friend and show that you care -- these are more effective ways to produce desired results. I thus learnt over time the importance of giving rather than taking.
Going Back To School And Learning About Amicability As the saying goes, ‘the more you learn, the more you know that there is more to learn’. I believe that learning is a lifelong commitment-we must expand our knowledge and continue to broaden our vision to become a better person and to understand life. My formal education ended at Primary 6 when I moved away from Rennie’s Mill to help out with the family business. I often found myself ill-equipped for the increasing demand of my job at the factory. I made up my mind to return to school part time, and enrolled at the evening classes at the Tak Ming Middle School near the MacPherson Playground in Mongkok of Kowloon Peninsula. The factory was still small in those days but my responsibilities were heavy and my chores cumbersome. It was difficult to keep working and studying. I barely managed to make the grade and had to stop after completing Form Three. Even so, I recognised the importance of learning, and later turned to English, bookkeeping and accountancy courses to educate myself. Whenever time allowed, I would reflect on my experiences, especially on how to deal with people and how to manage the business. By nature, I did not mind being taken advantage of by people which enabled me to build a large network with the factories outsourcers. I had, therefore, little trouble with getting work orders. But work orders can only be filled by workers. This thought got me thinking: how could I do to motivate others – including the housewives who did the
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
subcontracting work for us. How could we support them to be more dedicated so that we could raise their work efficiency? Our subcontracted housewives had to take care of their families. Some even took on orders from more than one source, which meant we were competing with other factories for labour. The question then came to my mind: ‘How do I make them take rushed orders from us willingly?’ And ‘What would make them willingly put in overtime?’ I thought about these questions through and through. And, as I became more and more seasoned in dealing with people, I came to realise the importance of ‘congeniality’ or ‘harmony.’ Just being willing to pay doesn’t mean others would complete the job to your satisfaction. Give it a human touch, reach out as a friend and show that you carethese are more effective ways to produce desired results. I thus learnt over time the importance of giving rather than taking.
Opening Another Workshop And Meeting The Love Of My Life Our first factory could no longer accommodate our expanding business. We rented a unit on the ground floor on Reclamation Street in Kowloon Peninsula as a second workshop. It was there that I met my future wife, Yvonne. She lived just upstairs from the second workshop and her family were also engaged in subcontracting work and regularly undertook work with our factory. She used her spare time after school to work on making some pocket money and often came downstairs to deliver finished products to us. Mother found her to be ‘a clever girl’ and became very fond of her. She encouraged us to go out with each other. Her mother, my future mother-in-law, was also fond of me, and had many nice words for me. When I was around 20 years old, our parents opened another sweater factory. Yet, the local labour market was tightening, and our sweater business fell short of target. Worse still, Canton Trust Bank, which had been supporting us since the beginning closed
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
down after a bank run. We were plunged overnight into a financial crisis and our factory was on the brink of shutting doors. Fortunately, the Chan brothers, our dear friends and clients, were willing to inject capital to reorganise our business. We joined funds with them in opening a factory in Sun Po Kong, Kowloon Peninsula - the Cordial Knitting Factory in 1965. I represented Father in the joint-venture factory. Except for the overseas customers of the Chan brothers, I was responsible for dealing with other clients as well as other facets of work, ranging from production supervision to back-office support such as finance and administration. The Chans and I had a good working relationship and our joint venture soon took off. In summing up this phase of my development, what I learnt and experienced was a source of inspiration for me, and laid down a solid foundation for the future development of my career in the garment industry.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
- The Difficulties Of Starting A Business Starting My Business with My Wife’s Support In the heydays of the quota system, we pulled together to start our own manufacturing business. Any factory with export quotas was king. Given the circumstances, Crystal could not help but to participate in quota trading. However we still focused on garment manufacturing and keep going till we succeeded today.
Setting Out On My Own With My Wife’s Support After several years partnering with the Chan brothers, I began to see that our visions were different and the thought came to me that I should start a business of my own. It so happened that a couple of friends were interested in partnering with me. I told Father I wanted to venture into the business world on my own terms. He agreed to take over Cordial’s operations. This was how my wife and I started The Crystal Group as a knitwear manufacturer in 1970. I give my dear wife a lot of credit for making the inception of The Crystal Group a reality. I was 23 years old and working at Cordial Knitting Factory when I got married. A few years later, Yvonne became the mother of our two children. When she was pregnant with our third child, she set up her own business with a small factory that specialised in unique crocheting garment design which brought in a higher profit margin. Her business was different from Cordial’s. In addition to caring for the children, Yvonne had to take up all chores big and small at the factory. She threw herself wholeheartedly into production, accounting, technical support, packing and even janitorial work. She worked seven days
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
a week and over 16 hours a day. Such a regimen would have been grueling for an ablebodied young person, let alone a pregnant woman like her! She continued to take good care of my well-being. She would even arrange for our parents to visit our home for a game of mahjong every week in an effort to bring our families even closer. For years, she placed my interests ahead of everything else, and I feel very grateful to her. It was this small factory that brought us our first pot of gold. We ventured into a new business with a capital of HK$700,000. Part of that came from the profit that she made from her own factory and part from our savings, while Father put in a small share and the rest came from funds invested by friends. Such was the humble beginning of the Crystal Group. In addition to helping me establish my own business with her hard-earned savings, Yvonne devoted herself to the running of the company throughout the years, taking charge of the finance and administration. She was an exemplary wife and mother and left me free from other worries to focus on the business. Thinking back on Crystal’s development, with both good and bad memories, I am filled with gratitude for her efforts. I was inexperienced as a beginning entrepreneur, and could not help but make mistakes every now and then. Crises seemed to follow one another, but I was able to learn from mistakes and kept the company going. Three years or so after taking over from me at Cordial, Father also decided to part with the Chans. In 1975, he founded Laws Fashion and managed it together with my younger brothers. Although Father had agreed to me starting out on my own; and helped me by holding shares in my company, deep in his heart, he wished that all six of his children would operate within the family business. I was not able to fulfil his wish in this regard. Looking at it from a different angle, however, it can be said that I gave my brothers and sister the opportunity to realise their potential. Today, we can all boast of our own achievements which I feel comes as a result of our parents trust in us.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
Stay Focused And Seize Every Opportunity Protectionism in the US and Europe directly hampered the growth of the garment industry in Hong Kong. As the government determined the quotas of a company on its past export volume, the higher the company’s past turnover was, the larger the quotas it would get. Those with higher quotas than they could use would sell their surplus to other companies for a profit. In some cases, companies would make more money selling their quotas than manufacturing or exporting. As a result, many in the industry began to stray from their original business of manufacturing garment and turn to trading quotas and diversifying into other sectors such as property development and the stock and bond market. Given the circumstances, Crystal also could not help but participate in trading quotas. However, our priority was on our garment manufacturing, the focus of our business throughout the years. Perhaps our single-mindedness in this regard explains our achievements today. In 2001, the People’s Republic of China became a member of the World Trade Organisation. In 2005, Western countries started to dismantle their trade barriers, and the export quota system was slowly abandoned. In 2008, the quota system for exporting garment to the US was eliminated at long last, thus setting the stage for an era of free competition for the garment industry worldwide. It is not easy to excel in an intensely competitive environment. Crystal, however, found brand new opportunities as well as challenges in such a competitive setting.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Win Or Lose: Opportunity Has Its Price My sincerity pulled me through the crisis. Yvonne was pregnant at the time. Despite her condition, she clambered up a rope ladder on the side of a ship that was bobbing up and down in the waves. Luckily, she made it on board safely. The cargo officer was a reasonable foreign gentleman. When he saw how the pregnant Yvonne made the desperate move of climbing the ladder, he was touched by our sincerity. He said yes to our request immediately and ordered that our goods be hoisted on board.
Inexperienced: Accepting Orders Brashly Out of the HK$700,000 we pulled together as capital for Crystal, HK$300,000 was spent on buying the factory site and the balance was put to use as working capital. Still new to the business, we focused on generating turnover and would take any order that came along. Several months into business, we accepted an order from a Sweden client with a face value of up to HK$400,000, a sum that almost equaled our working capital. It was only after we signed the contract with the Swedish company that we realised we might not be able to meet the delivery deadline. We tried to negotiate for a one-week extension, but the customer took this as a chance to bargain down the unit price. The customer would consider the extension but on its own term: unless we offered a big discount of 25%, the order would be cancelled. Since the production had already begun, a cancellation would be out of question. On the other hand, if we were to give the customer 25% off, we would suffer a huge loss, to say nothing of the damage it would do to our reputation. We decided that the only course of action was to go full steam with our production in the hope of completing the order on time. There was no turning back. Our workers put in a lot of overtime and finally we filled the order on the day of the
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
deadline. However, the merchandise had yet to be delivered. To withdraw payment for the merchandise from the bank, we would have to get a bill of lading, which meant that we had to get the goods on board the ship on time.
My Pregnant Wife Climbed Up A Rope Ladder At that time the containers didn’t exist, and trans-pacific shipment mainly relied on ocean-going freighter. The exporter must first tansfer goods to a barge and then to the freighter. The frieghter would rope down a big net to receive the goods - it was up to the chief tally clerk whether he wanted to accept the goods or not. My wife and I boarded a walla-walla (a noisy shuttle motorboat) with the goods and headed for the barge. The deckhand led us to a rope ladder dangling from the side of the freighter. We would have to climb up to get on board the freighter to get the cargo officer to accept our goods. Yvonne was pregnant at the time. Despite her condition, she clambered up the rope ladder on the side of the ship that was bobbing up and down in the waves. Luckily, she made it on board safely. The cargo officer was a reasonable foreign gentleman. When he saw how the pregnant Yvonne made the desperate move of climbing the ladder, he was touched by our sincerity. He said ‘okay’ to our request immediately and ordered that our goods be hoisted on board. We got the bill of lading! Early the next day, we went to the designated bank to apply for the document to be ‘marked good’ to ensure that we would get paid. Only then did we breathe a sigh of relief, glad that we had weathered the crisis. Looking back, had this been handled differently, this order could have put us in the red or even shut down the factory. This was truly an unforgettable incident. I mention this story here to showcase that my strong sense of commitment and my sincerity in managing the business. Yvonne is an excellent companion in my private and public life. We have our disagreements from time to time. After all, we are in each other’s company 24 hours a day and have to make tough business decisions together. Our personalities are so different. I for example tend to gloss over small details, whereas she seems to fixate on
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
them, so much so that I find her to be stubborn at times. Fortunately, she always puts my consideration ahead of her own. She would go all out to help me with my problems. When I am faced with criticism, she is to come to my defence even if she knew I was in the wrong. She would also make every effort to solve the problem for me. Her contribution to Crystal is indisputable. I am grateful for having her as my wife and business partner!
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
Trust Is The Long-term Competitive Edge Yvonne Lo, co-founder of the Crystal Group, recounts the early days of the Crystal Group. The first Crystal Group factory was in an industrial unit of about 8,000 square feet on Wai Yip Street in Kwun Tong, Kowloon Peninsula. It started out with sweater-knitting with limited machinery. When we received an order, we would buy materials and outsource the work down the chain to sub-contracting small factories who made the goods by hand. We would then sew the pieces together and wash the finished products before packing them for delivery. We got our orders mainly from trading companies. Both Mr Lo and I would make sales calls. Customers trusted us because Mr Lo was widely known for his commitment, integrity and punctuality in delivering quality merchandise. This was how our business expanded. In fact, some trading companies have been collaborating with Crystal for years. Based on the trust that was built over decades, these long-time customers are most confident in placing their orders with us and would not stipulate where we produce the goods. Some may wonder if meeting every customer request to the point of losing money is the proper way to do business. But Mr Lo and I both believe that we should not let our customers suffer at all. Some of the orders that we took on did lead to losses. To meet tight deadlines, we sometimes had to shift the work to production bases overseas that came with higher overheads. We simply absorbed the cost differential. To us, goodwill built on trust is Crystal’s most valuable asset. It gives us the competitive edge which secures for us a long-term relationship with our customers.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Days Of Chasing Quotas And Opening Factories We roamed the globe like nomads to set up manufacturing bases. Garment makers with limited quotas could not rely solely on buying quotas locally from other manufacturers if they hoped to expand their business, because the risk and the cost were high. As a solution, they would have to venture into new lines of merchandise or set up factories in jurisdictions that were not restricted by export quotas. If they moved production overseas, they could even make some money by selling off the quotas they had on hand. In the heydays of the quota system, the garment manufacturers were no different from nomads. Nomads in the past roamed all over the land in search of an oasis and water. For garment manufacturers, the search was to open factories in low-cost foreign jurisdictions that were exempted from export quota restrictions. It would have been difficult to survive any other way. Apart from garment manufacturing, no other industries had to set up manufacturing bases overseas in search of quotas.
Make Money on Quotas to Reduce Costs Garment makers with limited quotas could not rely solely on buying quotas locally from other manufacturers if they hoped to expand their business, because the risk and costs were high. As a solution, they would have to venture into new lines of merchandise or set up factories in jurisdictions that were not restricted by export quotas. If they moved production overseas, they could even make some money by selling off the quotas they had on hand. However, setting up production overseas might not be a permanent solution. As soon as exports from a country unrestricted by the quota system reached a certain volume, it would probably draw the attention of the protectionist US and European governments and the quota system would be imposed on it as well. Then the manufacturers would
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
have to seek another haven. By nature, the garment industry is labour-intensive with a low profit margin. Thus, besides dealing with the quota system, manufacturers had to consider how to reduce operating cost and ensure adequate labour supply when setting up a new factory overseas. In the past years, China’s relatively low operating costs made it viable for manufacturers to set up their production there. Indeed, many apparel makers moved across the border from Hong Kong, making the Mainland the ‘factory of the world’. But as life continued to improve in the rural areas in China, the residents there no longer saw much of a need to go to work in the cities. Meanwhile, operating costs soared, causing a number of apparel makers to pull out of China and shift their production to Southeast Asian countries where costs were lower and the supply of unskilled labour steady.
Set Up In Africa To Skirt The Quota Issue In 1972, I went to Mauritius with a few other apparel makers to scout for opportunities. We noticed that wages were very low and the country was not subject to export quota restrictions. As soon as we returned to Hong Kong, we worked on a plan to invest in a knitwear factory there. Mauritius was extremely backward at the time. To make a phone call to Hong Kong, one would have to go to the local office of the Hong Kong Cable and Wireless Ltd. to make a call to England where it would then be relayed to Hong Kong. It often took a long time to get the call connected, making communications extremely inconvenient. We relied mostly on telegrams to communicate between the factory and the Hong Kong head office. We often could not keep abreast of the latest information, which resulted in shipment delays sometimes. But then Mauritius garment exports were not subject to the quota system; we simply put up with the inconveniences.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
The Three Musketeers In Mauritius Sherman Lau, the Crystal Group’s Principal Adviser, recounts the pioneering days in Mauritius. We set up production in Mauritius mainly because a group of our European customers preferred to do their buying there. They were attracted by the low cost of the place and its proximity to Europe, which made it a convenient location for them. We set up our factory in Mauritius factory mainly to serve our European customers. However, in a period over ten years from 1972 to 1986, our Mauritius factory did not turn out the way we wanted. Could it be a personnel problem? Mr Lo had sent me and the finance director to Mauritius on a prospecting trip. One month later, Mr Lo asked me and Frankie Wong (now a Crystal executive director) to transfer from Malaysia to Mauritius to oversee the knitwear operations. Half a year earlier, Dennis Wong (currently also a Crystal executive director) had been assigned to Mauritius. The three of us, young men in their 20s, plus another colleague by the name of Mr Hung, thus assumed the big role of running the Mauritius factory. Frankie and I left for Mauritius as soon as we got the assignment. We did not even know what our salary was. Nor did Mr Lo mention it. As it turned out, it had completely slipped his mind. We had to wait until we returned to Hong Kong on a debriefing trip a few months later to find out. So there you have it – this was how much we trusted each other and cherished our relationship. We did not haggle over small matters.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
A Bold And Visionary Approach To Delegating In retrospect, Mr Lo was quite audacious to have delegated the running of his Mauritius business to three twenty-something with relatively little practical experience or advanced schooling. That, incidentally, was indicative of his trust in people. Mr Lo did have his own way of doing business, which was quite unconventional. He was especially fond of hiring young people. Later events proved his foresight. During his time in Mauritius, Frankie proved to be an excellent manager. Dennis also showed leadership qualities. Years later, all three of us were able to rise to the rank of senior management in the Crystal Group, thanks to Mr Lo’s careful grooming. However, Mauritius did not present much of an opportunity for growth. After all, it was a small distant country with a population of just about one million. As time went by, we had to import labour from other territories to help out in the factory. In the end, Crystal decided to exit from Mauritius.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
- Institutionalising Reforms Setting Up A Joint Venture In China With My Friend From US China’s economic reform opened up business opportunities, which we were eager to grab. China began its economic reforms in 1978. With its huge population, China had a high unemployment rate at the time, which was a good source of unskilled labour for Hong Kong manufacturers. Also, land was relatively cheap and labour cost low. Best of all, the Chinese government had a new policy to attract foreign investments. Hong Kong enterprises could set up production across the border under the policy of ‘Processing and Compensation Trades’. Recognising this as an opportunity, Crystal was among the first group of Hong Kong garment manufacturers to transfer its knitting and sewing operations across the border to Guangdong Province.
Expand Into China On ‘Processing And Compensation Trade’ Hong Kong was the first of Asia’s ‘Four Little Dragons’ as industrialisation took off in the late 1970s. The electronics, garment and toys industries were all vying for a limited labour force. There were more jobs than willing workers. Compared to the other industries, the work of making knitwear was tough and the pay was low. Few wanted to enter such an industry. Often, recruitment results were less than satisfactory, and labour shortage hampered business expansion. China began its economic reforms in 1978. With its huge population, China had a high unemployment rate at the time, which was a good source of unskilled labour for Hong Kong manufacturers. Also, land was relatively cheap and labour cost low. Best of all, the Chinese government had a new policy to attract foreign investments. Hong Kong
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
enterprises could set up production across the border under the policy of ‘Processing and Compensation Trades’. Recognising this as an opportunity, Crystal was among the first group of Hong Kong garment manufacturers to transfer its knitting and sewing operations across the border to Guangdong. And what is ‘Processing and Compensation Trade’? It refers to a joint venture approach specific to that era. Foreign enterprises were allowed to import raw materials, designs (including samples) and parts to produce merchandise in China. Within the agreed timeframe, the Mainland Chinese enterprise would repay the cost of the equipment, technology and such things with the goods produced, the value equivalent of the imports or the labour cost. Under this policy, Crystal set up its first mainland factory in Zhongshan (not on the same location as its current factories) to engage in add-on processing for export. At that time, we installed machinery on a large scale and trained a great number of unskilled workers to produce knitwear. China’s exports to the US also came under the quota system. We took a flexible approach to utilise our quotas. For instance, when exporting to the US, we used the mainland quota. For products involving just add-on processing, we used the Hong Kong quota.
American-Hong Kong Joint Venture To Start Sinotex An American client by the name of Mr Martin Trust became a good friend over time. We both entered China to take advantage of the “Processing and the Compensation Trades” policy. I first met Mr Trust, a Jewish American, when he was a client of Cordial. Just like me, he decided to start his own business in 1970. He named the company Mast Industries. The company was later acquired by Limited Brands Inc. (now called L Brands), the parent company of Victoria’s Secret. Crystal and Mast Industries established a 50-50 joint venture in 1980 and named it Sinotex Limited. Sinotex went on to set up production bases in China, Sri Lanka and Mauritius. It was a sizeable operation with over 1,000 workers in China and between 3,000 to 4,000 workers in Sri Lanka and Mauritius. Sinotex principally exported to Mast Industries’ subsidiaries in the US; it also sold goods to other US importers.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Crystal, Sinotex and Mast Industries all had their own Mainland and Hong Kongbased export quotas. Because Sinotex could utilise Mainland quota and exports from Sri Lanka and Mauritius were not subject to restrictions, the orders kept rolling in. Orders that came from L Brands and Mast Industries were mainly assigned to Sinotex. The latter also picked up other orders in Hong Kong. Under such circumstances, the joint-venture company thrived. During a visit to the Hong Kong office, Mr Trust, who was accompanied by the head of his principal investor Mr Les Wexner, remarked: ‘Sinotex is a cash cow.’ That was his view on Sinotex – an exciting money maker with a bright future.
A Broadened Vision And New Inspirations By taking advantage of China’s economic reform, Crystal was able to derive three benefits from its investments in China. First, we gained experience in setting up production bases in China and dealing with the Mainland’s regional and local government officials. Second, by utilising the Mainland’s vast workforce and its export quotas, Crystal’s business took a major step forward. Third, by partnering with Mr Trust, I soon realised the difference in management style between Western enterprises and Chinese family-owned businesses. Inspired by Western management model, I made up my mind to turn Crystal into a professionally managed modern enterprise. This was a major turning point in the Group’s development.
Part Amicably And Friendship Endures In time, the quota system was being phased out. Sinotex’s role thus began to diminish and its existence became awkward. For L Brands, Sinotex served a purpose because it had export quotas. But if quotas no longer figured in the equation, Sinotex would be nothing more than just one of L Brand’s suppliers. It would not have been viable for Sinotex to remain in business just
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
for Mast Industries. But if Sinotex were to get orders for itself, then its business would overlap with Crystal and might even compete with it. In the end, it was agreed that Crystal would take over all of Sinotex’s shares and integrate Sinotex’s manufacturing facilities under its wings. The joint venture was brought to an end on amicable terms. We terminated our collaboration but our friendship continued. Mr Wexner, Mr Trust and I are still in close touch with each other both on the personal and business levels. When my eldest son Andrew (currently Crystal Group’s Chief Executive Officer) went to the US to get trained at L Brand, he boarded at Les’s home. My wife and I frequently visited the US, and when we were there, we became Mr Trust’s house guests. Once, Yvonne and I went to Israel with Mr Wexner, Mr Trust and his wife on Mr Wexner’s’ private jet to check out the prospect of setting up production in that country. Although the plan did not pan out, our friendship was not the least bit affected. In the business world, it is common to collaborate and then go separate ways. But as long as you make friends and widen your network from every angle you will have a competitive edge no matter where you go.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Towards Modern Enterprise Management Having learnt from others, I decided to reform my own company. Figures and issues ranging from profit margins to the company’s future, which Chinese enterprises would find highly confidential, were put to public discussion at the meeting. They at Mast Industries were most relaxed about disclosing the company’s operation and detailed financial information to an outsider like me. This was in complete contrast to the secrecy with which Chinese businessmen treat such information. Yvonne and I were astounded.
A Model To Emulate Mr Trust ran his company the Western way. As his business ally, I was invited from time to time to visit and observe how his company was managed. What I witnessed broadened my horizons and sparked the idea in me to learn from his example. In our capacity as a supplier, Yvonne and I attended his annual general company meeting one year. That was when I noticed how transparent the management of his company was. Figures and issues ranging from profit margins to the company’s future, which Chinese enterprises would find highly confidential, were put to public discussion at the meeting. They at Mast Industries were most relaxed about disclosing the company’s operation and detailed financial information to an outsider like me. This was in complete contrast to the secrecy with which Chinese businessmen treat such information. Yvonne and I were astounded. Seeing how Mr Trust treated his employees as equals, how transparent the company communication was and how efficient the management was, I began to realise the virtues of western management. On a visit to Limited Brands, I noticed that its IT department took up over 10,000
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
square feet. That was an eye-opener indeed. Although logistics was still a new concept at the time, the company’s warehouse was already automated and was running smoothly. I could not but think that an enterprise should be run just like that. As the Chinese adage goes, one can use the stones from one hill to polish the jade from another, underlining the importance of learning from others. Having witnessed first-hand how modern companies operate, I began to wonder if Crystal’s family-way of business would be able to meet the need of future expansion. After much consideration, I made up my mind to transform Crystal into a modern enterprise that would employ the latest technology, encourage communication and foster transparency.
The First Annual Meeting With Mast Industries system as a model, we held our first offsite annual meeting at the Silvermine Bay Hotel in Mui Wo, Lantau Island in 1987. We have continued with this practice since. That particular meeting was especially memorable, not just because it was our first but because of an unexpected incident. Frankie, then Malaysia’s officer in charge, had flown in from Penang exclusively for the event. Unfortunately, during the meeting, he came down with a case of acute hepatitis and had to be airlifted by helicopter to the Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong. I visited Frankie at the hospital the next day. He was still placed in intensive care, however he could not take his mind off the factory in Malaysia. He was worried that with his hospitalisation, he would not be able to make it back on time to process the payroll. I told him to relax and to get better. In the end, Frankie pulled through. I was touched by the way Frankie put work before his own well-being. I kept thinking that if only our company had more managers as responsible and dedicated as Frankie, then we would have a bright future.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Company Transformed Upon Resolving Differences Yvonne and I founded Crystal together. If the company was to undergo any makeover to implement modern enterprise management, then I must first get Yvonne’s approval and support. Yvonne’s strength lies in her familiarity with the business and her hands-on working style. She was also hard-working and astute. She was the perfect person to be in charge of a family-style business. But when it came to putting in place a modern enterprise management system, she could be an obstacle. To succeed in putting in place the modern enterprise management, one must do away with the thought that the boss is always right. Increasing the organisation’s transparency, setting objectives, delegating authority, fostering team spirit and practicing a people-oriented corporate culture are all important. Above all, since people are required to execute policies and procedures, one must also motivate all employees from top to bottom to work towards the same goal. I persevered. With determination, patience and persistent efforts, I succeeded in transforming a ‘husband-and-wife team’ to a major people-oriented organisation staffed by a versatile and unified professional team that championed the Greater Good and the priority of the customer. During the transition, differences in opinion often got in the way. But through constant communication and by adopting a give-and-take attitude, my wife and I managed to resolve all disagreements and put Crystal at the top position it stands at today.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
Foray Into Japan: Getting Ready For A Rainy Day Paying attention to quality control has given us an added competitive edge. Andrew (currently the Crystal Group’s Chief Executive Officer) often asked me: “Would Crystal close down if the quota restrictions were lifted?”
Develop A New Market Hampered by the quota restrictions imposed by the US and Europe, Hong Kong’s garment makers could go only two routes to expand: either buy surplus quotas from competitors or set up production in jurisdictions unburdened by the quota restrictions. Under such circumstances, it was hard to make full use of one’s potential, like a dragon swimming in a shallow pond. For this reason, I had long held a wish to cultivate new markets outside of Europe and North America. In the early 1990s, a rumor had started going around the industry that the quota system would come to an end. Some apparel makers had survived under the protective umbrella of this system solely by transferring their quotas for a fee and turning in a considerable profit. If the quota system was dropped, however, clothing brand names would be able to source from any countries. This would intensify competition around the world, making it increasingly hard to do business. Andrew often asked me: “Would Crystal close down if the quota restrictions were lifted?” I decided to plan for the rainy day by developing a new market and preparing Crystal for the heated competition of the post-quotas era. My first target market was Japan, which did not have a quota system and boasted of a sizeable market.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Opening the Japan market was easier said than done, however. It was widely known that trying to do business with the Japanese would be difficult. They were particular about quality, which, incidentally, was entirely different from the US. Also, they valued long-term alliances; they would not work with a new partner unless there is no other way. Crystal was facing global competition in the garment industry. To survive, transformation is a must. Even though I knew it would be an uphill battle, I targeted Japan as our new market and plunged ahead.
My Fortuitous Encounter With Mr Tadashi Yanai To open the Japan market, we set up a dedicated team led by Dennis who just rejoined Crystal. The team’s efforts paid off. We were able to get orders from a number of Japanese brand names, including Jusco, UNY, Nissen, and a start-up company by the name of Fast Retailing Company, Limited. Fast Retailing (FR) had a chain known as Unique Clothing Warehouse, which soon took off like wildfire throughout the country under the acronym of Uniqlo. It is now a well-known fact that Uniqlo began as a small outlet and rapidly rose to the rank of the top four retail apparel brands in the world. Crystal has benefited from collaborating with Uniqlo for all that time and our business expanded along with that of our Japanese client. We have to thank Personal Care Systems (PCS) for introducing Crystal to Uniqlo. After setting up the collaboration between the two companies, PCS’s founder Mr Yasuhiko Hasegawa continued to work alongside Crystal. He and I became good friends. Mr Hasegawa now devotes himself to finding a new path for the younger generation in Japan. He frequently shuttles among Japan, Hong Kong and China, and continues to act as the bridge between Crystal and FR founder Mr Yanai. Mr Hasegawa belongs to the rare breed that puts friendship before self-interest. He derives great satisfaction from playing the ‘matchmaker’ between Uniqlo and Crystal
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
and sincerely hopes that the two companies can remain long-term allies. His one big wish is to see both companies take the top spot in the apparel industry. With him as a friend, what more can I ask for? Our experience in Japan tells us that as long as you build trust, you can develop a long-standing relationship with Japanese customers, some of whom would even put their own interests aside for you.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Learn Quality First From Japanese Dennis Wong, Executive Director of Crystal Group talks about the Uniqlo experience. I returned to Crystal in 1996 mostly responsible for opening new markets. Except for South American countries, Japan was the only territory without a quota system at the time. 90% of garments being exported to Japan came from China where pricing was highly competitive while profit margins were low. Furthermore, Japanese importers were most demanding on quality. That was why few Hong Kong garment manufacturers were interested in servicing Japanese brands.
Trust Built Upon Passing Tough Tests When we first contacted Uniqlo in 1996, the company gave us a tall order to fill as a test. In those days when technology was not that advanced, Uniqlo asked us to deliver 17 samples of collared T-shirts in 10 days. Different parts of each garment had to be in a specific color. If we failed to fill the order, we could forget about collaborating any further. This was really a ‘mission impossible.’ To accomplish the mission, there were three preconditions: the supplier’s co-operation, our own technical competence and our ability to respond quickly. Each color would have to be dyed onto the fabric first at precisely the specified tone. To do it on 17 different colors alone would have been an elaborate process. On top of that, we had to use different fabrics on different parts of the T-shirt. We estimated that it would roughly take 28 to 35 days to complete the job but we only had 10 days! Uniqlo probably did not expect us to deliver, we felt the order was given
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
as a tactful way to turn us down. We worked extremely hard and completed the samples on time. Then we visited Uniqlo in Japan and spread out all 17 T-shirts for them to inspect. They were stunned. They could not believe that a garment manufacturer in Hong Kong could actually accomplish something so highly technically demanding within such a tight deadline. They could see that Crystal was serious about collaboration. Our business alliance with Uniqlo was off to a good start.
Blaze New Trail As Quota System Ends We have learnt a lot from our client Uniqlo. Their meticulous and demanding way of doing things showed us a brand new approach to business. When the quota system was finally abandoned in 2005, we were able to draw on our experience in Japan to cultivate new niches in the US and Europe markets where competition had stepped up. Armed with substantial production capability, merchandise of high quality, competitive pricing and versatility, we stood a good chance. By promulgating sustainability in recent years, Crystal has managed to secure a certain position in the global market today. Crystal’s strategy of moving from the Japanese market to the global market brought to light the senior management’s vision. We have Mr Lo to thank for his foresight in staying ahead of others in managing the crisis well in advance that might crop up in the industry.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
- Setting The Scene To Become The World’s No. 1 An Expensive Lesson An underestimation of the risk resulted in a hasty retreat from Madagascar. This not only threw a wrench in our production plan but sent us scurrying to get export quotas from others. For the only time in Crystal’s history, we were in the red.
Lured By Incentives To Invest In Africa In 2002, the US launched a programme to help African countries develop their economy under the African Growth and Opportunity Act (AGOA). Under AGOA, exports from Africa to the US would be exempted from import duties. Crystal had had its production base in Mauritius for some years but growth was limited by the small gross domestic product value in that country. Rather than benefiting from it, Mauritius now faced intensifying competition from the rest of Africa under AGOA. With the duty free offer from the US within reach, we of course did not wish to miss out on the chance. Moreover, some clients were encouraging us to expand in Africa. After a preliminary study, we decided to set up three manufacturing plants in Madagascar and employ some 4,000 workers. The factories would focus on making T-shirts, sweaters and denim wear. Since our investment value was huge and we would employ a lot of workers, Crystal’s plan was supported enthusiastically by the prime minister, the minister of commerce and the minister of labour of Madagascar.
Caught In A Political Storm Upon completing phase one of the Madagascar production facilities, we imported a batch of scrap fabric to use as material for training workers. When the Madagascar
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
customs officers noticed that we had labeled the goods simply as ‘fabric’ and not ‘scrap fabric’ on the custom papers, they suspected us of making false declaration with an intention to violate the law. We thought at the time that these customs officers probably wanted to derive some personal advantage from the mix-up. However, since we were not in the wrong, we argued our case first with the minister of commerce, then the prime minister, but to no avail. The authorities there at that time even threatened to deprive Crystal’s three factories of their AGOA status. We found out later that it was the opposition wanted to strike out at the ruling party and boost its own power by sabotaging foreign investment. We were caught in a political storm and the issue of our customs declaration got stuck in a stalemate. Meanwhile, the political situation worsened. A civil war broke out in Madagascar. The roads leading from the port to our factories were barricaded. All transportation halted. Production also came to a stop. It has been my belief all along that industrial investment would boost employment and raise GDP. Those in power should act in the interest of its people and protect foreign investors rather than deliberately jeopardising their own business environment. Even in Sri Lanka where Crystal had manufacturing facilities, the civil war had raged on all this time without disrupting foreign-invested operations. That was because both the opposition and the government realised the need to uphold the interest of foreign investors. In Sri Lanka, no demonstrators or opposition forces would occupy the airport, barricade the container terminals or disrupt traffic. The Madagascar government had courted foreign investments zealously, which blinded us from its political instability. What confounded me was the Madagascar politicians’ wanton disregard of their countrymen’s welfare. They plotted to destroy the business environment and were only too ready to engage in skirmishes and victimize in the process foreign investors such as Crystal. We learned a big lesson at a hefty price.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Bite The Bullet And Cut The Losses Seeing how the political situation was getting out of hand and how production was paralysed, we decided to cut our losses. We would withdraw from Madagascar even if we failed to sell a single item of our products there. We suffered losses that amounted to almost the profit of the entire year for several reasons. Firstly, we could not recoup a single cent from the equipment installed within the factories. Secondly, we had to reassign the orders that we received to other production bases. This not only threw a wrench in our production plan but sent us scurrying to get export quotas from others. For the only time in Crystal’s history, we were in the red. Having learnt our lesson the hard way in Madagascar, we adjusted our strategy to invest only in countries closer to home, including Vietnam, Sri Lanka, Cambodia and Bangladesh, which are all within several hours of flying distance. This makes management much more feasible. Moreover, the cultures of these places are much closer to our own, and it would be much easier to recruit workers, manage the facilities and train workers. It followed that our production bases in other Asian countries expanded gradually from a workforce of a few thousand in each factory to employing upwards of 10,000 workers in each mega-factory. This was another important milestone in Crystal’s history.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
Acquisition Of A British Intimates Company We seized an opportunity and diversified geographically. Instead of sending someone from Hong Kong office to oversee CMI’s operations, we left it to the local management team. We only helped improve company strategies, raise efficiency and strengthen the financial position. Thanks to Crystal’s positive credit standing, CMI found it much easier to raise capital loans and do so on better terms - the financial problem was soon over.
Running Four Complementary Business Lines Crystal started out producing mainly sweaters. Later on, we added T-shirts and denim. In 2004, we also got into the business of intimate wear. Now we have four main business lines. The sweaters line is seasonal. For most of the time, we receive orders for the entire year in six months, but the overhead costs will have to be borne for the entire year. To expand and raise turnover, in 1975, we added T-shirts and denim to our production line. When we first joined the rank of T-shirt manufacturing, we focused on the collarless type because we were able to get the export quotas. Also, the production process of collarless T-shirts was simpler and easier. As for denim, we focused first on jeans for women. Jeans could be worn yearround so seasonal fluctuation was not a factor. Moreover, the export quotas for denim commanded a considerable price of up to several hundred Hong Kong dollars per dozen. The orders kept coming and we utilised our quotas fully. We did not know much about the underwear business. We just knew that lingerie, underpants and brassiere came in many different styles that changed with the fashion. The production technology was manifold and the production process was certainly more
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
complicated than that of T-shirts. It was only in 2004 that we started to learn about this particular business line. It was the same year that we acquired Martin Empress International Holdings Limited (MIH) - an intimate wear business.
Acquiring And Turning Around MIH MIH was a listed company in the United Kingdom. Founded in the 1920s, its major client was the British department store Marks & Spencer. As the majority shareholders had all passed away and the minority shareholders each held no more than 3% of the company’s shares, the lack of leadership began to take its toll. The company was managed poorly and the turnover declined while expenditure climbed year after year. The company was mired in financial woe. We decided to take over MIH so as to get business from M&S. Crystal had already been transformed into a professionally managed enterprise at the time. Following the acquisition, we set about amalgamating its personnel, assets and clientele and delisted MIH. We then changed its name to Crystal Martin International (CMI). Instead of sending someone from Hong Kong office to oversee CMI’s management, we left it to the original team. We only helped improve the company’s strategies, raise its efficiency and strengthen its financial position. Thanks to Crystal’s good credit standing with banks, CMI found it much easier to raise capital and do it on better terms. Its financial problem was soon over. In fact, CMI had a capable management team. It was just hamstrung by the lack of resources to live up to its potential. After improving operations and finances, the company soon turned around and has not been in the red since. It has been 10 years since the merger. The UK management team, which collaborates well with the rest of the Group, has put in a laudable performance. CMI is clearly contributing more and more to the Group.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
Say ‘No’ To Marks & Spencer Lawrence Ward, the retired CMI’s Chief Executive Officer, recounts Crystal’s acquisition of MIH. I first suggested to Crystal’s Andrew Lo about buying shares of Martin Empress International Holdings in April 2002. As a result, Crystal bought 27.7% of the then listed company. Some other Hong Kong investors also had their sight on MIH at the time. But I had known Andrew since October 1996 and also met his father in 1999 and his mother the year after. I was familiar with Crystal’s modus operandi and corporate culture. Crystal’s management style was something I could identify with. In the course of our collaboration, one incident was especially memorable that convinced me that Crystal was a partner that one could trust absolutely.
An Ally through Thick And Thin M&S began a process of strategic analysis in 1999. The responsible consultant had recommended to its board of directors that M&S showed reduce the number of its suppliers. We were supplying M&S with men’s sweaters at the time. Although our products were of high quality, our company size was smaller than most competitors’. Hence we were crossed off the M&S supplier list. Meanwhile, M&S also informed Crystal it would have to choose another ‘qualified supplier’ to continue a relationship with the department store. I was upset and frustrated. Out of desperation, I phoned Andrew with the news that M&S would drop MIH as a supplier. I then asked if Crystal would prefer to link up with another supplier to keep M&S as a client, adding that
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
I would support his decision, whatever it might be. In less than half an hour, Andrew called me back. He said although Crystal’s business would have much potential by continuing to serve M&S, the management had decided to say no to the retail giant. Crystal would keep MIH as ally and seek new opportunities together. It was obvious that Crystal’s management would not abandon an ally out of self-interest. Crystal would support us through thick and thin. That was why Crystal was our first choice of an investor.
Clients Return On Improved Finances In 2002, M&S approached us again to source merchandise – this time, intimate wear. By 2006, our company became M&S’s biggest supplier. After Crystal bought 27.7% of the MIH shares, our company’s financial conditions improved. So did our market value, which helped put us back on M&S’s supplier list. Now that the company had gained strong financial backing, our colleagues minds were put at ease and they could focus on doing a good job. We pulled together to channel our energy onto boosting the turnover. We were determined to turn around the company completely. By the end of 2003, I was convinced that Crystal had gained enough confidence in MIH. I thus proposed that Crystal buy the remaining 72.3% of MIH’s shares. However, the minority shareholders were harping on a higher acquisition price, thus delaying the acquisition process. Finally, on June 21, 2004, Crystal submitted for the London Stock Exchange’s approval its proposal to acquire all remaining shares of MIH.
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
Be Positive And Delegate Responsibilities On the day when Crystal announced the offer to acquire MIH, I flew to Hong Kong. When I arrived the next day at the Crystal office, I asked Mr Lo the reason for the acquisition. He simply said: “It was because I had promised you that I would acquire MIH. But I also want all shareholders to be given a fair deal.” This was the first time I witnessed first-hand how honorably Mr Lo conducted himself. I was deeply impressed. As I got to know Mr Lo over the years, I found him to be an excellent leader. He does not mind criticism, and is never rude in his reply. When he disagrees with you, instead of arguing, he simply excuses himself from the conference room. So every time he says he needs to step out, I take the hint that he has a different opinion. I will then sit back to think over what I have said and how I have said it. Mr Lo is a candid person. One time he told me up front that while he admired my enthusiasm and sense of responsibility, he wished I could be more positive and learn not to dwell on the negatives. He also said I should listen closely to people working beneath me and delegate duties more often. Finally, he advised me to have the courage to look inside myself for self-improvement and to pay attention to the things around me. I took to heart his advice and began to see my own shortcomings. I decided to change for the better, with the hope of making myself a more effective leader and a more caring manager.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
The Turning Point We fought an uphill battle against mounting odds and managed to turn a crisis into an opportunity. In my long years as an entrepreneur, I have always felt that the world is like a game of chess where things are changing all the time. Although it can be said that uncertainties can foster a sense of crisis, so much so that people could take preventive measures, events such as the spread of the SARS, the delay in China’s readmission to the GATT and the global financial crisis are things that no one could foresee. To manage crises, one simply has to plan ahead…
2005: A Critical Year Going into the 21st century, Crystal encountered one challenge after another. First, we decided to pull out of Madagascar in 2002. In the same year, we decided to invest a large amount in the SAP ERP system. In 2003, the Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS) terrorised Hong Kong for months, sending the local economy on a tailspin. In 2005, the World Trade Organisation announced that all 55 member countries with textile quotas would abolish this restrictive trade policy in phases. In 2008, the whole world was engulfed in a financial crisis. Crystal’s development could not help but be hampered to some degree. We found 2005 to be full of challenges. But it was also a turning point for Crystal. We fought an uphill battle and won. Indeed, back in the late 1990s, the WTO had announced that the textile quota system would be phased out. Recognising the imminent challenge that this would pose, Andrew said to Yvonne and I: “I’m worried that Crystal might have to close down!” The crisis had yet to occur, however, and so we did not do much in response to Andrew’s prediction. As the crisis drew close, pressure began to mount, and we started to give serious thoughts to our future survival. How would Crystal face the prospect of losing
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
the quota advantage? We devised a strategic reorganisation of the Group, involving such things as deciding which factory to reform and which subsidiary to close down, and then we mapped out a detailed development plan.
Rethink Strategy On Quota Abolition The abolition of the quota system meant that Crystal would face competition from around the world, which could send garment prices on a downward spin. Yet overhead costs would only rise by the day. On the other hand, once free from the restrictions of the quotas, the value of an order could rise multiple times or even a hundred times above that of the past. We saw an opportunity amidst the crisis. We decided to take the bull by the horns and make two strategic moves. We first increased our investment in China by opening more factories there. As soon as China resumed its status as a member of GATT, we could then take advantage of Mainland’s large labour force and the technological edge, and consequently raise our cost effectiveness there. Secondly, we started to plan mega production facilities so that we could gain from the economy of scale. We would also apply what we learnt from our Japan experience to raise the quality of our products and boost our productivity. This, we believe, would be our competitive edge.
Vision To Be The World’s No. 1 In the old days, export quotas from a single country would not generate enough volume to support the output capacity of a mega factory. A factory that employed 1,000 to 2,000 workers was deemed sizeable. But times have changed. Nowadays, everywhere you look, you will find factories employing over 10,000 workers. Uniqlo’s merchandise is widely popular among consumers worldwide. Riding on Uniqlo’s success, Crystal also went on a rapid expansion path. Inspired by Mr Yanai, we envisioned ourselves becoming the world’s top apparel maker. It was no day-dream. We have gone about it with an accurate scientific approach, setting targets and implementing our plan step by step. We truly believe that we are on the way to the top rung in garment
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
manufacturing globally. To become the world’s top apparel maker, one has to have a large production capacity. This is where mega plants come into play. This is the way to go as a trend of the times and as a corporate goal.
Plan Marred by China’s Delayed Admission to GATT As early as 2000, we had begun to increase our investment in China. We built more production facilities, fitted them out with all necessary equipment and trained workers – all in preparation for intensifying competition from the abolition of textile quotas. We wanted to take advantage of China’s status as the ‘factory of the world’. By 2005, trade barriers the world over were supposed to be dismantled. However, due to the political frictions between China and the US, the European Union and the US jointly filed a complaint with the WTO accusing China of breaking its promise to embrace free trade when it joined the WTO in 2001. In other words, in their eyes, China was yet to open its market entirely. As a result, China’s readmission to GATT was delayed. The upshot was that China’s textile designated for Europe and the US were still subject to quota restrictions. For Crystal, the impact was substantial. Garment manufacturers, especially those in the Mainland, saw their orders being cut down. This threw a wrench in our plan. Moreover, our production facilities overseas were just not adequate to handle the intensifying global competition. Our profit dropped considerably.
Riding Out The Storm Since we could not increase our revenue, we had to reduce our overhead. We decided then to move the Hong Kong-based workforce across the border where the costs of living were markedly lower, and to speed up the communications with the factory there. Fortunately, at this critical juncture, we received full support from our colleagues who stayed on to ride out the storm with the company. Their willingness to station themselves in the Mainland was most helpful in reducing our overhead. Finally in 2008,
C hap ter One : My Jou rney W ith C r ystal
China re-joined the GATT. Its textile exports to the US and Europe would no longer be subject to quota restrictions. It was only then that our production facilities became utilised in full. Our financial performance improved. In 2008, the global financial crisis hit. Crystal could not escape from the blow. Upon carefully analysing the situation, we believed that the crisis would abate before long. Crystal’s business was by then stable. Our confidence doubled that we would weather the onslaught of the financial crisis.
Think Ahead Like A Chess Player In my long years as an entrepreneur, I have always felt that the world is like a game of chess where things are changing all the time. Although it can be said that uncertainties can foster a sense of crisis, so much so that people could take preventive measures, events such as the spread of the SARS, the delay in China’s readmission to the GATT and the global financial crisis are things that no one could foresee. To manage crises, one simply has to plan ahead. I believe my philosophy is a workable one – with the Greater Good as the goal and a people-oriented philosophy as the basis, one can then build up a unified team. Train and nurture talents and be prepared always for contingencies. Step up to face difficulties bravely, and with a responsible spirit and a united workforce as a support, one is ready to confront challenges of all kinds.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Chapter Two Our Principles Build Core Values For The Greater Good.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter Two: Our Principles
- The Greater Good And The Respect For People ◆
The Greater Good And The Respect For People
◆
Learn From Water: The Key Of Self-Cultivation
◆
Six Pointers To Resolving Conflicts
◆
Changing Oneself To Change The World
- The Way To Build A Corporate Culture ◆
The Boss Is Not Always Right
◆
Promote Core Values in Times of Stress
◆
Crystal’s Eight Core Values
◆
Results Of 10 Years Of Effort
◆
Setting Up An Organisation With No Boundaries
◆
◆
Accountability System Implemented
◆
The ‘Pull’ And ‘Push’ Approach To Effecting Change
◆
Establishing A Board To Enhance Corporate Governance
◆
Anthony Griffiths: Corporate Culture Is Key To Reform
- The Grand Vision Of Becoming The World’s No. 1
92
Sherman Lau: Crystal’s Success Comes From Boundaryless Enterprise Culture
- Reform The Old Ways: Focus On Management
◆
79
Vision: To Be The World’s No.1 Apparel Maker
108
117
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
- The Greater Good And The Respect For People The Greater Good And The Respect For People If I do well for others, others will do well for me. In my years of enterpreneurial experience, I have seen numerous cases where people succeed for a short while but finally fail because they think only of their own success. By contrast, those who put the bigger picture ahead are often rewarded with a win-win situation for all. I truly believe that working towards the Greater Good is the way to do business and conduct oneself in this world.
Strive For A Win-win Situation With The Greater Good In Mind If one sentence can be used to describe the Crystal Group’s operating philosophy, it is “Put the Greater Good ahead of my personal interest and respect people.” I have, in all my years in the business world, held on to the belief of the Greater Good, with which I hope to inspire people around me. To work for the Greater Good, one has to focus not on oneself but on other people. and put the client’s interest on top of one’s own. On the opposite end of the Greater Good is the Lesser Good. The Greater Good is a relative concept, referring to the interest of a bigger group, but the people who make up the group depends on one’s position and perspective. The Lesser Good, on the other hand, concerns specifically the interest of the individual.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
As a subordinate, the bigger group can be the department where you work. As an employee, it can be the company of which you are a member. As a company, the bigger group can be customers. As a family member, it can be the family. As a citizen, the bigger group can be the city and the country to which you belong. It follows that as a human being, one’s bigger picture can be the environment, the human race and the entire world. In my years of enterpreneurial experience, I have seen numerous cases where people succeed for a short while but finally fail because they think only of their own success. By contrast, those who put the bigger picture ahead are often rewarded with a win-win situation for all. I truly believe that working towards the Greater Good is the way to do business and conduct oneself in this world.
Do Well For Others As the saying goes, “if I do well for you, you will do well for me.” Treat others fairly, generously and respectfully, and you will be treated the same by others. Most people would like to have the Lesser Good, that is, their own interest, taken care of before they turn to take care of the interest of others. In other words, the bigger group has to serve me before I will reciprocate in kind. If we turn it the other way around – do well for others instead of asking others to do well for you -- then everybody will think of the Greater Good, and the world will be a better place. People who live by the adage “If I do well for others, others will do well for me” will understand the point of sacrificing the Lesser Good for the Greater Good. When the Greater Good is served, the Lesser Good will in turn be taken care of. That is the meaning of my philosophy of putting the Greater Good ahead.
Walk The Talk The idea of being people-oriented is founded upon my belief in the Greater Good. The essence lies in getting into the habit of putting the consideration of other people’s interest before one’s own.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Such is the way Crystal runs its business. It shows a caring attitude not just towards the clients and their customers but also the employees, the shareholders and the whole human race. Someone who puts others ahead is a righteous, honest, caring and moral character. He is open-minded and respectful. He would not hold on obstinately to his way of doing things but is ready to consider other people’s point of view. He is not concerned with petty gains and losses as long as he could bring the job at hand to a success. Yet, a leader should not stop at slogan bantering, but must put theory to practice. Most of all, he needs to demonstrate his belief in the Greater Good by his own action. An enterprise is made up of people. It can only thrive if it cares for its employees and cherish them as the greatest asset. A fair and transparent appraisal system coupled with competitive remunerations and benefits will promote those who are capable and foster a harmonious working relationship among all. Being people-oriented is the way to motivate employees and build team spirit. If employees pull together with a single heart and mind, they will put the company within the reach of success. The same approach can and should apply to customer relations. My experience tells me that it is not a good thing if a manufacturer receives absolutely no complaint or demand from his clients. That usually signifies that the relationship will not last. A good client is one with demands. To keep a client in the long run, a manufacturer must continue to raise product quality, expand production capacity, and enhance technology. It is also important to understand the client’s needs and do one’s best to meet them in an uncomplaining and dedicated way. Being able to resolve a client’s problem is the best way to build long-term collaboration.
Adhere To The Principles I am convinced that in the 46 years of Crystal’s experience, we owe our success to my insistence on implementing the people-oriented culture. This has become the core value of the Group. It is from this that we derived the business formula of the ‘3Ps’ : our people, the planet and the company’s profitability. It is the guiding principle that took
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Crystal from its humble beginnings as a family garment business to its current status as a multinational corporation with an annual turnover of our US1.3 billion and on its way to become the world’s top apparel maker.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Learn From Water: The Key Of Self-Cultivation Nothing is as superb as water. Be commodious and you can be great. Water changes to fit in the environment it is in. When heated, it turns into steam; when frozen, it turns into solid ice. At room temperature, it simply takes on the shape of its container. When it comes to adapting to the environment, water is second to none.
Self-cultivation: Aiming For The Long Term Confucius outlines a progression of steps whereby an individual can come to affect the affairs of the world: “By cultivating oneself, one can unite the family; by uniting the family, one can govern the country. By governing the country, one can bring peace to the whole world.” My belief in the corporation’s ability to serve the Greater Good works in a similar way. Everything devolves onto the individual, who must begin with selfcultivation. To cultivate oneself, one must examine thoroughly one’s failings, and commit to changing them. A person in such a state of mind can give up the egotistical way of caring only for one’s own interest and turn to accept the viewpoints of other people. He will not bicker over trivial matters, but instead learn to give himself up for the Greater Good. Someone with cultivation has also to earn the respect of others. Self-cultivation goes hand in hand with a person’s character. It would be impossible to ask others to put aside their interest for the Greater Good when you remain a petty individual concerned only with your own gains and losses.
Put Oneself In The Place Of Others In business, integrity requires one to keep one’s promises and to bring actions and words into alignment. My strong commitment to integrity has made it possible for me to make many friends, maintain long-term relationships with clients and allies and enjoy a
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
good credit standing with banks. Sincerity and trustworthiness are the most valuable assets in human relations. It is important to be able to put yourself in someone else’s shoes. As Confucius said, “do not do to others what you would not have them do to you.” Those who are acquainted with me know that my wife and I love and respect each other. I have always believed that as husband and wife, we should be completely true to each other. Even though I might have to entertain clients at nightclubs and other places from time to time, I never did anything to give my wife any cause for concern. I am not a saint, but whenever I reflect on what Confucius has to say about putting oneself in someone else’s position, I cannot help but think: If I want my wife to be true to me, I have to be true to her. That is simply the basic understanding between husband and wife. One could say that I am too upright (and to the point of being obdurate) but there is nothing wrong with holding onto what is right. I feel the same about upholding my principle of putting the Greater Good ahead of narrow good of the individual and keeping others’ interest in mind. I have given decades trying to foster that culture and put it into practice within the company.
Tolerance And Gratitude In addition to integrity and holding fast to what is right, one should also have a tolerant and grateful heart. A person could do his utmost, but there is no guarantee that he will succeed. It is but the way of the world that things do not always turn out as expected. If you blame others for your own failure, and spend your time planning revenge, you will only make your life miserable. Anger is punishing oneself for the fault of others. What is the meaning of life if your mind is consumed with thoughts of being put upon? You will do much better by being forgiving. Just brush aside all slights and insults with a smile.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Life has its ups and downs, perhaps less ups than downs. Instead of fretting over the many problems one encounters in life, why not focus on moments of pleasure, even though they may be few and far in between? Then you may even feel grateful for what you have. That certainly will put you in a much happier mood than thinking of the “injustices” meted out to you. If you are honorable, live with a clear conscience and do not spend your time scheming against others, you will lead a happy life. You will command respect from your associates and others and your business will succeed.
Take A Cue From Water: Be Flexible I believe that the foundation to self-improvement lies in learning from water. The Chinese philosopher, Lao Zi described a sage as water. Water changes to fit in the environment it is in. When heated, it turns into steam; when frozen, it turns into solid ice. At room temperature, it simply takes on the shape of its container. When it comes to adapting to the environment, water is second to none. In fact, adaptability is also a characteristic of Crystal’s philosophy. The nature of our industry requires that manufacturers operate in a nomadic style. Like water, we adapt to and integrate with the community where we operate, wherever it may be. In our interaction with people, we should also take after water to be accommodating. This does not mean that we should just go with the flow, but that we have to listen to people and understand their needs. Whenever or wherever we find ourselves, having the capacity to accommodate others will make us big. In turn, others will find us approachable and affable. That, indeed, is what I mean by being people-oriented. Water can be soft, it can also be hard. Once an objective is set, we should go about achieving it with the persistence of water that can wear down the hardest rock. We might find it necessary to change our strategy to achieve our goals. Like a boat that rides the waves, we should adjust the sail to catch the most opportune wind.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Regardless of the circumstances that surround us and the problems, the issues and the people that we have to deal with, we will be able to adapt and stay versatile if we learn from water. At the same time, do well by people and build up a unified team will enable us to discover solutions and new opportunities.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Six Pointers To Resolving Conflicts Communicate with sincerity and strive for a win-win situation. Acting on behalf of the Greater Good requires us to consider the greater environment and the needs of other people. We need to resolve conflicts and build an environment without boundary where people on equal footing will respect one another.
The six approaches on resolving conflicts In a business environment or in our interactions with people with their divergence of position and interests, conflicts are likely to arise. This same goes for the husband-and-wife relationship. Conflicts often arise from difference in standpoint and approach. Imagine a husband-and-wife team managing a business. If the two were in frequent argument with each other, the people working for them would be caught in the middle of it. Implementing policies would be difficult, let alone making a company competitive. Over the years, I came up with six approaches to resolving conflicts, all of which evolve around my concept of working for the Greater Good: 1.
Keep a peaceful demeanor and avoid hasty reactions;
Go out of our way to communicate with others and focus on the issue at hand;
Be active, diligent and humble;
Put yourself in other people’s shoes and build up trust;
Put things down in writing for clarity;
Stick to your principles and be patient in explaining them.
Set Examples For Others Yvonne and I worked together to found Crystal, but we do not always see eye to
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
eye. If we refused to give in to each other, our colleagues would be at a loss. That is why we had to communicate with each other sincerely and humbly and learn to focus on the problems at hand. At times, face-to-face conversations might not necessarily help to clarify issues, especially when we had yet to regain a peaceful demeanor. At such moments, we would resort to writing things down. Language helps to filter out our aggrieved feelings, and makes it easier for the other party to accept our position. Email is therefore a good medium for making clear one’s viewpoints, and is helpful in resolving work and family conflicts. I will return to this at a later point in this book. Similarly, I believe that the above approaches can help resolve conflicts in other areas: business, society or politics. Acting on behalf of the Greater Good requires us to consider the greater environment and the needs of other people. We need to resolve conflicts and build an environment without boundary where people on equal footing will respect one another. We will then work and thrive together with harmony and benefits for all. At Crystal, we will begin by bettering ourselves, and spread the message of the Greater Good to the world. Our employees will influence their families, and our corporation will influence the world. Our positive energy will spread like ripples -- from the family, our society, the country and the whole world.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Changing Oneself To Change The World I adhere to my principles in carrying out my responsibilities. If Crystal is selfish in achieving its objectives, turns a blind eye to the Greater Good and ignores the interest of stakeholders, it will end up standing alone, helpless. Even if we are to attain success, it will not last long.
Build A Future On Principles Inscribed on every page of the 46-year history of Crystal are the words “Greater Good”. The meaning of the Greater Good lies in focusing on the people and treating them fairly and respectfully. We regard the team as more important than the individual, which means that we put the interest of the company, our clients and even the whole world above our own. By doing so, conflicts will be resolved and the whole team can take Crystal’s achievement to a higher plane. For the sake of the company’s long-term growth, I think traditional Chinese companies should stop focusing on short-term gains, as well as only looking upon the owner of the company as the supreme decision maker. Instead, I introduced modern management models, ranging from company governance, to information technology and strategic planning. Everything should be state of the art, digitalised and transparent. To build a workforce that is productive and customer-oriented, the head of the company has to give up short-term gains. The employees, likewise, has to abandon the territorial thinking and see beyond their Lesser Good. Middle management has to change their bureaucratic ways. The head of the company should establish corporate directions, and spare no effort in going from place to place, factory to factory, to explain them to the employees and to foster an environment of care. In this way, the company will be filled with positive energy from top to bottom, producing a superior workforce.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
To raise competitiveness, we need to pursue excellence and keep pace with the times. This means we must be ready to abandon old systems and ideas and embrace the most advanced production technology and digital management model. We will not stop short at mobilising the entire workforce to transform ourselves into the most superior and systematic lifelong learning organisation of the world. Faced with the threat of global warming, we need to make an effort to protect the earth by investing in sustainable development, making wise use of the earth resources and safeguarding the interest of the clientele while practicing a responsible and conscionable production method. To ensure the continuing growth of the company for years to come, we recognize the importance of advancing people on the strength of their ability and select only the capable to inherit the business of Crystal. For its future development, we need to continue to innovate to maintain our competitive edge.
Keeping In Mind The Interest Of Our Stakeholders To become the world’s No. 1 apparel maker, we have to excel in our capacity and track records, in addition to keeping in mind our corporate social responsibility. We should never build our success by hurting or taking advantages of others. If Crystal finds itself at the pinnacle of the world’s garment manufacturing industry one day, we will ensure that our stakeholders will come to benefit from it: ◆◆ The Earth: As much as possible, we will pay attention to environmental protection
and sustainable growth by adopting production methods that do not harm the environment. ◆◆ The Economy: We will promote economic development wherever we operate.
We will improve the livelihood of our employees in these developing countries and improve the GDP of the local economy. ◆◆ Employees: We will offer reasonable remunerations and bonuses as incentives
together with promotion opportunities… We will also share the fruit of our success with our team.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
◆◆ Consumers
and Clients: We will safeguard the reputation of our clients by
supplying them with quality products of the highest standard that are produced in socially responsible manner. We will ensure the safety of the products for the consumers. ◆◆ The Government: We will increase employment opportunities where we operate
and boost the local economy and government coffers. ◆◆ Shareholders: We shall give our shareholders a fair return for their investment.
If Crystal is selfish in achieving its objectives, turns a blind eye to the Greater Good and ignores the interest of stakeholders, it will end up standing alone, helpless. Even if we are to attain success, it will not last long.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
- The Way To Build A Corporate Culture The Boss Is Not Always Right Bad money drives out good. It was common for the owner of a business to hear compliments from those around him. Flattered, he would come to think that he had exceptional insights and ability. The bad coins chase out the good. In such a setting, finding it hard to realize their potentials, the capable ended up leaving the company. Those who remained were there to bide their time. Worse, they engaged in office politics, and kept the rumour mill churning. Under such circumstances, how could there be a future for the company?
Bureaucracy Is No Place For The Capable I began to champion the cause of the Greater Good not long after the founding of Crystal. The company was facing some management and development crises at the time and there was clearly a need for new ideas. When I first entered the business world, most of the garment manufacturers in Hong Kong were run as family businesses. Most people in management considered themselves as mere employees and were reluctant to speak their mind. Instead, they would say yes to their bosses. A bureaucratic culture pervaded where the mid-level management withheld information from the top for fear of upsetting them, and imposed orders on those below them to extract obedience. It was common for the owner of a business to hear compliments from those around him. Flattered, he would come to think that he had exceptional insights and ability. The bad coins chase out the good. In such a setting, finding it hard to realise their potentials, the capable ended up leaving the company. Those who remained were there to bide their time. Worse, they engaged in
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
office politics, and kept the rumour mill churning. Under such circumstances, how could there be a future for the company?
Nepotism And Territoriality Prevail In those days, the employer and the employees in Chinese enterprises often found themselves in conflicts. They were often on their guard. Generally speaking, the employer felt bogged down by the heavy responsibilities of minding the business. He believed he worked the hardest day in day out, but inasmuch as he wanted someone else to share responsibility, he was hard pressed to find someone he could trust. He was also worried that if he disclosed too much of the strategies and financial performance of the company to the staff, some might consider jumping ship or use the information against him by starting their own business. That was why quite a few Chinese business founders preferred to place family members or relatives in the key management positions. What they did not realise was that once they were in, it was hard to get those family members or relatives out of the company. Over time, these family members or relatives formed their own cliques and proceeded to stake out territorial claims. People then simply watched out for their own interests and ignored the company’s future. Operational efficiency suffered. Had the textile export quota system not offered a protective shield, quite a number of these family-controlled garment manufacturers would have been eliminated long ago.
Adopt Meritocracy To Fulfil Vision Both Yvonne and I were opposed to hiring relatives. That was why despite being short-handed from time to time, we had made it known from the very beginning that we would not employ relatives or family members. If any of our children showed interest in the business, we would give them a fair chance to try it out. But we definitely would not employ a daughter-in-law, a son-in-law, a relative or even a close friend. I believe that if a Chinese company wishes to attain multinational and international stature, it must be willing to transform itself from a family-oriented business into a
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
professionally managed enterprise. In addition to adopting a system of meritocracy, the company must transform its operational system and adopt modern management concepts. If one really wants to run a business on corporate management principles, one must start by fostering a corporate culture, build a capable team and champion the cause of the Greater Good and a people-oriented culture. One must also nurture an environment of trust, conscientiousness, fairness, transparency, care, collaboration and innovativeness. A meritocratic system ensures that the capable get opportunities to forge ahead and that fairness is applied to rewarding excellence and penalising the undeserving. In a proper corporate environment, employees enjoy a sense of belonging; they are proud to be part of the company.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Promote Core Values In Times Of Stress By prescribing the right remedy, I was able to make a breakthrough. At the time, I went to the trouble of writing down my ideas in minute detail. I was concerned that imprecise wording would only render these core values into mere slogans. I did not want to leave any room for distortion which would just leave them open to the risk of being turned into another type of bureaucratic culture.
Last Talents At The Height Of Emigration Wave There were management problems in the early years of Crystal. Conflicts and bureaucracy abounded. It was not unusual to see arguments between the factories and Hong Kong office as each had its turf to protect. I was in charge of sales and production while Yvonne headed the finance and general administration. Although the division of labor was quite clear, friction sometimes arose between the staff working under either of us. One staff member might complain about another, putting us smack in the middle of their arguments as heads of the respective department. In our basic instinct to back up our staff, we sometimes found ourselves in an awkward situation where we ended up fighting between ourselves. There seemed in general not enough trust between us and our staff. On the surface, each of us seemed to be taking care of his or her work, but when it came to discuss their duties at meetings, people began to shuffle their feet and tried to get out of doing their share. No one would ever say anything in the meetings; they would not make suggestions, express an opinion or ever object to what we said. After the meetings, however, they would go around making known their feelings of discontent. Some would come to me to badmouth others. I usually had these gossipers dismissed. In the 1980s, Hong Kong was hit by a wave of emigration as people pondered their future after Britain reached an agreement to return Hong Kong to Chinese sovereignty.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Caught in a sensitive situation, Crystal saw over half of its employees leaving the company every year around that time. Our own family also obtained Canadian residency so Yvonne and I had to travel frequently between Hong Kong and North America. Every time we came back to the Hong Kong office, we would discover that a few more management colleagues had left. With such a high turnover, morale was low. Operational efficiency was affected, and frequent changes in personnel also unsettled customers’ confidence. We began to worry about a business crisis that an unstructured workteam might set off.
Corporate Culture Brings New Hope Just as I worried more and more about the situation, a colleague recommended to me a corporate culture course organised by the Hong Kong Federation of Industries that he attended. The course instructor was Anthony Griffiths. After attending the workshop, I decided to make an appointment to see him, during which he kept stressing the importance of building a corporate culture. I gave the matter some serious thoughts, and came to accept the idea that developing a corporate culture would probably provide Crystal a way out of this stressful situation. Now that the road seemed clear, the thing to do is to find the right remedy for the problem. Through building a corporate culture in the 1990s, we hoped to reform the rather loose and lethargic workforce into one with a team spirit that understood the Greater Good and set its eyes on the company’s long-term interest. I realised that to develop a corporate culture, I would have to do it myself and not rely on others if I wanted to win the support from my colleagues. I did not mind taking time and effort to ‘sell’ my ideas in person. With due consultations with others, I laid down my thoughts in writing and summarised them into the ‘Eight Core Values of The Crystal Group.’
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Target Poor Practices For Elimination At the time, I went to the trouble of writing down my ideas in minute detail. I was concerned that imprecise wording would only render these core values into mere slogans. I did not want to leave any room for distortion which would just leave them open to the risk of being turned into another type of bureaucratic culture. In fact, each core value I laid down was meant to target a malpractice prevalent in the company at that time. Take the point about satisfying customers, for instance, which should be the very foundation of any business. Yet, there were some at Crystal who did not regard that as important. I recall a director, the head of operations at the time, who kept saying that as long as the company had textile quotas on hand, then business would be guaranteed. His view was that it was not necessary to pay special attention to the customers. He even felt that Crystal was on top and the customers were in the bottom. I singled out the need to satisfy customers as a core value precisely because I wanted to indicate my disagreement with him. Our production line had not been installed with any quality control and the checking of quality of products was haphazard. In fact, a client once told us frankly that the product quality of Law’s Fashion managed by my second brother was better than Crystal’s. I did not want to fall behind in the competition and made an effort to reform the company. Improving product quality was an important target, which gave rise to the core value of championing product quality.
Keep In Pace With The Times To Change The World In so far that Crystal’s eight core values were prescribed as remedies for the poor practices at that time, they are reflection of the era. Among them, however, upholding integrity and delighting customers are regarded as timeless values. The world has never stopped changing and often at breakneck pace. It is my firm belief that one should change oneself to change the industry and in time, the world. The change originates from oneself which then leads to changes in others. There is great
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
wisdom behind this. We could perhaps include it as yet another Crystal core value in the future. I hope that Crystal will do the little it can to change the industry and the world for the better.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Crystal’s Eight Core Values
-
Integrity ◆◆ Keep promises and honor agreements ◆◆ Act ethically and responsibly ◆◆ Communicate openly, honestly and responsively to build trust
-
Respect for people ◆◆ Treat everyone as an unique individual ◆◆ Treat
all people fairly and equally without discrimination, with
dignity and respect ◆◆ Recognise contributions of colleagues to our success and provide
them with development opportunities 3. Embrace innovation ◆◆ Think constructively to challenge the status quo for continuous
improvement ◆◆ Have an openness to ideas from anywhere and an entrepreneurial
spirit 4. Energise others ◆◆ Excite, motivate and inspire others with your vision and deeds ◆◆ Infect everyone with your passion for excellence, determination
and energy 5. Delight our customers ◆◆ Take pro-active actions to understand and anticipate customers’
needs ◆◆ Provide
fast solutions and high-quality services to exceed
customers’ expectations
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
-
Live Quality ◆◆ Make every activity right the first time ◆◆ Make quality a driver for more efficient working practices
-
Deliver Bottom Line Results ◆◆ Improve
shareholder value and ensure the best returns to the
Group and most efficient utilisation of resources 8. Boundaryless Enterprise ◆◆ Get
rid of boundaries, barriers and bureaucracy to facilitate
productive efforts ◆◆ Share knowledge and information ◆◆ Contribute to each others’ success
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Results Of 10 Years Of Effort With persistence, even something as soft as water can wear down the hardest rock. At the brainstorming meeting, all were unanimous in supporting the reform. But when change threatened their personal interest, the reform efforts ran into resistance. Some sat on their hands and remained uncommitted to the reform; others agreed on the surface to change but did everything to sabotage it in secret; yet others stood on the sideline to watch how things would evolve. They probably thought that I was pushing these core values at a whim. Once my enthusiasm died down, they figured, everything would be back to normal.
Core Values Plan Wrecked Upon Launch History tells us that the biggest problem with governance is to introduce reform. The same is true of introducing changes to the management of a business. It is often easier said than done. It is human nature to resist change once a person is ensconced in comfort. In Chinese society that tends to be at peace with the status quo, the challenge is doubled to alter the employees’ thinking and habits and to convince them to accept a brand new corporate culture, especially when it aims at replacing the patriarchal family-style management with modern and systematic way of governance. It would have been inappropriate to hire an outside consultant to take on this challenge of sweeping away the old and instating the new. I would have to do it myself and show the staff by my own example. I might just be able to impress them with my determination to go through this cultural change. A journey of a thousand miles starts with one’s own feet. My mind was now made up. I would just have to put my words into action. I began by looking into the thinking of
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
the staff to see what I had overlooked. It was the mid-1980s. I invited several dozen supervisory-level colleagues to a brainstorming meeting at the Panda Hotel in Tsuen Wan. Many spoke up, voicing their ideas as well as grievances. Some even criticised openly the company’s bureaucratic ways and the lack of collaboration between divisions and departments. The brunt of the criticism was aimed at the senior management, me included. At the brainstorming meeting, all were unanimous in supporting the reform. But when change threatened their personal interest, the reform efforts ran into resistance. Some sat on their hands and remained uncommitted to the reform; others agreed on the surface to change but did everything to sabotage it in secret; yet others stood on the sideline to watch how things would evolve. They probably thought that I was pushing these core values at a whim. Once my enthusiasm died down, they figured, everything would be back to normal. In this way, two or three years went by. Reform was met with strong resistance and I could not make an inch of progress. Instead of bringing a breath of fresh air to the company, my attempt at reform only gave rise to more conflicts, bringing upon me more complaints.
Persevere In What Is Right But I did not give up. Our business was in a struggle for survival at the time. If it continued to tolerate territorial claims and bureaucratic ways, it would even be harder to transform it from a family business into a modern, well-managed corporation. That would bring us closer to the brink of collapse. Recognising this, I could only persevere in the hope of finding a way out of this mire. Armed with my conviction in the Greater Good, and my indomitable spirit and dogged personality, I continued to push my new version of corporate culture, even
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
though I was doing it alone. Besides leading local workshops, brainstorming meetings and sharing sessions, I visited representatives of all our overseas production facilities and held many open-minded frank exchanges with the managers to champion the eight core values. In addition to these promotion efforts, I also listened to and try to understand other people’s standpoints. I kept reminding myself: ‘Listen carefully to others and you will understand.’ It is one thing for me to emphasise my views, but it would benefit me to impose them on my employees. This would not be the time for me to throw my weight around as the employer. Instead, I made sure that there was a two-way communication. Even if they did not accept my views right away, I would at least be able to explain the merits of my campaign. I firmly believed that time would make a difference. With persistence, even something as soft as water could wear down the hardest rock. I would get positive response eventually.
Corporate Culture Became A Reality After A Decade I kept at the eight core values. Members of the senior management did not see themselves in a position to voice their opposition, even though they were most reluctant to embrace the change. By contrast, those in middle management, not as bound by their position, were more open-minded and indicated they wanted to try new things. It took a whole decade of patient cultivation for the mind-set of Crystal’s management to get unified and the new concepts to congeal. A new corporate culture began to take root with the Group. When the workforce gradually got integrated behind the cause of the Greater Good and the people-orientated culture, the effect on the Group became increasingly apparent. In time, everyone from the top to the bottom was able to take into account first the bigger picture of the company and clientele. Everyone also developed the knack to learn continuously and acquired the versatility to manage change promptly. Productivity was boosted; our competitive edge was sharpened. Rome is not built in a day. After several decades of hard work, we at Crystal are
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
finally able to amalgamate corporate culture into our daily life and work. All this goes to show the wisdom of persisting in what is right.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Setting Up An Organisation With No Boundaries Everybody is on equal footing in a culture governed by policies and systems. It is not because I am ‘stingy’ that we always fly economy class
- this has always been the Group’s policy. Every employee from front-line workers right through to management is required by policy to fly economy class. In doing this, we practice our spirit of putting everyone equal, irrespective of one’s position in the company.
The ‘Golden Rule’ Manual Of the company’s eight core values, I pay most attention to this one – “collaborate in harmony and across all fronts”. I believe that to put an end to bureaucracy and introduce a new corporate culture one must start with breaking down barriers. “Collaborating in harmony and across all fronts” actually means that regardless of one’s rank, people should pull together for the Greater Good. To do so, one must set aside self-interests and consider the big picture.
Giving Up Privileges Many supervisors tend to blame those working for them when problems arise. Most of the time, they simply put on airs, order their staff around and show no respect for them. A barrier-free organization is meant to change this type of supervisor-subordinate relationship. To persuade others to accept an organization free from barriers, I decided to set a personal example in addition to distributing the Golden Rule Manual. For instance, when I arrived at a factory overseas, someone from the local office would usually rush up to carry my luggage. Unless it was very heavy, I would usually carry it myself. I never believed that because I was the boss, my staff would have to wait on me hand and foot.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Employers should not enjoy any special privilege. Yvonne and I use our action to show that everyone at Crystal should be treated alike. We, like other people in the company, are bound by policies and should not be allowed to do whatever we like. Andrew and I once traveled to the GAP’s headquarters in the United States for meetings. On that trip were other GAP suppliers and Crystal was the biggest of them all. All senior officers from the other suppliers flew business class while their employers flew first class. Only the two of us went by economy class. It is not because I am stingy that we fly economy class on business trips; that has always been the Group’s policy. Every employee from the front-line workers to the general manager and even the owner of the company is required by policy to fly economy class. If the distance is long, then we can take something equivalent to premium economy. This is a way to put into practice our spirit of equal treatment for all, irrespective of one’s position in the company. For the team to come together as a whole, the members must first of all respect one another. Rank division has to be broken down before people can think of themselves as being equal. This will require not only the management to make sacrifices but also the head of the company to practice what he preaches.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Crystal’s Success Comes From Boundaryless Enterprise Culture Sherman Lau, the Crystal Group’s Principal Advisor, talks about the Group’s corporate culture.
The Eighth Core Values I remember when Mr Lo first developed the core values for Crystal, he put down only seven of them. After some considerations, he came to the idea that if only all the employees could set aside their ‘territorial thinking,’ the company would naturally come to a brighter future. That was why he added the eighth core value – ‘boundaryless enterprise’.
Break Down Barriers To Learn From Others Nothing illustrates the spirit of an organisation without territorial claims or boundaries than the practice of different department learning from each other. If one factory within the Crystal Group adopted a new initiative to raise productivity, other Group factories are welcomed to visit and learn from the initiative. Every Crystal member shares its experience openly. As a result, quite a number of management models and production procedures have undergone improvement through the process, making Crystal a truly barrier-free organisation. This core value has always led Crystal forward since its introduction. To date, it has developed into the interactive spirit of the Crystal family.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
- Reform The Old Ways: Focus On Management Accountability System Implemented Colleagues are given the authority to realise their full potentials. By the target-setting system, once a target is set and agreed upon by all, each individual must take responsibility to complete his task. Those who meet targets within the prescribed deadlines will have their performance measured by an open, fair and quantified appraisal mechanism and enjoy reasonable rewards. Those who fail to meet target will have to reflect on ways to improve. There will be no more excuses.
Use Target As Basis For Fair And Open Assessment When a company reaches a certain level of management maturity, the more talented and ambitious an employee is, the less likely he or she would like to work under someone else’s thumb, let alone saying yes to every demand from the supervisor. Hence, upon launching the concept of the Greater Good, I started the accountability system to delegate authority to all colleagues in their respective posts. At the same time, clear and realistic targets were set. The idea was to give them a free hand to figure out the best way to complete their tasks well. Management must be transparent for the accountability system to function. At Crystal, we communicate to all staff their performance targets, the company’s financial performance and analyses of different management functions clearly, all of which are essential for all of them to discharge their duties.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Completing Assignment In the past, when I approached colleagues about facets of the company’s performance that were less than satisfactory, they would begin to pass the buck around, or pointed to all kinds of excuses to explain their failures, such as the poor global economy, the intense competition in the industry and the difficulty in recruiting capable people. In any case, the main point was that it was not their fault. By the target-setting system, once a target is set and agreed upon by all, each individual must take responsibility to complete his task. Those who meet targets within the prescribed deadlines will have their performance measured by an open, fair and quantified appraisal mechanism and enjoy reasonable rewards. Those who fail to meet target will have to reflect on ways to improve. There will be no more excuses. Nowadays, if someone fails to meet the target and makes excuses, he or she is likely to be told off directly. As it is, since all colleagues participate in setting targets – and these are realistic and achievable - they must be held accountable. Moreover, all Crystal employees have been delegated with specific and adequate authority to do their duties. Any excuses they come up with are mere covers for their own failure. Conversely, they could choose to face up to their mistakes and look for solutions. And so it was after introducing the system of individual accountability and delegation of authority – backed by a fair appraisal mechanism and highly transparent and result driven data analysis system – the company was able to bring the two wings of production and sales together. Those responsible for sales and merchandising were encouraged to do their job as if it were their own business and to interact regularly with their counterparts in the production. Those in production were asked to respect customers and to collaborate closely with their sales and marketing colleagues to know more about the customers’ needs. Irrespective of their posts, all Crystal employees can now manifest to the full the true spirit of the Greater Good.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
The ‘Pull’ And ‘Push’ Approach To Effecting Change Testing the waters with pilot schemes is a way to introduce change. Healthy competition is also encouraged. After assuming the post of CEO, Andrew went about managing change in a thoughtful and prudent manner. He never resorted to issuing command to force his people to give in. Instead, he encouraged them to try and innovate. His approach encouraged healthy competition among the various subsidiaries who vied to be the first to try out a new programme.
Pushing And Popularising The Use Of E-mail In 2000, email was by no means common in Hong Kong. I decided to promote the use of e-mail in the company. Employees were reluctant in the beginning; they also did not know how to use it. So I pioneered e-mail usage. When I wanted to communicate with someone, even if he or she was sitting right next to my office, I would send out an email message. Since the message came from me, no one dared to ignore it. Over time, everybody got used to communicating by e-mail. As the Internet gained popularity, using e-mail to communicate with buyers overseas was definitely most convenient. It enabled us to overcome the problem posed by time difference between regions and save on the long distance calls. When everybody could experience first-hand the merits of e-mail and got used to it, there was no more resistance. As the employer, I hard-sold my staff on the use of e-mail and made it popular. This is an example of success of the ‘push’ approach. This might go to show that the reform will be most effective if the drive comes from the top.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
From Push To Pull For Greater Versatility After assuming the post of CEO, Andrew went about managing change in a thoughtful and prudent manner. He never resorted to issuing command to force his people to give in. Instead, he encouraged them to try and innovate. His approach encouraged healthy competition among the various subsidiaries who vied to be the first to try out a new programme. In the past when I introduced a new programme to the company, I took upon it as the head of the company, and promoted it strongly to the staff. This could be called a ‘push’ approach. Today, the drive for reform comes from time to time from various department heads, and this can be called the ‘pull’ approach. If the change comes from a subsidiary, its entire team is likely to be more cooperative. In the end, change will be implemented more effectively and with better results. The objective of the reform at Crystal was to improve work efficiency and raise productivity. There was no hidden personal agenda in this. The launch of a new initiative was timed to suit the schedule of each subsidiary. If it was introduced at a convenient moment to them, the business heads would more likely be supportive of a new programme and implement it in earnest, leading to better results. It is common for a new initiative to run into problems. As long as the person-incharge keeps in mind the Greater Good, trys to see views from others angle, understands the end-user’s needs, and is willing to make various degrees of adjustment to the initiative, it can be foreseen that the problems will be solved. The initiative that works will be duly recognised and word would get around that it has led to good results. Other departments will want to adopt the successful initiative, and they will have the freedom to make their own adjustments. When enough departments have tried it out and find it useful, Hong Kong office will summarise their experiences to design and present the best model of the initiative, which will be standardised for easier management.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Establishing A Board To Enhance Corporate Governance We invited experienced and capable executives to join our board to make rational and professional decisions. Some listed companies do only the minimum to satisfy the listing regulations. At Crystal, our expectations for the Board’s performance not only match other listed companies but are more stringent than the listing rules… We commission a consultant every two years to evaluate the performance of the Board. This is how serious we are…
Towards Professionalism In Corporate Governance A company that aims at transforming itself from a family business to a modern enterprise run by professional Managers will have to stop thinking that the boss is always right. For himself, the company’s founder and the highest in command has to be willing to give up his absolute power. Yvonne and I did not mind that little sacrifice at all as we had in mind the long-term development of the company. Among many Chinese businesses, the employer is the person who sets the tone. There were times in the past when, under the limitations of our own standpoints, we made decisions that were not rational. That was not the best way to manage a company and might even harm its development. We made up our mind to set up a Board of Directors. As much as possible, we wanted the company to be run in a rational manner. In the beginning, Yvonne was not quite used to this new way of managing the company’s affairs. But once the Board got over its teething pains and began to run smoothly, its positive impact on the company was obvious and Yvonne became its staunch supporter. We first set up a Board of Directors in 1995. I was the chairman, with Yvonne the vice-chairperson. Right from the beginning, the company set high standards for the
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Board and Corporate Governance. Some listed companies do only the minimum to satisfy the listing rules. At Crystal, our expectations for the Board’s performance not only match other listed companies but are more stringent than the listing rules. For instance, every board meeting lasts at least six hours and sometimes up to eight hours to allow full discussion of the items on the agenda. Our board members are, moreover, serious about their responsibilities at the meetings. We commission a consultant every two years to evaluate the performance of the Board. This is how serious we are. It shows that we view the board and corporate Governance as highly important.
Create Committees For Execution In a corporate structure, the Board is put in the highest position in governance. It is, however, not involved in the day-to-day operation of a company, but is responsible only for approving major proposals and deciding on important matters such as the annual budget, long-term business strategies, and offering its opinions on matters on the macro level. Under the Board of Directors are the Executive Committee and the Audit Committee. For matters of corporation governance, there is an Corporate Governance Office, for which I am responsible. Furthermore, the Corporate Development Committee was set up in 2015 to oversee long-term development. The executive authority falls largely on the Executive Committee. Upon assuming the post of CEO, Andrew spent a lot of time and effort on pushing forward the reform programmes approved by the board. He took the initiative to analyse massive volumes of data, and submitted detailed reports to the Board for reference at meeting discussions. Although the Executive Committee has substantial authority, the system of accountability ensures that it answers to the board on all decisions it makes.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Board Members Appraised Annually As of 2015, the following individuals are on the board: Yvonne and I, Andrew, and Frankie and Dennis as executive directors. In addition, there are four non-executive directors: Anthony Griffiths, Benny Tse (a former HSBC executive), Alvin Mak (a former Citibank executive) and George Chang (a private equity fund manager). Throughout the years, Crystal Shareholders and the Board Members seldom had differences in opinion. Surely, being friends with one another is important, but we actually owe this harmony to the annual appraisal system of the Board Members, which is done anonymously. We assess one another based on pre-determined criteria to keep us on our toes. As the chairman, I am subject to the annual appraisal to ascertain whether I am competent for the post. Thus I have to keep improving and make an effort to make myself qualified for the job. Even though Crystal is not a listed company, our Corporate Governance procedures and systems match and even exceed the standards prescribed by the listing rules. All this was made possible because Yvonne and I surrendered our absolute authority. Thanks to this, Crystal is well on track towards achieving professional management, with longlasting significance.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
Behind The Success Story: Corporate Culture Is Key To Reform Anthony Griffiths, NED, shares his views on Crystal’s corporate culture. In 1992, my colleagues and I held a seminar on strategies and tactics at the head office of the Federation Hong Kong of Industries. Among those present were Mr Lo and Andrew. Afterwards, they invited me do a management study on the Crystal Group. In October that year, we held a brainstorming event attended by Crystal’s senior managers. From then on, we have been working closely together. In those days, Crystal was run as a family business. Mr and Mrs Lo took complete charge of the management. I made detailed proposals to them on how to set up a collaborative workforce, raise the quality of the management, build trust within the company and devolving authority. I pointed out that if a company were to continue with centralised power, it would never be able for the employer to develop a trusting relationship with his people. In the end, Mr Lo took my advice and changed his management style, including delegating authority to his team. However, a corporate culture takes time to build. In Crystal’s case, it took nearly a decade for change to be noticeable.
A Boss Without Airs Beloved By All Mr Lo is extremely clever; he also is a capable leader and a visionary. He steers the Group to seek improvement on the company’s existing foundation. He spends each day thinking how to do things better so that
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
aside from meeting customer expectations, the company can make profit. He is definitely not the traditional high-and-mighty autocratic boss. In fact, he never puts on a show and is careful to take others’ feelings into account. This is where he differs from a host of other employers, and this allows him to win over others. On the other hand, once he makes up his mind about something, he is utterly firm, to the point of being obstinate. The way he pushed forward the establishment of a corporate culture without seeking any external assistance is a fine example. He went all over the Group in person to preach the concept and to persuade senior management of the wisdom of his cause.
Delegation Expedites Company Reform I truly believe that Crystal’s employees have an excellent understanding of Mr Lo and are willing to follow his wishes. That is because they know that Mr Lo will be proven correct over time. So when he introduced the accountability system to delegate power, his team was able to respond in very short order. Credits are due to Mr and Mrs Lo and Andrew for implementing a corporate culture successfully. They went about championing the accountability system conscientiously and truly delegated authority. This was a major break from the tradition of centralising power in a family business. They are the midwife of Crystal’s rebirth.
C hap te r Two : Ou r Princip le s
- The Grand Vision of Becoming the World’s No. 1 Vision: To Be The World’s No.1 Apparel Maker Sharing the same aspirations, we pull together to achieve our common goal. We draw our road map by working backwards. We begin with the goal that we have in mind, and review what needs to be done to reach the goal. Using forecasts of the changing conditions of the market, reports of the production capacity of our subsidiaries and volume of the increase in work orders from our clients, we can easily get an idea on the resources, the amount of time and the turnover that it would take for Crystal to attain the No. 1 rank. Then we devise a long-term plan with reachable milestones along the way.
Strengthen The Team Spirit To Become The World’s No 1 While the concept of the Greater Good has already been ingrained into our corporate culture over the years and is now a common language among us, I believe that we can take the company to even higher height if there is a concrete goal that will mobilise the rank and file to set aside their self-interest and work collaboratively together. The concrete goal is to join hands to turn the Crystal Group into the world’s top apparel maker. I must admit that this was a vision inspired by my long-time business associate Mr Yanai. He had expressed his wish to make Uniqlo into the world’s top apparel brand among the consumers. As a Uniqlo supplier, Crystal was deeply impressed. Hence we
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
also made it our vision to be No. 1 in our own sector.
Project Backward In Order To Plan Forward Crystal promotes transparent management based on effective data analysis. If one analyses the data, one will come to the conclusion that becoming the world’s top apparel maker is not an unreachable goal. We draw our road map by working backwards. We begin with the goal that we have in mind, and review what needs to be done to reach the goal. Using forecasts of the changing conditions of the market, reports of the production capacity of our subsidiaries and volume of the increases in work orders from our clients, we can easily get an idea on the resources, the amount of time and the turnover that it would take for Crystal to attain the No. 1 rank. Then we devise a long-term plan with reachable milestones along the way. Once we know what it takes to reach our goal, we can base our plan on spans of five to ten years, breaking down what needs to be achieved each year, and setting annual targets accordingly. All this time, we must take into account the extent of our competitors’ expansion. Market conditions change, and do not always turn out the way one would like. We might have to adjust our plan from year to year. But as long as we adhere to our plan and move towards our goal one step at a time, it may take us longer than planned to reach our goal but we will get there in the end.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
Chapter Three Our Practice Of Learning From The Best Professionalism is our focus and the pursuit of excellence is our lifelong goal.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter Three: Our Practice of Learning From The Best
- Build An Institute Of Continuous Learning ◆
An Organisation Of Learning With An Open Mind
◆
Encourage Teams That Dare To Try
- Learn From The Best Of The Management Experts ◆
Tadashi Yanai: How To Get To The Top Of The World
◆
Mr Tadashi Yanai On The Future Of Garment Industry
◆
Iris Chow: Accept Loss To Build Trust
◆
7 Habits: A Common Language At Crystal
◆
Balanced Scorecard: A Strategic Planning Tool
◆
◆
◆
126
General Electric: Inspiration From The Three Management Insights Industrial Engineering: A Data-oriented Production Management Formula Learn From The World’s Top Management Models
- The Road To Computerisation ◆
121
Resolving The Conflicts Between Computerisation And Control
◆
SAP: Turning Point In Computerisation
◆
A Battle For Everyone
◆
Why And How SAP Is Adopted
◆
SAP Application Wins World’s Top Award
151
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
- Build An Institute Of Continuous Learning An Organisation Of Learning With An Open Mind Learning is a lifelong pursuit. Perfection can only be achieved through continuous self-improvement. Crystal employees are familiar with change as the business regularly introduces new management tools and systems. Over the years, we have built a workforce with superior adaptability and versatility. Our company is indeed a learning organisation
- the type favored by management academicians.
Learn From The Best Excellence is achieved only if one dares to try and learn from experience. For an organisation, clear direction is also critical to minimise mistakes. It is difficult to improve when one approaches life with a complacent attitude and is resistant to learning. This is reflected in the old Chinese saying ‘stones from one hill can be used to polish the jade from another.’ This saying reinforces the importance of learning from others. To rise to the rank of the world’s top apparel maker, we have to learn with humility and strive to implement the best possible management models into our operation. When it comes to selecting operation models; we firstly identify our needs and then select products and operations to support our business. In this spirit, we have introduced first class management tools and models such as the popular 7 habits for culture reinforcement, the balanced scorecard for strategy planning and performance management, the SAP ERP system for operation management, the Toyota lean production concept for production management and the 6S for factory management.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Take our introduction of SAP ERP for instance. In 2002, we made a decision to replace all existing application software systems with SAP ERP. The initial reaction from our employees was ‘frustration’ – However, once every employee had learnt the new system acceptance was reached and overall, all staff were happy to have made the shift. As every colleague was required to learn the new programme, there were complaints in the beginning. After our colleagues had familiarised themselves with the programme, everybody agreed that it was the right decision to replace the old system with the new. With its limitations, the old system would never have allowed us to continuously expand to the extent we have today.
New Executives To Learn From Management Classics Knowledge can change one’s destiny. It’s often through continuous learning that we realise our inadequacies. I love reading. When I come across a good book, I often buy a batch to give to our colleagues. I will then arrange a sharing session to discuss how Crystal can learn from it. Today, whenever a new executive reports for duty, he or she is given the five most widely read management classics. These include:
- The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People by Stephen R Covey;
- Jack Welch and the GE Way : Management Insights and Leadership Secrets of the Legendary CEO by Robert Slater;
- The Toyota Way: 14 Management Principles from the World’s Greatest Manufacturer by Jeffrey Liker;
- The Balanced Scorecard: Translating Strategy into Action by Robert Kaplan and David Norton; and
- Harboring Hope Forever by Tadashi Yanai. Crystal bases its management technique in line with the fundamental message delivered by these classics. Going directly to the sources will enable our newcomers to
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
understand Crystal’s management philosophy. If they fully understand the content of these books, they will be able to decide how to apply these principles in their work. Crystal employees are familiar with change as the business regularly introduces new management tools and systems. Over the years, we have built a workforce with superior adaptability and versatility. Our company is indeed a learning organisation - the type favored by management academicians. After assuming the post of CEO, my son Andrew really exceeded my expectations and achieved far more than I was able to when it came to further developing Crystal as a progressive ‘learning’ organisation. His analytical and executional skills are also superior to mine. In addition, he is especially good at identifying learning targets - he knows how to combine theory and practice to create the ‘best practices’ for Crystal’s specific environment. Crystal management techniques are in step with the times and the company is moving forward confidently and in the direction of becoming the best apparel maker in the world.
Four Approaches To Excellence To summarise my experience over the years; I advocate the following approach to excellence:
- Be willing to change and to learn from the best;
- Persevere in what is right and go deep beneath the surface;:
- Run pilot programmes and study the outcome;
- Set targets and analyse the results.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Encourage Teams That Dare To Try We learn from our mistakes and by giving up the old and useless and embracing the new and useful, we improve. At the mention of innovation, the conservative type baulks because, I think, there is always the risk of failure in innovation. People are worried about failure, and are afraid they might get blamed for it and lose their jobs as a result.
Learn From Mistakes Having been placed in charge of a household at a tender age, I have had the opportunity to develop the skill of observation which has led me to discover some insights about the world. I understand, for example, that when it comes to adopting a business concept, a management system, a way to solve a problem, or how to manage people or a financial decision - having adequate knowledge and a willingness to try will help a great deal. However, at the mention of innovation, the conservative type baulks because I think, there is always the risk of failure in innovation. People are worried about failure, and are afraid they might get blamed for it and lose their jobs as a result.
Giving Up The Old And Embracing The New Emphasis on efficiency and a modern management are the keys to Crystal’s success. If a management system or a pre-existing production line is outdated, I do not hesitate in replacing it. As long as there is a general overall consensus that the new measure is beneficial to the company, people are willing to try it out and stick with it. We at Crystal are used to learning as we go. However, when it is clear that things are coming to a dead end, we have to have the courage to admit failure. We as a team agree that ‘failure is the mother of success.’ If we can learn from experience and do not give up, we can always try again. Just because we had our fingers burnt once does not
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
mean we have to shy away from using fire. At Crystal, we practice the collective responsibility system. We encourage innovation. Even if the innovation results in failure, we do not blame the people who came up with the new idea in the first place. As a result, everybody is not afraid of failure and dare to commit themselves to a lifelong process of learning and innovation. Although it is commonly known that garment manufacturing is a dying industry, we believe that there is still room to grow. As long as we stay on course and courageously try out new things - where there is a will, there is a way.
Garment Making: A Deceptively Easy Trade Garment making is a trade that looks easy, but is infact difficult to master. The production process of garment involves many minute and complicated steps. Problems arise quite often. Even an order of the same cut that comes from the same client may give rise to multiple changes. The slightest difference in the material or design is enough for us to treat it as a new order. A willingness to try, to learn, to stay focused and to persist has thus become part of our corporate culture. It has also laid the foundation for our success today.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
- Learn From The Best Of The Management Experts Tadashi Yanai: How To Get To The Top Of The World Have a global vision and never lose hope. When we first heard him explain his grand vision and forecast of the scale and timing of the businesses expansion; he looked totally confident. We were a bit doubtful, however. Today, Uniqlo’s success speaks for itself.
Always aim to overachieve; always be the best Asia’s top retail brand Uniqlo is a long-time client of ours. Tadashi Yanai, the founder of its parent company Fast Retailing Co., Ltd. (FR), is among Japan’s most successful entrepreneurs. He is also my mentor, a close friend and a long-standing business partner of Crystal’s. Mr Yanai and I met for the first time in 1996 in Hong Kong. We have been collaborating since. Our meeting marked an important milestone in the development of Crystal. Among his various management ideas, ‘One Win Nine Losses’ is perhaps the most well-known. He argues that the seed of success is to be found in a series of failures. Even if one suffers defeat nine times but enjoys victory once, that is a record to be proud of. This philosophy conforms exactly with our belief in the courage to innovate, to confront difficulties and to persevere till we reach our goals. Mr Yanai has announced publicly that Uniqlo’s next goal was to ‘march towards making the world’s No 1.’ Hanging from a wall at his Japan head office’s conference room is a scroll with these words written in ancient Chinese script: ‘The world’s number one.’ This is the way that he reminds himself and encourages his colleagues to strive towards
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
that goal. It is estimated that in 10 years, Uniqlo will surpass all other retail fashion brands to arrive at the top of its sector. I am deeply influenced by Mr Yanai’s business philosophy. Over the years, I learnt a lot from his words and actions about his business thinking, his way with people and his working style, all of which I regard as models for learning. I read his books: ‘One Win Nine Losses,’ ‘Harboring Hope Forever,’ and others with great thoroughness and have come to benefit tremendously from his philosophy of courage and optimism found in these pages. Inspired by Mr Yanai’s vision and plan, Crystal has also set its goal to become the world’s No 1 apparel maker. Mr Yanai and Uniqlo have had a strong impact on Crystal’s corporate culture and the way we run our business. One example is that we treat our suppliers as partner and collaborate with them on the basis of mutual benefit. Although we cannot hold a candle to Mr Yanai and Uniqlo in our determination and efficiency, we have learnt to pursue and persevere.
Lessons From Years Of Friendship Uniqlo was only a small clothing retail store when Mr Yanai and I first met in 1996, but he impressed me with his astuteness, his insightfulness and his thinking that was ahead of the times. He is audacious – his boldness unimaginable to ordinary souls. He is unshakable in his convictions, which makes him fearless in front of failures. I am glad that as his business partner, I get to witness every moment of his success. Mr Yanai treats his suppliers as business allies, with whom he works to arrive at a win-win situation. If a manufacturer runs into an issue during production, he comes up with a solution to help. He might find ways to help the manufacturer reduce production costs but he does not compromise on high quality standards. Compared to other retail fashion brands, Uniqlo does not work with many suppliers - and not too many garment manufacturers can satisfy his stringent demand of high product quality anyway. Mr Yanai is prompt and resolute in his actions. He gives clear and concrete instructions. Once he makes a decision, he will go about doing it immediately. He is
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
highly efficient and is an expert manager. Every time he attends a meeting, for instance, he requires that discussions be completed within 30 minutes. This requires all meeting attendees to be well-prepared ahead of time; once the issues have been addressed - the meeting is adjourned.
Outspoken And Decisive Mr Yanai’s business ideas are not the same as those found in traditional management textbooks. Retail fashion brands throughout the world invariably develop different market segments such as young women, mature men and so on. Uniqlo does just the opposite. It has positioned itself as a fashion retailer for the entire human race, selling clothing that is ‘made for all.’ It persists in this marketing approach and succeeds in getting recognised as such. His decisiveness and insights are second to none. For example, he has a policy to turn around merchandise quickly at the retail level. Items that do not sell well within the prescribed period will be taken off the shelf. I think it takes super-human willpower to be able to make such firm decisions. Sometimes, people find Mr Yanai’s opinion rather unconventional and audacious. He has announced his goal of making Uniqlo ‘the world’s No 1’ retail fashion retailer and championed the cause of ‘the migration of the races.’ Other people may not even have the courage to put these thoughts to words, and yet he is ready to put them in action.
An Alliance To Strive Towards A Common Goal When he makes a business decision, Mr Yanai retains strong focus on the outcome. This is in line with our thinking of anticipating results in setting targets. People who fall below his expectations would most likely not to be graced by his friendship. In a partnership, those who fail to meet the target will be given another chance to prove themselves - but that does mean that they are off the hook as Mr Yanai continues to monitor performance. If they fail to deliver to his satisfaction a few more times, he will look for another supplier.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
Being selective about his business allies is a secret to Mr Yanai’s success. Having known him for decades, I get the impression that Mr Yanai is a down-to earth person. To those who can deliver, he lends unstinting support. He never sweettalks anyone; nor does he make empty promises. That is why he never declares that he would offer complete support to Crystal. He simply keeps sharing with us his vision and invites us to build a future together. When we first heard him explain his grand vision and forecast of the scale and timing of the businesses expansion; he looked totally confident. We were a bit doubtful, however. Today, Uniqlo’s success speaks for itself.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Mr Tadashi Yanai On The Future Of Garment Industry Interview at Mr Yanai’s office on December 19, 2014 Q: How did Uniqlo and Crystal manage to collaborate for more than 18 years? A: Our respective objective and our management philosophy are very much alike. When I first met Mr Kenneth Lo, I knew right there and then that he could be a good long-term ally and partner. Q: You own a brand whereas Mr Lo is a manufacturer. Your roles are different. How do you view the relationship between the two parties? A: No matter whether you are in retail or garment manufacturing, you should have the same objective in mind. Both of us strive to offer the best products to the world. I really don’t mind that we play different roles. I only know that Mr Lo is a great partner. Q: As Crystal’s strategic partner, what suggestions do you have for Crystal and its management team? A: Crystal is already a superb organisation with stellar performance. It’s doing so well in business that I really do not have anything to add. They can produce merchandise that meets our expectations and demonstrate an excellent team spirit. All these years, Crystal has been able to deliver products that meet the highest standards. Moreover, there’s been virtually no turnover on its management team. I think it is indeed a team that is hard to beat. These are the
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
reasons why we can collaborate so successfully. Crystal is an industry leader in Hong Kong. When we first started our alliance, their size was much smaller. We had something in common in that we both want to focus on apparel as our core business. We are single-minded in this regard; we stay focused so we are not distracted by any sideline business. Q: We understand that Uniqlo wants to be the world’s No 1 fashion retailer. Similarly, Crystal aspires to be the world’s top apparel maker. What suggestions do you have for your business partner in this regard? What should they do to be able to do better and better? A: I am impressed by the Crystal Group’s excellent business reputation and financial performance. I can’t really think of any recommendations to make. As you know, both Mr Lo and Andrew have been faced with challenges from time to time, but they still manage to do very well in Europe, the US as well as Japan. When we seek to reach the World’s No 1 position, we shall continue to collaborate with Crystal to open up new frontiers. As far as I’m aware, no company has ever managed to reach the global top spot. Some companies may do an excellent job in some segments but certainly not in all segments of business and all over the world. I’d say our collaboration is really close to being ideal. Q: You are a visionary fashion apparel leader. How do you see the future of the fashion industry? Can you do a forecast on the fashion industry as well as garment manufacturing? A: I think both the fashion and garment industries need a bit more
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
inspiration. Compared to information technology and the service industries, people tend to think that apparel fashion, textiles and retail are old-fashioned lines of work. Some might see them as dying. Having said that, one must recognise that even with the most modern style of living, garment and retail fashion are still something that the human race cannot do without. That’s why we should be proud to be in the apparel industry. I can see the arrival of an Asia Era. Asia will soon reach a high point of prosperity. We are stepping into a golden age. Think of it this way: we should really be grateful that we are in Asia. The population of Europe is about 800 million; in America, just about 300 million. Between Europe and North America, several hundred million people live in developed countries, enough to set up a civilisation of its own. However, here in Asia, the combined population is 4 billion, and we are making breakthroughs in the world economy. The world’s centers of manufacturing and IT are in China and Hong Kong. Crystal is thus very well positioned. I believe Crystal should utilise this advantageous position to create a prosperous future. Q: We all know that the emergence of the Internet has changed the world drastically, in business as much as in everyday life. In your opinion, how has the Internet changed the apparel industry? A: The world is moving forward in the right direction because of the Internet and IT. It is easy for anybody to look up information online and can even set up one’s own platform to communicate with anyone at any time and at any place. It links people with people, business with business. Such is the world we live in today! For this reason, the physical boundaries between countries should no longer pose any
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
limit on the development of a business. The internet can turn the whole world into Hong Kong. What I mean to say is that the Hong Kong people have gone on the same road of development that the rest of world is now traveling. With the internet, Hong Kong people are put in an even more advantageous position. It will continue to adapt and survive in this new environment.. Q: The technological sector has introduced many accessories. Do you think that will have an impact on the traditional garment industry such as T-shirts and jeans? A: Although I believe that garment is constantly evolving, I’m not sure if the fashion industry will evolve to a stage whereby it will be taken over by the IT industry. We might add a computer or a Google product onto the garment. But an accessory is not the garment itself. That’s why I don’t think IT accessories will do much to warp the development of the garment industry. Q: Uniqlo has introduced quite a bit of new technology to garment making, for instance, HeatTech and AIRism. Would Crystal be able to work with Uniqlo to develop these new technologies? A: New materials aside, we really need to work together to discover what the consumers need. HeatTech is an example: for ages, no one saw that it was a fabric that consumers would like. Therefore, a retailer like Uniqlo and an apparel maker like Crystal should collaborate to find out the latent needs and wants of the consumers. It is only then that together, we can supply consumers with garments that they like. What a customer really wants is not always obvious; they never tell us but they want us to try to find out.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Q: We witnessed how Uniqlo and Crystal collaborated and expanded. Uniqlo gave Crystal a lot of good ideas and was instrumental in helping the latter lay its cornerstone for growth, nurture its corporate culture and raise its quality standards. You have such a close-knit partnership. You allow Crystal to do long-term strategic planning for further growth. Mr Lo always tells others that he has learned a lot from you, much to Crystal’s benefit. How you predict the future development of both sides as business partner? A: The nature of our industry is such that if we don’t move forward, we fall behind. We must work with businesses with similar experiences and ideals. Only then can we work in a harmoniously long-term relationship. This is a matter of mutual need and is not merely a money-driven relationship.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
Accept Loss To Build Trust Iris Chow, VP, Sales and Operations, T-shirt and Sweater Division, talks about servicing Uniqlo. I have been working in the garment manufacturing industry for years. I would say that Uniqlo is the only apparel brand I have come across that can form a true alliance with a garment manufacturer. When I first started servicing Uniqlo, its order volume was not high. Yet the company could actually meet the targets they set in its one-year, five-year and ten-year plans. Now Uniqlo’s order volume with Crystal is the largest in the whole of Japan; it has also become our only client in Japan. Crystal and Uniqlo now regard each other as long-term partners. Uniqlo places high importance on its partner’s integrity and planning work. The company always requests suppliers do detailed planning ahead of production, and submit a reasonable quotation after a thorough review of the entire production process. Uniqlo also expects a supplier to be honest and trustworthy. Everything must be discussed in advance. The company simply does not want a supplier to haggle once production has started. If a supplier raises the price at the last minute, Uniqlo will not shy from making its displeasure known. That is not to say that Uniqlo is completely rigid. Anything is open to discussion as long as it is reasonable. Of course, Uniqlo would rather we do as we say and deliver as we promise. I remember there was once a security issue on our part. Several hundred labels for a line of garments that we were manufacturing for Uniqlo were stolen. Without any delay, we offered our apologies and took remedial
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
measures and made monetary compensations to Uniqlo right away. Although we suffered a big loss that time, we took the lesson from one of Mr Lo’s favorite saying, “Losing money is alright as long as we don’t lose sight of the situation.” We paid what we owed and salvaged what could be salvaged. Uniqlo appreciated our integrity, our sense of responsibility and what we did subsequently to improve our security system. Far from jeopardising our collaborative relationship, this incident actually contributed to augmenting the trust between Uniqlo and Crystal.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
7 Habits: A Common Language At Crystal Be proactive, take initiative and begin with the end in mind. It used to be that everyone insisted on having things done his or her own way, which often resulted in a stalemate, while consensus eluded us. Nowadays, we abide by the principle of the ‘7 Habits’ Method of “beginning with the end in mind”. We first consider how to arrive at the goal that we envision for ourselves and then set up milestones to reach our objective. In the progress of our work, we focus on such things as whether we ‘put first things first’, ‘think win-win’ ‘seek to understand, then to be understood’, and ‘synergize’. In this way, we reduce our disagreements and it becomes possible for us to put our consensus in action.
Integrate The 7 Habits Into Corporate Culture As a multinational corporation with production bases in several countries, Crystal often has to deal with multiple cultures and communicate across borders. That is why it is highly important that our workforce speak a ‘common language’. By this, I do not mean the language that we use from day to day, such as English or Chinese. Rather, I am referring to a common corporate culture, a common attitude and a common viewpoint so that a consensus can be reached to resolve issues. When we first introduced the ‘7 Habits’, our objective was to strengthen the team spirit and upgrade our staff’s soft skills in the hope of resolving conflicts between colleagues, improving their interpersonal relationships and turning them into a more cohesive force. Subsequently, I noticed that the ‘7 Habits’ behaviour would have to start from within. Since these habits make people look more into themselves, they are a good approach to character cultivation and self-improvement. It used to be that everyone insisted on having things done his or her own way, which often resulted in a stalemate, while consensus eluded us. Nowadays, we abide by
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
the principle of the ‘7 Habits’ method of beginning with the end in mind. We first consider how to arrive at the goal that we envision for ourselves and then set up milestones to reach our objective. In the progress of our work, we focus on such things as whether we ‘put first things first’, ‘think win-win’ ‘seek to understand, then to be understood,’ and synergize efficiency. In this way, we reduce our disagreements and it becomes possible for us to put our consensus in action. Colleagues at Crystal now practice the ‘7 Habits’ concepts not only at work but also in their personal life. The method has changed their way of dealing with people, making them more popular socially and improving their relationship with their family, neighbors and friends.
Derive Harmony From ‘Emotional Bank Account’ In Covey’s book on the ‘7 Habits,’ he talks about how to develop harmony through the use of an ‘Emotional Bank Account.’ He likens human relationship to banking activities. But instead of monetary units, we deal with emotional units in our relationship with people. A deposit in someone else’s account serves to develop, maintain and enhance trust. Conversely, a withdrawal may erode the trust. This concept encourages a person to enter a relationship with honesty, respect, affability, politeness, trust and the courage to admit mistakes. Over time, he will become a ‘millionaire’ in his emotional account. When this person needs help, he can withdraw from the emotional account by asking for ‘favors.’ By making regular deposits into the emotional accounts, on the other hand, people will be able to reduce the chance of coming into conflicts with others and the core value of “harmony from top to bottom and surpassing all boundaries” will be served. With the application of the ‘7 Habits concepts, colleagues from different factories, different subsidiaries and different racial, cultural and linguistic backgrounds can come together and use this common language in their dealings with one another. Equipped with an ‘Emotional Bank Account.’ they can furthermore work together congenially, and
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
march together towards our goal of becoming the world’s No 1.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Balanced Scorecard: A Strategic Planning Tool A quantitative concept, the Balanced Scorecard allows for a clear mapping of strategic direction. The Balanced Scorecard quantifies concepts into initiatives for actions, which can then be converted into implementation plans to give us a road map towards the goal of becoming the No. 1 apparel maker in the world.
Quantify Concepts To Plan For The Future Concepts are often abstract. On Crystal’s journey to becoming the world leader in garment manufacturing, unless concepts are put into action, they are no better than mere fantasies, we must first convert thoughts into actions. When Andrew assumed the role of deputy CEO, he introduced the Balanced Scorecard (BSC) to facilitate Crystal’s planning for the next five to 10 years, moving the company in the direction of strategic planning. The Balanced Scorecard quantifies concepts into initiatives for actions, which can then be converted into implementation plans to give us a road map towards the goal of becoming the No. 1 apparel maker in the world. The roadmaps shows clearly the main points of our plan, including our vision, and our strategies regarding our finance, customers, internal process as well as learning and growth of our people. Under each strategic target are listed the name of the person in charge, the action plan and the criteria of success. Whether we will succeed will depend on our strictly executing the action plan and striving for the goals that we set. We need to have a medium and long-term development plan to ensure Crystal’s profit and growth which is spelled out in the five-year development blueprint. With this in place, various units of the company can delineate clearly how to develop the key customers in the market, fulfill the needs of the production, gather funds and channel
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
them to places where they are needed. Individually, they will do their part to raise efficiency to propel Crystal forward to become the world’s No. 1 apparel maker.
Crystal’s Strategic Planning Process:
Crystal Global Business Enviroment Forum
SWOT Analysis
5-year Business Plan
Balanced Scorecard Strategy Map
Balanced Scorecard Targets and Initiatives
Balanced Scorecard Strategic Review Meeting
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
General Electric: Inspiration From The Three Management Insights Act with resolve to confront a crisis. Draw a curve to appraise performance. Mr Yanai puts forward his idea of ‘One Win Nine Losses’ on the belief that victory will come to those who keep trying in the face of repeated failures. Welch, on the other hand, advocates decisiveness. The two principles operate at different levels. The former emphasises an indomitable spirit; the latter resolve. I personally think the two are mutually inclusive. Depending on the circumstance, one is preferable to the other…
Three Insights To Guide Management Crystal looks up to the world’s top management experts as models to learn from. Their thinking, their vision and their management philosophy serve to provide our company with operational inspirations. Jack Welch, the CEO at General Electric (GE) of America from 1981 to 2001, is among the business leaders we look up to. In our management directions and daily operations, we are especially inspired by Robert Slater’s book, Jack Welch and the GE Way: Management Insights and Leadership Secrets of the Legendary CEO, which chronicles Welch’s legendary leadership. The following three insights have in particular influenced, our thinking:
- Lead or leave
- Fix, close or sell
- Use the ‘Vitality Curve’ to screen talents
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
Lead Or Leave Welch once said: ‘Be number one or two in your business or get out!’ This is now popularly quoted to remind people of the market reality. A number of other successful entrepreneurs share the same view. For instance, Samsung’s founder Lee Byung-chul also said: ‘If you do it, you might as well do it well. Otherwise, you should just stay away.’ Once a business reaches a certain scale but fails to expand further as a market leader, it will only drift in mid-stream where it risks losing the urge to pursue a higher level of excellence. Under these circumstances, it might as well withdraw and give up before hitting the rocks. With this in mind, Crystal is in pursuit of excellence at all times. We strive to be the world’s top apparel maker.
Accept Reality And Act decisively In the business world, one often comes across difficulties and setbacks. Times change; new technology replaces old; policies take a different turn; office politics get in the way. These are issues that confront and challenge a business on a daily basis. When one comes face to face with a problem such as fighting an uphill battle to become either No. 1 or No. 2 in a sector or getting caught a project that delivers little return - what should one do? Welch points out that one must confront the reality of situation and act decisively. There are three ways: ◆◆ Fix it: confront the problem head on and try your best to come up with a solution; ◆◆ Sell it: sell the troubled business to a third party; ◆◆ Close it: bite the bullet and cut the losses.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Mr Yanai puts forward his idea of ‘One Win Nine Losses’ on the belief that victory will come to those who keep trying in the face of repeated failures. Welch, on the other hand, advocates decisiveness. The two principles operate at different levels. The former emphasises an indomitable spirit; the latter resolve. I personally think the two are mutually inclusive. Depending on the circumstance, one is preferable to the other.
The Three Steps Towards The Solution The apparel making industry is labor intensive. In the early days of the global textile quota system, apparel makers acted like nomads to set up factories in different countries in pursuit of additional quotas. Of course, they were also seeking sources of cheap labor to raise the profit margin. I have been in this trade for years and worked in various markets, and have been confronted with numerous problems ranging from mismanagement to declining prospects. The abolition of textile quotas led to the closure of many factories. In response, we turn to engage in production in neighboring Asian countries, and our development is on track. For factories that are facing irresolvable difficulties and no prospective buyers are in sight to take over, prompt closure is the wise thing to do. We went through the pain of closing our facilities in Madagascar. The losses were deep, but given the situation, we are glad that we pulled out.
Use Vitality Curve To Screen Talents An astute observer, Welch is of the opinion that a successful leader must possess the trait of 4E and 1P. The 4Es and 1P refer to: ◆◆ Energy ◆◆ Energise ◆◆ Edge ◆◆ Execute ◆◆ Passion.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
In my view, there are plenty who possess the 4Es, but it is rare to find someone who qualifies for the 1P. Welch formulated the ‘Vitality Curve’ at GE and used it to appraise the performance of the employees, dividing senior executives into three categories. The top 20 percent belonged to Category A, the next 70 percent to Category B, and the lowest 10 percent to Category C. Rewards and penalties were meted out accordingly. Category A managers were given stock options and promotions – awards that were two to three times higher in monetary value than those in Category B, who were compensated according to their individual contributions. Those in Category C would get fired. We modify the model of GE, and group our employees into five categories rather than three. They are given salary increases or bonuses accordingly, but we do not immediately dismiss those who fail to perform. The reasons are three:
- Culturally, Chinese companies are regarded as lacking compassion for dismissing their employees immediately due to performance;
- In this beginning stage of implementation, the appraisal criteria have yet to be fine-tuned, and might not be as impartial as they should be;
- With our people-oriented culture, we hope that those who fail in the initial appraisal will improve. This latter group are given further training and coaching. The majority of them succeed in doing better the next year. If any employees performs poorly continuously for two or three years, we have to regrettably let them go.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Industrial Engineering: A Data-oriented Production Management Formula Design procedures to plan production strategically. Upon in-depth explorations, it became clear to us that IE quantifies production by units of time and is thus a scientific management system for setting standards. IE can be used to improve production not only in theory but in practice. We proceeded to do a trial run in our Mauritius factory. There are many things to be said for Industrial Engineering (IE). It can be used to design the best workflow procedures and achieve the highest production efficiency with the lowest costs. It can also be used to analyse the capacity of each work station, each assembly line and each production facility to detect degree of under usage, the possibility of raising productivity and the need for improvement.
Overseas Consultant Hired To Teach Techniques Traditionally, garment factories relied on the experience of the seniors or ‘masters’ to estimate the production capacity of various units in the making of different styles of clothing. An estimate could then be made on the overhead, the delivery deadline, wages, expenses and so on. Different masters might come up with different estimates. Such a mixed bag of data was hardly helpful towards managing production, but the industry was hard-pressed to come up with anything better. In the mid-1980s, KSA (Kurt Salmon Associates), a consultancy firm based in the US, strongly recommended that Crystal to adopt the IE approach. Upon in-depth explorations, it became clear to us that IE quantifies production by units of time and is thus a scientific management system for setting standards. IE can be used to improve production not only in theory but in practice. We proceeded to do a trial run in our Mauritius factory. Unfortunately, in the beginning, we entrusted the job of doing the trial run to
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
someone who was slow in picking up the fine points of the KSA approach. We were about to give up. Yet, we persevered and brought in computer technology to interpret the data that we collected. Finally, when the positive effect of IE became obvious, other units wanted to try it out as well. Starting in 1986, we gradually implemented IE throughout the Group’s production bases. If we had been less persistent and given up on IE in Mauritius, our company would not have been equipped at all to meet the production requirements at today’s scale, and we might as well forget about becoming the world’s No 1 apparel maker.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Learn From The World’s Top Management Models Continue to learn to better oneself. It is not enough to think but not to learn or to learn but not to think. In the learning process, it will not do to ‘gobble’ up information without due reflection. It is better to figure out what one is weak at and learn from those who are strong so as to make good one’s inadequacies.
Lifelong Learning To Incorporate The Best practices Since I founded The Crystal Group 46 years ago, I have insisted that my colleagues and I engage in continuous learning to upgrade ourselves. It is said that the undertaking of any learning requires careful forethought. That is why it is important that we choose our models of learning wisely. We have to give due consideration to our own conditions and then draw insights from the experience of the world’s top management models and the wisdom of world-recognised masters of management. It is not enough to think but not to learn or to learn but not to think. In the learning process, it will not do to ‘gobble’ up information without due reflection. It is better to figure out what one is weak at and learn from those who are strong so as to make good one’s inadequacies. We intend to turn Crystal into an organisation of continuous learning, where our workforce is willing to accept new knowledge and ideas. We all look up to world-class business management models for guidance in our pursuit of excellence. We view as mentors those who are successful, and learn from the best practices. Nothing but the best is good for us, and we shall integrate what we learn to lay the foundation to climb to the top of the world. Surely, learning is like groping one’s way across the river even when one is learning
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
from the very best. We may not succeed with every step we take. All we need to do is to regard learning as a process of accumulating experience. Every mistake that we make is a lesson learnt. In the end, we stand to gain from it. In addition to the management classics and masters described earlier, our company also learns from the following models.
Toyota’s Lean Production In production, Crystal has been borrowing ideas from Toyota Motor Corporation’s Lean Manufacturing Methodology, which focuses on supply chain management, workflow optimisation and wastage reduction. The objective is to create economic value for the manufacturer, the dealers and the end-users. Toyota uses the ‘just-in-time’ method to keep from having to stock auto parts. Arrangement is made in such a way that at precisely the stage when the parts are needed, they will be delivered to the assembly line. This requires close coordination between the parts suppliers and the auto assembly lines. It also calls for proper planning to ensure a perfect workflow. The method has been proven workable in the making of automobiles. This led me to wonder if the same approach would be applicable to the garment making industry. By acting in concert with industrial engineering, we were able to apply the Lean Manufacturing concept to garment making and gained a new advantage as a positive result.
The 6S Method Besides Toyota’s Lean Manufacturing, the 5S is another well-known Japanese factory management practice. Historically meant for housekeeping, the 5S is now applied widely in manufacturing in Japan. The 5S refers to the five Japanese words that begin with the phoneme “s”: ‘seiri’ to structurise, ‘seiton’ to systematise, ‘seisou’ to sanitise, ‘seiketsu’ to standardise and
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
‘shitsuke’ to self-discipline. Years ago, the Japanese began to apply this housekeeping philosophy to the workplace, notably factories, to enhance efficiency. At Crystal, we have adopted the augmented method by putting in the sixth S -- safety -- to raise workers’ safety awareness in the workplace. In our production process, besides utilising IE data analysis, we also apply activitiesbased costing (also known as ABC). This system improves the accuracy of forecasting the production cost and profitability of various production lines.
Automation Introduced To Maintain Quality On top of IE, we have actively automated our production processes in earnest. The costs of production automation are high, and it is sometimes easy to take on more than is practical. Nevertheless, I still encouraged automation because I wanted to standardise our products and guarantee their quality. Moreover, I believed that since automation would replace manpower to a degree, it would help reduce overhead over time and add to the modernisation of the production management. A considerable portion of our production is now handled by automation. For instance, we use laser technology to sketch patterns on jeans to give them the ‘faded’ look. We use robotic equipment to hot-print patterns onto T-shirts. These automated processes save us a huge amount of time. More than that, the finished products are much more uniform than those produced in a labor-intensive environment. Since our designs are stored in computer files, it makes the job of filling subsequent similar orders a lot easier.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
- The Road To Computerisation Resolving The Conflicts Between Computerisation And Control One must learn wholeheartedly to be able to use a computer system well. A flawed system requires frequent upgrading. The introduction of the computer system is meant to raise productivity, but the outcome seems to be just the opposite. Are we not asking for trouble if the computer application results in a lowering of productivity?
Wrong Use Of The System I started off with the wrong foot when I first introduced computer technology to the company. I wanted to use it as a way of monitoring the employees instead of raising productivity. In the beginning, I wanted to use digital data to monitor all the activities in the company. Yet, given the sensitive nature of the data, I was worried that they might fall into the wrong hands. I therefore put in multiple layers of approval and clearance, which, far from delivery the higher efficiency that was intended, only added to the bureaucracy. It was years later that I realised that computerisation did not produce the result I wanted simply because I did not put it to the right use. In other words, the problem that I faced originated from the contradiction between computerisation and control. Many enterprises routinely customise the hardware and software to suit their specific circumstances when they adopt computerisation into their operations. They focus on the problems they face at the moment, but very often ignore their future needs. The end-users do not know the system well enough to exploit it fully. Some even give up
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
using the internationally accredited components of the system, making the whole thing neither fish nor fowl. A flawed system requires frequent upgrading. The introduction of the computer system is meant to raise productivity, but the outcome seems to be just the opposite. Are we not asking for trouble if the computer application results in a lowering of productivity?
Golden Rules To Resolve Conflicts In anticipation of the Millennium Bug, we decided to revamp our information system just before the year 2000. To summarise my understanding at the time of the purpose of computerisation for an enterprise, I put forth the three golden rules:
- Keep an open mind and change the old thinking to set a new direction for computer application;
- Learn from the successful computer management experience of top enterprises world-wide;
- Upon selecting a system, train the end-users on the application processes instead of amending the system to suit the flawed operational model. All of the rules above were intended to increase productivity and improve the existing workflow along international standards that are already built into the computer system. They generated much discussion among the staff because they involved changing an old mind-set and learning a brand new workflow process. But once launched, the three golden rules eliminated contradictions between computerisation and the control that plagued us earlier. From there on, computer application served its intended purpose of improving productivity, and the computerisation of the company turned out to be a great success.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
SAP: Turning Point In Computerisation Workflow processes were upgraded to launch a new era. Of the 100 top US IT companies, 78 use the SAP system, including IBM, Microsoft, Hewlett Packard and even Apple Computers. Since these multinational hardware or software companies are among the SAP clients, I saw no further need to compare prices with other suppliers and adopted the SAP system right away.
Adopt A System Widely Used In The IT Industry At the turn of the last century, computer systems the world over were bracing for the Millennium Bug. Crystal also made two drastic changes in its computerisation policy. Firstly, we decided to drop Computer Business Applications, a system that we tailor-made for our own use. Instead, we would pick a system from the market that best suited our requirements. Secondly, we would consolidate our computer needs and utilise just one highly efficient system and collaborate with just one to two suppliers. Although in name the company was using one type of hardware all these years, it turned out that each subsidiary and each factory had its own system. Some staff even did not use a computer and recorded everything manually. In other words, everybody was doing their own thing leading to considerable confusion. This prompted me to revamp and consolidate the computer system and unify computerised workflow processes to facilitate management. This was an important milestone in Crystal’s development and had a long-lasting impact. According to Fortune magazine, of the 100 top US IT companies, 78 use the SAP system, including IBM, Microsoft, Hewlett Packard and even Apple Computers. Since these multinational hardware or software companies are among the SAP clients, I saw
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
no further need to compare prices with other suppliers and adopted the SAP system right away.
Piloting The New Computer System The Germans are known for their discipline. They are meticulous and precise with everything they do. SAP, a German company, exemplifies this very spirit. The SAP system stipulates that from the very first step of data input, the entire process must follow strictly its procedures. If one is the least bit careless in the beginning, one has to rectify the mistake by repeating every step from the beginning. Since our employees had been using an old system for many years, it would take them a long time to adjust to this major revamp. To learn the new system was extra work which in itself, was compounded by their lack of confidence in something they were unfamiliar with. Complaints arose. Given the considerable capital investment in revamping the system for the entire company, Karl Ting, head of Crystal’s computer department suggested that we pilot-run only a part of the SAP system as a start. I agreed with his suggestion, and after some discussion, decided that the knitwear division headed by Andrew would try out SAP with assistance from the computer department. The going was slow in the beginning, largely because the system was of the standard version with no customisation at all to take into account the requirements of garment making. Colleagues were not able to apply it to their daily work, and as a result, found it hard to commit to memory what they learnt about the system.
Effect Begins To Show In Two Years The staff began to get used to the system after about a year. It so happened that SAP was launching a set of applications specifically for the apparel and footwear industry at that time. The SAP Business One Apparel and Footwear software came with new functions to handle sector-specific aspects such as seasonal fluctuations and outsourced orders in addition to providing data analysis. Major sportswear brands such as Nike, Puma, Adidas and even the Mainland-based Li Ning all became SAP clients. With
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
such a client lineup, SAP was motivated to enhance its apparel-industry applications even more. Our colleagues became more adept in using SAP. The end-to-end SAP management software and data processing system we use can handle all the steps of the workflow process from beginning to end, including receipt of orders, sourcing of materials, production planning, shipment logistics, financial matters and statistical analysis. As SAP Business One was designed according to the ‘make-to-stock’ production model whereas Crystal ran its assembly lines upon receipt of orders (‘make-to-order’), adjustments had to be made to tailor the software to our specific needs. To make it compatible with our operational practices, we also augmented the SAP Business One with some plug-in systems. To us, SAP is the frame to which we attach a series of plugins to suit our various requirements. Although the piloting of SAP at our knitwear division was long and arduous, the system was integrated well into our operations after two years. Armed with the experience, our knitwear colleagues were able to utilise its strengths, get used to the changes and understand well its application purposes. SAP’s positive impact on daily operations became increasingly apparent.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
A Battle For Everyone We worked hours and days on end to ring in the new century with our computer revamp. The revamp was met with some resistance in the beginning, but the successful outcome goes to show that as long as there is a will, there is a way. Our determination succeeded in changing the mindset of our workforce and directing them to adopt a superior model of operation. Strong leadership was crucial in the process, and so was teamwork. The workforce pulled together with one heart and mind, handling adversities with aplomb and creativity. Success was sure to come in a matter of time.
An Elite Workgroup Plans For The Big System Rollout SAP launched a new software just after the millennium with features tailored for the apparel and footwear industries. Now that our knitwear division had been successful with piloting an earlier version of the SAP system, everyone in management felt that the time was ripe to consider applying SAP to the rest of the Group. This would involve more than just our knitwear division, a few times more, as a matter of fact. Our IT department went ahead and prepared a blueprint for computer conversion in the T-shirt, denim, intimate and knitwear divisions. We decided the project be led by a senior executive familiar with the Group’s operations. Frankie Wong, who headed operations at the time, thus took on the challenge to prepare the Group SAP-related workflow and applications. Extremely familiar with our production operations, Frankie is also the most efficient kind who does not like to waste time. He has his own opinions but he also listens to others. In other words, he is the perfect choice to lead this important computer revamp at Crystal.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
War Room Keeps Busy During SARS A War Room was set up at Hong Kong office dedicated to the use of those involved in the computer revamp. Those heading production and sales in our various subsidiaries as well as IT representatives were invited to be in the SAP taskforce. Frankie required the task force of more than 10 persons to meet from 4 - 8 pm every weekday. They would put their heads together in the War Room to discuss the SAP project. They mapped out these major functional specifications requiring that the new system:
- cover the requirements of all divisions ranging from quotations for orders to shipment of products and be able to raise operational efficiency on every front;
- provide the head office and various subsidiaries with real-time consolidated data to be accessible by remote control;
- be integrated with SAP’s popular mainframe that is adopted world-wide;
- be set up in accordance with an IT blueprint that was highly standardised and transparent to be used by all subsidiaries, irrespective of their product lines. Everybody in the War Room worked in earnest. Diagrams were put up on the walls detailing every step of the workflow – from sales to production to shipment and accounts receivable. Every step was discussed in detail as to how it would be handled by SAP. The resulting blueprint contained an intricate set of details. That was because it was feared that if one small step was missing, it might lead to a big gap in the revamp. The taskforce worked day in day out, sometimes even missing meals and well in the late hours of the night. These colleagues made a shining example of the team spirit and our corporate culture of the Greater Good. I was impressed. It was 2003, the year SARS hit Hong Kong. Normally, our managers would be on the road making sales calls. The fact that SARS restricted travels from Hong Kong actually gave us a great opportunity to put them all under one roof to work on the SAP conversion. Before long, the task force came up with a draft of functional specifications and put together a set of technical requirements.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Unified System Launched Globally The SAP conversion was tried out first in the T-shirt subsidiary. When that proved to be successful, it was introduced to the rest of the business lines. Soon the entire Group’s operations were supported by SAP. Since the launch, we have upgraded the system several times making major as well as minor changes. We also update the system whenever new versions are released. SAP is also helpful to Crystal’s long-term business development. Nowadays, every production line has a different system module so that when a new factory is set up, all we need to do is to select and put together the relevant modules and link them up to the mainframe to obtain information and monitor the workflow procedures. The new factory can then promptly swing into production saving lots of time. I believe that without the support of SAP, Crystal would have to take a longer and more arduous path in becoming the world’s top apparel maker. As expected, the revamp was met with some resistance in the beginning, but the successful outcome goes to show that as long as there is a will, there is a way. Our determination succeeded in changing the mindset of our workforce and directing them to adopt a superior model of operation. Strong leadership was crucial in the process, and so was teamwork. The workforce pulled together with one heart and mind, handling adversities with aplomb and creativity. Success was sure to come in a matter of time.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
Why And How SAP Is Adopted Behind this system revamp were four principles and four approaches. Staying one step ahead is the only way to be in a leadership position and to enjoy sooner the fruit of success. As writers of martial arts novels are fond of saying: ‘No martial art under the sun is invincible; but speed can make the difference.’
Teamwork Changes Mind Set Whether a system runs smoothly or not depends on implementation. No matter how advanced it is, a system is no use if the team does not choose to work with it. In the introduction of the SAP system, the Crystal workforce adhered to the following principles:
- Team spirit and the Greater Good: Everyone pulled together with one heart and mind, ignoring personal inconveniences for the sake of the Greater Good. Everyone was prepared to make personal sacrifices to contribute to the group, working overtime even into the late hours of the night to put together the system.
- Adaptability and perseverance: Although Crystal’s previous experience with computerisation was not satisfactory, the team trusted the management’s decision and rallied together in pursuit of excellence. Everyone believed that changing to this new system would yield better operational outcome.
- Being in the lead: Everyone shared the vision of trying to become the No. 1 apparel maker in the world. Everyone was proud to adopt the top computer software and believed that it would give us the competitive edge to be in the lead.
- Changing thinking and enhancing effect: By dropping the initial misconception of using a computer system for control, senior management was able to rethink the company’s IT strategy to focus on raising productivity and operational efficiency.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Four Approaches Used To Implement Revamp During the revamp, we derived four approaches from our experiences:
- The Golden Rule: Select a world-renowned system, learn from its strength without changing its original logistics and framework. This facilitated our group’s efforts in raising the group’s software to international standards.
- Simplify, simplify, simplify: Our IT department abides by one motto – KISSS, which translates into ‘keep it simple, standardised and speedy,’ which encapsulates the wisdom of our IT department’s approach to the revamp – to counteract complexity with simplicity.
- Speed it up: Staying one step ahead is the only way to be in a leadership position and to enjoy sooner the fruit of success. As writers of martial arts novels are fond of saying: ‘No martial art under the sun is invincible; but speed can make the difference.’
- Target Win-win situation: This is one of the ‘7 Habits’ of the highly effective people and part of our corporate culture. We expected our various subsidiaries and operating units to learn from the experience of the system revamp, march forward together, serve customers with high productivity and achieve a winwin situation for all. As it is, we apply these principles and approaches not only during the revamp but also in our daily operations. They are now inherent in the Crystal corporate culture.
Cha pter Three : Ou r Practice Of Learning From The Best
SAP Application Wins World’s Top Award Crystal won the top award and gained admittance to the Hall of Fame. Karl announced in his resonant voice from the stage: “I am from Hong Kong, a city in China. I am Chinese; I am a Hong Konger.” The audience broke into loud applause. Karl had brought honor onto China, Hong Kong and Crystal.
Being Asia’s No. 1 in SAP’s System Accreditation Our implementation of the SAP software led to remarkable results. Consequently, SAP has commended our use more than once, and we are regularly invited to share our experience with SAP’s prospective and existing clients as an exemplary user. SAP applies a rigorous monitoring and measuring system to check if a client adequately utilises its software. The checklist consists of 17 authentication specifications, each backed by facts and figures. To qualify as a certified elemental grade SAP user, an organisation has to comply with four specifications. In the past, only three companies in Hong Kong succeeded in meeting the high standards and Crystal was among them. The other two were CLP Holdings and the Kowloon-Canton Railway Corporation. Riding on previous success, Crystal proceeded to move further up the ladder of SAP certification. In 2008, we became SAP’s best user in the whole of Asia and were named by SAP to compete internationally for even greater recognition. The contest was held in the Republic of Ireland in 2008. Each of the five finalists must send a representative to Ireland to present to the judges. We sent our IT head, Karl Ting. On the day that the results of the context were announced, Karl was notified that Crystal won first place for the year. He was invited to share his experience four hours later on stage at the award presentation ceremony.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Honor For Crystal As Karl made his way to the stage, he heard the astonished murmurs from the audience that the top place should go to an Asian organisation. The Russian representative even asked someone if the man on stage was from Japan. In response, Karl announced in his resonant voice from the stage: “I am from Hong Kong, a city in China. I am Chinese; I am a Hong Konger.” The audience broke into loud applause. Karl had brought honor onto China, Hong Kong and Crystal. Even after a few years later, Crystal kept its leadership status in Asia. In 2011 Crystal received the world’s best company in SAP application; in 2013, Crystal won second in SAP’s headquarters in Germany, coming before Volkswagen. Crystal was just a relatively small client for SAP, but because it won three international contests, it became the first Asian organisation to be admitted into SAP’s Hall of Fame. It is the smallest of the seven or eight multinational organisations that have received the honour. In Hong Kong, Crystal participated in the China & Hong Kong Enterprise Market Development Association’s Big Data Analysis Awards 2014 contest and won the ‘BDA Award in Manufacturing.’ The organisers praised Crystal for integrating operational data into management and using the instantaneous retrieval of data from anywhere in the world to facilitate analyses, forecasts and efficient execution. Crystal’s ultimate objective is to become the world’s top garment manufacturer. We are proud to say that as far as the application of the SAP software is concerned, we have reached the highest level. We have our IT colleagues to thank for such success. They contributed selflessly to the Greater Good, went untiringly in their pursuit of excellence and made the best use of what they had.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Chapter Four Our People People come first in our corporate culture. We nurture talents through learning.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter Four: Our People
- A People-oriented Culture ◆ ◆
Genes Of Crystal’s Workforce Frankie Wong: Our Approach To Recruit, Develop And Retain Talents
◆
People As Core: Share, Care And Grow
◆
Spring Lei: Caring Fund Established In Zhongshan
◆
Tina Wong: First-hand Account Of The Closure Of The Malaysian Factory
- A Proper Work Attitude ◆
Autonomy Fosters Responsibility
◆
Lead By Example
◆
Be Righteousness In Resolving Conflict
- Human Resources Strategy ◆ ◆
◆
Pay Policy: Set Earning Targets Performance Management: Measure Performance against Agreed Targets
- Attract And Develop Talents
◆
184
Andrew Lo: How Many Talents Does Crystal Need for Future Growth? Matrix Structure: Division Of Labour In Our HR Teams
◆
179
Plan for A Rainy Day: Solution For Talent Supply
◆
◆
165
Associate Programme: Develop Leaders Of The Next Two Generations Leadership Development: Prepare Next Generation Leaders To Carry The Baton
◆
PACE: Raise Personal Value Of Female Workers
◆
Feedback from PACE Graduates
◆
Howard Lo: An Invigorating Office Environment
196
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
- A People-oriented Culture Genes Of Crystal’s Workforce People constitute an important core value of our corporate culture. As long as employees can focus on aligned goals, collaborate with one another selflessly, adapt to change and commit themselves to continuous learning - team spirit will naturally emerge. And with strong team spirit in place, will a company fail to power ahead?
Grooming People And Building A Culture The foundation of any successful enterprise comes down to the people working as part of the team. For this reason alone, my management style has always focused on the ‘people’ so that success can follow. In the 46 years of Crystal’s history, we have shifted through four stages of people development. In stage one and during the company’s formative years, the business had not yet fully developed and a lot of work was required to piece the puzzle together. Our employees took on an independent mindset did as they pleased without any regard for formality or structure. My days were spent hiring and retaining people and handling office politics and all kinds of interpersonal matters - these tasks combined left me utterly exhausted! Stage two was when we first introduced Crystal corporate culture. After years of efforts, everybody in the organisation gradually came around to embrace the people-
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
oriented culture defining our core set of values. Stage three began with the introduction of the 7 Habits. Every single senior executive and most of management team participated in related training. Soon afterwards, colleagues started to speak a common language that further enhanced the corporate culture with the company. The workforce became more cohesive as the company gradually became an organisation without internal barriers. Stage four, where we are now, reflects the concept of sustainable development. With it, all colleagues work together to turn Crystal into a corporation that respects the individual and cares for the world while working for the Greater Good. We initiate leadership development and work on our succession planning. This phase will contribute greatly to propelling Crystal towards its goal to be the world’s No. 1 apparel maker.
Being People-oriented In Word And In Action Treating people with respect as a core value is a reflection of the spirit of the Greater Good. It is part of the corporate culture that I have spent years inculcating at Crystal. The Crystal workforce is in the common understanding that being people-oriented is not just a slogan. It is a value that is deep within people’s hearts and one which they put into practice on a daily basis in order to promote respect for others. We have created a corporate culture that supports the needs of others. All Crystal staff pay attention to the welfare of various business relationships with stakeholders, shareholders, clients and colleagues. The strong focus we place on people is incorporated into the system and culture at Crystal. We uphold a humane way of management and implement it at all levels. We are lucky to be commended by many of our clients and colleagues in the field as exemplary in our human resource management, for which we have received many awards and recognitions.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Our Team Goal: To Be The World’s No. 1 For employees operating in a role that requires an autonomous and managerial focus, Crystal encourages a high level of ‘teamwork’ in this regard. We encourage staff to share their experiences with colleagues rather than engaging in destructive competition. A number of business allies and clients – including Uniqlo’s Mr Yanai, Texwinca Holdings Limited’s Chairman, Mr Poon Bun-chak and Pacific Textiles Limited’s Chairman and CEO, Mr Wan Wai-loi – have expressed their admiration for our workforce. They commend the team spirit that our employees exhibit, the prevalent practice among them of putting customers ahead of themselves and their adaptability. Moreover, our stable management team has won their trust. As long as employees can focus on aligned goals, collaborate with one another selflessly, adapt to change and commit themselves to continuous learning - team spirit will naturally emerge. And with strong team spirit in place, will a company fail to power ahead?
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Our Approach To Recruit, Develop And Retain Talents Frankie Wong, Crystal Group’s Executive Director, talks about his 33-year career at Crystal.
Business Talk Deep In The Night I joined Crystal in 1982. For the first eight years, I was posted outside Hong Kong, first in China and Malaysia and lastly as the general manager of our Mauritius factory, a position that I took up in 1986. In the 1980s, communication and transportation were by no means as convenient as they are today. As someone posted overseas, I only met and discussed business with Mr Lo a few times per year. Mr and Mrs Lo always found time to visit the overseas production bases at least once per year. The first objective was to get an understanding of the state of our operation on ground; the second objective was more important – to get feedback from colleagues and to boost morale. I recall that at the time, flights from Hong Kong to Malaysia and Mauritius would arrive only late at night. As soon as they touched down, they would invite me to their hotel room and stay up until the wee hours to get my report on the performance of the factory I was responsible for.
Delegate Downwards To Build A Sense Of Responsibility Since our face-to-face meetings were far and few in between, I always would take the opportunity to seek advice from them regarding the difficulties I encountered. Mr Lo never gave me a direct answer; he would only share his viewpoints and his experience. That used to confound me.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Since he was the boss, the owner of the company, why would he not give me clear instructions? It was only after that I got to understand the reason behind this. He wanted those in management to develop a sense of responsibility and to exercise it appropriately. A supervisor needs only communicate clearly to his or her people the nature and the main points of their work and the company’s ultimate objective. He or she should by all means share his or her experiences to remind them of certain details and to plan ahead to forestall problems. A good leader does not give endless instructions or make decisions for his people all the time. I was transferred back to Hong Kong in 1989 to take charge of the T-shirt and knitwear division. In 1995, I was named an executive director. After returning to the head office, I had more opportunities to interact with Mr Lo and observe how he treated his people. I gained a much better understanding of his philosophy towards recruiting, developing and retaining people. In recruitment, other than just looking at a candidate’s educational and work qualifications, it is important to consider if the person is honest, proactive, and willing to learn and accept changes. Mr Lo regards it as most important whether a person takes the initiative to learn. He often says that while a person may be capable today, one needs to know how well he will do in a year or five years down the road. The world is progressing all the time and the competition will only become more and more intense. If the employees cannot keep pace with the changing world and hang on to the old ways of doing things, then it will be hard for an enterprise to escape the fate of being eliminated.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Skirting Responsibility Means Giving Up Power Apart from monitoring and coaching employee performance, Mr Lo places a high importance on his sense of responsibility and personality. He talks about ‘authority and responsibility’ as going hand in hand and being mutually generative. Regardless of how senior a person may be within an organisation, someone without a sense of responsibility is a weak leader. In order to achieve respect from colleagues it is important to always accept responsibility. Mr Lo strongly believes in delegating authority to encourage colleagues to handle affairs independently and learn from real-life experience. He enforces that the value of learning from a mistake makes more of an impact to someone’s learning experience and lead to advantages for all in time to come. Progressive improvement through individual learning is a tactic that is valued at Crystal. Mr Lo practices what he preaches. He always acts out of a sense of the Greater Good and puts others ahead of himself. He is the Group’s ‘spiritual leader.’ By osmosis, he nurtures a unique corporate culture of core values. Our efficient workforce is passionate about its work. It is open-minded, eager to learn, trustworthy, responsible and ready to take on challenges.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
People As Core: Share, Care And Grow Use positive energy to spread the message of care. Our people come from different parts of the world with different cultural backgrounds. Therefore, when we show that we care for our people, we must start by respecting the pluralistic nature of culture. We hold dearly in our heart the principle of valuing people in such a way that we share with them, care for them and grow with them.
Show Respect And Concern For The Individual One often hears in the news stories about the exploitation of child labor in some countries and how workers have to live and operate in harsh and demeaning conditions. Every now and then, stories also come to light that to prevent internal theft, some factories lock up their workers in the dormitory at night, which leads to a heavy loss of life when a fire breaks out. It is heart-breaking just to read of stories like that. The root of the problem lies not just in poor management but also the lack of respect for people. In many Mainland factories, workers often come from poor regions far away to seek employment in the more prosperous southern province of Guangdong. They often leave behind their young and old to fend for themselves at home. How can an enterprise be so callous as not to lend these migrant workers assistance? At Crystal, we highly respect the right of every worker as a person!
Promote Harmony And ‘Home Within Company’ Our people come from different parts of the world with different cultural backgrounds. Therefore, when we show that we care for our people, we must start by respecting the pluralistic nature of culture. We hold dearly in our heart the principle of valuing people in such a way that we share with them, care for them and grow with them. Many of our factories come with a ‘caring center.’ Workers can go to the Center to
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
speak to the resident councillor about issues such as their longing for home and various other emotional problems. If the problems are work-related, the counsellor will refer the worker to the person-in-charge or the proper management for follow-up actions. Of course, neither work nor life is to be neglected when it comes to taking care of the welfare of our people. For instance, slip-proof mats are put on the floor of the workshops to safeguard the safety and comfort of those who need to stand for hours on end at work. On Women’s Day, senior executives present flowers to their female workers. In winter, the hours of hot water supply in dormitories are extended. Mainland Chinese staff have a habit of taking naps after lunch. For this reason, the lights at our Dongguan factory are turned off after lunch. We also placed lounge chairs in certain areas to allow our workers a place to rest after lunch. Our factories in various locations cater to the culinary preferences of their workers. For instance, many of our workers in our Dongguan facilities originate from Hunan Province and spicy food is preferred during lunch hour here. For our migrant workers, we like to ensure that staples such as noodles, dumplings and home-land tastes are presented during meal time. Comfort food can lift spirits and can also prevent homesickness in our teams. When we design our staff menus; we have these considerations in mind.
Care Extended To Family Members In order to integrate external family members we encourage staff to invite their loved ones to various extra-curricular events held frequently. By doing this, we hope to educate family members about the Crystal working environment and to also create a common understanding of the working conditions. This helps us to minimise turnover and create a ‘family-like’ work culture. It is common for Mainland Chinese to apply for work with Crystal as married couples. If possible; we try to arrange for the couple to remain in the same dorm to maintain a sense of belonging to the company.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Care Extended To The Community ‘Respect the individual’ is my motto in life. It is simply part of the Crystal culture to value each individual person where everyone is treated as a member of a family. New recruits have to go through an induction programme about the Crystal culture so that they get an understanding of what it means to be ‘people-oriented.’ For front-line employees, we provide opportunities for them to put what they learn in practice in the workplace. It is naturally better that they get to appreciate the benefit of the peopleoriented philosophy in real situations than just learning it in abstract. It is more a blessing to give than to receive. We have volunteer teams both in Hong Kong and across the border which encourage employees to participate in civic and community activities to demonstrate their care for society. The company sponsors activities such as caring for the elderly and the underprivileged, tree planting, blood donation, and scholarships for deserving students. These activities will promote our belief in the value of people, thus making it a common language among our employees, strengthening their sense of self and enriching their spiritual life. A low attrition rate makes for a stable workforce, which increases work efficiency while cutting down on recruitment cost. However, we do not engage in all these employee caring programmes with that self-serving purpose in mind. If we act only out of selfinterest, we are just being hypocritical. We could retain employees by paying higher wages - but I doubt if we would be able to accomplish a strong team spirit in doing this.
Stable Management With Turnover Close To Zero The Greater Good is an ideal that Crystal upholds. That is why we think that the interaction between the individual and the bigger group to which he belongs is very important. A new entrant to the company needs to be acclimatised to the bigger group. Those who do not identify with the basic concept or fail to adapt to the bigger group will soon leave on their own accord. The employees who remain clearly find this concept acceptable.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
The turnover rate of our management team is very low and with the senior management, it is virtually nil. It is very common to speak with executives who have been with the company for more than 20 years. Having worked with Crystal for this length of time, these individuals are strong supporters of the Crystal culture. Their sense of solidarity with the company is strong; so is their sense of responsibility. On occasions, some might choose to leave, but when they had a chance to find out about the culture of other companies, they came to the realisation that ours was superior and wanted to come back.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Caring Fund Established In Zhongshan Story of the Company’s Caring Culture as told by Spring Lei, Community Communication Service Manager, at the Zhongshan Denim Factory.
Establishment Of ‘Loving Care Fund’ One of our workers in Zhongshan by the name of Ling was struck with cancer. She thought of ending her own life, but was too ill to even carry it out. The company found out about her illness and started a fundraising campaign to help her with the medical expenses. Miraculously, she recovered and returned to her job in the factory. The company then arranged for her to work in the logistics department to handle chores that were physically less demanding. Subsequently, our unit set up a ‘caring fund’ to help others in need of assistance. Donations were gathered from employees including workers throughout the factory and supplemented by the company. If an employee suffers from a major illness and cannot pay for the medical expenses, the fund will be brought in to help. Even the immediate family members of a worker can make use of the fund. A few years ago, the father of another Zhongshan worker needed an operation. The family was hard pressed to come up with the money. The worker sought help from the chairman of the workers’ committee and a sum was allocated from the caring fund to him to pay for his father’s surgery.
Visiting The Family Of Outstanding Workers There was once a news article extracted from the Nanfang Gongbao
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Newspaper, China, titled ‘A Zhongshan enterprise travelled a long way to visit his outstanding worker at his home in Hubai during Chinese New Year’. The above mentioned story highlighted our denim factory visited the family of a 3-time winner of our outstanding worker award named ‘Yang Yong’ during the holiday season. In an effort to showcase care; our human resources manager Desmond Lam personally visited Yang’s home in Hubei together with a few colleagues. When they returned, they brought the worker’s entire family out to the factory’s spring festival dinner. Both Yang and the family were deeply touched by their efforts.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
First-hand Account Of The Closure Of The Malaysian Factory As Told by Tina Wong, Assistant General Manager, Purchasing of the T-shirt and Sweater Division. Crystal’s Malaysian production base opened in 1976 as Palace Garment Manufacturing Sendirian Berhad. Its early days were marred by labor dispute highlighted by the incident where disgruntled workers carried a coffin to protest at the factory gate. Subsequently, Hong Kong office appointed the now executive director Frankie Wong to take charge. Frankie spared no effort in carrying out the job and convinced the local workers that the company was sincere in caring for their well-being. Not long afterwards, all Palace Garment employees, regardless of rank, worked together in harmony. I was the unit’s sales manager and I was proud to be a member of the Malaysian team. All colleagues gave their best at their respective posts day in day out - outstanding results and productivity were achieved. When the textile quota system was abolished globally, Palace Garment came face to face with the issue of rising costs. The Group needed to transform this business line, which would require the Malaysian production base to close down. It was a painful decision. Some staff had been employed for more than 30 years and it was very sad that we were required to terminate employment for these loyal members. Because of their longstanding experience and loyalty to Crystal Group however; it was not difficult for these team players to secure work elsewhere.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
When the news of the imminent closure spread down production lines, everybody agreed that the company had no other choice. Far from slackening the pace of work, we all tried to find ways to raise productivity and reduce operating costs in the hope that we could extend the ‘lifespan’ of the factory as much as possible. In the interest of the Greater Good, the head of quality control in Malaysia passed on his experience and expertise to the Mauritius unit so that Crystal could continue to serve the same client from another production base with the same quality of expertise. By collaborating wholeheartedly to reduce costs, we managed to defer the closure of the Malaysian factory by several years. Palace Garment finally shut down in 2006, putting a perfect full stop to its history. On the last day, Mr and Mrs Lo came to Malaysia to attend the farewell luncheon. For them, what might have been an embarrassing situation turned out to be a surprisingly joyous farewell party. There was no awkwardness between management and the employees. In fact, the staff put on a variety show to express their gratitude towards the company. It was a touching scene; it was hard to say goodbye. It was so wonderful to celebrate the closure of one of our factories on such a positive note. The festivities, the team spirit, the laughs we shared
- this was a memorable day indeed.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
- A Proper Work Attitude Autonomy Fosters Responsibility When there is work to do, one must take responsibility to meet the targets. When the company assigns you a task, you own the task, and so you must take up the related responsibility to deliver what is expected of you. If you cannot hit the target, then you must look inside yourself to find out where you have gone wrong.
Take Responsibility To Complete The Task Every colleague at Crystal understands the system of delegation and responsibility that is enforced within the Group. The message is clear: when the company assigns you a task, you own the task, and so you must take up the related responsibility to deliver what is expected of you. If you cannot hit the target, then you must look inside yourself to find out where you have gone wrong. At Crystal, we have always abided by the principle of delegation and authority. Once a management committee agrees on targets, they are handed down to the various subsidiaries and, in turn, the related departments and personnel. All employees are given adequate authority within their own positions to complete assignments and resolve issues. The company expects them to make the commitment to deliver the agreed targets. When a critical new initiative is launched, we use a blueprint, starting with a feasibility study. Once a decision is made to carry it out, a steering committee and a project team will be set up. These two teams must each appoint a leader to track the progress until the project is completed. In the process, the two leaders and the team under them can use whatever it is within their power to collaborate to get the job done.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Accusations Do Not Solve Problems Our people-oriented culture does not tolerate accusations and the shirking of responsibility. We encourage colleagues to show a positive attitude and appreciations for the contributions other people make before offering constructive critique. Finding fault for the sake of finding fault is not the way to go. The company’s practice is first to resolve a problem, then go into a post-mortem to find out the root causes. The focus is put on the matter at hand and to analyse the problem and not the people involved in the job and pass censure on them. We know full well that pointing an accusing finger on one another is not the way to remedy a problem. The correct approach is to exchange ideas on how to prevent the problem from arising again. People who are enterprising enough to venture into new grounds make more mistakes than those who are satisfied by following the tried and tired methods. But as long as one derives lessons from the mistakes one makes, one can expect improvement to come. In the end, both the company and the individual concerned will benefit from the courage of these adventurous souls.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Lead By Example Be righteous and honest and above all, be fair. Those in leadership positions have to be demanding of themselves. They should set a personal example, and being more people-oriented than the people working for them. Only then would they command respect from them.
Ten Properties Of Leadership Those in leadership positions have to be demanding of themselves. They should set a personal example, and being more people-oriented than the people working for them. Only then would they command respect from them. I come up with the following ten points about our people-oriented leadership behaviours both for my management team and myself:
- Exercise a leader’s charisma to earn respect and trust from the team;
- Practice what you preach;
- Be righteous and honorable in character and be fair in action;
- Be up front and transparent with what you do and do as you say;
- Avoid bureaucracy in your work and your relationship with people and putting a personal agenda in your action;
- Be responsible as a leader and reflect upon your actions regularly;
- When an employee fails to perform, bear the responsibility as his supervisor;
- Never do or say anything to demoralise your staff;
- Have a vision and contribute to the company’s sustainable development;
- Encourage employees to embrace the company goals as own goals and work towards the common goal of making Crystal the world’s top apparel maker.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Be Righteousness In Resolving Conflict Put yourself in other people’s place and try to see things from their viewpoints. Transferring employees who cause trouble to another unit is similar to burying one’s head in the sand. It does not solve the problem. If the problem stems from an individual’s conduct, you are simply shifting the problem to another unit.
Understand Others’ Feelings I always anticipate someone else’s needs in everything I do. When I make a decision, I consider how other people would react and if my decision would inflict any harm. I remember when I worked in a joint venture company partly owned by my father in my young days, I was put in charge of production. I noticed that the supervisor of the laundry department was a slacker on his job. On the surface, he acted as if he followed closely the job orders but often did just the opposite. I told him off right to his face one time. But he was not the sort who could look honestly at his mistake, and came back with all sorts of excuse for his behavior. Young and impulsive, I rebuked him, and in my temper, resorted to obscenities. When I had a moment to think about what I did, I could see that a dishonest fellow like him would be fired sooner or later. However, I should have the self-respect and the respect for him as a person. I could not but feel bad that I could sink as low as using foul language. I went to him the next day to apologise. I said, I am sorry that I used such terrible language yesterday.’ I did it out of respect for the dignity that all humans are entitled to. A sincere apology is not something to be ashamed of. After years of hard work, I finally put in place a culture of respect for people at Crystal. Colleagues interact with one another as if they were members of the same big
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
family. Rarely do we see any confrontation or discord. If a conflict does arise, we will focus on the issue and not the people involved. Insulting others verbally is definitely not allowed. All this goes to reflect the core value we place on people.
Clear Delegation To Avoid Disagreement If disagreements arise between colleagues, someone in management will need to find out the root of the disagreements and then find a permanent solution. In my experience, transferring employees who cause trouble to another unit is similar to burying one’s head in the sand. It does not solve the problem. If the problem stems from an individual’s conduct, you are simply shifting the problem to another unit. At Crystal, besides our people-oriented philosophy, we also uphold the importance of being transparent and accountable. When handing down an assignment, we communicate clearly the details of the assignment to the colleagues concerned so that they understand our expectations, the targets that they have to complete and the appraisal criteria that will be applied. As they have been given full authority and a clear indication of the goal from the very beginning they will not have the opportunity to return with excuses for their failure. If a colleague reneges on what they agreed to in the beginning, it only shows that one is not willing to own responsibilities. Otherwise, he should have voiced his objections when receiving the assignment.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
- Human Resources Strategy Plan for A Rainy Day: Solution For Talent Supply We foresee our people needs and start to groom talents in house. Since our Group is expanding and since we pride ourselves for having a unique corporate culture, we find it more difficult to recruit talents within our industry. To further develop and promote staff from within seem to be the more viable option.
Industry Lacks New Talent We have devoted 46 years to turn what others call a sunset industry into one with a bright future. However, whenever we try to recruit management talents from the market we encounter extreme difficulties in identifying qualified candidates for middle or senior management positions. I believe that has something to do with the fact that Hong Kong’s garment manufacturing industry is made up of small to mid-sized enterprises. Those who are capable are already established in senior positions. Some have even struck out on their own to set up their own business. The other option open to us is to look for talents north of the border. Although the Mainland has a large population, it lacks management-level personnel that are welltrained in the garment manufacturing. Additionally, our factories are positioned in small towns - an environment not so appealing to ambitious and well educated young talents. Talent shortage is a severe problem in the garment manufacturing industry. To most young people, it is not a ‘dream’ industry so it is hard to recruit. Many of my fellow garment manufacturers are having trouble finding successors - even if they are to source
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
additional talents from within their families.
Anticipate Needs To Plan Ahead In our journey to reach the world’s top spot in apparel making, the company has been expanding rapidly in accordance with the 5 and 10-year plan in place. Recruiting qualified personnel remains a problem. In fact, there exists a vacuum in the management hierarchy tier alone. If we continue to ignore succession planning, Crystal will find it difficult to expand when the present generation of management retires. That is why we place high importance on training and developing young people to keep the workforce young and vital.
Training Three Pools Of Talents Since our Group is expanding and since we pride ourselves for having a unique corporate culture, we find it more difficult to recruit talents within our industry. To further develop and promote talents from within seem to be the more viable option. We have three reasons for taking this approach:
- Staff tends to welcome a system that favors internal promotions;
- Even if we were to ‘parachute’ someone qualified from another company to fill a senior position, he or she may have a hard time adapting to the Crystal culture and modes of operation and would come in conflict with the existing team causing disruption;
- Those who are integrated into our corporate culture and wish to stay and grow in the company have a strong sense of belonging to Crystal. When given the proper development, these individuals are likely to do better than an outside hire.
Adaptability: A Focus In Recruitment Irrespective of the position, it is important that a candidate is suited to the Crystal culture.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
When hiring senior managers, we may contact the candidates’ ex-supervisors, excolleagues and acquaintances informally to find out what kind of persons they are. We want to make sure that the people we hire can integrate well into the company and collaborate with the rest of the workforce in advancing our business. We look for the following traits in recruiting managers: ◆◆ Ability to set right targets and result driven, that is, ‘begin with the end in mind’; ◆◆ Ability to work well with others as a team player; and ◆◆ Ability to lead with strategic mindset.
The newly joined managers are required to undergo a series of orientation and training activities to help them adapt to Crystal’s environment, culture and operations as soon as possible so that they can make positive contributions.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
How Many Talents Does Crystal Need For Future Growth? Andrew Lo, Group CEO, talks about people needs. I have challenged my senior management team: Before retirement, each team member must develop capable next generation leaders including themselves for his or her own team. The company currently has over 60 colleagues in positions of assistant general managers and above – just enough to handle our daily operations at this point. When the company further expands we will need twice the number of managers at such levels to manage the business. I predict it may be more than 100. That is why we must start the process of attracting, developing and promoting people without delay. Apart from increasing the number of executives, we also need to improve the management quality of this layer. In the early days, the educational level of those in management in Hong Kong’s various manufacturing industries was relatively low. Rarely would one witness a college graduate among them. Nowadays, education is more widespread and the quality of candidates has improved - making it easier to recruit mid-career talents who are mature and all-rounded in their thinking and ability. I raised the issue of succession planning with my team two or three years ago but they failed to understand the urgency at that time. Now they have generally come around and have started to plan for succession and talent development. My target is to have each subsidiary develop a pool of 30 to 40 ‘next
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
generation leader talents. Currently in their 30s, they will be ready to pick up the baton in 10 to 15 years. If a unit has fewer than 10 potentially suitable candidates, it will have to work harder and right away. Developing leaders and managers constitutes an important link in succession planning for any enterprise. It is only when we invest in people development that we can be sure of having enough talent for seamless succession once the existing generation of leaders retires. Only when we have enough leader talents for the future, can we move forward with the confidence of becoming a perpetual enterprise.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Matrix Structure: Division Of Labour In Our HR Teams Through clear channels of communication, the Hong Kong office lends assistance to the subsidiaries in human resources matters. A subsidiary is free to introduce its own policies within the Group’s broad policies, that are beneficial to employees. If another subsidiary wants to do the same, it can modify them in accordance with its own circumstances. This has become quite common in the company.
Hong Kong Headquarters Helps With People Planning Crystal Group has five subsidiaries, each with its independent human resources department and person-in-charge reporting directly to the company head. These human resources heads are responsible for the daily administration related to human resources at the subsidiary level, including recruitment, payroll, employee care and training. Besides, they may take up a local governance role and vendor compliance. They also assist in raising public awareness of the Crystal brand. At the head office, the corporate HR team focuses on strategic people planning, organization development and human resources strategies and policies on Group basis to meet the Group’s growth plan. In our organisation hierarchy, the corporate HR team does not oversee the subsidiaries’ HR function and they have no direct reporting relationship with them in a matrix structure. As long as it does not involve anything legal, a subsidiary is free to introduce its own policies within the Group’s broad policies, that are beneficial to employees. If another subsidiary wants to do the same, it can modify them in accordance with its own circumstances. This has become quite common within the Group. Just like any other specialty unit, the corporate HR department lends support to the subsidiaries by providing necessary advice and help to define the overall HR needs
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
and strategies touching on the following:
- Identify which areas of expertise or skills are missing from a given workforce, and then plan the needed training to acquire such skills;
- Plan the overall HR needs and development with focus on the management layer;
- Cultivate cross-team commitment and best practice sharing within the HR community and responsible for Group led training and development programmes.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Pay Policy: Set Earning Targets We want our workers to have a stable income. We encourage them to work with high efficiency to earn more. If our workers earn a fat paycheck one month but because of insufficient work orders, have their income drastically cut the next, or worst still; make only minimum wage. Their morale at work is likely to dissipate. If this occurs regularly demoralisation can occur, leading to resignations.
Boost Morale By Providing A Stable Earning Environment As with other garment manufacturers, our workers’ regular income and incentives are based on their output. With our philosophy of putting people first, we understand that our workers would like to have a stable income and at Crystal; we aim to serve our workers with a stable earning environment. If our workers earn a fat paycheck one month but because of insufficient work orders, have their income drastically cut the next, or worst still; make only minimum wage. Their morale at work is likely to dissipate. If this occurs regularly demoralisation can occur, leading to high attrition rate. That is why we introduced the ‘Target Earning Scheme’ for our sewers in the production floor. In our Dongguan T-shirt factory, for instance, the average target earning of our sewers is 115 % of the market average, that is, 15 % higher than the market. Yet, most sewers actually surpass the target earning. Those who work with exceedingly high efficiency even have an income double that of the market average. Of course, we instituted this system of target earning not to give our workers the idea that they could get paid without performance. In recognition of the seasonal fluctuation of the garment industry, however, we hope that this would provide a stable environment for them to earn a stable income with upside. Fortunately, based on the work orders we have on hand, the seasonal fluctuation is not that obvious. Our workers’ monthly workload and income are quite stable. Given
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
that our Group has a people-oriented culture with all the family-friendly measures, we can sustain a stable and cohesive workforce.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Performance Management: Measure Performance Against Agreed Targets Our appraisal system is transparent and fair. Some in management were not accustomed to an appraisal system tied to profitability. They believed that whether a financial target could be met depended on many factors – both external and internal – so profitability should not be a criteria for performance appraisal. Others of the old school felt that quantifying performance appraisal was not the conventional way of the garment industry and would just exert undue pressure. There was quite a bit of opposition…
Reward Based On Fair Assessment In a traditional industry such as garment manufacturing, one must pay attention to results to be able to survive and grow. This is especially the case when it comes to profitability and customer satisfaction. In fact, one should use these two factors to set targets. Andrew was trained in business administration in college. He is accustomed to using quantifiable standards to measure success or failure. In assessing the performance of the people in management, he has been striving all along to use objective criteria. He encourages his management team to focus on targets and begin with the end in mind so as to turn Crystal into a meritorious, modern enterprise based on the concept of ‘performance driven.’ For this reason, Andrew brought in General Electric’s (GE) objective target-based appraisal system as well as its merit-based ‘Performance Management System.’ At the end of each year, Andrew meets with his management team individually to determine the target for the next year. Taking into consideration of the rank and the nature of the work of the individual, key performance indicators (KPIs) are set. An interim review of the KPIs is done at mid-year, then a final review at the end of the year,
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
to see if the targets are met.
Managers Take Responsibility For Effective Implementation KPIs and PMS (Performance Management System) are important tools to quantify performance of an employee that many multinational companies are using. They are not just unique in Crystal. But how these tools are put to use may differ from one organisation to another and the results may accordingly vary. The critical point lies in managers who must have regular and frank discussions with their people regarding their KPI progress. If a target is not met, then both parties should examine the reasons. The manager then should make suggestions as to how his subordinate can improve the performance and document the entire conversation. If a manager does not carry out his or her duty to communicate regularly with his team members and follow up on their KPIs, then the latter will be at a loss as to how they perform. Do they meet the expectations of the company? Is the appraisal fair? Worse still, they will not know how to improve. In that case, the outcome will be disastrous.
Merits Seen At Pilot Point When it was first introduced to the Group, the Performance Management System (PMS) was met with some resistance. This was expected. Some in management were not accustomed to an appraisal system tied to profitability. They believed that whether a financial target could be met depended on many factors – both external and internal – so profitability should not be a criteria for performance appraisal. Others of the old school felt that quantifying performance appraisal was not the conventional way of the garment industry and would just exert undue pressure. There was quite a bit of opposition. We understood that pushing such drastic change over night would cause some resistance within the Group - therefore we decided only to launch the PMS within our sweater division. We planned to implement it through the rest of the Group after success is seen. We would only implement it throughout the rest of Group after making adjustments to counter problems that might arise from the pilot run.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Knowing that pushing such a drastic change overnight would bring on a lot of disgruntlement, we decided in the end to pilot the PMS at the knitwear division. We would only implement it throughout the rest of Group after making adjustments to counter problems that might arise from the pilot run. Years have passed since the Group adopted PMS. People within the Group gradually realised that profitability is essential to the survival and expansion of any enterprise and came to accept target setting and the meritorious system. PMS is highly transparent, fair and result-driven, and has the function of encouraging colleagues to strive for improvement. Now that everyone is in support of the PMS, execution is becoming more effective day by day.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
- Attract And Develop Talents Associate Programme: Develop Leaders of the Next Two Generations Nursing a seedling into a shady tree. Each BA or PA is assigned with a reporting manager, who also will act as a coach. The two interact regularly, with the hope that with such close monitoring and coaching plus real job experience, a young talent can mature into his job, like a sapling growing gradually into a shady tree.
Recruit On Campus To Fill Talent Pool The company wishes to have more young blood on board but the younger generation in Hong Kong is rarely interested in entering the garment manufacturing industry. We took the most direct approach by visiting the universities in search of suitable graduates for the positions of business associate (BA) or production associate (PA). BAs and PAs will be put through a training programme lasting two to three years During this time they are assigned to sales team (for BA) or production team (for PA) with a reporting manager to guide their learning. The BA and PA programme was launched in 2012. The persons in charge of hiring BAs and PAs are neither the HR head of our Hong Kong office nor those of the subsidiaries. Rather, they are the heads of the sales and production teams. They personally screen the applicants, focusing on their language ability, their communication skills, their performance at the interview, their response to our questions and their leadership potential. Each BA or PA is assigned with a reporting manager, who also will act as a coach. The two interact regularly, with the hope that with such close monitoring and coaching
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
plus real job experience, a young talent can mature into his job, like a sapling growing gradually into a shady tree. Many large corporations feature a similar programme, what is sometimes termed ‘management trainee.’ Usually, trainees get assigned to different departments to learn various functions on a rotational basis during their training. But since department heads do not know whether a particular trainee will return to work under them eventually, they usually pass on merely superficial skills or knowledge. Trainees thus find it hard to learn anything in an in-depth way. We do it differently in Crystal. Our BAs and PAs will stay with either the sales or the production team of the business throughout their training. It is to the advantage of the reporting manager to pay close attention to developing them so that they can contribute to the future good of their specific teams.
Career Expressway When we first established the BA and PA programme, we were fully aware that turnover was unavoidable. It is natural that young people would like to see more of the world and try out different things or hope to have a successful career as soon as possible. In addition to salary, therefore, we realised that our offer must be compatible with those in the market. Meanwhile, we also hoped that the influence of our corporate culture and the clear career path that we outline for them would be incentives to keep them in the company. According to the experience of most organisations, only about 20% of management trainees stay with their first employer for five to 10 years after training. It usually takes the average university graduates entering Crystal five to eight years to reach the assistant manager level. But those recruited as BAs and PAs can become assistant managers if they complete the program successfully with a final presentation to a development board after two to three years of training. Depending on their subsequent performance, they have the chance to scale even higher up the corporate ladder in a speedy fashion. That is why the BA and PA programme has been nicknamed the ‘Career Expressway.’
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
We do not expect all BAs or PAs to arrive effortlessly at the finishing line. Rather, we want them to understand that it is not a given that they can complete their training and get promoted. At the end of the training programme, participants are appraised according to a rigorous system. Only those who cut the grade will make it to the assistant manager position. Those who fail at the end of the programme will be asked to leave Crystal. The objective of the BA and PA programme is to groom our future leaders. We hope sincerely that every BA or PA will succeed and can assume the post of assistant manager after the training. For those who make it, the promotion is just another starting point and not the finishing line. They should continue to learn and strive towards the next milestone of their career path. Since we want them to move up the corporate ladder, we also have post-BA/PA programme follow-up to track their performance and development. In our production base in China, some of our BAs and PAs have already made it through to become assistant managers. They have a boundless future ahead of them at Crystal. Since early 2015, the Associate Programme has expanded to encompass both Technical and Finance areas nurturing more talents as the future leaders of various disciplines.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Leadership Development: Prepare Next Generation Leaders To Carry The Baton Capable lieutenants are selected for meticulous grooming. We have begun a systematic search in house for outstanding middle managers with leadership potential. These individuals will be invited to participate in the ‘Next Generation Leader’ programme.
Select Lieutenants To Lead The Troops Andrew has estimated in his strategic plan that the Group will need to train over 100 talents in the next 10 to 15 years to meet the need of our expansion. When he and his peers retire one after another, the most capable among this group of talents will take over as general managers or even presidents of subsidiaries. They will lead the business to realise the Group’s vision of becoming the world’s No 1 apparel maker. If Crystal is to continue as a viable enterprise, it must do a good job of succession planning. In the long run, we look to the BAs and PAs for the next two generations of leaders. In the medium term, we will promote from within those who show leadership traits and ‘genes’ of the corporate culture. They are in for grooming to take the baton from Andrew’s generation. Normal retirement age at Crystal is 65 years old. We figure that each executive can stay in a senior position for at least 15 years. That is why we have begun a systematic search in house for outstanding middle managers with leadership potential. These individuals will be invited to participate in the ‘Next Generation Leader’ (NGL) programme. After careful nurturing, we hope that they are ready to take over our executive roles in 5 to 10 years. Irrespective of his or her nationality or job nature, a Crystal employee can enter the NGL as long as he or she shows leadership potential. After passing the initial assessment, the person will undergo training for three to five years. Meanwhile, the external human
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
resources consultant we commissioned is drafting a development programme for our NGL tailored to our corporate culture and our growth needs.
Careful Grooming To Enhance Strengths NGL aside, we also reinforce the training of our existing middle and senior managers to raise their professionalism and upgrade their leadership skills. The purpose is to keep them abreast with the latest skills to meet the company’s future expansion. At around 2012, Dennis Wong, the President of the T-shirts and Sweater division and the Group’s executive director, had the foresight to point out that given the rapid rate of expansion of his division in the next few years, the existing management team might not possess effective leadership skills to meet the business needs. Subsequently, joining forces with corporate human resources head and an outside human resource consultant, Dennis launched the ‘Leadership Development Programme’ (LDP) and enrolled his backbone managers in the programme. The consultant did a ‘Leadership Effectiveness Analysis’ to identify the characteristics of a leader, which include the following:
- Vision creation
- Followers development
- Vision implementation
- Overall process follow-up
- Results achievement
- Team playing. Each participant must undergo a personality test to understand his or her own character. The shortcoming thus detected will be the focus in ‘Strategic Leadership Development Workshop’ (SLD). The Workshop is made up of three phases. Members are divided into different learning groups where they learn to be leaders of different programmes. They have to submit reports of their progress at designated times and interact and learn from one
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
another - this kind of interaction raises leadership ability.
Sustained Training To Develop Talents After going through SLD, participants must submit to Dennis an ‘Individual Development Plan’ with a view towards improving on the weaknesses that they discover in themselves with the help of the programme. As the mentor, Dennis offers feedback and suggestions for improvement to each participant, including arranging suitable assignments. The participant’s performance is reviewed in 12 months to see if progress has been made and development goals attained. After two years of the results programme within the T-shirt and Sweater division, positive results were evident. A common language and a set of common knowledge gradually came to being on management and leadership matters. In 2014, the Hong Kong Management Association recognised the merits of our LDP by bestowing on Crystal the gold award in Development in its annual ‘Excellence in Training and Development Award’ event. That Crystal was able to win such a high recognition on the first try is a record in the history of the award. Seeing that the pilot LDP at the T-shirt and Sweater division has helped boost the division’s performance and profitability, Andrew subsequently decided to extend this programme to the entire Group. To date, nearly 100 managers have participated in LDP, upgrading immensely the development and leadership skill of Crystal’s executives and managers. We believe that Crystal’s future executive team will be stronger and more capable of meeting future challenges.
Three Pools Of Talents Ain sum, LEA provides leadership training for the current middle and senior team, NGL prepares those capable managers with potential for moving onto the executive levels, while the BA and PA programme looks to develop new blood from fresh graduates. The three go hand in hand to ensure that there will be no interruption in the supply of talents and leaders within Crystal.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
PACE: Raise Personal Value Of Female Workers Through this programme, female workers can improve themselves and change their lives. Sometimes the trainees call late at night, but our instructors are glad to be patient listeners and offer counselling as appropriate. There is close bond between the instructors and the students, which further strengthens the family atmosphere at Crystal.
Enhanced Programme Benefits Female Workers Many organisations provide employees with training on soft skills, such as personal development and communication skills. Most of these programmes target management layers however, while workers are given only training in technical skills directly related to their work. Mostly women are hired to work on the sewing production line in our industry. In general, these women are not highly educated. They earn their living mainly with their dexterous hands. Many of them leave their hometown and loved ones to work in a strange land. All they seek are three full meals and a roof over their heads. Personal development or upgrade is not their top priority. In 2007, Gap Inc., a key client of Crystal’s, launched a programme called the ‘Personal Advancement & Career Enhancement’ or PACE. Its objective is to help women working in the clothing industry gain skills and confidence to advance in their career as well as in life, notably, in raising their self-esteem. Frankie Wong, the head of the denim division and an executive director, was impressed with PACE. He accepted Gap’s invitation to try out a similar programme at our Zhongshan denim factory in 2012. The programme stretched over 10 months and involved 80 hours of training divided into seven modules - each with a wealth of practical tips ranging from communication to problem solving, strategic planning, legal matters
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
and female physical well-being. Our female workers’ reaction to the programme was highly positive. Jointly with the denim factory’s HR head, Frankie amended the original American PACE programme to incorporate mainland Chinese elements. The programme was most successful. Nearly 500 female workers had graduated from two classes of PACE training. Their graduation was attended by Gap representatives visiting from the US headquarters. The visitors were keen to find out how successful PACE had been in Zhongshan. Seeing the success of PACE in Zhongshan, other subsidiaries also expressed interest in launching the programme.
Boosted Confidence Leads To Further Development Although PACE originated from Gap Inc., an American company, it reflects fully Crystal’s spirit of valuing people. All the instructors of our PACE programme are employees of our Zhongshan denim factory, including its HR team. They devote plenty of their personal time to the programme. Aside from teaching the courses, they have to keep a close tab of the lives of their ‘trainees’. Sometimes the trainees call late at night, but our instructors are glad to be patient listeners and offer counselling as appropriate. There is close bond between the instructors and the students, which further strengthens the family atmosphere at Crystal. Female workers who went through PACE programme see not only an upgrade of their personal qualities but also an improvement in their family life, interpersonal skills and above all, their self-confidence. Word of mouth quickly confirms the value of the programme, bringing more and more workers to enroll in the next programmes. The PACE programme serves a split purpose. On the one hand, female workers can upgrade themselves; on the other, the company can add to the reserve pool of front-line supervisory talents. Out of the two groups of graduates, 30 of them with increased selfesteem after the training and decided to go for promotion opportunities. They enrolled in the training programmes for line supervisors. Those who finish this training with distinction will be promoted to line supervisor.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Feedback From PACE Graduates ❤ In my opinion, the primary merit of PACE is raising my personal ability and developing my career. Our communication skill was greatly improved. We also learnt about problem solving, time management and stress management skills. In addition, the programme taught us about caring for our own health as women, our legal rights, our executional ability within our own positions, our family, and our relationship with our husband, our in-laws and our children. Due to the lack of appropriate soft skills, we often found ourselves faced with problems we could not solve. After PACE, we are much better prepared to tackle them.
❤ For me, the biggest change that PACE has brought to my life is how to coach my son. In the past, my boy was virtually impossible to manage. I had to leave him behind at home when I moved away to make a living. When he rejoined me, he was already 12 years old. He was rebellious and disobedient. Besides giving him a beating, I did not know what I could do to bring him under control. After enrolling in PACE, I shared what I learned at class with my son. I started to reason with him and to encourage him. Slowly, the messages seemed to sink in and his behavior began to change. I really think the method of interaction that they teach at PACE is highly useful in a family situation. PACE has helped me change my son. Now I can devote my full attention to work.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
❤ I never dared tell my loved ones out loud that I cared a lot for them. We Chinese simply tend to be a bit reserved and reluctant to express our feelings. A PACE instructor told us that if you love someone, you have to speak out. I never told my husband that I loved him. But after PACE, I actually blurted out three words in front of him: “I love you!” After that, our feelings for each other improved. He is now much more thoughtful. When I get home from working overtime, he sometimes gets ready a late night snack and a hot bath for me to await my return.
❤ PACE is helpful to us both in our work and our life. We used to baulk at every assignment handed down to us at work. Now, we communicate frankly with our supervisors and try to see things from their standpoint. Change has also occurred to me regarding my relationship with the family. I now call home daily, speaking regularly with my husband and my motherin-law. When my husband visited me at my workplace in the past, we would argue as soon as we set eyes on each other. After we quarrelled, I would hide in a corner and cry. Today, I take the initiative to communicate. I also refuse to haggle over small details. Perhaps because of my change in attitude, my husband has also changed his mindset, too.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
An Invigorating Office Environment Interview with Howard Lo, the redevelopment project incharge and SVP of Sales, T-shirt and Sweater Division Dongguan, Guangdong is the headquarter of our T-shirt and knitwear division. The re-development of the factory buildup opened in 2012 as an example of modern and environmentally friendly architecture. The layout is functionally spacious and aesthetically pleasant. Environment friendly facilities were integrated into the design of the building. Such a modern factory compound is hard to find in southern China. In planning this building complex, we wanted to incorporate elements of modern architecture for two reasons. On the one hand, we hoped to enhance the corporate image; on the other, we wanted to provide colleagues with a pleasant working environment to boost the team spirit. I studied and grew up overseas. I also worked for a few years at a foreign bank. When I was put in charge of this redevelopment project, I looked up quite a few books on interior design. I was pleasantly surprised to find that many of the Western architectural concepts were oriented from the ‘people oriented’ ideas. We picked the open-plan design for our office interiors, minimizing as much as possible the number of rooms. Managers now sit right next to their staff. Rooms are partitioned by glass to give a highly transparent feel and to encourage interaction between supervisors and subordinates. For the same purpose, the height of the partitions between cubicles are kept low enough so that all one has to do is to stand up to speak to one’s neighbour.
C hap ter Fou r : Ou r Peop le
Recognising that colleagues spend a lot of time at work every day, I made sure that their work space would be bright and airy. As much as possible, we put workstations near sources of natural light. Most of the areas next to windows are not blocked by rooms for that reason. With the middle of the floor laid out in an open plan, everybody can see the windows. The middle part of each floor is connected by stairs. Our walls are covered by live plants to complement the natural lighting. At the spacious atrium in the center, one needs only to look up to see the sky. Overall, it is a refreshing working environment. Although having the stairwell in the center of the building takes up a lot of space, it has the positive effect of reducing the physical distance between colleagues. Working in a classy and cozy environment such as this naturally has boosted productivity. Arriving to work in a stylish office has made our colleagues more aware, on a subconscious level, of how they should dress. Thus the new office has another effect of polishing our employees’ self-image. Some colleagues even take to snapping selfies in the office to share with others. Their fondness for the new workplace certainly has an impact of strengthening a sense of belonging and devotion to the company.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
Chapter Five Our Operation Models Begin with the end in mind.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter Five: Our Operation Models
- Decentralising Authority To Encourage Autonomy ◆
Decentralise And Delegate
◆
Effective Data Management With Transparency
- Technology Simplifies And Speeds Up Management ◆
Use Of Technology: Three Guiding Principles
◆
Technology Is Everywhere
◆
Karl Ting: How Technology Takes Us Into The Future
- Bridging Sales And Production ◆
Production Culture: Keep It Lean With 6S
◆
Industrial Engineering: Develop Production Capacity Standards
◆
◆ ◆
217
227
Order Allocation By Strengths: Global Production Planning Strategy Mega Factories: Where Our Future Lies Sales And Production Collaboration: Treating Company Business As Your Own
- Manage Finance Prudently ◆
Prudent Management To Ensure Financial Soundness
◆
Sensitive To Risk: Stay Alert For The Unexpected
- Cultivate Quality Culture To Delight Customer
211
◆
Quality Comes First: Right First Time, Every Time
◆
Quality Assurance As Our Competitive Edge: Zero Defect
243
247
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
- Decentralising Authority To Encourage Autonomy Decentralise And Delegate Backed by Hong Kong office, individual subsidiaries are free to test their own ideas. Under the principle of ‘decentralisation and delegation,’ it is no longer necessary for Hong Kong office to pass down instructions on every little detail , but to set targets for the subsidiaries and leave them to reach them in the best way they know how. The framework of decentralisation and delegation is simple: Hong Kong office focuses on macro and directional arena. Once these are agreed upon, it will then authorise the subsidiaries and their teams to pursue them.
Decentralisation Takes Time To Run Smoothly During Crystal’s early days, the authority on policy making, administration, personnel and financial matters was centralised in the Hong Kong office. The results of such an arrangement was far from desirable. In fact, it was felt that centralisation hurt the efficiency of our subsidiaries. In the 1990s, we decided to take a different approach. We gave up micro-management and adopted what we called ‘decentralisation with proper delegation.’ ’Under the principle of ‘decentralisation with proper delegation,’ it is no longer necessary for Hong Kong office to pass down instructions on every little detail , but to set targets for the subsidiaries and leave them to reach them in the best way they know how. The framework of decentralisation and delegation is simple: Hong Kong office focuses on macro and directional arena. Once these are agreed upon, it will then authorise the
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
subsidiaries and their teams to pursue them. At first, members of the senior management were not accustomed to the new approach. They were worried that the company would lose control of the operations. In saying this however, no one came out to voice their objections - probably because they thought it would make them look bad. Instead, they declared their support of the new management approach, but took no active part in implementing it. At the same time, the subsidiaries had yet to develop a sense of responsibility of their work. They were, in other words, not prepared either in their ability or state of mind for such a change. It took more than a decade for the new approach to run smoothly.
Personal Experience Supports The Move To Delegate Before assuming the post of CEO, Andrew was the head of a subsidiary. This experience enabled him to understand how it felt to be working at an outpost where he was required to take instructions from a bureaucracy system. It is easy for Hong Kong office to pass judgement to the frontline without knowing the situation. As a result, very little of what the office had to say contributed to reaching a solution. Instead, their less than structured criticism only added to the pressures felt by frontline staff. As the saying goes, ‘do not do to others what you would not have them do to you.’ In line with his experience, Andrew did not wish to see the subsidiaries subjected to such pressure and did not want them to have to wait for answers from the Hong Kong office. Neither did he wish to get involved in daily operational details of our subsidiaries. When he became the Group’s CEO, he decided that he would continue on the course of decentralisation and delegate authority to subsidiaries. He would direct his attention to macro matters, including annual performance of the subsidiaries, changes in their operation environment, the Group’s development strategies and the continual pursuit of excellence and sustainability. Apart from taking care of macro issues, Hong Kong office supports the subsidiaries by providing them with up-to-date market information, setting direction for expansion,
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
promoting best practices, planning risk control and crisis management and encouraging inter-unit communications and arrangements for group-wide training. The role of Hong Kong office is to assist and not to rule over various subsidiaries. At Hong Kong office, we have a small but efficient team. The functional departments are well connected with the world, including all the subsidiaries and more than 20 factories in Mainland China and overseas. The productivity at most of our factories has improved year by year. It is evident that our policy of decentralisation and delegation works.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Effective Data Management With Transparency An open and fair reward and disciplinary system is put in place. Any authorised middle or senior manager can obtain all sorts of information at the touch on the keyboard. The information could be the Group’s financial performance on the macrolevel or the profit and loss of a specific order on the microlevel . He or she can get real-time update of the bottom line, the source of earnings and how the earnings are made.
Data Transparency Facilitates Strategic Decision It is possible to have a rough idea of the company’s financial status at any point if the business is small. When company continues to expand and venture into more and more business lines, however, it will be impossible to analyse the situation effectively without access to data, let alone measuring its performance. Without accurate information of this kind, making policy decisions will be like groping one’s way in the dark and effective management will be elusive. In most Chinese family businesses, the power of control is centralised within the founding family. Occasionally, some may introduce modern management techniques into their companies, but the business owner is still the commander-in-chief, who usually places family members and relatives in the most important roles. Most business owners in the family businesses do not normally trust outsiders to handle finances and guard closely ‘highly confidential’ information such as profit and loss, overhead costs and profit margins. The limitations of a company run in this mode are obvious. Nowadays, the management of the entire Crystal Group is supported by data. Financial and production information is readily accessible via the Intranet. Any authorised middle or senior manager can obtain all sorts of information at the touch on the keyboard. The information could be the Group’s financial performance on the macro-level or the profit and loss of a
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
specific order on the micro-level. He or she can get real-time update of the bottom line, the source of earnings and how the earnings are made. The workforce can derive three major advantages from data management with its high transparency:
- Delegation of authorities sends a clear message to the employees that they have the trust of the company.
- With adequate data on hand, one can better analyse the market, make a more accurate forecast of profit and loss, and set more realistic targets.
- Colleagues now know clearly how they perform, whether they meet their target and at what rate. With such platform in place, the computer system plays an important role in providing management with data and objective monitoring of the company’s performance. As a result, we can obtain clear overall picture anytime. It is now much easier to strategise and gain control of the situation, amend policies and adjust the execution plan even when there is a sudden change in market conditions.
Fairness Comes First All decisions at Crystal are backed up by impartial information about targets and outputs, which our corporate culture emphasis. Management by data has made these decisions transparent. Information on production details and line performances are recorded as data, which are open for review by any team online. One only needs to compare the data to see which team is doing better. At a glance, colleagues will know who will get rewarded and who will not. Internal activity is fair and square leaving no room for suspicion or jealousy. Instead, transparency enables everyone to strive for higher achievements and the company as a whole benefits from employee enthusiasm and constructive competitive behaviours. We are often asked: ‘If your company is so open about such highly confidential data, how do you prevent your competitors from obtaining such information?’ Well, I am confident that given the strong sense of belonging and integrity
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
within our workforce, none of my employees will pass on the company’s data to unwarranted parties. In fact, even if some of the information falls into the hands of a competitor, it is unlikely that they will be able to make use of it unless the business, like Crystal, has a corporate culture that serves the Greater Good and values people as we do. The competitor would need to manage their business in a scientific way (similar to Crystal) to take advantage of such information.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
- Technology Simplifies And Speeds Up Management Use of Technology: Three Guiding Principles When confronted with a problem, we seek not just the solution but the way to move forward. Technology simplifies a process and speeds things up. Our IT department is in place to serve us - not enslave us. The primary function of our computer system is to boost operational efficiency providing us with useful data so that we can stay one step ahead. Management by data requires a company be backed by a highly efficient information technology system. We are fortunate to have Karl Ting heading our Corporate Information System Department (CISD). With him at the helm over the years, CISD has been delivering new initiatives and winning a number of awards in public contests. The CIDS team consists of only 30 people, yet serves a workforce of more than 60,000 employees - proving how lean and efficient the operation is. We owe the success of this partiular department to three core values: an attitude to challenge the status quo, strategic partnership and a desire to simplify.
Challenge The Present to Seek Improvement Our IT department is to serve us, not to enslave us. The primary function of our computer system is to boost operational efficiency, providing us with sufficient data so that we can stay one step ahead in the competition and eventually be the market leader. It is therefore important that a company keeps apace with the times in its IT
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
development. It must never be complacent with the status quo. At Crystal, we keep introducing new versions of software applications in our pursuit of excellence. We believe that it is only through improving our operating conditions that we can move forward and maintain our leadership position in the industry.
Suppliers Give Us Priority To Try New Software Technology advances by leaps and bounds. To stay at the forefront, we maintain an excellent and long-term relationship with SAP, Microsoft and other software suppliers. That is why we are often given priority to pilot their new software programmes before they are released to the public. To a software supplier, getting Crystal business is not only the revenue that matters, it is the Crystal name pledged onto its products which enhances its business credibility. In return, we get to use the software at a discounted price. In addition, we have the advantage of being ahead of our competitors to experience the benefits of new technology which serve to reinforce our position in the industry.
Simplify In Pursuit Of Excellence At Crystal, we favor simplification and we always seek to complete a job following the most simple of procedures. That is why we keep coming up with a fresh approach to raising work efficiency. We consider simplification from three angles:
- Can we attain the same outcome using a different method or a new set of rules?
- Are the amount of time and overhead used on the job acceptable?
- Can we further simplify the workflow process? As long as we can streamline the workflow, we can save time and remove the unnecessary pressure of our workforce to enhance efficiency. That is why the concept of simplification was supported throughout the Group and laid the foundation for the modernisation of Crystal’s management.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
These three core values and the four approaches discussed in Chapter 3, i.e to stick to the Golden Rules, to simplify things, to speed things up and to target win-win combined to form the success of our IT department.
Overview of Crystal’s IT System The chart below illustrates how the Crystal’s IT system tracks the workflow.
The chart shows how our IT functions are in line with production work at Hong Kong office and in all the subsidiaries. The operation of the company is highly transparent because the IT system allows for real-time retrieval of data. It also makes work much easier for all concerned.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Technology Is Everywhere Technology enhances efficiency and reduces operating costs. Data gathered by the ‘Radio Frequency Identification’ system allows management to have a clear picture of the output volume and productivity of each worker and every production line. The data also indicates whether a production system is running smoothly, whether workers are performing well and whether the progress on an order is going according to plan. Management is thus able to fully grasp this important information in real time.
IT Applied Throughout The Organisation A look at Crystal’s production and operation systems demonstrates that IT is being deployed throughout our operations. When it comes to factory production lines, every worker is equipped with a nonradioactive ‘Radio Frequency Identification’ (RFID) tag which records the amount of time required to finish a particular task. Data gathered by the ‘Radio Frequency Identification’ system allows management to have a clear picture of the output volume and productivity of each worker and every production line. The data also indicates whether a production system is running smoothly, whether workers are performing well and whether the progress on an order is going according to plan. Management is thus able to fully grasp this important information in real time. In front of each production line is a big screen showing production statistics of the team in real time. By checking on the screen, workers can compare their output with one another encouraging healthy competition.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
Electronics Allow For Paperless Operation The company’s operations are supported entirely by the SAP system electronically. Its capacity is such that the company can process orders upwards of tens of billions of Hong Kong dollars per year. With the help of the computer system, we are able to handle most steps of the workflow process and in a paper-free way. The process begins with quotations - then to receipt of orders, purchasing of materials, production, shipping documentation, warehousing, banking, invoicing and delivery. Every step is successfully processed electronically by computer systems. After we adopted the SAP ‘Evaluated Receipt Settlement’ (ERS) process, the system can verify invoices directly with the suppliers. This is indeed an example of a good use of technology to speed up and to simplify a complicated process. It saves us time and allows our work to be more accurate. Learning quickly about how valuable ERS was to us, we extended its use to banking. These days, our accounts receivable and payable no longer requires manual processing. More than that, a workflow process that used to take over 10 days can now be completed in single day, reducing substantially our man hours and related cost, at the same time supporting the world trend in favor of a paperless environment.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
How Technology Takes Us Into The Future Karl Ting, General Manager, Corporate Information Department, gives an account of Crystal’s experience in mobile technology. True to the spirit of challenging the status quo, Crystal closely follows technological trends by launching world-class and state-of-the-art electronic systems and software to maintain stance within the industry. By doing so, we also look ahead to prepare ourselves for the future. The Corporate Information System Department (CISD) is now being used to examine the feasibility of a number of conceptual projects to include the Crystal Enterprise Mobility (CEM) platform, portable applications, Internet of Things and cloud computing.
Covering All Four Corners Of The Earth Our company places high importance on communication, both internally and externally. As most of our production bases are set up in developing countries, visiting them is costly and somewhat time-consuming. In the past, people in management roles would visit these outposts several times a year. Facsimile and long-distance calls had allowed for more frequent communication, but even then, discussions were often done without the support of data making management of the operations difficult. Nowadays, using the most advanced ‘information communications technology’ that links telecommunication systems with computer networks, we can save time and costs in getting people connected. All we need to do is to log on to the Intranet, open the email box, turn on the video-conferencing and instantaneous communication software and those in management can discuss issues with our overseas factories with
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
real-time data displayed on their screens. Governance is thus enhanced. Our communication network is presently hooked up to our telephone system, which allows colleagues to get in touch or hold video-conferences with one another by accessing either the 3G or 4G network via computer, telephone, tablet or cell phone. Also, they can transmit data in a stable and safe environment. This is indeed a major step in improving operating efficiency. Communication can now overcome the limits posed by national boundaries, regions and time. As an industry leader in the use of technology, we look forward to adopting the upgraded version of Skype for Business and Skype Personal software and integrating the two in the near future. When that happens, our communication system across national boundaries, regions and time will be even more user-friendly, faster and more advanced.
Crystal Enterprise Mobility (CEM) Makes Good Use Of Cloud Computing The CEM mobile programme that we developed in house is a formula for portable devices that is one step ahead of similar programmes in the market. It has freed up colleagues from the restriction imposed by mobile platforms. Now colleagues can use the formula on any device, a desktop computer, a tablet or a cell phone. The user can connect to the company’s Intranet via cloud to access news, business analytics, HR data and figures related to the supply chain. The data can be retrieved as charts, images or text, making it much more convenient for daily use and analysis. Additionally, data can be transmitted readily from one unit to the next; once again fulfilling the purpose of communication free from the limits of national boundary, region and time.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
This programme hugely reduces Crystal’s internal communication costs. It also meets the growing demand for information. The programme’s potentials are by no means limited to this. We shall use it as a blueprint to develop other feasible IT roadmaps in the hope of providing more convenience to our operations.
Added Advantage With Mobile Apps In the past decade or so, Smartphones and Androids have been selling like hotcakes, and mobile applications or ‘apps’ are gaining more and more traction. Apps are easy to use. One can retrieve information by merely touching a key or clicking a button without having to log in and search. Some time ago, Crystal collaborated with a supplier to write an app for cell phones, which is now being developed in house.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
We customised each individual user interface to the specifications the functions that are required. For example, the mobile app for sales managers features information on turnover, the materials of an order and other items they require for their job. Other routine tasks such as leave applications and staff reimbursements for pre-paid expenses are also written into the mobile app so that employees can execute such functions anywhere and anytime using their cell phones.
Technology To Enter The Era Of ‘Industry 4.0’ The Internet has revolutionised industries. Quite a number of Internet tools have been integrated into our daily operations. It is important in our business to be able to access real-time accurate data to analyse the prevailing conditions and trends. The talk of using the ‘big data’ that is currently in vogue is mainly for behavioural analysis. The subject of the analysis can be behaviours of the consumers, the production lines, the clients and the employees. The analysis provides not only quantity but also quality related results. Collated data can yield charts and tables that can be used to predict trends, hence converting quantity (data) into quality (values). Crystal is managing the use of the big data or predictive analytics to extract value from figures. We apply the big data to different links of our operation to get a deeper understanding of their performance and to provide a foundation for our management decisions. Beyond big data and cloud storage, we see the Internet of Things (IoT) as the next stage of our technological advancement. IoT is an electronic environment whereby humans can transmit data or communicate by means of portable data and the Internet. It combines wireless technologies, micro-electromechanical systems and the Internet to operate electronic
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
products in our daily life. For instance, one can use a cell phone to issue a command via cloud to turn on the air-conditioner by remote control before arriving at home. As far as the manufacturing industry is concerned, IoT allows for instantaneous collation of data from different sources, thus enhancing data transparency by a large degree. As we enter the era of ‘Industry 4.0.’ factories will be equipped to upload automatically data via cloud to show details of production at different production lines, including volume and logistical information. Searching for stored information has never been easier. The management as well as the clientele can access data real time to get a good grasp of the production and logistics situation. The concept of the IoT world is to link up as many objects as possible to derive the greatest collaborative impact. According to a forecast by SAP, future technology will impact on manufacturing in the following way:
- Change the current business model
- Apply digitalisation from start to finish.
- Integrate sales with production
- Add value with real-time network
- Improve the working environment We are making efforts to grasp the future of technological advancement in the directions described above. Our objective is to master IoT and big data to build a ‘smart factory’ in the Industry 4.0 era. Industry 4.0 refers to the Fourth Industrial Revolution with the computerization of manufacturing using automation, data exchange and manufacturing technologies. Cyber-physical Systems, the Internet of Things and the Internet of Services are utilized to create a value chain. The term was introduced at the Hanover Fair in 2011 in the context of a high-tech strategy project that was being conducted by the German government.
1
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
- Bridging Sales And Production Production Culture: Keep it Lean With 6S In production, we adopt Toyota’s ‘just-in-time’ approach as well as the 6S Factory Management Practices. In line with the principle of ‘lean manufacturing,’ we apply industrial engineering (IE) techniques and quality control to the workflow process to minimise wastage. IE can also be used to enhance management by data, and look for problematic links so that they can be corrected as soon as possible.
Lean Production Optimises Processes The cornerstone of our production management is the ‘lean manufacturing’ concept borrowed from Toyota, which focuses on managing the supply chain so that materials arrive ‘just in time’ for each step of the production. The idea is to maintain logistics and information flow at the same pace as production and to reduce pointless wastage. The outcome is the creation of economic value for the manufacturer, the client and the end-user. However, we do not replicate Toyota’s model completely, simply because of the difference in our business. As a car maker, Toyota has to keep inventory using the ‘buildto-stock’ approach. Its workflow process involves ‘one piece flow.’ The company designs its own specifications so that they are the same for each automobile in the same batch. In garment making, we go by a very different model, one that is called the ‘build-toorder’ model. Specifications for each order in the garment industry are not the same. The design and the quantity are dictated by our clients. Specifications change frequently and the production process is relatively diverse. Making a garment takes far less time than producing an automobile, so it is even more critical that we manage time properly.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Nevertheless, it has to be said that we learned a lot and benefited hugely from the concept of ‘lean manufacturing,’ for example, in the use of the Visual Management technique. The Japanese are adept at using visuals to help organise things. Thus they often use stickers with icons to label the designated content of each tool kit compartment. If a tool is misplaced, the label on the empty slot will tell which tool is missing. This will increase work efficiency.
Minimise Wastage Across The Board In line with the principle of ‘lean manufacturing,’ we apply industrial engineering (IE) techniques and quality control to the workflow process to minimise wastage. IE can also be used to enhance management by data, and look for problematic links so that they can be corrected as soon as possible. By ‘pointless wastage,’ we mean all procedures or actions that do not add value to the production process (as listed below) and therefore must be eliminated: ◆◆ Taking time to transport materials that are not yet needed; ◆◆ Over-capacity at the warehouse; ◆◆ Workers
engaging in too much action or movement that is unnecessary for
production; ◆◆ Idle time arising from workers waiting for their turn to execute the next step; ◆◆ Overproduction; ◆◆ Rework stemming from a mistake incurred the first time a garment is made; ◆◆ Defects in a product; ◆◆ Checking an item too many times; and ◆◆ Wastage that results from correcting earlier mistake.
Add Safety To 5S Since we are keen to expand in the Japanese market, we must speak a common language with our Japanese clients about production processes. Apart from the concept of lean manufacturing, we commissioned a trainer from Japan in 2000 to introduce to our company a factory management process commonly used in Japan – the 5S. On top of 5S, we added a sixth ‘S’ – safety (at the workplace). The 6S is now commonly adopted
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
at all of our production bases. The outcome of the 6S practices was quite remarkable. Our production floors became much cleaner and orderly than the industry norm, a big help to reduce costs. How is that so? We know of one sub-contractor whose workplace used to be so dirty that he spent several tens of thousands dollars every year on cleansing agents to wash clothes that were newly produced but got soiled in the unclean workplace. After practicing 5S and paying attention to cleaning the workshop and tidying up the production line, the same factory was able to reduce 95% of what it spent on cleansers. With 6S, our factories are much cleaner and orderly and our productivity rose while our wastage and rework volume dropped. Our principle of ‘doing it right the first time’ is also served. In financial terms, the reduction of operational costs has helped boost our profit margins.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Industrial Engineering: Develop Production Capacity Standards We seek to optimise workflow and our capacity. IE serves another important function of formulating for the industry a set of common standard to measure productivity and to facilitate communication. It also provides measurable data as the basis for capacity management.
Upgrading The Production Model In the 1980s, Crystal introduced Industrial Engineering into the factory in Mauritius. At the time, IE had already come to extensive use in the garment industry in Europe and North America. The academia also recognised its significance. The Hong Kong Polytechnic (now The Hong Kong Polytechnic University) even offered programmes on IE, but it never caught on among Hong Kong garment manufacturers. For all their rich experiences, most managers in the industry were not highly educated. They regarded IE as no more than a passing fad. The introduction of IE in Crystal changed the garment manufacturing in a profound way. What used to be produced manually in family workshops was now taken over by a modern scientific production method, one that is backed by measurable data. The role of IE of this transformation is not to be underestimated.
Plan Workflow To Optimise Production Capacity As a manufacturer, Crystal’s earning power is determined by its productivity. We stand to make a profit only if we invest the minimum amount of resources to produce the maximum output while minimising mistakes. When integrated with the methods of lean manufacturing and 6S, IE has the positive effect of shortening each production cycle. We now set goals every year to shorten it even more, with the hope that we can increase our productivity and reducing our cost.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
Set Time Standards To Quantify Output In addition to designing an optimal workflow process, IE serves another important function of formulating for the industry a set of common standard to measure productivity and to facilitate communication. It also provides measurable data as the basis for capacity management. Through IE, one can apply the so-called ‘standard allowed minute’ (SAM) or ‘standard allowed hour’ (SAH) to measure the production capacity. SAM and SAH are applicable to any product. Productivity used to be measured by the number of pieces of garments produced, but now it is measured by the time of production. For example, it may take 20 minutes to finish sewing a pair of jeans but only 10 minutes to complete a T-shirt. By converting these data to SAM or SAH, the measuring of production capacity can be standardised.
Plan Workflow With Data And Fine-tune Designs To Add Value Upon receiving an order, our IE specialists will brainstorm a set of production procedures to take the least amount of time. In the planning process, they must take into account not just the ‘cut and make’ involved in that particular order but also think of the process from a business angle. For instance, if an order to produce 5 million items of clothing involves 1,000 different designs of 5,000 pieces each, then our IE specialists must determine right there and then as to which production line at which factory will be able to meet the order in the most efficient way. If a factory wants to introduce production automation, it can make use of the standard amount of time to calculate productivity savings versus cost before deciding whether to introduce an automated process or not. Product innovation is another value-added services that Crystal is always striving to achieve for our clients. At Crystal, the main line of production is the apparel designed by our clients. The design is done by the time we receive the orders. Nevertheless, we try our best as a
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
‘collaborator’ to implement the concepts and ideas behind the designs. Using their market sense and creativity, our in-house designers at the factories often lend artistic support to our clients, and in the process, might serve to inspire our clients in their design.
Data Analytics Leads To Consensus We continuously update ourselves on IE techniques and apply them to production management. IE is backed up by a wealth of data, which is helpful in all kinds of analyses, decision making processes and building consensus. In 1988, it was suggested that Electronic Ticketing System (ETS) be adopted to replace the earlier practice of manual tickets. The project would involve substantial capital investment in a new computer system. We had to decide whether the effort was worthwhile. Using IE’s productivity measures, we estimated that with ETS displacing manual recording, we would save 30 minutes daily for each worker. Convert this 30 minute into business opportunities and we could estimate the amount of time that each factory would gain in production and how greater increase in capacity would be. We were therefore able to figure out the return on investment and the payback period. Armed with such analytics, it was easy to make the unanimous decision to proceed with the project. At Crystal, using IE has led to the following results: ◆◆ Reduce conflict of interest among colleagues that stem from personal biases and
help people to reach consensus easily and enhance efficiency in execution; ◆◆ Sustain improvement in productivity and quality. The data can be used to sharpen
our competitive edge; ◆◆ Minimise production cost and reduce wastage ◆◆ Raise the utilisation rate of equipment and production capacity ◆◆ Shorten production lead time with flexibility and lower capital investment; and ◆◆ Provide useful data for financial analyses and strategic decisions
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
Order Allocation By Strengths: Global Production Planning Strategy To increase our competitiveness, we remain flexible in assigning production orders to factories in different locations that can best deliver the optimal results. Having learned from that experience, we have changed our policy by setting up factories in preferred countries with low cost within a radius of five to six hours of air-travel time from Hong Kong which should make it easier to handle matters relating to management, supplies and transportation. The cultural and social conditions of these countries are also more akin to Hong Kong.
Overheads Become A Key Factor With Changing Times The garment manufacturing industry used to operate like nomads by roaming all over the world to set up production bases in places that were free from quota restrictions. Cost and labour supply were factors to consider, too. At different times, Crystal has had factories in different parts of the world to include Macau, Malaysia, Sri Lanka, Jamaica, Dubai, Outer Mongolia, Morocco, Mainland China, Bangladesh, Cambodia - and even as far as Mauritius and Madagascar, Africa. At the peak of our global enterprise we operated factories in 11 different jurisdictions simultaneously. After the global quota restriction system was abolished, quotas were no longer a concern. Instead, the industry had to face intensifying competition. Meanwhile, our retreat from Madagascar taught us a big lesson. Although the root cause of our defeat was the political instability of the country, which we could not possibly foresee, we should have realised that the location was too far and too costly for providing timely support from Hong Kong office. The cultural and social differences also made it hard to manage. All this added to the cost and reduced operational efficiency as well as our competitive advantage.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Having learned from that experience, we have changed our policy by setting up factories in preferred countries with low cost within a radius of five to six hours of airtravel time from Hong Kong which should make it easier to handle matters relating to management, supplies and transportation. The cultural and social conditions of these countries are also more akin to Hong Kong. By the ‘International Product Life Cycle’ theory, production migrates to jurisdictions where the cost is low. Low cost, rather than the quota, is the main factor to consider when we set up a new production base in selected countries. The opening up of China offered foreign manufacturers favorable treatment and low operating cost attracting many Hong Kong manufacturers to invest. We, too, set up factories across the border. In recent years, however, the cost of living in the mainland has considerably risen and there is a shortage of labor in Guangdong Province. Quite a number of Hong Kong manufacturers have consequently relocated their production plants to Southeast Asian countries as a result. Crystal is no exception - we started producing in Vietnam, Bangladesh and Cambodia some years ago.
Different Production Base For Different Orders Despite increasing overheads, Mainland China still has its unique advantages, such as a relatively skillful workforce, a world-class supply chain and infrastructure - and not to mention, the highest level of productivity in the world. All of these allow Chinese factories to meet changing market demands speedily. In addition, Mainland’s cultural affinity with and geographical proximity to Hong Kong also mean that it is suited to producing certain types of merchandise, for example, those with high added value, those that call for fast react to the market demands and those with a high demand in craftsmanship but small in quantity. Today, we cater mainly to two types of orders. Merchandise with relatively simple style but comes in large quantities is allocated to our production bases in Southeast Asia where the operating costs are lower. Our factories in China, on the other hand, are given to take care of orders involving speedy fulfilment and more complicated add-on processes. We pick the production base according to its uniqueness. In this way, we can
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
allocate different orders to different production bases to raise our competitiveness. Surely, on top of operating costs, we also take into account such things as the client’s global strategy, import-export taxes, the under-use rate in different plants, direct material costs and favourable government policies. By applying IE techniques, we manage to optimise our production processes. We analyse the degree of complexity of each order and select the best production process. Moreover, our division of labour has become quite mature and we are able to process orders smoothly and respond quickly to market demands. IE has added strength to Crystal, making us all the more competitive than ever.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Mega Factories: Where Our Future Lies Learning from our experiences allows us to increase our scale of production. Retail brands are becoming more globalised while casual wear is becoming increasingly popular. Nowadays, the value and the quantity of one single order may be greater than those in the past by several hundred times. That is why garment manufacturers must work towards large-scale production to achieve economy of scale.
Plan Mega Factories As Our Future Development Trade barriers have been lifted all over the world and garment makers are no longer required to go after quotas. In deciding where to set up production facilities, manufacturers now consider the operating costs, the labor supply, taxation and other government policies and the political, cultural and social environment. The competition has become more intense than before. Retail brands are becoming more globalised while casual wear is becoming increasingly popular. Nowadays, the value and the quantity of one single order may be greater than those in the past by several hundred times. That is why garment manufacturers must work towards large-scale production to achieve economy of scale. We at the scene of course are sensitive to changes in market conditions. When we planned long-term strategies a few years back, we introduced the concept of the ‘mega factory.’ In the past, a factory was considered big if it employed more than 1,000 workers. Today, it is not uncommon to see factories employing anywhere from 10,000 to 20,000 workers. We already have a factory with more than 10,000 employees and plan to expand the workforce to 30,000 with intelligent production facilities.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
It is not easy to turn a few thousands of workers into a cohesive team to raise productivity. We must therefore have a management model that can progress with the changing times.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Sales And Production Collaboration: Treating Company Business As Your Own The functions of sales and production are brought together better to serve our clients. Our sales people must carry out fully their responsibility of communicating clearly and collaborating closely with the production workforce, starting from the receipt of an order to its fulfillment, delivery and settlement of the payment. Although each has a well-defined function to carry, both the sales team and the production team must also realise that they have to work closely together. People in Crystal are encouraged to treat the company’s business as their own and think like entrepreneurs - particularly when they are faced with managing clients. Customers are then satisfied and the company stands to make reasonable profit.
Foster Symbiotic Relationship Between Sales And Production Being able to manage the sales and production functions as an integrated whole is a characteristic of Crystal’s operations. Our sales people must carry out fully their responsibility of communicating clearly and collaborating closely with the production workforce, starting from the receipt of an order to its fulfillment, delivery and settlement of the payment. Although each has a well-defined function to carry, both the sales team and the production team must also realise that they have to work closely together. People in Crystal are encouraged to treat the company’s business as their own and think like entrepreneurs - particularly when they are faced with managing clients. Customers are then satisfied and the company stands to make reasonable profit. In a way, basically all Hong Kong garment manufacturers operated under the ‘production-and-sales integration’ model back in the 1970s and 1980s. That was because
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
the business owners themselves went around looking for business, and upon receiving the orders, personally monitored the production. They were involved closely in estimating the budget, planning the workflow, checking the quality of the product, shipping and logistics and collecting the payment. The fact that they owned the business means that they would give all they had to develop it.
Separation Of Sales and Production Creates Conflict Subsequently, the industry took off in a boom and garment manufacturing entities expanded. While the business owners still kept a tight rein on the entire company, they often hired specialists to share the burden of running a big business. Once an order was received, it was handed down to production lines. At this point, our sales individuals would regard the job as successfully completed as there was no requirement for them to be involved in the production process. In saying this, our sales and production teams regularly struggled with conflict as they were required to focus on their own needs that fell outside of the realm of corporate structure - it was only natural for tension to be present. For example, a most typical scenario was for the sales team to take on an excessive amount of orders without considering if the production team had the capacity to manage the volume. If delivery deadlines could not be met or the quality of the product was low; the company would incur loss as a result. When this occurred, the two teams would squabble over who is ‘right’ and who is ‘wrong’ - in the end - the company was the biggest loser.
Data Support Leads To Better Service In an effort to encourage both sales and production teams to take responsibility of the bottom line - quality and on time production; I decided to integrate both processes to develop a ‘team’ focused environment. I wanted the staff to treat the business as their own and to thoroughly understand customer needs, production timelines, quotations and profits. If staff were to grasp all these production phases then the overall quality and
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
punctuality would improve. With management by data in place, all orders are recorded and processed through our internal computer systems. Our sales persons were only required to input order details into the ‘Central Production Planning and Control’ (CPPC) system and as a result, a search was carried out on all of the Group’s factories to check such data. Based on the type of merchandise, volume required and other client specifications, the CPPC system will select what it deems to be the most appropriate factory for the job and then performs a virtual production run. We are then able to determine whether the capacity of the factory can satisfy client specifications and whether or not the workflow process will be smooth and on-time. Lastly, using the Activity-based Costing (ABC) accounting method, the CPPC system will analyse the costs to facilitate the pricing for the quotation. Based on the ABC method, each unit must be responsible for its own profit and loss. With such transparency in data dissemination, controlling cost became easier. In preparing quotations for an order, the sales team must ensure that the deal would not cause any other unit to suffer a loss. If, for one reason or another, an adjustment has to be made to the pricing, a sales person can do so after seeking approval from his or her manager. During the production process a sales person can check on the status of the order via CPPC or an internal network. If a problem is detected, the sales person can take timely action to liaise with the factory to resolve the issue. Our sales and production functions collaborate congenially and continuously in the true spirit of the Greater Good. In the interest of fulfilling our clients’ needs, the two functions have removed all boundaries. By commencing a project with the end in mind, both teams confer and agree on the mode of production and then the factory carries the job out. They also work together to resolve issues, making it a win-win situation for the clients, the company and the two functions themselves.
Two-way Internal Customer Relations Integrating the sales and production functions can foster entrepreneurial spirit
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
through making the workforce more cohesive - conflicts can be resolved and both parties ultimately win at the end of the day. A win-win situation for all, in turn, is based on the concept of ‘two-way internal customer relations.’ Under this concept, after receiving an order, the sales team passes it on to the industrial engineering department to draft the production workflow. The production team then follows through to fulfill the order. In this sense, the IE department as well as the production team views the sales team as their ‘internal client’ and must do their best to provide the relevant services. The sales team must treat the IE department and the production team as its internal clients and clearly relay the requirements and expectations of the external client. The three units do not report to one another, but they seek mutual benefits on equal footing. Backed by their own special skills, they put their best foot forward to serve one another the same way that they serve the external clients.
Real-time Data Facilitates Timely Response Business planning usually is done six months in advance. In the middle of every year, it is necessary to do a forecast on the business for the second half of the year. Following years of collaboration, the sales team has a solid grasp on the capacity that can be handled by each corresponding factory. In line with this understanding, the sales team approach orders that will fulfill and utilise factory abilities. As a result, our production teams seldom has any spare capacity. If a client changes the specifications of an order a factory may end up with idle time. In this case, the sales team are required to source another order to process so that the factory remains at capacity. Sometimes, the new order may lead to a trading loss on the books, but if the factory is kept from being idle, an overall profit may still be attained for that deal. Once again, decision making on this type of situation is facilitated by data. All one needs to do is to allow the system churn out the figures to get to see a clear picture.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
In fact, customers frequently ask for urgent orders to be processed with little notice. It is not uncommon to see orders being altered. Hence subsidiaries regularly hold meetings to discuss strategic change management. These meetings are headed by the President of subsidiaries and attended by the heads of various departments. The status of each order is reviewed and if an urgent order needs to be handled in a flexible manner, then the production plan may be modified strategically in the hope that the capacity and workload of all production bases can be fully utilised.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
- Manage Finance Prudently Prudent Management To Ensure Financial Soundness We hedge on our risk and use credit lines prudently. Managing credit appropriately can help a company build financial soundness. Crystal has earned considerable credibility from lenders and enjoys very favorable banking terms. Yet, we are reluctant to borrow too much and abide strictly by a lending ratio written into our financial control guidelines…
Prudent Management: From Mother To Son Yvonne took care of the company’s finances for years before handing the responsibility to Andrew. When Andrew became CEO, he hired a Chief Financial Officer (CFO) to take care of all finance-related matters. Throughout the years, prudence has stood behind the way in which we manage finance. Andrew continues with Yvonne’s conservative approach in financial management. He is opposed to over-extending credit. He believes that since profit is the sum total of revenue less expenditure, then as long as one can control the cost, one can increase the profit. As it is, many factors may affect a company’s revenue - some of which are beyond the company’s control. It is, however, within the power of a company to monitor costs closely and to reduce wastage. Add a stable cash flow to the formula and sound financial management is achievable. For every financial year, we conduct a forecast on expenditure; and it is not hard at all to figure the regular operational costs. Fortunately, there has been a surplus at the
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
end of each financial year. In addition to keeping costs under strict control, we regularly compare our own financial performance against our competitors. With the objective data that we obtain from external parties we can carefully review our own expenditure to see if we can enjoy a competitive edge. The ability to control costs differs from one subsidiary to another. Even if two subsidiaries serve the same clients, one can be much better than the other in this regard. We make appropriate adjustments from time to time so that as a whole, the company can be more cost effective.
Borrow Appropriately To Build Trust When the economy is good and lending rates low, it is easy for money to generate more money and borrowing usually poses no problem. In fact, under such circumstances, banks often encourage more borrowing by increasing a company’s overdraft line or the credit ceiling. Some businesses over-extend their credit at banks to meet rapid expansion. But once the market weakens, lenders will tighten credit, putting pressure on borrowers to repay. Companies that fail to turn around will wind up in the end. Our approach to banking is to set our lenders’ minds at rest. We do not deal with that many banks. Those we bank with, we regard as business allies. And our integrity has helped us build longstanding relationships with them. Managing credit appropriately can help a company build financial soundness. Crystal has earned considerable credibility from lenders and enjoys very favorable banking terms. Yet, we are reluctant to borrow too much and abide strictly by a lending ratio written into our financial control guidelines. Market conditions change constantly and some are beyond our control. As a business, we cannot help being exposed to possible losses. Luckily, based on the trust we have built over the years, we can count on our bankers to support us under adverse market conditions. Our bankers know that we keep our word, manage finance wisely and maintain a healthy lending ratio. Rather than backing out, they tend to lend us more support when necessarily.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
Sensitive To Risk: Stay Alert For The Unexpected Managing risks is a way to forestall a crisis. Prevention is better than cure. One must be prepared for the unexpected.
Watch The News With An Eye For Trouble Crises can happen to any organisation. The bigger the organisation is, the greater the threat these crises can pose. Prevention is better than cure. One must be prepared for the unexpected. That is why I catch up on news around the world every day. If I hear about a major incident, I will ask myself if Crystal may be confronted with a similar crisis and remind colleagues to stay on the alert. I once read that a foreign country had locked their dormitory at night and when a fire broke out - many workers died. I immediately reminded colleagues to avoid this incident from re-occuring at Crystal and made sure we had adequate firefighting equipment on hand. I also heard news of an illegal structure falling to crush a team of employees - I immediately then commissioned a structural engineer to visit all of our factories and properties overseas to ensure that they were safe. I am always on guard to forestall incidents. Mega factories are on our drawing board. Putting tens of thousands of workers all under one roof can be related to having a time bomb in our hands. Hence we must be doubly cautious when planning such structures to ensure the safety of our workers.
Working Together To Resolve Crisis Annual strategic planning conference is held at Crystal when potential risks and crises are discussed along with the state of the industry and market conditions. The entire management team brainstorms to discuss strategies and countermeasures.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
We have summarised the types of crises that we may face as follows:
- Prevailing Uncertainties in the Global Business Environment
- Daily Operational Hazards
- Unforeseeable Risks
- Business Liabilities
- Labor Relations Perils
- Political Uncertainties
- Trade Barrier Risks. We set aside as reserve a percentage of the income from each order. This is akin to buying insurance. On the off chance that a client is not able to settle the arrears for one reason or another, we can draw on the reserve to compensate for the loss in part or in full. Of course, such a reserve is not to be tapped casually; nor do we want to ever have to draw from it.
Loss Of Earning Power Deemed Biggest Crisis Risks always exist but one should not go overboard in anticipating them. Some time ago, plane crashes occurred one after another. Does this mean that we should give up air travel altogether? In Andrew’s opinion, the biggest crisis for Crystal would be loss of the ability to make profit. If, in the process of avoiding risk we end up suffering a loss - the company will then be placed into bigger peril. Therefore, we must balance risks with profitability. It will be sufficient to manage uncertainties up to a certain point by creating a safety net and developing crisis management readiness.
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
- Cultivate Quality Culture To Delight Customers Quality Comes First: Right First Time, Every Time We use clear-cut standards to manage quality across all product lines. In the context of implementing quality control, the message of ‘right first time, every time’ is tantamount to a ‘quality revolution’ in Hong Kong garment industry.
Manage Quality To Reduce The Need For Rework In the old days, quality management or quality assurance was a concept alien to the garment manufacturing industry. In Crystal’s early days, the company was once plagued by problems relating to product quality. Not only did this eat into our profit, it also caused client dissatisfaction and affected the reputation of the company. As a result, I was motivated to brainstorm ways to raise the quality of our products. In the 1990s, the Western concept of ‘total quality management’ (TQM) was becoming popular in Hong Kong. Under the leadership of a British quality professional William Preen, Crystal set up a Corporate Quality Assurance Department (CQA) in 1992 to implement a systematic approach to total quality management. Sure enough, in a matter of three to four years, the quality of our products improved by a large margin. In the context of implementing quality control, the message of ‘right first time, every time’ is tantamount to a ‘quality revolution’ in Hong Kong garment industry.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Set Standards For Products And Systems The work of quality assurance can be divided into two streams – one for products and the other for systems. When the concept of product quality assurance was first promulgated in the company, it was met with some resistance. Many did not understand the meaning of quality assurance and felt that the preparatory work would only add to their workload. Their mind-set was against change. There existed different standards of quality, they also argued. The production team would insist that they had done enough to meeting the quality standard, the CQA would, on the other hand, insist that there were things yet to be done. Conflicts resulted. Later, the production wing was brought around when, with the concept of ‘quality cost’ they could see that the quality of product can influence production cost. Quality and cost are in fact connected with each other. They now understand that if things are handled correctly during production, the staff required for quality assurance will reduce. To raise consciousness of quality among workers is a way of increasing productivity and reducing cost at the same time. As for quality assurance of the system, Crystal introduced ISO 9001 quality system in 1997 in Mauritius, winning for us the Malcolm Baldrige National Quality Award. Our quality assurance work there was credited with international recognition. With a system of quality control, ‘quality’ becomes a target for the whole factory to strive after, not only raising the process capability, but also boosting the morale and changing an outdated way of looking at the question. The quality of the products now rises just as the quality mindset among the employees rises. With our successful cases as references, Crystal gradually implements the quality control system in all its subsidiaries. Starting with the expressed commitment from each management, our quality assurance framework and requirements were clearly defined which at the end enhanced our production efficiency. The participation of the whole
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
workforce in the effort finally brought about a quality culture in Crystal.
Set Quality Targets To raise quality to a certain level, indicators must be set up. Implementation should then be planned accordingly. The outcomes of the implementation should be measurable and the success or failure examined. It is only in so doing that we can advance continuously. One important indicator to be used in quantifying quality is the ‘Customer First inspection Pass Rate (CFIR). Others include the percentage of defects, customer feedback and quality-related claims. On the whole, after years of effort, Crystal has reached a CFIR of 99.3%, reflecting that the stringent demand that employees in the company pose for themselves. The whole team has also established a culture of emphasising product quality and turned it to one of our competitive strengths.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Quality Assurance As Our Competitive Edge: Zero Defect To establish a system fostering a quality culture. Product quality and customer satisfaction work hand in hand with a reasonable return to shareholders and fair treatment to employees. Although there is always room for improvement in quality, there must always be a balance between cost and effectiveness. We can claim that our CFIR is on target at 99.3%, but there is still considerable room for improvement. In the long term, of course we should arrive at zero defect without the use of quality checking. We could then claim a 100% CFIR. A healthy quality control framework is meaningful only when people put it to work. To foster a quality culture, it is important that the concept of quality cost be understood. Additionally, the commitment of the top team and the participation of the entire workforce cannot be ignored. Quality culture defines for the world outside an ‘overall impression’ they have of Crystal, and this ‘overall impression’ should reflect our employees’ conviction in quality. In this day and age, ‘quality’ no longer refers to the products, but has by extension become a standard client requirement. This basic requirement is getting broader and broader in scope, and begins to subsume under elements such as corporate structure, product safety control systems, employee management and environmental and operational sustainability - not to mention all sorts of legal compliance. All this suggests that an enterprise should not be complacent, but should instead seek to improve on its work. Only then would it become
C hap ter Five : Ou r Op e ration Mod e ls
the excellent vendor that clients have come to expect. If we want to become the world’s No. 1 apparel maker, quality culture, a quality workforce, quality management, quality products are all indispensable. We cannot do without any of them.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
Chapter Six Our Sustainability Mission Respect clients as part of our sustainability mission.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter Six: Our SustainabilityMission
- Our Sustainability Mission ◆ ◆
Nurturing The Seed Of Sustainable Development 3P Triple Win: The People (Society), The Planet (Environment), And Profit (Economy)
◆
Business Is Not A Zero-sum Game
◆
Raise Standards In Pursuit Of Continuous Improvement
- Sustainability Strategy ◆
Concept Of Sustainable Development
◆
Invest In Hardware For Long-term Success
◆
Frankie Wong: Building A Water-saving Enterprise
◆
Total Innovation As A New Norm
◆
From Products Of Excellence To Products Of Integrity
◆
Workers Are Our Family Members
◆
Be An Outstanding Corporate Citizen
- Perpetual Operation ◆ ◆
◆
265
287
Greater Good Drives Sustainable Development Catherine Chiu: The 360-degree Sphere Of Influence Of A Great Industrialist A Spokesperson Of Sustainable Development
- Perpetual Collaboration ◆
The Power Of One Plus One Greater Than Two
◆
Adam Koo: Crystal, A Trailblazer Of Sustainable Apparel
◆
To Create Business Opportunities With Sustainable Development
- Vision: Reaching The World’s Top Spot
255
◆
Be A Sustainable Apparel Enterprise
◆
Ranked number one in Asia in “Fortune” magazine awards
◆
Turning A Setting Sun Into A Midday Sun
295
301
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
- Our Sustainability Mission Nurturing The Seed Of Sustainable Development Begin with the Lesser Good and end with the Greater Good. To my alarm, I discovered that global warming was turning into a major problem. I asked myself how I could start to support environmental protection or even sustainable development.
The Greater The Influence, The Greater The Responsibility Today, Crystal operates in more than 20 locations across six countries and employs more than 60,000 employees and riding an annual uptrend in production output. In 2014 alone, we manufactured more than 300M garments which can be translated into; one in every 17 people globally wearing an item of clothing produced by Crystal. As we increase in size, so will our share in the global apparel market and our influence upon the industry. What this also means is that our responsibility to society will also increase in size. When we first started our business, we remained strongly focused on creating a steady foundation. After this was established, we were able to focus our attention to expansion. We are currently in the phase of stabilising our current operations - and this has been a strong focus for me for the last decade or so. It is important for me to ensure that our operation models will keep up with the times and that our relationships with business partners remains strong. Mastering the art, or perhaps the science of sustaining a business or an enterprise is never easy. For me, the concept of sustainable development is delivered like a godsend. Whether an enterprise can continue operating is reliant on the ‘people’. The market
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
constantly changes and so do the demands of consumers. What an enterprise deems as ingredients for success today may become causes for its failure at a later date. The only means to sustainable development is to rely on ‘people’ to handle change flexibly and adapt when required.
A Movie Changed My Way Of Thinking In 2006, I watched a documentary on a long-distance flight named ‘An Inconvenient Truth’. At large, the movie was about the former US Vice President, Al Gore’s personal crusade to halt the alarming damage of global warming which was fast becoming the human race’s major moral challenge. As the narrator of the documentary, Gore made a passionate appeal to mankind to tackle promptly this ‘planetary crisis’ before it became out of hand. To my alarm, I discovered that global warming was turning into a major problem. I asked myself how I could start to support environmental protection or even sustainable development. Upon my return to Hong Kong I purchased several copies of the documentary to share with my senior executives. I also wanted them to realise the problems associated with climate change. I then decided to ask everyone as part of my management team to find the time to watch the film - afterwards, I arranged for a discussion session so that we could all share our thoughts. This was all in an effort to encourage our management team to start caring for the environment and to brainstorm ways Crystal could play a role in promoting sustainable development.
Mutual Benefits As The Foundation At the time, most of us did not know much about ‘sustainable development’, and only were familiar with supporting environmental protection. One of our China-based factories won the ‘Guangdong Cleaner Production Enterprise’ award. In order to be in the running to receive this award we were required to submit financial statements to support our claims of savings in energy, resources and other related costs. Only then it dawned on me that environmental protection was not just about saving resources but raising operational efficiency and lowering operating costs. In 2007, we defined our idea of sustainable development using the 3Ps – people,
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
planet and profit. As cornerstones, we established a framework specific to Crystal’s circumstances to cover the following five key areas: ◆◆ Environment; ◆◆ Innovation; ◆◆ Product Integrity; ◆◆ Employee Care; and ◆◆ Community Engagement.
The above five areas give us a framework that is more comprehensive than the scope of the 3Ps. For Crystal to succeed however, it must win the support of all the stakeholders, which include shareholders, the Group CEO, the Board of Directors, the management team, all our employees and clients. In our pursuit of sustainable development, we must also observe the spirit of the Greater Good. By now, both sustainable development and the Greater Good have become the ‘DNA’ in every Crystal employee, and have been integrated in our corporate culture. After establishing the framework, we went about drafting a five-year plan for sustainable development. Setting environmental friendly targets is clearly not enough and so we proceeded to devise a system to monitor activities regularly to make continuous improvement. Right around that time, quite a few of our clients had started units dedicated to sustainable development. I recall that Catherine Chiu Yuk-wah who headed our Corporate Quality Assurance (CQA) Department asking me at the time: “Do we need to establish a corresponding unit to interface with our clients in sustainable matters?” I always believe that ‘leaner is better’ as far as organisational structure is concerned. I did not want to increase headcounts unless I had to. So I replied: “Why don’t we add another letter to your department’s initials and make it CQS, i.e., ‘S’ for sustainability? From now on, sustainability matters will come under the responsibility of your department!”
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
3P Triple Win: The People (Society), The Planet (Environment), And Profit (Economy) Sustainable Operation Depends on a ‘virtuous cycle.’ Only when an enterprise makes a profit can it create a virtuous cycle of investing more in sustainable activities.
Sustainable Development To Yield Multi-faceted Benefits Sustainable development and quality assurance are precautionary measures. They have to meet certain predetermined conditions to continue to improve. The spirit of quality assurance involves doing something right the first time in such a way that the product will have no defect requiring attention. The practice of sustainable development is about minimising destruction, saving resources and reducing waste. Integrating quality assurance with sustainable development will produce synergy that works to the advantage of the 3P – people, planet and profit – leading to what I will call the ‘triple win’.
Profit Reinvested To Drive Virtuous Cycle In the beginning, everyone agreed with the concept - some were worried that the launching of sustainable development programmes would incur costs. Many in the business world looked upon environmental protection as costs. Likewise, some entrepreneurs thought that social responsibility would impose certain constraints on and weaken a company’s competitive edge. All the time, voices were heard in certain business segments that environmental protection was just distractions from the more serious work of running a business. These critics also expressed concerns that environmental protection measures would create a financial burden and weaken a company’s prowess with the result that it would trail behind competitors. In reality, caring for the environment can yield financial returns. Environmental protection measures can reduce pollution, water usage and energy consumption. Taking account of these cost savings - it is easy to figure out the time it takes to recoup the
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
investment that is put in the service of environmental protection. The savings thereafter are the returns of the long-term investment. It was in the spirit of the Greater Good that I set out to promote sustainable development. I started on the basis of caring for the environment and protecting the earth from destruction. Crystal CEO, Andrew Lo also agreed with the idea of sustainable development but had in mind the view that the profitability of an enterprise was key to sustainability. As it is, no matter how much an enterprise wishes to protect the environment and care for employees, it will not be able to make much of an impact without profit. Once an enterprise closes down, not much else can be done. That is why to care for the earth and employees in the long run. An enterprise must strike a balance between profitability and sustainable development. Only when an enterprise makes a profit can it create a virtuous cycle of investing more in sustainable activities to deliver jobs and career opportunities to our people. We regard this as a winwin situation for all. After years of practicing sustainable development, I can vouch that there exists a complementary relationship among profitability - caring for the environment and for society.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Business Is Not A Zero-sum Game I have a mission to make the world a better place. Business is not a zero-sum game whereby my gains add up to your losses. Rather, business is about making individual efforts to advance the cause of the entire industry, benefit the economy and improve livelihood of the masses. This, I believe, is the mission that an industrialist or an entrepreneur must pursue.
Strive For Prosperity Together In less than a decade, Crystal’s sustainable development program has achieved results beyond our own expectations. Our company has won nearly 400 grand and small awards for our contribution to sustainability; including a gold Hang Seng Pan Pearl River Delta Environmental Award, the Hong Kong Awards for Environmental Excellence (gold award, manufacturing category) and the Mirror Post’s Outstanding Corporate Social Responsibility Award. We thank our corporate culture of the Greater Good for winning such an impressive array of accolades. Considering that all reforms have to rely on people if they are to succeed, our people-oriented culture is extremely important too. I am pleased to observe that all Crystal employees from management teams seem happy with their work and lives outside of work. Our care for them begins with their workplace and then shifts to their family, neighbours, and finally the community as whole. We pay attention not only to their career but also their physical and mental wellbeing, their legal rights, the management of their finance and skills that they need for daily life. We simply wish that all employees act as one cohesive force, work and realise their potentials, strive in the spirit of the Greater Good and enjoy the fruits of their efforts. I am always of the view that while it is important to make a profit, an enterprise must not neglect the needs of the environment and its people. Business is not a zero-
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
sum game whereby my gains add up to your losses. Rather, business is about making individual efforts to advance the cause of the entire industry, benefit the economy and improve livelihood of the masses. This I believe, is the mission that an industrialist or an entrepreneur must pursue. In addition to respecting the needs of employees and caring for their well-being, a business has an even greater responsibility to promote harmony in the society. It should also help the employees to help themselves so that they can discharge their duties and realise their potentials. They will then help the enterprise to raise its productivity and competitiveness. For themselves, they will enjoy a happy and satisfying family life. In establishing production bases in developing countries, we not only generate returns for the shareholders but also create value for the local communities in the following ways: ◆◆ A management style that respects the value of people – with their wages, local
workers stand to raise their living standards and live in better harmony with their family and their neighbours. ◆◆ An operation that is aimed at sustainable development – through employing
local workers, we raise the gross domestic product of the country where we operate and champion local environmental protection. ◆◆ The
social value of product integrity – consumers who buy products we
manufacture have come to expect our manufacturing process to be socially conscionable. By promulgating product integrity, we add value to society. With our global production strategy we have been contributing to the socioeconomic advancement of developing countries or territories as well as meeting the demands of our clients and consumers. All parties stand to gain.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Raise Standards In Pursuit Of Continuous Improvement We quantify the outcome of our programme and share our experience with others in the industry. Traditionally, denim jeans manufacturing was regarded as a high-polluting and high-energy-consuming line of business in the garment industry. When we selected our denim jeans factory in China as a pioneering ‘Showcase Factory for Sustainable Development,’ we deliberately chose to go about it the hard way. If our denim jeans factory could demonstrate positive outcomes in its sustainability efforts, then it would be much easier for our other factories to succeed. At Crystal, we have always paid credence to data management. When we launched our sustainability programme in 2007, we also set standards as a target for two purposes. Firstly, we felt that using quantifiable results would help implementers manage their programmes better. Secondly, targets also set the direction for people to strive towards. That year, we placed the following goals in place: ◆◆ At the Group level, establish an environmental steering committee; ◆◆ Draft and agree on an environmental policy for the entire organisation; ◆◆ Establish five-year environmental protection targets for the Group; ◆◆ Make the denim factory in Zhongshan the ‘Showcase Factory for Sustainable
Development’; and ◆◆ Promote
internally an awareness of environmental protection and put the
awareness in action. Traditionally, denim jeans manufacturing was regarded as a high-polluting and high-energy-consuming line of business in the garment industry. When we selected our denim jeans factory in China as a pioneering ‘Showcase Factory for Sustainable Development,’ we deliberately chose to go about it the hard way. If our denim jeans
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
factory could demonstrate positive outcomes in its sustainability efforts, then it would be much easier for our other factories to succeed. The positive outcome would then be replicated from factory to factory, creating a ripple effect through the industry to advance the cause of environmental protection. We made it as our direction to build factories overseas according to sustainability standards. For instance, the denim jeans factory we opened in Cambodia in 2015 was modeled after our denim jeans factory in Zhongshan, China, our showcase production base. The high environmental protection standards that were put into place in the Cambodia new denim jeans factory cover energy-saving equipment, advanced sewage treatments and a wastewater recycling system. I put these procedures in place not only for Crystal’s interest, but also to set up a point of reference to formulate local standards of environment-friendly facilities and to introduce to the developing countries the idea of ‘environmental-friendly factories’. By so doing, we hope to raise the standard of development for the local community in such a way that their economy and humanistic landscape will stand to gain. Change ourselves, change our company and change the world. I am hoping to share Crystal’s experience in sustainable development with others and motivate the entire garment making industry to participate in the movement. Although as a single person, what I can do is limited, I do believe that even one person can help to power the cause forward. In 2008, I joined other like-minded leaders in the textile and apparel industry to form the Sustainable Fashion Business Consortium (SFBC) to network with the various parties in the supply chain in the fashion industry. We discussed issues ranging from climate change to air and water pollution, shared our actual experiences in safeguarding the environment and tried to find workable solutions. We also participated proactively in various environmental protection projects, including the 2009 Low Carbon Manufacturing Program conducted by the Hong Kong chapter of the World Wild Fund (WWF). The pilot scheme called for Crystal to allow the
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
WWF officials to visit its facilities so that they could gain an in-depth understanding of the work process of garment making and to check out possible environmental protection measures on site. In return, the Group had a chance to pick up more knowhow regarding carbon reduction. In 2010, Crystal participated in the compilation of the Higg Index of the Sustainable Apparel Coalition (SAC). The Higg Index is a suite of self-assessment tools to measure the environmental, social and labor impacts for the entire garment industry – from upstream suppliers of materials and fabrics to mid-stream manufacturers and downstream fashion brands and retailers. Using this index, industry participants get a holistic perspective to benchmark themselves against best practices of the industry and identify areas for further improvement. Crystal has more experience in this regard, and is therefore pleased to do its part to help in the formulation of standards for the industry. Crystal’s role is a subject matter expert in offering suggestions to the compilation of the Index. Crystal joined SAC officially as a member in 2012. Now we are committed to promulgating the use of the Higg Index as a tool for internal training and assessment. We share our experience on various occasions in the hope that more industrial participants can learn to understand the significance of the Index as a set of industry standards and learn to implement them in their daily operations.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
- Sustainability Strategy Concept Of Sustainable Development Beginning with the end in mind, we progress with a pragmatic approach. We launched our first five-year plan for sustainable development between 2008 and 2012 when we set simple and realistic targets to safeguard the environment, making them as quantifiable as possible.
Put Ideas Into Practice I have devoted my life to developing the Crystal Group and as a result; I have created a sizeable organisation from scratch. As part of our development, my wife, myself and our entire management team have devoted blood, sweat and tears and have faced many setback on the road to Crystal’s success. This has in turn left me with the question of whether or not to continue in front-line management. I often think: how do I carry out sustainable development? It’s not only about my personal achievements, but also about being responsible to my team and society. Surely, sustainable development of an organisation is not something that you can reach out and grab from thin air. Since seeing the documentary ‘An Inconvenient Truth’ and then coming to the realisation of understanding the 3Ps of sustainability, I am more convinced that I should fulfill my commitment to develop a sustainable business that will operate perpetually. I can not however rely singularly on my own independent efforts to make it a reality. Crystal has a large workforce. We manufacture what can be called the ‘second skin’ for human beings. I.e., clothing. For this reason, people are an indispensable factor in
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
cultivating the idea of sustainable development into our corporate policies and practice. People are the motivation behind such a concept; they must also be involved in turning the concept to reality. As long as the team work side by side towards sustainable development, Crystal’s goal of perpetual operation is certainly be attainable.
Management Philosophy Combines East And West As we set off in 2007 with the framework to pursue sustainable development, we developed our policy and related targets. In addition, we also formed a steering committee to guide and monitor progress. In this sense, we had adopted a western management approach to emphasise the use of a system and data management. The outcome was quantified and the data was transparent. Everything with the system was visible and traceable, facilitating continuous improvement. For the Greater Good is an oriental concept, and we put in place Western management practices to promote this philosophical concept. In this sense, the East and the West meet - laying a good foundation for the perpetual operation of Crystal.
Five-year Plan Set To Aid Implementation We launched our first five-year plan for sustainable development between 2008 and 2012 when we set simple and realistic targets to safeguard the environment, making them as quantifiable as possible such as lowering carbon dioxide emissions and planting one million trees and so on. We realised that setting targets alone is not enough. We also need to monitor the progress regularly before we can continue to march toward success. One indication concerned the practical matter of reducing the amount of airfreighting merchandise for the single reason that it raised costs and squeezed company earnings. Additionally, with every air kilometer and every kilogram of air freight comes loads of carbon emissions. Surely, if we allowed enough lead time in the manufacturing process, there would be no need to ship any merchandise by air. We could easily cut cost in this way, which was already a commitment we made earlier on - one that we would keep in mind all the time. But by adding this sustainability target, we quantified the commitment and provided our team with a reminder to do their share towards
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
protecting the earth from further damage. The results of our first five-year sustainability plan are highlighted below: ◆◆ Reduced carbon dioxide emission per garment by 21.3%; ◆◆ Lowered energy expenditure per garment by 6.6%; ◆◆ Saved trimmed material usage by 34.4%; and ◆◆ Planted 1,046,647 trees.
Our second sustainability plan began in 2013 and will last through to 2017. When we drafted this plan, we focused on the continuity of our sustainability efforts on making breakthroughs. We established the following targets for the second phase: ◆◆ Lessen the carbon footprint of each garment we manufacture by 6%; ◆◆ Lower the fresh water usage for each garment by 10%; ◆◆ Reduce the energy consumed for each garment by 5%; ◆◆ Use recycled water for up to 50% from product processes; ◆◆ Zero Landfill of our waste from production; ◆◆ Trim paper usage by 10%; ◆◆ Use recycled energy up to 10%; and ◆◆ Plant another million trees.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Invest In Hardware For Long-term Success We reduced costs and strengthened what we did well. Planting a tree sapling is just like offering hope to a community.
Save Resources To Enhance Competitiveness To reach sustainability targets, we have been investing effectively with notable results. In the process, we have come to the realisation that far from being a financial burden, investing in sustainable development can sharpen a company’s competitive edge. Even though the operating costs are higher in our mainland factories we have been able to attain savings of as much as 30% on energy consumption. This has had the effect of trimming down the overall increase in operating costs, adding to our competitive advantage. To date, the environmental protection projects that we have put in place include:
◆
Paperless office We began with the policy of simplifying procedures and introduced three ways to improve the authorisation process. First, cut down on unnecessary signing; second, if signing must be involved in the approval process, reduce on the number of signatories; and third, increase the use of electronic approval. When it comes to suppliers, we use ePayment and ePacking List to process transactions. We also use e-banking to transfer funds. In step with technological advancement, we have reduced considerably the physical signing of paper documents.
◆
Paperless assembly lines The use of paperwork to keep track of each worker’s output was replaced by radio-frequency identification, a system using electromagnetic fields to
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
recognise and transfer data. The new method is much more accurate, in addition to saving time and effort, improving productivity and lowering purchasing costs. As much as possible, our factory teams reduce the use of paper by reusing scrap paper. Apart from helping the environment, this also cuts down on the time and expense needed to process wastepaper. We are eliminating more than 10 million sheets of paper per year in doing this.
◆
Water resource management This covers minimising the use of fresh water and chemicals and using recycled water as much as possible. All of Crystal’s denim jeans factories use sustainable processes and technologies for wet processing to reduce the use of drinkable fresh water. At the same time, we minimise the release of dirty water and maximise water recycling. To date, up to 80% of our waste water is being recycled. 65% of the recycled water is used in production and 15% in cleaning and irrigation. Our annual savings on fresh water is estimated to be up to 1.8 billion litres. In China, our two denim jeans factories won acknowledgements for their watersaving efforts. In 2012, Jiangsu Province named our factory in Changzhou a ‘Jiangsu Provincial Level Water-saving Enterprise.’ In 2014, our Zhongshan factory was recognised among the ‘first batch of water-savings enterprises in Guangdong Province.’
◆
Recycled energy As much as possible, we use natural light to minimise the use of electrical lighting in the factories. Both at the production lines and in the dormitories, hot water is supplied by a solar heating system, which reduces the use of fossil fuels. Since the use of steam makes up 50 to 60% of energy consumption at our factories, we had switched to recycled biological material fuel to cut down on carbon emission.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
◆
Energy-saving installations We started with lighting fixtures, changing fluorescent tubes from the T8 to T5 model and most recently, LED (light-emitting diodes) units. Through brightness tests, we further identify excessive lighting fixtures and eliminate them to raise energy efficiency. In addition to retrofitting our existing units with a variable frequency drive (VFD), we also introduced new cold-water-storage and ice-storage air conditioning systems. This allows for cooling energy to be produced in the evening when power usage is low and stored for release during the day, thus preventing the peaking of electricity usage and stabilising power supply. This helps to improve the supply of power in the cities where our factories operate in addition to achieving energy savings for ourselves.
◆
Modern production technology We seek to raise production efficiency by using less to produce more. The additional advantage is, of course, environmental protection. To raise productivity, we practice lean management, adopt state-of-the-art technology and equipment – we even develop our own machinery in house. Our factories are equipped with many automated systems, including the rover system to improve productivity and individual worker efficiency by reducing physical labor. Laser technology also replaced old harmful production techniques. Now production lines have increased and products are more innovative, providing clients with more diversified choices and added value.
Plant Trees To Spread Hope Up till now, Crystal planted more than 1.5 million trees in the countries or territories where we have factory operations. Some people asked why we should bother to plant trees when the company could not generate any direct profit as a result. They wondered whether that was at odds
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
with my principle that an environmental protection activity must reduce costs while impacting the environment positively. But my thinking revolves around the fact our company does not make any direct returns from planting trees - the trees become part of the community and may grow for years to come. For that particular community, the ‘wealth’ that such trees deliver is difficult to calculate. For example, in Qingyuan and Qujiang of Guangdong Province, the trees we planted created a forest that revitalised the local ecology. In Sri Lanka, the 150,000 coconut trees we planted not only revived the local ecology but also offered the local folks a new livelihood; they take care of the trees and sell the coconuts from them for living. In my mind, planting a tree sapling is just like offering hope to a community.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Build A Water-saving Enterprise Interview with Frankie Wong, Executive Director, Crystal Group The Yida Apparel Limited in Zhongshan, China of our denim jeans division was the pilot point in Crystal’s environmental protection campaign. This Zhongshan factory began operations in 2005. Two years later in 2007, the Group established the sustainable development programme. Back in 2003, Mr Lo and I had traveled all over the Pearl Delta in search of a location for a factory. We had the idea to develop a specialised quality product to launch us on the path to the world’s top spot. After doing some research and analysis, we decided our denim jeans would be the product line. At the time, Mr Lo reminded me that a lot of fresh water would have to be used in the process of denim jeans making as it involved many washes. He said he preferred not to use fresh water. Furthermore, he also told me that our denim jeans factory has to comply with the law to minimise the release of pollutants.
Set Up Filter Plant On Foresight We could foresee back then that environment protection regulations would tighten in the future. In addition to meeting Mainland China’s wastewater treatment standards, we would have to be more visionary in setting up even better facilities ahead of the more stringent regulations to come. When we drew up the blueprint for the Zhongshan plant in 2004, we
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
included two water systems – one to supply fresh water and the other recycled water. When the construction was under planning, we stipulated the use of the most advanced sewage treatment plant so that soiled water from denim jeans washing could be used again after being treated. The recycled water was to be used in other production processes and for other purposes such as toilet flushing, gardening, and washing of pavements. In so doing, we would reduce wastewater discharge. It can be seen that Crystal was aware of environmental protection even back then.
Willing To Try And Build Our Culture We enrolled for different environmental protection awards mainly to unify the workforce to participate wholeheartedly in safeguarding the environment. The awards that we won bear testimony to the success of our efforts in this dimension. With these high-profiled recognitions, the workforce will be more willing to devote themselves to more environmental projects. I witnessed how our people got into the team spirit as they worked intensely to prepare for the contests. As a showcase factory in the Crystal Group, the Zhongshan factory not only set an example of success for other sister factories to follow but also shortened their process of learning about environmental protection. Above all, the Zhongshan factory won client recognition for effort. We are most happy to share our experience with other garment manufacturers and even other industries in an effort to gradually shift their thinking to the environment. Investing in environmental protection
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
is not a matter of spending and getting nothing in return; on the contrary, environmental protection can reduce operating costs and raise competitiveness. Mr Lo has been running Crystal for 46 years and spent more than 50 years in this industry. I am sure it is his wish to turn Crystal into an ‘evergreen enterprise’ through practicing sustainable development, our core values and our corporate culture. It is also his wish to share with the industry our way of minimising the negative impact on the environment, reducing resource wastage, raising enterprise standards and giving back to society while growing our business.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
Total Innovation As A New Norm We encourage total innovation as a way to achieve a win-win situation. There have been many instances of innovation in Crystal’s production workflow and management models. Employees are encouraged to propose fresh ideas on all sorts of things: bettering workflow, increasing work efficiency, raising the quality of life for the workers and so on. We welcome all kinds of suggestions.
Total Innovation As Core Values Crystal emphasises innovation on all fronts, which is a core value in an enterprise. Innovation on all fronts refers to all facets, steps, procedures, products, and services throughout the manufacturing process. We encourage innovation on all these fronts. Innovation is but part of a ceaseless process. Crystal encourages all involved to take part in innovation. We introduce advanced automation facilities and at the same time participate actively in research and development of new technology. Both are crucial in raising the Group’s productivity. On top of fostering an environment of innovation, each subsidiary is set up with a dedicated product development center that conducts R&D to come up with new products and new technology. Each subsidiary also features an IE division to help raise productivity. The bigger factories each have a technical development function dedicated to R&D of pre-washing garments technology, machinery and software such as computer programmes, RFID applications, big data analysis, upgrading Industrial 4.0 applications and so on. All this supports our focus to keep up with innovation and ensuring that new ideas and technology will be carefully managed and implemented.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
To date, the Group has in place: ◆◆ Mainland China’s first national-wide in-house denim jeans testing laboratory
accredited by the state; ◆◆ A denim jeans technology center accredited by the Guangdong Province; ◆◆ An intimate wear technology center accredited by the City of Zhongshan; ◆◆ T-shirt and sweater development centres; ◆◆ Four sustainable improvement centres.
Sustainable Improvement Centres promote the research on garment manufacturing equipment as well as the improvement on production, innovation on technologies, products, craftsmanship and workflow enhancement. It also seeks to raise productivity through tools it develops. For example, sewing pockets on denim jeans involves complicated procedures and requires high skill from workers. The innovation team developed tools specifically for sewing pockets, which raised productivity as they lowered demands on worker skills - in return; providing relief to pressures related to labor shortage.
Innovate Towards Win-Win There have been many instances of innovation in Crystal’s production workflow and management models. Employees are encouraged to propose fresh ideas on all sorts of things: bettering workflow, increasing work efficiency, raising the quality of life for the workers and so on. We welcome all kinds of suggestions. Many suggestions from the rank and file were related to production such as sewing and other work methods. All of them helped raise product quality as well as sustainable development. Employees who come up with feasible suggestions are rewarded. That is why most of our team are quite enthusiastic about voicing new ideas. Seeing their ideas being acted upon also has the effect of boosting their morale at work. Many of Crystal’s innovations have revolutionised the traditional way of garment making and raising work quality. As second-rate products come down in number, wastage is reduced and working hours shortened, with an overall positive impact on
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
productivity. With their efficiency raised, workers are able to earn more as the company stands to gain.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
From Products Of Excellence To Products Of Integrity We care the world by producing ‘products with a heart’, If the quality of our product is high, we protect our clients’ brand. Much of our industry has yet to be regulated by law - that is not to say that we can avoid certain grey areas. I strongly believe that enterprises should have the foresight to manufacture ‘products with a heart’ and transform themselves into ‘enterprises with a conscience’.
Quality Comes First Product quality is the most important factor in all manufacturing enterprises. Our commitment to product quality is rooted in our corporate value. We establish a quality assurance department whose duties are to set up and implement policies regarding product quality. Our objective is to offer international retail brands, our clients, and the independent consumer products of high quality - additionally, ones that meet social responsibilities and product safety requirements. They are priced reasonably and are delivered on time. The development process involved in making these products must have a positive impact on the environment. We want our consumers to experience the satisfaction in knowing they are doing their part for the environment, too. Regarding quality, we strive to do it right at first go and do it right every time. Garment manufacturing requires a series of complicated processes each that interlock with one another. This is why if one step is executed incorrectly, the entire process snowballs. Because of this, we strongly enforce the spirit of doings things right the first time. We certainly do not wish to see problems arise let alone multiply! By
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
introducing a quality management system and setting quality standards, we give the workforce a clearer understanding of the Group’s quality focus so that they will come to regard it as part of their daily task. Allow me to refer to ‘safety’ again as an example: Crystal has put in place design risk analysis to educate clients about potential safety issues associated with apparel design. In line with our understanding that prevention is better than cure; we explain and discuss various issues with clients and suggest improvement options. As a double safety catch, we also perform product testing to ensure that they pass the test in functionality as well as chemical and physical properties.
Produce With A Heart To Show Care In addition to emphasising the importance of a product’s quality and safety, we are more serious of social value relating to ‘products with a heart’. Traditionally, manufacturers only pay attention to products on the production line, often ignoring their effect on the workers involved in the manufacturing process, the consumers in the marketplace and the public in general. At Crystal, and when it comes to dealing with our customers, end consumers and workers, we uphold the belief of sustainability. In fact, we manufacture ‘products with a heart’ that are environmentally friendly, safe and worthy of our commitment to consumers, society and the earth. In addition to quality assurance, we also ensure that our employees operate within a safe and risk free environment. As part of our production workflow we have implemented the concept of low carbon emissions so that each step of the manufacturing process consumes less energy than the traditional method and is more ecologically friendly. Manufacturing with a conscience relies on the dedication and enthusiasm contributed by management and its workforce. Much of our industry has yet to be regulated by law - that is not to say that we can avoid certain grey areas. I strongly
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
believe that enterprises should have the foresight to manufacture ‘products with a heart’ and transform themselves into ‘enterprises with a conscience’.
Brand Names Safeguarded To Keep Clients Worry Free I believe that every person should have a sense of responsibility towards the environment, the world and the human race. We should never sacrifice the Greater Good for our selfish interests. If everybody ignores the need for the Greater Good, we run the risk of facing payback from the environment one day. Ultimately, it is those who behave selfishly today who will suffer in the end. In addition to our dedicated and crucially important workforce is the trust of our customers. In today’s day and age, international brand names are beholden to their customers, i.e., the consumers. If the products we manufacturer present a defect then consumers lose confidence in these brands as a result. We take pride in our clients brands and regard them as if they were our own. We pay close attention to their business direction to ensure that changing factors are implemented in our production processes. To the clients, we are a supplier they can count on and as a result, we receive regular and stable orders. This kind of business thinking enhances our strategic relationship with our clients and is mutually beneficial. Currently, and in the near future, we stand to raise our competitive approach which will in turn facilitate sustainable development of the Group.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
Workers Are Our Family Members As an organisation that values people, we reach out to our employees to care for their well-being. This approach to personal development and care for others around us not only supports our corporate culture but also the confidence in our employees. Such growth can benefit their daily lives at home and work. Crystal is a people-oriented enterprise that cares for its employees. Our policy is based on the theory of ‘Hierarchy of Needs’ of the renowned psychologist Abraham Harold Maslow. Apart from satisfying employees’ basic needs, we also make them aware of room for further development and contributions they can make to society so that they can grow within the organisation. Most importantly, we also support our employees in their personal and professional areas of growth. We help them to believe that to change the world, they must first start with themselves. In doing this, we increase their sense of belonging and foster their respect for one another. This approach to personal development and care for others around us not only supports our corporate culture but also the confidence in our employees. Such growth can benefit their daily lives at home and work.
Keep Workers Safe Above all of our principles, we place worker safety at the top tier. We have established a comprehensive safety standard for our workers and have gone above and beyond normal standards. When we made up our mind to develop Crystal into the world’s top apparel maker we foresaw that the company would employ an enormous workforce. With tens of thousands of employees each working and living under the same roof, we have a key
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
responsibility for fire safety, industrial safety, occupational safety and public health. We have ‘zero tolerance’ for errors in industrial safety. We treat our people as if they are family members. Under no circumstance must we subject staff to unnecessary personal danger. Risk cannot be completely eliminated, but we can avoid unnecessary harm if we enforce proper safety measures.
Female Workers Receive Special Training Female workers make up 70% of Crystal’s workforce and in saying this, we frequently reference the popular Mao Zedong quote meaning to ‘hold up half the sky.’ To support our female workers we have launched a number of tailor-made programmes to pay special attention to these women and to offer them a chance for self-improvement. Seminars for mothers-to-be, ‘Health Enables Returns’ programme (HER) and the Personal Advancement and Career Enhancement programme launched by our client Gap Inc, for instance, cover topics ranging from personal health to family planning, pressure at the workplace, emotion and mood management, communication skills, legal rights and finance management. For our female workers, we encourage that health education can improve physical well-being so that they can adequately meet the demands of work and family life. Those who are physically fit can perform better at work, thus having a better chance of promotion and eventually raising living standards. By learning communication skills, they can also improve their relationships with family members and neighbors. We have extended harmony and health for our female workers and in addition, to their families and communities. To date, we have seen more than 15,000 Crystal female workers benefit from these programmes.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
Be An Outstanding Corporate Citizen Give back to society what you take from it. Some of the children who received help from the Yuk Ching Charity Trust in the past have now graduated and applied for Crystal’s trainee programme. It is comforting for us to see that our initiatives have supported such positive results.
Give Back To Society What You Take From It Crystal is more than willing to repay society and set a good corporate citizenship example. Our Corporate Human Resources Department has come up with a slogan: ‘we share, we care and we grow together.’ This precisely reflects our vision of building a community undivided by boundaries. We encourage colleagues at all levels to engage in community services in the spirit of the Greater Good to serve the underprivileged or the needy. We were honored to have won the first ‘Hong Kong Corporate Citizenship Award’ organised by the Hong Kong Productivity Council in November, 2010. During Crystal’s early days, Yvonne and I often visited different regions to conduct on-site feasibility studies for new factories. When my wife saw the elderly begging on the pavement and unaccompanied children roaming the streets, she was deeply touched. As a result, she began liaising with friends to form volunteer organisations in an effort to engage in charity work. She arranged for schools, big and small enterprises and government departments to visit Crystal’s factories with the hope of injecting positive energy into society. She succeeded in promoting the ‘7 Habits’ method in Luodingbang Middle School of Shunde, and arranged tours to Crystal factories in an effort to expand teacher and student the cultural visions. What one takes from society, one should give back. Since I owe my achievements to society, it is only right that I repay society. We keep instilling this idea in the minds of our workforce and encourage them to give back to society. Every Crystal factory has a volunteer group that helps the local community build facilities or launch programmes to care for the needy. Working as volunteers has a double impact on our people. On the one hand, they
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
know that they have the ability to help others; on the other, they realise that in this society, there are others worse off than they and that we cannot take happiness for granted. This latter realisation can boost their fighting spirit, giving them a bigger heart to care for others and improving their quality of life.
Take Action To Give Back Some may wonder whether it is helpful to business for an entrepreneur to take so much time and effort to engage in community work. Why not just donate money? However, Yvonne and I understand that it is not all that difficult to give money, but how can one be sure that the donation goes to those who are in need of help? How do we help others to get back on their own feet? In this light, we believe that to truly aid in a community’s sustainable development and carry out our social responsibility, we must get involved personally and help others help themselves.
Set Up Charity Trust To Pull Together Resources The Lo’s family had a charity which I chaired called Windshield Charitable Foundation. It’s committed to caring for the underprivileged. I encouraged Yvonne to set up a trust fund in her own name to carry out the idea of getting engaged personally. In October 2004, the Yuk-ching Charity Trust (bearing her Chinese first name) was set up with the objective of improving the lot of the needy. Every year, the Crystal Group collaborates with the Trust to service people living in the poor regions of Mainland China. In 2009, the trust fund sponsored Guangdong’s Shaoguan Municipal Government in establishing a volunteer association in the district of Qujiang. With the slogan of ‘help others, serve society,’ the association promoted the concept of social responsibility. To date, it boasts more than 14,000 volunteers whose combined efforts in serving the community is estimated to hit more than 90,000 manhours by the end of 2015. Funded by the trust, the ‘Forever Hopeful Vision Programme’ co-operates with eye hospitals in various Mainland Chinese regions to offer free cataract surgery to needy
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
older people. The rationale behind this programme is that once their sight is restored, the elderly will be able to care for themselves and in addition, the grandchildren who are often left to their charge by migrant parents working miles away from their hometown. The trust also funds medical facilities in remote parts of China to upgrade equipment and provide continuing training to the medical specialists. We further believe that education is an important investment towards bettering society. In 1997, we participated in the ‘Hopeful School Project’ organised by the Agency for Volunteer Service of Hong Kong. Separately, the Yuk-ching Charity Trust also built and renovated schools in China’s remote and poor cities to provide free education to the children. We hope to change the destiny of the children through education. It is our wish that by receiving higher education, underprivileged children can find good jobs, increase their household income and in time, pull themselves out of poverty. In fact, some of the children who received help from the Yuk Ching Charity Trust in the past have now graduated and applied for Crystal’s trainee programme. It is comforting for us to see that our initiatives have supported such positive results. Crystal’s volunteer teams regularly visit patients recovering from cataract operations. They also visit schools in remote areas funded by the trust to play with the children and in addition, donate furniture and other supplies. During festivals, our volunteers will try their hands on cooking festive dishes for all to share. In times of natural disasters, Crystal is ready to lend a helping hand. On top of donating money, food, clothing and other supplies, our volunteers also offer emergency financial aid and organise donation drives to provide urgent relief.
Work Hand In Hand To Spark Hope Although this type of ‘social investment’ does not result in any financial benefit for an enterprise, it brings considerable hope to the community and the recipients of donations or services. In that it exudes positive energy, it is worth more than gold.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Crystal has set off in pursuit of sustainable development but the journey is far from easy. Much determination, a sense of responsibility and a far-seeing vision are required to keep one going. During the course of the ‘journey’ I have come to appreciate the importance of ‘hope’ and ‘opportunity’ for individuals. As long as one has the hope to advance and the opportunity to enrich oneself, then one can eventually be self-reliant. I am fortunate to have Yvonne by my side and to keep me company during hard times. From the raising of a family to the building of a business, we have been fighting shoulder to shoulder all the way. I am enormously grateful to my wife for her loving care and support in the past 50 years.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
- Perpetual Operation Greater Good Drives Sustainable Development Our corporate culture is the foundation of perpetual operation. Although Crystal is a family business, it aspires to perpetual operation with the ideal of the Greater Good. In accordance to this belief, our vision gradually expands, giving the management the courage to ride through short-term setbacks and plan longterm investment.
Sustainability Concept Stems from Corporate Culture For an enterprise to pursue perpetual operation, it has to have an in-depth understanding of the ideal of the Greater Good and the idea of sustainable development. It has to identify with both and dedicate itself to turning them into its corporate culture. Although Crystal is a family business, it aspires to perpetual operation with the ideal of the Greater Good. In accordance to this belief, our vision gradually expands, giving the management the courage to ride through short-term setbacks and plan longterm investment. The management of an enterprise, especially people in the highest leadership level such as the CEO, has to take care not only of the shareholders but also the employees, the clients and the interests of society. They should put the Greater Good ahead of other considerations, putting aside the selfish Lesser Good, and work towards the collective goal of the team. They should do their part to encourage each and every employee to excel in their position. If they can do all these, they will manifest the entrepreneurial spirit in developing long-lasting interest.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
In my many years in the business world, I have witnessed the decline of several major enterprises. When I analyse why the loss occurred, I can see that they have a strong focus on the present and fail to cast their vision into the future. I believe that short sight focus present in any corporate leaders can corrupt teams and send an enterprise into decline. The price of paying attention only to the short-term gain is the sacrifice of the future competitive power. In the end, such an enterprise will be swept aside by the waves of a business storm.
Build Competitiveness On Soft And Hard Skills Members of our workforce never stake out any territorial claims, but instead pull together with one mind towards a common goal in the spirit of the Greater Good and in pursuit of sustainable development. It is a highly efficient workforce that instills confidence in clients. In a workforce that prioritises the Greater Good, our people set aside self-interests. When a problem occurs, they come together to bear the responsibility. We also put talents in key positions and delegate adequate authority relevant to each position. People are free to do what they like in their respective sphere. Moreover, our people treat each other as if they were members of the family, taking time to understand their viewpoints and needs. The entire company functions as if it was a small community. Transparency is enhanced; colleagues respect one another - and the workforce functions as a cohesive body. That Crystal has been able to build strategic partnerships with the world’s top fashion retail brands is attributable to the fact that our company can lend them comprehensive support – from product quality to reasonable pricing, goodwill, and interface platforms and systems for research and development. These brands are reassured by Crystal’s support while Crystal can have a steady supply of orders now and in years to come. The Crystal team is equipped with both soft and hard skills. On the side of soft skills, our team is staffed with talented individuals, who, under the sway of the corporate culture go about their work with sustainable development on their mind and interact with the customers with respect. On the side of hard skills, they are supported by
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
information system, innovative technology and quality system. These combine to give Crystal its competitive advantage that makes it possible to march towards perpetual operation. It would be difficult for others to acquire the same set of soft and hard skills or to duplicate our success, let alone taking our place in the garment industry.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
The 360-degree Sphere Of Influence Of A Great Industrialist Catherine Chiu, General Manager, Corporate Quality and Sustainability Department, describes Mr Lo’s sustainability philosophy. I have been working at Crystal for two decades and personally saw how Mr and Mrs Lo show their concern and care for society and the environment and how they decided to get personally involved in areas they strongly believe in. Mr Lo often says that if we engage in environmental protection and carry out social responsibility only within the organisation, then our colleagues will be the only people to benefit from our effort. On the other hand, if all of us at Crystal support these causes to influence those around us – including family members, friends, the community, clients, suppliers, the government and academic arena – then we shall create a 360-degree sphere of influence. What we do will get passed on from one enterprise to the next, and in turn, the entire industry, the society, the country and the world. In this sense, our contribution to the earth will be much greater. I used to think only industrialists who could wield such influence. They set up factories in different countries and employ many local workers and managers. Also, they establish wide logistic networks in each location they do business. In Crystal’s case, the company directly or indirectly drives the local economy wherever it operates. It raises the locals’ living standards, spreads awareness of the environment and enhances the ability of local managers through its infrastructure, its training, its pursuit of sustainable development and its unique corporate culture.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
It has contributed substantially to the ecology, the economy and people’s livelihood locally, thus benefiting multiple parties. As an employee, I am touched and encouraged when I hear him openly discuss his sustainability philosophy. Mr Lo also keeps reminding us that a business should not chase profit only; it must also keep in mind the future, the sustainability of people and the environment. Otherwise, it will be impossible for a manufacturer to expand endlessly.
Take Lessons From The Sage I have been working with Mr Lo since 2007 to promote sustainable development at Crystal. In addition to minimising material wastage and reducing pollutants, we have created a viable corporate culture. Although the process has not been entirely smooth, what I could learn from Mr Lo is enough to last me for a lifetime. The following remarks he makes from time to time have become mottos that I live by: ◆◆ Everybody should have a dream and should strive to make the
dream come true. ◆◆ Don’t be afraid of failure as it is just a stepping stone to success. ◆◆ If you want to change the world, you must start with yourself.
I admire Mr Lo a lot. Not only is he the head of the Crystal, he is also a ‘spiritual leader.’ Although he is 75 years old, he still toils tirelessly to uphold and promote sustainable development. Recently, he even changed his usual low-keyed ways to publicly speak to the world the importance of sustainability. He is an extremely kind, passionate and empathetic leader. He promotes
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
the corporate culture creatively. To encourage the younger generation in different ways, he is most willing to share with them his experience – from the hardships of growing up to the struggles of being a young entrepreneur. He is keen to inculcate in them a proactive and positive attitude towards life and to instill in them a sense of hope for their future. He is also an open-minded and playful grandfatherly type. I could observe from his volunteer work and on other occasions his interactions with his family members. How much he must care for them. He places great importance on family education and communication among family members. His personality has had a powerful impact on me, leading me to think in a macro way and inspiring me to deal with others sincerely, benevolently and openly. I firmly believe that Mr Lo’s style can influence the entire department for which I am responsible and strengthen our sense of unity. Mr Lo’s spirit will serve to promote a congenial collaborative relationship. I enjoy working at Crystal and am grateful for my loving family. In addition to mentoring me and coaching me at work, Mr Lo has also inspired me to change my attitude towards my family and my way of dealing with them. My parents are grateful to see this change in me over the years. As a department head and a mother, I am willing to carry the baton to promote the concept of sustainability and make the world a better place.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
A Spokesperson Of Sustainable Development I am looking for echoes from the world outside to the changes that are taking place inside me. Crystal is fortunate enough to be one of the pioneers to embark on the journey of sustainable development and as a result, has received many commendations. Our strategy is to do our best to share what we know with the hope of setting a standard for the industry.
Work Hard To Promote Ideas To Influence The World In the past, I thought it would be enough if one was to conduct oneself properly and do the right things. I gladly shared my ideas about business, life and personal relationship with my colleagues within the company, but I seldom made my views known to the public. Crystal is fortunate enough to be one of the pioneers to embark on the journey of sustainable development and as a result, has received many commendations. Our strategy is to do our best to share what we know with the hope of setting a standard for the industry. In 2010, the year of Crystal’s 40th anniversary, I published the Group’s first sustainability report as a private company. Thereafter, we published a sustainability report every year in the format of the Global Reporting Initiative framework. For us, this sustainability report has become a powerful communication platform. Not only does it allow our colleagues, clients, suppliers and the general public to take part in our sustainability efforts and other related plans, the report also highlights the transparency that we always uphold, which allows others to give us their feedback on our work. Our people are the chief internal stakeholders of the Group. To change the enterprise, one has first of all to change the people working in it. For this reason, we set up the ‘Global Sustainability Development Forum’ where we connect relevant
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
departments from factories in various regions to share and learn. We organise tours of the factories to provide them with a chance of drawing lessons from one another. In addition, our ‘Sustainable Development 101’ organises lectures for colleagues working in production, sales, design and quality assurance to learn about sustainable development and practice it in their work. There is a larger variety of external stakeholders, but the most important of them are the clients. To serve them, I arrange tours of our factories for them and their employees. In response to the requests of the clients, I open my doors to their suppliers and even our competitors so that we can share with them our practical experience in sustainable development. Our friends in the industry are also targets of our sharing efforts. I collaborate with the major chambers of commerce and local governments, especially those working in the garment field, to arrange tours with the same goal of getting people to learn from one another. My team and I hope that the younger generation will get to know the garment industry and sustainable development. I therefore work closely with schools and arrange university and middle school students to tour our factories, and promote collaboration with them on academic research and setting internship programmes. We have thus a busy calendar of sharing and touring activities. The number of visitors to our facilities now exceeds ten thousand.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
- Perpetual Collaboration The Power Of One Plus One Greater Than Two Synergy has the effect of gathering and multiplying strengths. We must take into consideration those stakeholders impacted by our operations. At the same time, we must not ignore the influence that stakeholders have on us.
Respect Stakeholders In Building Synergy For an enterprise, sustainable development is about internalising factors that are normally regarded as ‘external’. We must take into consideration those stakeholders impacted by our operations. At the same time, we must not ignore the influence that stakeholders have on us. Hence we must handle well the collective strengths of stakeholders to generate synergy towards attainable mutual benefits.
Industry Model Professionally Groomed Since 2007 when Yida Apparel Limited (Yida) piloted sustainability initiatives, the Zhongshan denim jeans factory has reduced the consumption of electricity by 1.5 million KWh. In fact, it was able to recoup costs on quite a number of sustainability items in half a year. In addition, Yida contacted organisations such as the Hong Kong Productivity Council (HKPC) and the World Wildlife Fund (WWF) to participate in their sustainability programmes. In HKPC’s Cleaner Production programme targeting the reduction of resource wastage and carbon emission, our factory volunteered to be audited by specialists and obtained a clean bill of health. In WWF’s Low Carbon Manufacturing Programme piloted in the Pearl River Delta, the factory learned about the best practices and ways of measuring and managing the carbon footprint. Yida won the programme’s
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
gold award and was the first denim jeans factory to receive such a high-level public recognition, it set a shining example of success for the Group.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
Crystal, A Trailblazer Of Sustainable Apparel An appraisal of Crystal’s sustainability efforts by Mr Adam Koo, ex-CEO of the World Wildlife Fund’s Hong Kong Chapter. The World Wildlife Fund is a global organisation dedicated to environmental protection. Its mission is to build a future of harmonious co-existence between man and Nature. Since Hong Kong is Asia’s commercial hub, local businesses are important allies for WWF’s Hong Kong chapter in fulfilling the city’s vision of becoming Asia’s capital of sustainable development. Among these business allies, the Crystal Group is a long-time supporter of WWF. Crystal was fully aware that most people saw little correlation between garment manufacturing and the environment. Back in 2009, Crystal was among the first batch of companies to participate in WWF’s Low-carbon Office Operation and the Low Carbon Manufacturing Programme. The Group won certification for five consecutive years and kept raising its carbon reduction efficiency. In fact, Crystal had approached us at the start of these two projects to discuss how to champion sustainable development in the garment manufacturing industry. To that end, Crystal’s Chairman Mr Kenneth Lo also collaborated with others in the industry to found the Sustainable Fashion Business Consortium. Crystal has been a corporate member of WWF since 2010. It proactively establishes and implements environmental protection initiatives within the Group. Crystal’s employees regularly participate in activities to raise public awareness of the ecology at our Yuan Chau Tsai Park Nature
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Protection Study Center, our Mai Po Educational Center and the Ho Hai Wan Marine Life Center. For a number of years, Crystal has been participating in our annual Earth Hour programme by switching off lights to reduce carbon emission. Since 2011, Crystal has also been the sponsor of T-shirts commemorating the activity.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
To Create Business Opportunities With Sustainable Development Market Potentials for Eco-products. Crystal has always taken upon itself to pursue sustainable development. With its open mind, it attracts to its side many like-minded individuals and corporations, and establishes partnership with many of its clients.
The World’s Trend: Boundless Business Opportunities The positive outcome of the transformation of Yida denim jeans factory into an environment-friendly production plant has successfully altered the entrenched thinking. Now people believe that denim jeans production can serve to protect the environment. Eco-Products have become the trend of the world market. Crystal is happy to produce such garments for its clients which are all international brands. To this end, it purchased environment-friendly equipment to manufacture new eco-products that it develops with the clients. At present, the environment-friendly technologies that Crystal possesses include ozone bleaching, laser technology, the use of environmentfriendly chemicals and sustainable washing formula and others. Among the new ecoproducts are the 1969 series that it developed with GAP, with some items that reduces 80% of energy, water and carbon footprint in their production. In the Water Reuse/ Recycle Programme that it developed with Levi’s, the water used in the production is 100% recycled water. There are similarly environment-friendly production methods, such as using organic and recycled materials in the production of apparel. Crystal has also developed ’Eco-Wash App’ for the use of its clients in calculating the total energy use and the world’s resources that can be conserved in the production process of denim products. Crystal has always taken upon itself to pursue sustainable development. With its
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
open mind, it attracts to its side many like-minded individuals and corporations, and establishes partnerships with many of its clients.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
- Vision: Reaching The World’s Top Spot Be A Sustainable Apparel Enterprise By investing in people, we can build a team. With its people-oriented philosophy, Crystal has nurtured a team that is willing to take on the job of supporting the culture of sustainable development. The team works with one mind, and gives the company its major competitive edge.
Invest In People To Build A Cohesive Team It is the trend these days to work towards the strategic direction of sustainable development. Yet, only people can turn strategies and policies to reality. If the person in charge of a company does not support the idea, it is natural that the sustainable development will lack momentum. Enterprises that focus only on short-term gains often overlook the importance of investing in people. In face of uncertain circumstances, these companies would waver. Plans for perpetual operation would be thrown out of the window. With its people-oriented philosophy, Crystal has nurtured a team that is willing to take on the job of supporting the culture of sustainable development. The team works with one mind, and gives the company its major competitive edge. In protecting the environment, not only do we have the right infrastructure and system in support, we also stress the importance of the green culture. We offer our people regular training on the subject, communicate externally with the employees of our suppliers and initiate quite a number of campaigns to ensure that going green is part of our corporate culture.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Ranked number one in Asia in “Fortune” magazine awards Change the company, change the world In 2016, Fortune Magazine announced the “Change the World” top 50 companies, where Crystal Group ranked 17th globally. Crystal was ranked first among all Asian companies, and was the only Hong Kong company on the list. Crystal’s accolade was worth celebrating, and it also meant that the group’s spirit of ‘initiating change from within to attain greater changes’ has gained international recognition. Crystal’s dedication to protect the environment and care for its employees was mentioned by Fortune Magazine. They include: in 2015, Crystal’s garment production reduced fresh water consumption by 30%; carbon dioxide emissions was decreased by 6%; psychological counseling was provided to employees; through the “Personal Advancement & Career Enhancement” programme, female grass-roots staff was trained on their management and computer skills. These are Crystal’s relentlessly efforts in promoting sustainable development, as well as the embodiment of the “people-oriented” culture and the “Greater Good” spirit.
Never stop improving Fortune Magazine is a worldwide reputable magazine within business world. The consorted effort of all our employees within the Group resulted in Crystal’s awardwinning moment. All members of the entire Group are proud of this achievement. We would like to thank our employees, family members of our employees, customers, suppliers and our the management team for their support and encouragement. Despite the success, we do not become complacent. Instead we are even more reflective in our behaviors and strive for greater effort to improve. Crystal will continue to focus on sustainable development, with all hands on deck. We will continuously enhance ourselves in the journey to become the world No 1 in our industry.
C hap ter Six : Ou r Su stainabilit y Mission
Turning A Setting Sun Into A Midday Sun Step by step, we move closer to realising our vision of becoming the world’s No 1 apparel maker. Based on our achievements in sustainability, I hope we shall make Crystal the world’s No 1 apparel maker, attracting more young people to join the industry, and realising our dream of transforming what people call a ‘sunset industry’ into one with a future as bright as the noontime sun.
Appeal To Talents With Sustainable Development A less-than-easy life during my formative years had taught me this – to improve one’s livelihood, one must start by changing oneself. When one’s circumstances improve, one should help others in need. With such thoughts in my mind, I worked hard in the hope of pulling myself out of poverty. This thinking had instilled in me a certain sentimental attachment to the garment manufacturing industry. Garment making is labor intensive, and so it can provide more job opportunities for the people of the grassroots to help them achieve self-reliance. If I can then build mega factories to employ more people and give them a satisfying job and a fulfilling life, I can do more to change the world. Supported by our engagement in sustainable development, Crystal is moving closer step by step to its ultimate goal of becoming the world’s top apparel maker. By adhering to our corporate value of caring for the Greater Good, we manufacture products with a heart, which are in line with world trends and market direction and sustainability for international fashion brand names. In this way, we help these retail brands maintain their competitive advantage and win over their confidence. Working alongside our clients, we shall continue to provide consumers with clothing items that are safe and worth their money.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Based on our achievements in sustainability, I hope we shall make Crystal the world’s No 1 apparel maker, attracting more young people to join the industry, and realising our dream of transforming what people call a ‘sunset industry’ into one with a future as bright as the noontime sun.
C hap te r Seve n : Perp etu al Enterp rise
Chapter Seven Perpetual Enterprise Let the capable take over for a sustainable enterprise.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Chapter Seven: Perpetual Enterprise
- Pass The Baton To The Capable ◆
Succession Approach: Avoid Fettering Family Members
◆
Passing The Torch: Pick Suitable Candidates
◆
The Succession Plan In Place
- Getting The Next Generation Ready For Succession ◆
A Father’s Approach: Encouragement Without Coercion
◆
Andrew Lo: An Entrepreneur Who Dreamed Of Making Rockets
◆
Family Meeting: Formulate Succession Rules
◆
Andrew Lo: Succession By Eldest Son Not A Given
◆
Future Path: Make Joint Efforts To Further Development
◆
Andrew Lo: Learning From Father’s Tutelage And Actions
◆
A Capable Candidate From The Second-and-a-half Generation
◆
◆
315
Howard Lo: Being The Successor That Belongs To The Second-and-a-half Generation
- Show Foresight Of A Perpetual Enterprise ◆
307
Global Setup: Plan Succession Overseas Retiree’s Role: Guard Against Crises – A Message From Kenneth LO
337
C hap te r Seve n : Perp etu al Enterp rise
- Pass The Baton To The Capable Succession Approach: Avoid Fettering Family Members Rare is the family that succeeds in passing down its wealth through three generations. I therefore favour handing over the business to the capable. A successor chosen from within the family must not only take care of the entire business but also meet the expectations of the family. If he does not wish to do so or if he does not have what it takes to handle intricate familial matters, then the burden of family and business should not be inflicted if the responsibility isn’t welcome. This situation can lead to unwarranted self-struggle.
Descendants Fight Over Inheritance One reads often in the news how the descendants of rich and distinctive families fight over the estate of the patriarch. Family members end up on opposite sides in court. Regardless of the final judgment of the court, both sides are losers from the start. The family business ends up being ripped apart with descendants fleeting in different directions. Even though it is said blood is thicker than water, they treat one another like strangers, to the point of not ever talking again. I think the whole thing is just really sad. As the Chinese say, ‘rare is the family that can pass down its wealth through three generations.’ The first generation starts a business with the intention of creating a comfortable and carefree life for the descendants. If the next generation gets into a squabble over inheritance, even though the assets remain within the family, the harmony is gone. This certainly is not what the business founder wishes to see. What he really wants is for the descendants to take the business one notch higher. Another Chinese saying has it that ‘while it is hard to start a venture, it is even harder
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
to keep it going.’ It has always been the biggest challenge in Chinese society to figure out how to hand a booming business from generation to generation until perpetuity with the family remaining as united as ever.
Pick The Capable One To Succeed In the Chinese society, the bloodline is often regarded as the very thing that brings families together and that thriving businesses rely on. It is worrisome not to have a male heir under the shadow of patriarchy. Conversely, there is nothing more joyous than to hand down a Chinese business empire from father to son. I however do not believe in the above style of thinking. I do not agree in allowing a family member to succeed simply because of the blood relationship. A successor chosen from within the family must not only take care of the entire business but also meet the expectations of the family. If he does not wish to do so or if he does not have what it takes to handle intricate familial matters, then the burden of family and business should not be inflicted if the responsibility isn’t welcome. This situation can lead to unwarranted self-struggle.
Woe To Family Business: Family Members Would Not Let Go I am of the opinion that harmony is most important within a family. The primary consideration of the succession of a family should be harmony, but for the succession of a business, it should be ability. Company ownership should be completely separate from management control. For a family business to last from generation to generation, it is not necessary that the person at the helm be a descendant of the founder. Family members can simply be shareholders while the running of the business can be left to the hands of outside professionals. Keeping the family congenial and happy is far more important than having family members take control of the business. More importantly, one should not allow wealth to harm what is the most important thing in a family and turn your closest kin to foe and tear apart family in the process.
C hap te r Seve n : Perp etu al Enterp rise
If a business wants to expand and succeed in the long term, I do not recommend forcing the family handover. Meanwhile, focus rather on the future of the business and sourcing an adequate management team.
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
Passing The Torch: Pick Suitable Candidates A successful enterprise requires an industrious leader. Steering clear of nepotism; family members who fit the bill should be considered. If a next generation family member possesses skill, ability, good character and visionary excellence they should be groomed for business handover. During this time, development should be observed to determine suitability for the role.
Do Not Rule Out Family Members In Succession Planning As a garment manufacturer, Crystal’s business requires diligent no-nonsense individuals to assist in day to day management. Unlike a property investor or a financial institute, a manufacturer has to put in a lot of hard work to succeed. I foresee even keener competition ahead for the garment manufacturing industry. Only the fittest will survive in such an economic climate. Perhaps only a few international manufacturers will remain in the end and opposed to a plethora of small operations, there will be few, however will be much larger in scale. A Crystal wants to stand among the survivors, it is all the more important that we proceed cautiously in our succession planning. My ideal successor has to be moral, capable, hardworking, and innovative. As a good leader who practices the corporate culture for the Greater Good, he has to put the interest of others ahead of his own. Although I do not approve of basing succession decision solely on the blood line, there is no reason to bypass a suitable candidate from within the family simply to avoid the suspicion of nepotism. In fact, if someone capable is available among the descendants, it is even better. For this reason, if one finds a member of the next generation with the ability, the vision and the good character to carry the business, that person should be groomed carefully over a period of time, during which his or her development will be observed to determine if he or she is the right person to take over
C hap te r Seve n : Perp etu al Enterp rise
the business.
Vet Candidates First By Character Ability is a must for someone to lead a sizeable enterprise. While the successor must have adequate knowledge of the industry, there is no need for him to be familiar with all the ins and outs of the business. Leadership and management skills can be groomed over time. As long as the successor has the character to win the support of the employees and is able to identify the capable and entrust them with important duties, he or she can also recruit talents to help him with the running and the development of the company. As a leader, the person at the top must also take care of the welfare of the entire workforce. He or she must lay down policies with clear directions, handle affairs with heart and mind, apply self-discipline and win the respect of his team, business allies and clients. Character is my primary criterion in selecting a successor. I require that the person to be able to see the big picture, to keep alive the spirit of initiating change from within to attain greater changes beyond, and above all, to have the vision and the charisma of a leader.
Practice Soft Skills And Cultivate Charisma Industry knowledge should not be the focus of the grooming process. If a next generation family member possesses skill, ability, good character and visionary excellence they should be groomed for business handover. During this time, development should be observed to determine suitability for the role. If no one in the family can measure up to expectation, we might as well let the family members be shareholders and hire professionals from the outside to run the business. That will be a better arrangement for both the company and the family. In this day and age, as shareholders, family members must also know their own role and be careful not to interfere with professional management teams or else risk
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
affecting the morale of the workforce and the development of the company. Otherwise, they will end up ruining the family business with their own hands.
C hap te r Seve n : Perp etu al Enterp rise
The Succession Plan In Place An arrangement has been made for the Group’s top post to be passed from one brother to another. Our workforce understands that when Andrew retires from the top post at 65, Howard will resume leadership. The heads of various subsidiaries are also in full support of this plan which dispels any uncertainty about the Group’s future.
Talents In The Next Generation Both Crystal and I are extremely fortunate to have successors among our children in the next generation. Some might think that Crystal is no different from other family enterprises if it has designated its successors from within the family. But I must clarify for the record that neither Yvonne nor I had the slightest intention of letting any family member take over. It was just a matter of luck that it turned out this way. Our first-born, Andrew presented that he had the ability and the desire to take over the family business. After assuming the post of the chief executive director in 2008, he has repeatedly proved himself as the most suitable successor. Most of our senior executives belong to the same generation as Andrew. In other words, they are about the same age and will be at retirement stage in around 15 years from now. In saying this, it is difficult to find someone from within that group to take the helm as third-generation leader. But I am pleased to observe that Andrew is even more skillful and thoughtful than I regarding succession planning. He has begun grooming the third-generation successor to take over his role in roughly 15 years from now.
A Reserve Of Talents Making his way to the top (after Andrew) will be our youngest son, Howard. Andrew
F o r t h e G reat e r G ood
is 13 years older than Howard. In 2015, 50-year-old Andrew and 38-year-old Howard reached an understanding that when Andrew steps down at age 65, Howard will take over. Fortunately, Howard is interested in pursuing this direction and has proven to be the most suitable candidate to take over the business. Our workforce understands that when Andrew retires from the top post at 65, Howard will resume leadership. The heads of various subsidiaries are also in full support of this plan - which dispels any uncertainty about the Group’s future. Inevitably, those who have been recruited for middle to senior management positions will be retiring soon. Our succession planning involves more than just randomly selecting someone to take over at the helm - it means we need to groom enough talent to step into different corporate positions at various points in time. Crystal has begun recruiting young people from universities to train as ‘reserves’ with the objective of satisfying the entire corporation’s management needs over time. We have also increased training for existing middle managers so that we have an adequate amount of capable people to support Howard when he takes the top slot.
Succession Plan Endorsed By Business Allies Uniqlo’s founder Mr Tadashi Yanai is the most successful entrepreneur in Asia’s retail industry and in conjunction, has topped Japan’s most wealthy list. He is a longtime partner and a close friend. When he heard about our succession planning, he was instantly pleased and envious and he showered us with his heartfelt blessings.
C hap te r Seve n : Perp etu al Enterp rise
- Getting The Next Generation Ready For Succession A Father’s Approach: Encouragement Without Coercion I leave it up to my children to decide freely whether to take
FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS •
Revenue for the six months ended 30 June 2026 amounted to US$1,296 million (30 June 2025: US$1,229 million).
•
Net profit for the six months ended 30 June 2026 amounted to US$109 million (30 June 2025: US$98 million).
•
The Board has resolved to declare an interim dividend of HK18.0 cents (approximately US2.3 cents) per ordinary share (30 June 2025: HK16.3 cents).
INTERIM RESULTS The board (the “Board”) of directors (the “Directors”) of Crystal International Group Limited (the “Company”) is pleased to announce the interim results of the Company and its subsidiaries (together, the “Group” or “Crystal”) for the six months ended 30 June 2026, together with the comparative figures for the six months ended 30 June 2025. The interim results and condensed consolidated financial statements for the six months ended 30 June 2026 have been reviewed by the independent auditors of the Company.
- For identification purposes only
–1–
CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF PROFIT OR LOSS AND OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME FOR THE SIX MONTHS ENDED 30 JUNE 2026
NOTES Revenue Cost of sales
3
Gross profit Other income, gains or losses Impairment losses recognised under expected credit loss model, net of reversal Selling and distribution expenses Administrative expenses Research and development expenses Finance costs Share of results of associates Profit before tax Income tax expense
4 5
Profit for the period Other comprehensive income (expense) Items that may be reclassified subsequently to profit or loss: Exchange difference arising on translation of foreign operations Fair value changes on trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income Impairment loss on trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income under expected credit loss model, net of reversal
Items that will not be reclassified subsequently to profit or loss: Surplus on revaluation of properties Deferred tax expense arising on revaluation of properties
Other comprehensive income (expense) for the period Total comprehensive income for the period –2–
Six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (unaudited) 1,295,926 (1,039,764)
1,229,475 (986,873)
256,162 12,773
242,602 12,070
(64) (19,917) (92,882) (16,952) (5,091) 352
(2,043) (16,135) (93,977) (16,308) (6,498) (4)
134,381 (25,684)
119,707 (21,384)
108,697
98,323
4,386
(7,391)
146
415
(9)
(4)
4,523
(6,980)
6,240
5,164
(1,354)
(1,205)
4,886
3,959
9,409
(3,021)
118,106
95,302
NOTE Profit for the period attributable to: Owners of the Company Non-controlling interests
Total comprehensive income for the period attributable to: Owners of the Company Non-controlling interests
Basic earnings per share for profit attributable to the owners of the Company (US cents)
–3–
7
Six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (unaudited) 108,681 16
98,265 58
108,697
98,323
118,090 16
95,244 58
118,106
95,302
3.81
3.44
CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION AT 30 JUNE 2026
NOTES ASSETS Non-current assets Property, plant and equipment Right-of-use assets Deposits paid for acquisition of property, plant and equipment Goodwill Intangible assets Interests in associates Loan receivables Deferred taxation assets
Current assets Inventories Right-of-use assets Trade, bills and other receivables Trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income Amounts due from related companies Loan receivables Financial assets at fair value through profit or loss Tax recoverable Short-term bank deposits Bank balances and cash
8 9
Total assets
–4–
At 30 June 2026 US$ ’000 (unaudited)
At 31 December 2025 US$ ’000 (audited)
733,117 110,758
686,315 118,083
56,339 74,941 58,815 12,779 411 2,379
19,910 74,941 61,274 12,339 485 2,513
1,049,539
975,860
414,937 1,414 156,724
321,605 3,042 142,882
315,269 217 366
355,792 217 954
5,628 1,333 12,265 444,365
– 2,305 – 382,310
1,352,518
1,209,107
2,402,057
2,184,967
At 30 June 2026 US$ ’000 (unaudited)
At 31 December 2025 US$ ’000 (audited)
EQUITY AND LIABILITIES Capital and reserves Share capital Reserves
3,654 1,633,375
3,654 1,604,470
Equity attributable to owners of the Company Non-controlling interests
1,637,029 3,408
1,608,124 3,561
Total equity
1,640,437
1,611,685
18,514 36,726
22,388 35,241
55,240
57,629
541,840 11,227 15,338 89,115 31,107 17,753
469,087 13,253 10,859 – 22,454 –
706,380
515,653
2,402,057
2,184,967
NOTE
Non-current liabilities Lease liabilities Deferred taxation liabilities
Current liabilities Trade and other payables Lease liabilities Amounts due to associates Dividend payable Tax liabilities Bank borrowings
10
Total equity and liabilities
–5–
NOTES TO THE CONDENSED CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE SIX MONTHS ENDED 30 JUNE 2026 1.
GENERAL AND BASIS OF PREPARATION The Company was previously incorporated in Bermuda as an exempted company with limited liability and registered by way of continuation in the Cayman Islands as an exempted company with limited liability. The Company is directly held by its controlling shareholders, Mr. LO Lok Fung Kenneth and Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne, both executive directors of the Company. The address of the registered office of the Company is Ugland House, P.O. Box 309, Grand Cayman, KY1-1104, Cayman Islands and the principal place of business of the Company is 5-7/F., AXA Tower, Landmark East, No. 100 How Ming Street, Kowloon, Hong Kong. The Group is principally engaged in the manufacturing and trading of garments. The shares of the Company were listed on the Main Board of The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (the “Stock Exchange”) on 3 November 2017. The condensed consolidated financial statements are presented in United States dollars (“US$”), which is also the functional currency of the Company. The condensed consolidated financial statements have been prepared in accordance with International Accounting Standard 34 “ Interim Financial Reporting ” issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”) as well as with the applicable disclosure requirements of the Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on the Stock Exchange.
ACCOUNTING POLICIES The condensed consolidated financial statements have been prepared on the historical cost basis except for certain properties and financial instruments that are measured at revalued amounts or fair values, as appropriate. Historical cost is generally based on the fair value of the consideration given in exchange for goods and services. The accounting policies and methods of computation used in the condensed consolidated financial statements for the six months ended 30 June 2026 are the same as those applied in the preparation of the Group’s annual consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2025.
–6–
Application of amendments to IFRS Accounting Standards In the current interim period, the Group has applied the following amendments to IFRS Accounting Standards as issued by the IASB, for the first time, which are mandatorily effective for the Group’s annual period beginning on 1 January 2026 for the preparation of the Group’s condensed consolidated financial statements: Amendments to IFRS 9 and IFRS 7 Amendments to IFRS 9 and IFRS 7 Amendments to IFRS Accounting Standards
Amendments to the Classification and Measurement of Financial Instruments Contracts Referencing Nature-dependent Electricity Annual Improvements to IFRS Accounting Standards – Volume 11
The application of the amendments to IFRS Accounting Standards in the current interim period has had no material impact on the Group’s financial positions and performance for the current and prior periods and/or on the disclosures set out in these condensed consolidated financial statements. 3.
REVENUE AND SEGMENT INFORMATION Information reported to the chief executive officer of the Group, being the chief operating decision maker (the “CODM”), for the purposes of resource allocation and assessment of segment performances, focuses on types of products. (i)
Lifestyle wear
(ii)
Sportswear and outdoor apparel
(iii) Denim (iv)
Intimate
(v)
Sweater
These operating segments also represent the Group’s reportable segments. No operating segments identified by the CODM have been aggregated in arriving at the reportable segments of the Group.
–7–
Segment revenue and results The following is an analysis of the Group’s revenue and results by operating segments: Six months ended 30 June 2026 (unaudited) Sportswear and Lifestyle outdoor wear apparel US$ ’000 US$ ’000
Denim US$ ’000
Intimate US$ ’000
Sweater US$ ’000
Total US$ ’000
SEGMENT REVENUE External sales
380,704
338,630
239,521
227,798
109,273
1,295,926
Segment profit
76,580
69,472
40,171
47,463
22,476
256,162 12,773
Other income, gains or losses Impairment losses recognised under expected credit loss model, net of reversal Selling and distribution expenses Administrative expenses Research and development expenses Finance costs Share of results of associates
(64) (19,917) (92,882) (16,952) (5,091) 352 134,381
Profit before tax
–8–
Six months ended 30 June 2025 (unaudited) Sportswear and Lifestyle outdoor wear apparel ’ US$ 000 US$ ’000
Denim US$ ’000
Intimate US$ ’000
Sweater US$ ’000
Total US$ ’000
SEGMENT REVENUE External sales
339,672
312,906
262,202
209,784
104,911
1,229,475
Segment profit
69,801
64,869
42,892
43,637
21,403
242,602
Other income, gains or losses Impairment losses recognised under expected credit loss model, net of reversal Selling and distribution expenses Administrative expenses Research and development expenses Finance costs Share of results of associates
12,070
(2,043) (16,135) (93,977) (16,308) (6,498) (4)
Profit before tax
119,707
The accounting policies of the operating segments are the same as the Group’s accounting policies. Segment profit represents the profit earned by each segment without allocation of other income, gains or losses, impairment losses recognised under expected credit loss model, net of reversal, selling and distribution expenses, administrative expenses, research and development expenses, finance costs and share of results of associates. This is the measure reported to the CODM of the Group for the purposes of resource allocation and performance assessment. Certain amounts of depreciation of property, plant and equipment and right-of-use assets are included in the measure of segment results in each segment. No further analysis is presented for certain items included or excluded in the measure of segment results as such information is not regularly provided to the CODM. Segment assets and liabilities No analysis of segment assets or segment liabilities is presented as such information is not regularly provided to the CODM.
–9–
Geographical information Information about the Group’s revenue is presented below by geographical location based on port of discharge. Six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (unaudited) Asia Pacific (note a) North America Europe (note b) Other countries/regions
503,328 438,368 306,214 48,016
478,286 462,934 252,705 35,550
1,295,926
1,229,475
Notes: (a)
Asia Pacific primarily includes Japan, the People’s Republic of China (the “PRC”) and South Korea.
(b)
Europe primarily includes the United Kingdom (the “U.K.”), France, Germany, the Netherlands.
– 10 –
PROFIT BEFORE TAX Six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (unaudited) Profit before tax has been arrived at after charging (crediting): Directors’ emoluments Other staff costs Retirement benefit schemes’ contributions for other staff
1,808 328,735 37,051
1,748 291,744 32,029
Total staff costs (note)
367,594
325,521
Depreciation of property, plant and equipment (note) Depreciation of right-of-use assets (note) Amortisation of intangible asset (included in selling and distribution expenses) Cost of inventories recognised as expenses (including write-down of inventories amounting to US$7,427,000 (2025: US$1,236,000)) (note) Loss (gain) on disposals of property, plant and equipment Net gain arising from changes in fair value of derivative financial instruments Interest income Net foreign exchange loss Finance costs: – interest expense on lease liabilities – interest expense on bank borrowings – interest expense on factoring arrangement
35,387 10,934
31,000 9,184
2,459
2,459
1,039,764 150
986,873 (192)
(5,644) (4,061) 5,428
– (9,058) 3,113
1,085 100 3,906
688 2,276 3,534
Note: Cost of inventories recognised as expenses include staff costs, depreciation of property, plant and equipment and depreciation of right-of-use assets used for production, which amounts are also included in the respective total amounts disclosed separately above.
– 11 –
INCOME TAX EXPENSE Six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$’000 (unaudited) (unaudited) The income tax expense comprises: Hong Kong Profits Tax – current period – under-provision in prior years Overseas taxation – current period – over-provision in prior years Income tax under Pillar Two Rules
Deferred taxation
13,059 –
13,005 2
12,029 (1,003) 1,789
9,829 (906) –
25,874 (190)
21,930 (546)
25,684
21,384
Under the two-tiered profits tax rates regime, the first Hong Kong dollars (“HK$”) 2 million of profits of the qualifying group entity are taxed at 8.25%, and profits above HK$2 million are taxed at 16.5%. The profits of group entities not qualifying for the two-tiered profits tax rates regime continue to be taxed at a flat rate of 16.5%. The directors of the Company consider the amount involved upon implementation of the two-tiered profits tax rates regime as insignificant to the condensed consolidated financial statements. Hong Kong Profits Tax is calculated at 16.5% of the estimated assessable profit for both periods. Under the Law of the PRC on Enterprise Income Tax (the “ EIT Law ” ) and Implementation Regulation of the EIT Law, the tax rate of the PRC subsidiaries is 25% for both periods. Certain subsidiaries incorporated in Cambodia are exempted from tax on profit in both periods while they fulfil certain requirements pursuant to the relevant laws and regulations in Cambodia. Taxation arising in other jurisdictions is calculated at the rates prevailing in the relevant jurisdictions. The Group is subject to the global minimum top-up tax under Pillar Two Rules. Pillar Two Rules have become effective in certain jurisdictions, where the annual effective income tax rate is also estimated to be below 15%. Therefore, a top-up tax is accrued in the current period using the tax rate based on the estimated adjusted covered taxes and net Global Anti-Base Erosion (“GloBE”) income for the year. The Group has recognised a current tax expense of US$1,789,000 (six months ended 30 June 2025: nil) related to the top-up tax for the period ended 30 June 2026 which is expected to be levied on the Company.
– 12 –
DIVIDENDS Six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (unaudited) Final, declared, of HK24.5 cents per ordinary share for 2025 (2025: HK19.0 cents per ordinary share for 2024) Special, declared, of HK5.5 cents per ordinary share for 2024 (2025: nil for 2025)
89,185
69,055
–
19,990
89,185
89,045
Pursuant to a resolution passed by the Board on 19 August 2026, the Board has resolved to declare an interim dividend of HK18.0 cents (six months ended 30 June 2025: HK16.3 cents) per ordinary share, totalling HK$513,508,000 (equivalent to US$65,472,000) (six months ended 30 June 2025: HK$465,010,000 (equivalent to US$59,312,000)) estimated on the number of shares in issue at 30 June 2026. This declared dividend is not reflected as a dividend payable in these condensed consolidated financial statements, but will be reflected as an appropriation of reserve for the year ending 31 December 2026. 7.
EARNINGS PER SHARE The calculation of the basic earnings per share attributable to the owners of the Company is based on the following data: Six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 ’ US$ 000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (unaudited) Earnings: Profit for the period attributable to owners of the Company for the purpose of calculating basic earnings per share
Number of shares: Number of ordinary shares for the purpose of calculating basic earnings per share
108,681
98,265
’000
’000
2,852,822
2,852,822
No diluted earnings per share was presented for the six months ended 30 June 2026 and 2025 as there were no potential dilutive ordinary shares in issue during both periods.
– 13 –
TRADE, BILLS AND OTHER RECEIVABLES At At 30 June 31 December 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (audited) Trade receivables – contracts with customers Less: allowance for expected credit losses
81,445 (585)
86,325 (517)
Bills receivable Temporary payments to suppliers Other receivables, deposits and prepayments
80,860 627 23,403 51,834
85,808 7,758 10,817 38,499
156,724
142,882
The following is an aged analysis of trade receivables, net of allowance for expected credit losses, based on invoice dates. At At 30 June 31 December 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (audited) Within 60 days 61 to 90 days 91 to 120 days Over 120 days
– 14 –
75,065 5,459 312 24
78,497 5,907 780 624
80,860
85,808
TRADE RECEIVABLES AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME As part of the Group’s cash flow management, the Group factors certain trade receivables to financial institutions before the receivables are due for repayment. The factored trade receivables are derecognised on the basis that the Group has transferred substantially all the risks and rewards to the relevant counterparties. Such trade receivables, that are held for the collection of contractual cash flows and sale of financial assets, have been classified as trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income (“FVTOCI”). The following is an aged analysis of trade receivables at FVTOCI based on invoice dates. At At 30 June 31 December 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (audited) Within 60 days 61 to 90 days 91 to 120 days over 120 days
267,809 37,633 6,319 3,508
240,205 107,253 7,237 1,097
315,269
355,792
TRADE AND OTHER PAYABLES At At 30 June 31 December 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (audited) Trade payables Bills payable
292,431 3,654
198,612 4,295
Accrued staff cost Other payables Other accruals
296,085 99,374 61,805 84,576
202,907 111,815 58,639 95,726
Total trade and other payables
541,840
469,087
– 15 –
The following is an aged analysis of trade payables (including bills payable) based on invoice dates. At At 30 June 31 December 2026 2025 ’ US$ 000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (audited) Within 60 days 61 to 90 days 91 to 120 days Over 120 days
238,569 41,384 14,022 2,110
162,810 26,284 12,254 1,559
296,085
202,907
PLEDGE OF ASSETS At the end of the reporting period, the Group had the following assets pledged to banks as security for general banking facilities granted to the Group. At At 30 June 31 December 2026 2025 US$ ’000 US$ ’000 (unaudited) (audited) Property, plant and equipment Inventories
– 16 –
1,540 3,235
1,559 3,270
4,775
4,829
MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS MARKET OVERVIEW The global apparel industry operated in a mixed market environment during the first half of 2026, characterised by resilient consumer demand in key markets alongside heightened geopolitical uncertainty. Consumer spending remained strong in the world’s two largest consumer markets. In the United States, retail and food services sales increased by 6.4% year on year in the second quarter of 2026. According to the National Bureau of Statistics of China, total retail sales of consumer goods increased by 1.3% year on year in the first half of 2026, while retail sales of apparel, footwear, hats, and textile products rose by 6.7%. Meanwhile, consumer demand in Europe remained relatively stable, supported by a resilient labour market and improving consumer confidence. A key challenge during the period was the disruption to global supply chains across the apparel industry arising from the Middle East conflict. First, uncertainty in fuel supply led to increased volatility in electricity availability and energy costs across parts of Southeast Asia. Second, rising crude oil prices increased the cost of synthetic fibres and other petroleum-based materials used in garment production. Third, the rerouting of shipping services away from traditional trade corridors resulted in longer transit times, higher logistics costs, and reduced supply chain flexibility. In this environment, apparel manufacturers with flexible production capabilities, a diversified product mix, and a broad portfolio of brand customers were better positioned to navigate market volatility and capture growth opportunities. BUSINESS REVIEW In the first half of 2026, the Group continued to benefit from strong order momentum from its brand customers and was only marginally affected by the conflict in the Middle East. As a result, the Group delivered solid growth in both revenue and profitability during the period. End consumers increasingly prioritised innovation and value for money in their purchasing decisions. In response to changing consumer preferences, the Group worked closely with its brand customers to develop diversified product portfolios and effectively addressed evolving market demand. Supported by a diversified portfolio covering lifestyle wear, sportswear, outdoor apparel, denim, intimate apparel, and sweaters, the Group was able to partner with brand customers across multiple product categories and maintain a balanced business mix amid shifting consumer trends.
– 17 –
The Group ’ s earnings are derived primarily from processing work for garment manufacturing, rather than fluctuations in raw material prices. Costs of key raw materials such as fabrics, are generally borne by brand customers, enabling effective pass-through of material cost changes. Transportation and freight arrangements are also managed largely by brand customers. Consequently, the impact of the Middle East conflict on the Group was limited mainly to electricity supply volatility and related energy costs in certain manufacturing locations. To ensure stable operations, the Group incurred modest additional costs to secure alternative energy sources and maintain adequate self-generated power capacity. Improving workforce productivity was a key operational priority during the period. The Group made encouraging progress through disciplined execution and continuous efficiency improvement initiatives. Together with healthy order demand and effective cost control, these productivity gains further strengthened the Group’s competitiveness and contributed to the improvement in its financial performance. The Group’s revenue for the six months ended 30 June 2026 increased by 5.4% to US$1,296 million, compared to the same period last year (six months ended 30 June 2025: US$1,229 million). Gross profit for the six months ended 30 June 2026 increased by 5.6% to US$256 million (six months ended 30 June 2025: US$243 million). The gross profit margin increased to 19.8% from 19.7% in the same period last year. The net profit margin improved from 8.0% to 8.4%, resulting in a 10.6% increase in net profit for the six months ended 30 June 2026 to US$109 million (six months ended 30 June 2025: US$98 million). In keeping with our practice of sharing operational results with shareholders, the Board resolved to declare an interim dividend of HK18.0 cents per ordinary share (six months ended 30 June 2025: HK16.3 cents), representing a payout ratio of 60%. Capital expenditure for the six months ended 30 June 2026 was US$112 million (six months ended 30 June 2025: US$60 million). The increase in capital expenditure was attributable primarily to the Group’s strategic expansion project in Egypt, including a one-off payment made during the period in relation to the acquisition of a land parcel in New October City, Egypt. The land parcel, with a total site area of approximately 800,000 square metres and an acquisition consideration of US$30.4 million, forms the foundation of the Group’s manufacturing development project in Egypt and represents an important milestone in its long-term capacity expansion strategy.
– 18 –
FINANCIAL REVIEW Revenue The Group’s revenue for the six months ended 30 June 2026 compared to the same period in 2025, by product category, each expressed as an absolute amount and as a percentage of total revenue was: For the six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 % US$ ’000 Lifestyle wear Sportswear and outdoor apparel Denim Intimate Sweater Total Revenue
380,704 338,630 239,521 227,798 109,273 1,295,926
29.4% 26.1% 18.5% 17.6% 8.4%
%
339,672 312,906 262,202 209,784 104,911
27.6% 25.5% 21.3% 17.1% 8.5%
100.0% 1,229,475
100.0%
Despite capacity constraints, the Group’s revenue increased by 5.4% compared to the same period last year. The Group’s sales analysed by geographical region based on port of discharge were: For the six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 US$ ’000 % US$ ’000 Asia-Pacific (note a) North America Europe (note b) Other countries/regions Total Revenue
503,328 438,368 306,214 48,016 1,295,926
38.8% 33.8% 23.6% 3.8%
478,286 462,934 252,705 35,550
38.9% 37.6% 20.6% 2.9%
100.0% 1,229,475
100.0%
Notes: (a)
Asia Pacific primarily includes Japan, the PRC and South Korea.
(b)
Europe mainly includes the U.K., France, Germany, and the Netherlands.
– 19 –
%
Gross Profit and Gross Profit Margin For the six months ended 30 June 2026 2025 Gross Gross Gross Profit Gross Profit Profit Margin Profit Margin US$ ’000 % US$ ’000 % Lifestyle wear Sportswear and outdoor apparel Denim Intimate Sweater
76,580 69,472 40,171 47,463 22,476
20.1% 20.5% 16.8% 20.8% 20.6%
69,801 64,869 42,892 43,637 21,403
20.5% 20.7% 16.4% 20.8% 20.4%
Total Gross Profit
256,162
19.8%
242,602
19.7%
Gross profit margin remained stable at 19.8% in the first half of 2026, compared with 19.7% in the first half of 2025. Other Expenses and Finance Costs Selling and distribution expenses remained stable at 1.5% in the first half of 2026, compared with 1.3% in the first half of 2025. Administrative, research and development expenses, and other income and expenses remained stable at 7.5% in the first half of 2026 compared with 8.0% in the first half of 2025. The effective borrowing rate for the Group in the six months ended 30 June 2026 ranged from 2.95% to 5.04% compared to 1.52% to 5.64% for the same period in 2025. The Group had no fixed-rate borrowings at 30 June 2026. Finance costs amounted 0.4% of revenue in the first half of 2026 compared to 0.5% for the same period in 2025. Net Profit The Group achieved a net profit of US$109 million for the six months ended 30 June 2026. Net profit as a percentage of revenue increased from 8.0% in the first half of 2025 to 8.4% in the first half of 2026.
– 20 –
Capital Management The consolidated financial position of the Group remained sound throughout the first half of 2026. The positive operating cash flow of US$162 million in the six months (US$155 million for the same period in 2025) contributed to cash balances of US$444 million at 30 June 2026, compared to US$382 million at 31 December 2025. Cash balances were mainly denominated in HK$ and US$. Bank borrowings, mainly denominated in HK$ and US$, have increased from US$nil at 31 December 2025 to US$18 million at 30 June 2026. All bank borrowings of US$18 million at 30 June 2026 contained a repayable on demand clause and US$18 million was repayable within one year. The Group held a positive net cash position of US$439 million at 30 June 2026. The gearing ratio (total interest-bearing bank borrowings, less bank balances and cash, divided by total equity) at 30 June 2026 was nil (31 December 2025: nil). Our conversion cycle remained stable at 81 days as at 30 June 2026, compared with 81 days as at 31 December 2025. Turnover of trade and bills receivables averaged 60 days in the first half of 2026, compared with 62 days average turnover throughout 2025. Inventory turnover averaged 65 days in the first half of 2026, compared with 52 days throughout 2025. Trade and bills payables turnover averaged 44 days in the first half of 2026 compared to 33 days throughout 2025. Capital expenditure incurred, in the main, for the building, equipping and upgrading of production facilities, has been carefully managed. For the six months ended 30 June 2026, capital expenditure amounted to US$112 million, compared to US$60 million for the same period in 2025. Capital commitments at 30 June 2026 were US$72 million compared to US$80 million at 31 December 2025. Foreign currency exchange contracts are used to manage foreign currency exposure. The Group’s policy is to monitor its foreign currency exposure and use foreign currency exchange contracts, as appropriate, to minimise its foreign currency risks. Funding and Treasury Policy The Group has adopted a prudent treasury policy and thus maintained a healthy liquidity position throughout the period. The Group strives to reduce credit risk by performing ongoing credit assessments and evaluations of the financial status of its customers. The Group regularly reviews its funding requirements to maintain adequate financial resources in order to support its current business operations as well as its future investments and expansion plans. Pledge of Assets At 30 June 2026, pledge of assets of the Group are set out in note 11 to the condensed consolidated financial statements included at the start of this announcement.
– 21 –
Acquisitions and Disposals of Subsidiaries, Associates and Joint Ventures For the six months ended 30 June 2026, the Group had no material acquisitions and disposals of subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures. Significant Investment Held For the six months ended 30 June 2026, the Group held no significant investments. Material Acquisitions and Future Plans for Major Investment In January 2026, the Group reserved a land parcel in Egypt for a consideration of US$30.4 million in connection with its strategic expansion project in Egypt. For details, please refer to the announcement of the Company published on 20 January 2026. At the date of this announcement, the approval process by the relevant Egyptian authorities is still underway and the land acquisition has not yet been completed. Save as disclosed above, the Group did not have any other future plans for major investments or acquisitions for major capital assets at the date of this announcement. Contingent Liabilities At 30 June 2026, the Group had no material contingent liability (31 December 2025: Nil). Subsequent Events after the Reporting Period At the date of this announcement, no material event has occurred after the reporting period. EMPLOYMENT, TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT The Group employed around 87,000 people at 30 June 2026. Total staff costs, including administrative and management staff, for the six months ended 30 June 2026 equated to 28.4% of revenue, compared to 26.5% in the same period in 2025. The Group remunerates its staff according to their performance, qualifications, and industry practices, and conducts regular reviews of its remuneration policy. Employees may receive discretionary bonuses and monetary rewards based on their ratings in the annual performance appraisals. The Group also offers rewards or other incentives to motivate the personal growth and career development of its employees, such as ongoing opportunities for training to enhance their technical and product knowledge, as well as their knowledge of industry quality standards. Each new employee of the Group is required to attend an introductory course, and various types of training courses are available to all employees of the Group.
– 22 –
SUSTAINABILITY Vision and Strategy Sustainability is a strategic imperative for our business and the key to creating long-term environmental and social value for our stakeholders. Our overarching sustainability strategy is underpinned by our Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 ( “ CSV2030 ” ), which comprises eight impact areas across the environmental, people, and community dimensions, and sets specific goals we are committed to achieving by the end of the decade. We and all our factories are developing and implementing tailored, detailed, actionable items to meet our CSV2030 objectives. For more details on our CSV2030 goals, please visit our corporate website at https://www.crystalgroup.com/csv2030. We are working collaboratively to fulfil our commitment to achieving net zero emissions by 2050, thus contributing to limiting the global temperature rise to below 1.5°C. Against the backdrop of an escalating climate threat, we completed a climate scenario analysis to identify short- to long-term risks and opportunities, which were incorporated into the Group ’ s key risk management system to inform operational strategies, capital allocation, and resilience planning. CSV2030, along with our broader sustainability initiatives, aligns with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals 1 (UNSDGs) to ensure we contribute to addressing global societal problems. As a participant in the United Nations Global Compact, we support the Ten Principles on human rights, labour, environment, and anti-corruption. We are committed to making these principles part of our strategy, culture, and daily operations while actively engaging with industry stakeholders in various collaborative projects. Net Zero 2050 Vision Our efforts to realise an ambitious net zero roadmap are ongoing. The roadmap comprises strategies focusing on energy efficiency, renewable energy, productivity enhancement, and fuel switching. Our 2050 net zero target was validated by the Science Based Targets initiative ( “ SBTi ” ), affirming its alignment with SBTi criteria and climate science. To spearhead progress towards the Group’s decarbonisation targets and enhance accountability in our factories, we have established individual carbon intensity targets for each garment factory on an annual basis. To improve energy efficiency, all our factories are progressively implementing their decarbonisation plans, with the aim of completing more than 260 energy efficiency measures by 2028. To date, 158 of these measures have been completed, reducing carbon emissions by over 51,000 tonnes and energy consumption by approximately 60,000 MWh per year. 1
The United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (UNSDGs) are a collection of 17 global goals set by the United Nations General Assembly in 2015 for the year 2030. These goals provide a blueprint to achieve a more sustainable future and address global sustainability challenges.
– 23 –
We continued to expand our onsite renewable electricity supply by installing more rooftop solar PV capacity. Our goal is to eventually expand its use across all our factories where operationally feasible. The Group’s total rooftop solar PV capacity has increased from 4.5 MW in late 2021 to about 25 MW at present, with additional systems being installed or planned. Alongside sourcing offsite green electricity through power purchasing agreements, three of our factories achieved 100% renewable electricity coverage on a market-based greenhouse gas accounting basis in 2025 by purchasing International Renewable Energy Certificates (I-RECs) matching their grid electricity volume. Notably, none of our wholly owned factories operate coal-fired units. Our carbon inventory, decarbonisation efforts, and risk management practices were disclosed through CDP. We were recognised in the CDP Climate A List (leadership) for three consecutive years from 2023 to 2025 and were also included in the CDP Supplier Engagement Assessment A List for the second year in a row. These accolades reflect our leadership in climate transition and recognise our commitment to climate transparency and supplier engagement. Resourcing People and Revitalising Community Women make up nearly 70% of our workforce. To improve their status in many of the countries in which we operate, we took steps to improve gender equality by empowering over 77,000 female employees through our self-developed CARE2 programme, which enables our workers to achieve greater effectiveness and personal breakthroughs. In addition, we joined the Reimagining Industry to Support Equality (RISE) initiative – becoming part of a global movement aimed at advancing equitable workplaces throughout the garment supply chain – and expanded relevant training across our operations. Supported by clear guidelines under our human resources development policy, our operations planned and carried out training programmes that promote personal and career growth for employees at all levels. Examples include production training for workers, supervisory skills training for supervisors and line leaders, a Crystal Officer Training Curriculum for officer-grade staff, and a Talent Acceleration Programme for managerial-grade staff. To create new pathways for workers to advance into leadership roles and strengthen our talent pipeline, the structured six-month Assistant Supervisor Programme in our knits division in Vietnam was launched to equip participants with the technical and supervisory capabilities needed for their first leadership positions. By June 2026, 186 high-potential workers had completed the programme, with 151 of them promoted to Assistant Supervisor roles.
2
The CARE programme is an employee well-being programme self-initiated by Crystal. It has five levels to help employees build on their skills, promote a healthy work-life balance, strengthen their self-respect, enhance their sense of belonging, and help them attain self-actualisation.
– 24 –
Employee wellness is also central to our people strategy. Our Group operations promote a culture of sports activity by providing sports centres or sports grounds onsite and organising sports programmes, ranging from large-scale inter-factory competitions to regular gym and yoga sessions. Regarding visual health, we partnered with non-profit organisations such as VisionSpring and The Fred Hollows Foundation to offer free vision screenings for workers. Since 2024, more than 38,000 workers have undergone vision screening in Vietnam, Cambodia, and Bangladesh, with nearly 12,700 of those diagnosed with refractive errors receiving quality eyeglasses at no cost. Recognised for excellence in human resources practices, strong employee engagement, and a positive workplace culture, Crystal’s headquarters in Hong Kong, all factories and fabric mills in Vietnam and China, and our Singapore office were named among the Best Companies to Work for in Asia by HR Asia, reflecting our ongoing commitment to fostering a workplace of choice. Our care goes beyond employees, as our team contributes their skills, time, and compassion to various community programmes that focus on community activities, education, environmental protection, health and medical care, and community resilience. In line with our commitment made in 2024 to plant two million trees globally by 2030, we have planted over 940,000 trees to date across all five of our production countries. This includes 60,000 mangroves, which serve to protect coastal areas, enhance biodiversity, and support local fisheries. Our goal is to create a lasting positive impact on the communities in which we operate. OUTLOOK AND PROSPECTS Looking ahead to the second half of 2026, the Group will continue to drive workforce productivity while accelerating business growth through labour expansion. Building on the momentum achieved in the first half, the Group expects year-on-year growth in the second half to outpace that in the first half of the year. Labour productivity recorded a meaningful recovery during the first half. As automation initiatives continue to be rolled out across factories, further efficiency gains are expected. Higher productivity not only increases output and supports earnings growth for the Group but also enhances employee retention by creating greater wage income opportunities for workers. This alignment of employee and business interests strengthens workforce stability and creates a virtuous cycle that improves the Group’s competitiveness and supports sustainable long-term growth. To support future growth, the Group has accelerated talent recruitment and expanded manpower deployment across Vietnam, Bangladesh and China through multiple approaches, including the development of satellite factories. A total of 6,000 new employees were onboarded in the late first half of 2026. Upon these employees become fully integrated into operations, their contributions to productivity and output growth are expected to become increasingly evident in the second half of the year.
– 25 –
While capital expenditure in 2026 is expected to reach a historically high level, the Group’s commitment to shareholder returns remains unchanged. Supported by a net cash position and strong cash generation capability, the Group is well positioned to fund both strategic growth initiatives and dividend distributions. The Board will continue to pursue a balanced approach between growth investment and shareholder returns, with the objective of delivering a stable dividend and, over time, increasing dividend returns in line with earnings growth. CORPORATE GOVERNANCE AND OTHER INFORMATION Interim Dividend The Board has resolved to declare an interim dividend of HK18.0 cents (approximately US2.3 cents) per ordinary share for the six months ended 30 June 2026 payable to shareholders of the Company (the “ Shareholder(s) ” ) whose names appear on the register of members of the Company on Tuesday, 8 September 2026. The interim dividend is expected to be paid on Thursday, 17 September 2026. At the date of this announcement, the Company does not hold any treasury shares (whether in the Central Clearing and Settlement System or otherwise). Closure of Register of Members and Record Date For determining the entitlement to the interim dividend, the register of members of the Company will be closed from Friday, 4 September 2026 to Tuesday, 8 September 2026, both days inclusive, during which period no transfer of shares will be registered. To qualify for the interim dividend, all properly completed transfer forms accompanied by the relevant share certificates must be lodged for registration with the Company’s Hong Kong share registrar, Computershare Hong Kong Investor Services Limited at Shops 1712-1716, 17th Floor, Hopewell Centre, 183 Queen ’ s Road East, Wanchai, Hong Kong, not later than 4:30 p.m. on Thursday, 3 September 2026. The record date for determining a Shareholder’s entitlement to the interim dividend is Tuesday, 8 September 2026. Purchase, Sale or Redemption of the Company’s Listed Securities During the six months ended 30 June 2026, neither the Company nor any of its subsidiaries has purchased, sold or redeemed any of the Company’s listed securities (including sale of treasury shares).
– 26 –
Public Float At the date of this announcement, based on the information that is publicly available to the Company and within the knowledge of the Directors, the Company has maintained the prescribed public float under the Rules (the “Listing Rules”) Governing the Listing of Securities on The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (the “Stock Exchange”) and as agreed with the Stock Exchange throughout the six months ended 30 June 2026 and up to the date of this announcement. Corporate Governance Practices The Board and the management of the Group are committed to the maintenance of good corporate governance practices and procedures. The Board has reviewed the Company’s corporate governance practices and is satisfied that the Company has complied with all code provisions set out in Part 2 of the Corporate Governance Code (the “CG Code”) contained in Appendix C1 to the Listing Rules throughout the six months ended 30 June 2026, except for the following deviation: Code provision B.3.5 of the CG Code provides that issuers should appoint at least one director of a different gender to the nomination committee. Although the nomination committee of the Company (the “Nomination Committee”) currently comprises members of single gender, the Company has put in place the board diversity policy and the workforce diversity policy to promote greater diversity and inclusion (including gender diversity) in its recruitment, and the Nomination Committee also takes into consideration the board diversity policy when reviewing the Board composition, appointing and re-appointing Directors and making recommendations for succession planning to facilitate the development of a diverse talent pipeline. In addition, the Board is satisfied that its overall composition has already reflected strong diversity, with a balanced mix of professional expertise, industry experience and backgrounds, and the inclusion of two female Directors. All members of the Board bring extensive senior management experience, supporting effective governance and strategic oversight. Therefore, the Board considers that the deviation from code provision B.3.5 of the CG Code is appropriate. The Board will continue to review the composition of the Nomination Committee, and will consider appointing a director of a different gender to the Nomination Committee at a time when it is appropriate and suitable by taking into account the circumstances of the Company. Model Code for Securities Transactions by Directors The Company has adopted as its code of conduct regarding directors ’ securities transactions, the Model Code for Securities Transactions by Directors of Listed Issuers (the “Model Code”) as set out in Appendix C3 to the Listing Rules. Upon specific enquiry being made of all Directors, each of them has confirmed their compliance with the required standards set out in the Model Code throughout the six months ended 30 June 2026 and up to the date of this announcement.
– 27 –
Audit Committee There was no change in the composition of the Audit Committee during the six months ended 30 June 2026. The primary duties of the Audit Committee continue to be to review the adequacy of the financial reporting and internal control systems of the Group, oversee the external and internal audit processes, review the Group’s management of its existing and potential risks, review connected transactions and perform other duties and responsibilities as delegated by the Board. For the six months ended 30 June 2026, the Audit Committee met the external auditors to discuss their findings during the audit of the consolidated financial statements for the year ended 31 December 2025. Nothing of a significant nature regarding internal controls and risk management was reported. The Audit Committee reviewed the actions taken by management to address the findings and was satisfied the actions were appropriate and effective. In respect of the work of the Internal Audit in examining the application of policies and internal controls in specific locations within the Group, the Audit Committee was again satisfied with the high quality of the work undertaken. Nothing of a material nature was revealed and appropriate remedial measures to strengthen compliance further are being implemented. The Audit Committee reviewed the quality of the work of the external auditors together with their independence and was satisfied with both. It recommended to the Board the reappointment of Messrs. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu as the Company’s auditors for the ensuing year. The Audit Committee has reviewed, together with the management of the Group, the accounting principles and policies adopted by the Group and discussed with them the unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements and interim report of the Group for the six months ended 30 June 2026, recommending their adoption by the Board. The Audit Committee continued, during the first half year, its periodic reviews of the approved connected transactions and expenditure. In addition, the unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements of the Group for the six months ended 30 June 2026 have been reviewed by the independent auditors of the Company, Messrs. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu. Risk Management and Internal Control Systems The Board is responsible for ensuring the Group establishes and maintains appropriate and effective risk management and internal control systems. The Board is satisfied with the effectiveness of the risk management and internal control systems in place.
– 28 –
The Board’s oversight of the Company’s risk management and internal control systems, both directly and via the Audit Committee, is on-going. In this regard, the Audit Committee reviewed the progress of the Company’s cyber security initiatives, their roll out within the Group and statistics of cyber attacks, their nature and location. The Audit Committee was satisfied with the defences in place and remedial actions taken. Various assessments of the Group ’ s information technology (IT) environment had been undertaken to identify any potential vulnerability in cyber security. Among other important risks examined, business compliance was reviewed. Business compliance is a complex area and the Audit Committee is satisfied with the steps taken so far. The Group has a written risk assessment process to identify, evaluate and manage significant risks. The Audit Committee satisfied itself, upon review, that the process continued to be implemented effectively. The Board being responsible for the structure and effectiveness of both the risk management and internal control systems, the Audit Committee also satisfied itself regarding the appropriateness and strength of internal controls. The Audit Committee continued its practice of reviewing risks pertaining to the Company as a standing item at each of its meetings inviting input from the Chief Financial Officer and the relevant management of the Company. It used the reviews as an important factor in determining the priorities of the Internal Audit programmes. Publication of Information on the Website of the Stock Exchange This announcement is published on the website of the Stock Exchange at http://www.hkexnews.hk and the website of the Company at http://www.crystalgroup.com. The 2026 interim report of the Company for the six months ended 30 June 2026 will be made available (and dispatched, where applicable) to Shareholders and published on the respective websites of the Stock Exchange and the Company in due course. By Order of the Board Crystal International Group Limited LO Lok Fung Kenneth Chairman Hong Kong, 19 August 2026
At the date of this announcement, the Board comprises Mr. LO Lok Fung Kenneth, Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne, Mr. LO Ching Leung Andrew, Mr. WONG Sing Wah and Mr. LO Howard Ching Ho, as executive directors; Mr. WONG Chi Fai and Mr. LEE Kean Phi Mark, as non-executive directors; and Mr. CHANG George Ka Ki, Mr. MAK Wing Sum Alvin, Mr. WONG Siu Kee and Mrs. MAK TANG Pik Yee Agnes, as independent non-executive directors.
– 29 –
Announcement date
19 August 2026
Status
New announcement
Information relating to the dividend Dividend type
Interim (Semi-annual)
Dividend nature
Ordinary
For the financial year end
31 December 2026
Reporting period end for the dividend declared
30 June 2026
Dividend declared
HKD 0.18 per share
Date of shareholders' approval
Not applicable
Information relating to Hong Kong share register Default currency and amount in which the dividend will be paid
HKD 0.18 per share
Exchange rate
HKD 1 : HKD 1
Ex-dividend date
02 September 2026
Latest time to lodge transfer documents for registration with share registrar for 03 September 2026 16:30 determining entitlement to the dividend Book close period
From 04 September 2026 to 08 September 2026
Record date
08 September 2026
Payment date
17 September 2026 Computershare Hong Kong Investor Services Limited Shops 1712–1716, 17th Floor
Share registrar and its address
Hopewell Centre 183 Queen’s Road East Wanchai Hong Kong
Page 1 of 2
v 1.1.1
EF001 Information relating to withholding tax Details of withholding tax applied to the dividend declared
Not applicable
Information relating to listed warrants / convertible securities issued by the issuer Details of listed warrants / convertible securities issued by the issuer
Not applicable
Other information Other information
Not applicable
Directors of the issuer At the date of this announcement, the board of directors of the Company comprises Mr. LO Lok Fung Kenneth, Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne, Mr. LO Ching Leung Andrew, Mr. WONG Sing Wah and Mr. LO Howard Ching Ho, as executive directors; Mr. WONG Chi Fai and Mr. LEE Kean Phi Mark, as non-executive directors; and Mr. CHANG George Ka Ki, Mr. MAK Wing Sum Alvin, Mr. WONG Siu Kee and Mrs. MAK TANG Pik Yee Agnes, as independent non-executive directors.
Page 2 of 2
v 1.1.1
At the annual general meeting (the “AGM”) of Crystal International Group Limited (the “Company”) held on 29 May 2026, all the proposed resolutions as set out in the notice of the AGM dated 24 April 2026 were taken by poll. The poll results are as follows: Number of Votes (%)
Ordinary Resolutions**
**
For
Against
To receive the audited consolidated financial statements 2,578,108,397 and the reports of the directors and auditors for the year (99.990983%) ended 31 December 2025.
232,481 (0.009017%)
To declare a final dividend of HK24.5 cents per 2,578,340,878 ordinary share for the year ended 31 December 2025. (100%)
0 (0%)
3(a).
To re-elect Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne as an 2,574,806,243 executive director of the Company. (99.862910%)
3,534,635 (0.137090%)
3(b).
To re-elect Mr. WONG Chi Fai as a non-executive 2,574,232,143 director of the Company. (99.840644%)
4,108,735 (0.159356%)
3(c).
To re-elect Mr. MAK Wing Sum Alvin as an 2,472,731,146 independent non-executive director of the Company. (95.903965%)
105,609,732 (4.096035%)
For identification purposes only The full text of the resolutions is set out in the notice of the AGM
1
Number of Votes (%)
Ordinary Resolutions**
For 3(d). To re-elect Mrs. MAK TANG Pik Yee Agnes as an 2,576,705,378 independent non-executive director of the Company. (99.936568%)
Against 1,635,500 (0.063432 %)
3(e). To authorise the board of directors to fix the respective 2,577,677,297 directors’ remuneration. (99.974263%)
663,581 (0.025737%)
To re-appoint Messrs. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu as 2,512,795,258 auditors and to authorise the board of directors to fix (97.457837%) their remuneration.
65,545,620 (2.542163%)
To give a general mandate to the directors to repurchase 2,578,307,878 shares of the Company not exceeding 10% of the total (99.998720%) number of issued shares of the Company (excluding treasury shares, if any) at the date of the passing of this resolution.
33,000 (0.001280%)
To give a general mandate to the directors to issue, allot 2,345,880,142 and deal with additional shares (including sale or (90.984096%) transfer of treasury shares, if any) of the Company not exceeding 20% of the total number of issued shares of the Company (excluding treasury shares, if any) at the date of the passing of this resolution.
232,460,736 (9.015904%)
To extend the general mandate granted to the directors 2,438,290,042 to issue, allot and deal with additional shares (including (94.568180%) sale or transfer of treasury shares, if any) in the capital of the Company by the aggregate number of the shares repurchased by the Company.
140,050,836 (5.431820%)
As more than 50% of the votes were cast in favour of each of the resolutions numbered 1 to 7, these resolutions were duly passed as ordinary resolutions. **
The full text of the resolutions is set out in the notice of the AGM
Notes: (a)
At the date of the AGM, (i) the total number of shares of the Company in issue was 2,852,822,000 shares; (ii) there were no treasury shares held by the Company; and (iii) there were no repurchased shares which are pending cancellation and should be excluded from the total number of issued shares of the Company for the purpose of the AGM.
(b)
The total number of shares of the Company entitling the holder to attend and vote on the resolutions at the AGM was 2,852,822,000 shares.
(c)
There were no shares entitling the holders to attend and abstain from voting in favour of the resolutions at the AGM as set out in rule 13.40 of the Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (the “Listing Rules”).
(d)
There were no shareholders of the Company who are required under the Listing Rules to abstain from voting on the resolutions at the AGM.
2
(e)
None of the shareholders of the Company have stated their intention in the Company’s circular dated 24 April 2026 to vote against or to abstain from voting on any of the resolutions at the AGM.
(f)
The Company’s Hong Kong share registrar, Computershare Hong Kong Investor Services Limited, acted as the scrutineer for the vote-taking at the AGM.
(g)
All directors attended the AGM.
By Order of the Board Crystal International Group Limited LO Lok Fung Kenneth Chairman Hong Kong, 29 May 2026 At the date of this announcement, the board of directors of the Company comprises Mr. LO Lok Fung Kenneth, Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne, Mr. LO Ching Leung Andrew, Mr. WONG Sing Wah and Mr. LO Howard Ching Ho, as executive directors; Mr. WONG Chi Fai and Mr. LEE Kean Phi Mark, as non-executive directors; and Mr. CHANG George Ka Ki, Mr. MAK Wing Sum Alvin, Mr. WONG Siu Kee and Mrs. MAK TANG Pik Yee Agnes, as independent non-executive directors.
3
FINANCIAL HIGHLIGHTS •
Revenue for the year ended 31 December 2025 amounted to US$2,641 million (2024: US$2,470 million).
•
Net profit for the year ended 31 December 2025 amounted to US$225 million (2024: US$201 million).
•
Proposed to declare a final dividend of HK24.5 cents (approximately US3.1 cents) per ordinary share. Together with the interim dividend paid, total dividend per ordinary share for the year ended 31 December 2025 would amount to HK40.8 cents (2024: HK38.3 cents).
ANNUAL RESULTS The board (the “Board”) of directors (the “Directors”) of Crystal International Group Limited (the “Company”) is pleased to announce the audited consolidated financial results of the Company and its subsidiaries (together, the “Group” or “Crystal”) for the year ended 31 December 2025, together with the comparative figures for the year ended 31 December 2024.
For identification purposes only
–1–
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF PROFIT OR LOSS AND OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2025 NOTES Revenue Cost of sales
3
Gross profit Other income, gains or losses Impairment losses reversed (recognised) – under expected credit loss model, net Selling and distribution expenses Administrative expenses Research and development expenses Finance costs Share of results of associates Profit before tax Income tax expense
4 5
Profit for the year Other comprehensive (expense) income Items that may be reclassified subsequently to profit or loss: Exchange difference arising on translation of foreign operations Fair value changes on trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income Impairment loss on trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income under expected credit loss model
Items that will not be reclassified subsequently to profit or loss: Surplus on revaluation of properties Deferred tax expense arising on revaluation of properties
Other comprehensive income (expense) for the year Total comprehensive income for the year –2–
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
2,641,179 (2,115,482)
2,469,629 (1,983,406)
525,697 21,585
486,223 30,360
4,742 (43,807) (183,515) (34,560) (12,477) 854
(3,255) (39,209) (181,390) (32,441) (11,238) (940)
278,519 (53,684)
248,110 (47,282)
224,835
200,828
(1,848)
(13,667)
173
(978)
4
55
(1,671)
(14,590)
3,611
10,718
(773)
(2,586)
2,838
8,132
1,167
(6,458)
226,002
194,370
NOTE Profit for the year attributable to: Owners of the Company Non-controlling interests
Total comprehensive income for the year attributable to: Owners of the Company Non-controlling interests
Basic earnings per share for profit attributable to the owners of the Company (US cents)
–3–
6
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
224,658 177
200,498 330
224,835
200,828
225,825 177
194,040 330
226,002
194,370
7.87
7.03
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION AT 31 DECEMBER 2025 NOTES ASSETS Non-current assets Property, plant and equipment Right-of-use assets Deposits paid for acquisition of property, plant and equipment Goodwill Intangible assets Interests in associates Loan receivables Deferred taxation assets
Current assets Inventories Right-of-use assets Trade, bills and other receivables Trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income Amounts due from related companies Loan receivables Tax recoverable Short-term bank deposits Bank balances and cash
Total assets
–4–
8 9
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
686,315 118,083
599,409 115,174
19,910 74,941 61,274 12,339 485 2,513
22,295 74,941 66,191 11,793 686 3,627
975,860
894,116
321,605 3,042 142,882
281,434 1,465 206,086
355,792 217 954 2,305 – 382,310
294,586 218 227 2,862 146,744 426,715
1,209,107
1,360,337
2,184,967
2,254,453
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
EQUITY AND LIABILITIES Capital and reserves Share capital Reserves
3,654 1,604,470
3,654 1,527,002
Equity attributable to owners of the Company Non-controlling interests
1,608,124 3,561
1,530,656 4,790
Total equity
1,611,685
1,535,446
– 22,388 35,241
352 17,415 36,308
57,629
54,075
469,087 13,253 10,859 22,454 –
477,694 10,313 6,663 23,291 146,971
515,653
664,932
2,184,967
2,254,453
NOTE
Non-current liabilities Other payables Lease liabilities Deferred taxation liabilities
10
Current liabilities Trade and other payables Lease liabilities Amounts due to associates Tax liabilities Bank borrowings
10
Total equity and liabilities
–5–
NOTES TO THE CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 31 DECEMBER 2025 1.
GENERAL INFORMATION The Company was previously incorporated in Bermuda as an exempted company with limited liability and registered by way of continuation in the Cayman Islands as an exempted company with limited liability. The Company is directly held by its controlling shareholders, Mr. LO Lok Fung Kenneth and Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne, both executive directors of the Company. The address of the registered office of the Company is Ugland House, P.O. Box 309, Grand Cayman, KY1-1104, Cayman Islands and the principal place of business of the Company is 5–7/F., AXA Tower, Landmark East, No. 100 How Ming Street, Kowloon, Hong Kong. The shares of the Company were listed on the Main Board of The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (the “Stock Exchange”) on 3 November 2017. The consolidated financial statements are presented in United States dollars (“US$”), which is also the functional currency of the Company.
APPLICATION OF NEW AND AMENDMENTS TO IFRS ACCOUNTING STANDARDS Amendments to an IFRS Accounting Standard that are mandatorily effective for the current year In the current year, the Group has applied the following amendments to an IFRS Accounting Standard as issued by the International Accounting Standards Board (“IASB”), for the first time, which are mandatorily effective for the Group’s annual period beginning on 1 January 2025 for the preparation of the Group’s consolidated financial statements: Amendments to IAS 21
Lack of Exchangeability
The application of the amendments to an IFRS Accounting Standard in the current year has had no material impact on the Group’s financial positions and performance for the current and prior years and/or on the disclosures set out in these consolidated financial statements.
–6–
REVENUE AND SEGMENT INFORMATION (a)
Revenue The Group is principally engaged in the manufacturing and trading of garments. All revenue generated by the Group is recognised at the point when control of the goods has transferred to the customers, being when the goods have arrived at the specific location (delivery).
(b)
Segment information Information reported to the chief executive officer of the Group, being the chief operating decision maker (“CODM”), for the purposes of resource allocation and assessment of segment performances, focuses on types of products. (i)
Lifestyle wear
(ii)
Sportswear and outdoor apparel
(iii) Denim (iv)
Intimate
(v)
Sweater
These operating segments also represent the Group’s reportable segments. No operating segments identified by the CODM have been aggregated in arriving at the reportable segments of the Group. Segment revenue and results The following is an analysis of the Group’s revenue and results by operating segments: Year ended 31 December 2025
Lifestyle wear US$’000
Sportswear and outdoor apparel US$’000
Denim US$’000
Intimate US$’000
Sweater US$’000
SEGMENT REVENUE External sales
743,895
598,963
539,964
466,260
292,097 2,641,179
Segment profit
151,390
125,176
90,311
94,416
64,404
Total US$’000
525,697 21,585
Other income, gains or losses Impairment losses reversed under expected credit loss model, net Selling and distribution expenses Administrative expenses Research and development expenses Finance costs Share of results of associates
4,742 (43,807) (183,515) (34,560) (12,477) 854
Profit before tax
278,519
–7–
Year ended 31 December 2024
Lifestyle wear US$’000
Sportswear and outdoor apparel US$’000
Denim US$’000
Intimate US$’000
Sweater US$’000
SEGMENT REVENUE External sales
694,237
554,603
518,920
434,782
267,087 2,469,629
Segment profit
134,591
114,490
85,047
90,473
61,622
Total US$’000
486,223
Other income, gains or losses Impairment losses recognised under expected credit loss model, net Selling and distribution expenses Administrative expenses Research and development expenses Finance costs Share of results of associates
30,360 (3,255) (39,209) (181,390) (32,441) (11,238) (940)
Profit before tax
248,110
Segment profit represents the profit earned by each segment without allocation of other income, gains or losses, impairment losses reversed (recognised) under expected credit loss model, net, selling and distribution expenses, administrative expenses, research and development expenses, finance costs and share of results of associates. This is the measure reported to the CODM of the Group for the purposes of resource allocation and performance assessment. Certain amounts of depreciation of property, plant and equipment and right-of-use assets are included in the measure of segment results in each segment. No further analysis is presented for certain items included or excluded in the measure of segment results as such information is not regularly provided to the CODM. Segment assets and liabilities No analysis of segment assets or segment liabilities is presented as such information is not regularly provided to the CODM. Revenue from major customers Revenue from a customer individually contributing over 10% of the Group’s revenue is as follows: Segment Customer A
Lifestyle wear, Sportswear and outdoor apparel, Denim, Intimate and Sweater
–8–
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
973,848
898,614
Geographical information Information about the Group’s revenue is presented below by geographical location based on port of discharge:
Asia Pacific (note a) North America Europe (note b) Other countries/regions
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
1,060,193 988,109 511,744 81,133
982,088 942,461 480,265 64,815
2,641,179
2,469,629
Notes: (a)
Asia Pacific primarily includes Japan, the People’s Republic of China (the “PRC”) and South Korea.
(b)
Europe primarily includes the United Kingdom (the “U.K.”), France, Germany and the Netherlands.
Information about the Group’s non-current assets other than deferred taxation, and financial instruments is presented below by geographical location of the assets:
Asia Pacific (note a) Europe (note b)
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
959,883 79
876,766 137
959,962
876,903
Notes: (a)
Asia Pacific primarily includes Bangladesh, Cambodia, Hong Kong, the PRC, Singapore, Sri Lanka and Vietnam.
(b)
Europe primarily includes the U.K..
–9–
PROFIT BEFORE TAX 2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
Directors’ emoluments Other staff costs Retirement benefit schemes contributions for other staff
5,898 584,257 66,380
6,460 530,846 57,692
Total staff costs (note a)
656,535
594,998
864 460
824 214
2,117,609 60,231 21,007
1,983,406 63,065 16,439
4,917 –
4,917 125
(2,127) (43) 13
– (515) –
– (15,846) 8,453 (4,578)
154 (23,020) 7,022 (5,913)
1,501 3,733 7,243
1,364 3,131 6,743
Profit before tax has been arrived at after charging (crediting):
Auditors’ remuneration: – audit services – non-audit services Cost of inventories recognised as expenses (including write-down of inventories amounting to US$17,359,000 (2024: US$15,244,000)) (note a) Depreciation of property, plant and equipment (note a) Depreciation of right-of-use assets (note a) Amortisation of intangible asset (included in selling and distribution expenses) Impairment loss on interest in an associate Impairment loss reversed in respect of property, plant and equipment (included in cost of sales) Gain on disposals of property, plant and equipment Loss on termination of leases Net loss arising from changes in fair value of derivative financial instruments Interest income Net foreign exchange loss Government grants (note b) Finance costs: – interest expense on lease liabilities – interest on bank borrowings – interest on factoring arrangement Notes: (a)
Cost of inventories recognised as expenses include staff costs, depreciation of property, plant and equipment and depreciation of right-of-use assets used for production, which amounts are also included in the respective total amounts disclosed separately above.
(b)
During the year ended 31 December 2025, the Group recognised government grants of US$4,578,000 (2024: US$5,913,000) from government authorities in different countries to support the operations of subsidiaries of the Company.
– 10 –
INCOME TAX EXPENSE 2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
The income tax expense comprises: Hong Kong Profits Tax – current year – over-provision in prior years Overseas taxation – current year – (over)under-provision in prior years Income tax under Pillar Two Rules
25,204 (190)
24,593 (121)
28,142 (160) 1,664
25,094 112 –
Deferred taxation
54,660 (976)
49,678 (2,396)
53,684
47,282
Under the two-tiered profits tax rates regime, the first HK$2 million of profits of the qualifying group entity are taxed at 8.25%, and profits above HK$2 million are taxed at 16.5%. The profits of group entities not qualifying for the two-tiered profits tax rates regime continue to be taxed at a flat rate of 16.5%. The directors of the Company consider the amount involved upon implementation of the two-tiered profits tax rates regime as insignificant to the consolidated financial statements. Hong Kong Profits Tax is calculated at 16.5% of the estimated assessable profit for both years. Under the Law of the PRC on Enterprise Income Tax (the “EIT Law”) and Implementation Regulation of the EIT Law, the tax rate of the PRC subsidiaries is 25% for both years. Certain subsidiaries incorporated in Cambodia are exempted from tax on profit in both years while they fulfil certain requirements pursuant to the relevant laws and regulations in Cambodia. Taxation arising in other jurisdictions is calculated at the rates prevailing in the relevant jurisdictions. The Group is subject to the global minimum top-up tax Pillar Two Rules. Pillar Two Rules have become effective in certain jurisdictions, where the annual effective income tax rate is also estimated to be below 15%. Therefore, a top-up tax is accrued in the current period using the tax rate based on the estimated adjusted covered taxes and net globe income for the year. The Group has recognised a current tax expense of US$1,664,000 related to the top-up tax for the year ended 31 December 2025 which is expected to be levied on the Company.
– 11 –
EARNINGS PER SHARE The calculation of the basic earnings per share attributable to the owners of the Company is based on the following data:
Earnings: Profit for the year attributable to the owners of the Company for the purpose of calculating basic earnings per share
Number of shares: Number of ordinary shares for the purpose of calculating basic earnings per share
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
224,658
200,498
’000
’000
2,852,822
2,852,822
No diluted earnings per share was presented for the years ended 31 December 2025 and 2024 as there were no potential dilutive ordinary shares in issue during both years. 7.
DIVIDENDS
Final, paid – HK19.0 cents per ordinary share for 2024 (2024: HK13.0 cents per ordinary share for 2023) Interim, paid – HK16.3 cents per ordinary share for 2025 (2024: HK13.8 cents per ordinary share for 2024) Special, paid – HK5.5 cents per ordinary share for 2024 (2024: nil for 2023)
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
69,055
47,434
59,312
50,392
19,990
–
148,357
97,826
A final dividend of HK24.5 cents (2024: HK19.0 cents) per ordinary share in total of HK$698,941,000 (equivalent to US$89,814,000) (2024: HK$542,036,000 (equivalent to US$69,055,000)), in respect of the year ended 31 December 2025 has been proposed by the directors of the Company and is subject to approval by the shareholders of the Company in the forthcoming annual general meeting.
– 12 –
TRADE, BILLS AND OTHER RECEIVABLES 2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
Trade receivables – contracts with customers Less: allowance for expected credit losses
86,325 (517)
159,209 (4,801)
Bills receivable Temporary payments to suppliers Other receivables, deposits and prepayments
85,808 7,758 10,817 38,499
154,408 1,473 13,988 36,217
142,882
206,086
The following is an aged analysis of trade receivables, net of allowance for credit losses, based on invoice dates.
Within 60 days 61 to 90 days 91 to 120 days Over 120 days
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
78,497 5,907 780 624
121,978 31,242 1,077 111
85,808
154,408
TRADE RECEIVABLES AT FAIR VALUE THROUGH OTHER COMPREHENSIVE INCOME As part of the Group’s cash flow management, the Group factors certain trade receivables to financial institutions before the receivables are due for payment. The factored trade receivables are derecognised on the basis that the Group has transferred substantially all the risks and rewards to the relevant counterparties. Such trade receivables that are held for the collection of contractual cash flows and sale of financial assets, have been classified as trade receivables at fair value through other comprehensive income (“FVTOCI”). The following is an aged analysis of trade receivables at FVTOCI based on invoice dates.
Within 60 days 61 to 90 days 91 to 120 days Over 120 days
– 13 –
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
240,205 107,253 7,237 1,097
236,485 45,972 9,834 2,295
355,792
294,586
TRADE AND OTHER PAYABLES 2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
Trade payables Bills payable
198,612 4,295
176,404 3,476
Accrued staff cost Other payables Other accruals
202,907 111,815 58,639 95,726
179,880 122,280 66,348 109,538
Total trade and other payables
469,087
478,046
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
469,087 –
477,694 352
469,087
478,046
Analysed for reporting purposes as:
Current Non-current
The following is an aged analysis of trade and bills payables based on invoice dates.
Within 60 days 61 to 90 days 91 to 120 days Over 120 days
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
162,810 26,284 12,254 1,559
160,336 17,689 1,140 715
202,907
179,880
PLEDGE OF ASSETS At the end of the reporting period, the Group had the following assets pledged to banks as security for general banking facilities granted to the Group:
Property, plant and equipment Inventories
– 14 –
2025 US$’000
2024 US$’000
1,559 3,270
1,574 3,333
4,829
4,907
MANAGEMENT DISCUSSION AND ANALYSIS MARKET OVERVIEW In 2025, the global apparel industry continued the growth momentum of the previous year, although performance varied among apparel brands. End-customer demand remained resilient, characterised by a focus on product differentiation and price sensitivity. Apparel brands that adapted swiftly to market changes and continued product development were better positioned to capture consumer preferences. During the reporting period, the reciprocal tariff policy implemented by the United States of America (“USA”) presented the most prominent challenge for the garment industry. Particularly in the initial phase of its implementation, policy fluctuation created uncertainty within the global apparel supply chain. However, with the rollout of the final tariff scheme, the differential tariff rates across key garment-exporting countries proved less severe than the initial concerns. Additionally, cost pressures stemming from tariffs were gradually passed on to consumers. Consequently, the overall operational impact on garment manufacturers remained manageable. Brand customers refocused their purchasing priorities on core elements, such as overall supply chain efficiency and response speed. Meanwhile, Vietnam further strengthened its position as a preferred destination for labour-intensive manufacturing. In particular, following the implementation of USA tariffs, an increasing number of Chinese companies relocated their production lines to Vietnam. Strong growth in labour demand intensified competition in the local labour market. Rising employment costs and shortages of skilled workers posed new challenges for business expansion in Vietnam. BUSINESS REVIEW Leveraging its co-creation business model and diversified multi-category product portfolio, the Group deepened collaboration with brand customers, supporting them to respond quickly to evolving consumer needs for differentiation and value. This strategy enabled the Group to gain market share among key brand customers and achieve revenue growth across all five business segments. In response to the uncertainties stemming from the USA reciprocal tariff policy, the Group relied on its global production network and strong brand customer partnerships to effectively mitigate tariff-related disruptions. Continued investment in automation upgrades and production optimisation further offset the pricing pressures from tariffs, contributing to improved operating returns. Vietnam, currently the Group’s largest production base, faced intensifying labour market competition, which imposed constraints on the Group’s growth. Some enterprises raised recruitment packages to attract skilled workers to accelerate shipments during tariff window periods. Such workforce mobility adversely affected the Group’s overall productivity. To address labour market dynamics in Vietnam, the Group initiated satellite factories towards the end of 2025 to broaden access to labour pools and improve recruitment flexibility. – 15 –
The Group’s revenue for the year ended 31 December 2025 increased by 6.9% to US$2,641 million (2024: US$2,470 million). The gross profit margin increased to 19.9% in 2025 from 19.7% in 2024. The net profit margin expanded to 8.5% in 2025 from 8.1% in 2024. The Group’s net profit for the year ended 31 December 2025 increased by 12.0% to US$225 million (2024: US$201 million). Consistent with practice of sharing its operation results with shareholders, the Board has proposed a final dividend of HK24.5 cents per ordinary share. Together with the interim dividend declared and paid, the total dividend per ordinary share for the year ended 31 December 2025 will amount to HK40.8 cents. During the reporting period, capital expenditure totalled US$183 million, with approximately 66% allocated to increasing garment production capacity and automation upgrades, and the remainder supporting upstream fabric business development. As part of the Group’s overarching sustainability strategy, it continued to make steadfast progress towards its Crystal Sustainability Vision 2030 and Net Zero 2050 vision to tackle broader environmental, people and community challenges. To ramp up its decarbonisation efforts, the Group progressively increased its solar photovoltaic (“PV”) installations in its operating countries, expanding its total PV capacity to 23MW. Solar electricity generated accounted for approximately 15% of the electricity consumed in factories with solar PV systems. The Group is also conducting a consultancy study on a solar roadmap to maximise its potential solar capacity. Regarding social sustainability, the Group joined Reimagining Industry to Support Equality (RISE), an industry-transforming initiative to promote women’s empowerment and accelerate gender equality across global factories. In recognition of its collective efforts and achievements, the Group was honoured to receive the Sustainable Corporate Leadership Award in the Standard Chartered Corporate Achievement Awards 2025 and the Distinction Award (Large Organisations Category) in the Hong Kong Management Association’s Hong Kong Sustainability Award 2025. In addition, the Group was commended for the Best ESG Report – Midcap, the Carbon Neutral Award, and the Excellence in Environmental Positive Impact in the Hong Kong ESG Reporting Awards 2025.
– 16 –
FINANCIAL REVIEW Revenue The Group’s revenue for 2025 compared to 2024, by product category, each expressed as an absolute amount and as a percentage of total revenue was: For the year ended 31 December 2025 2024 US$’000 % US$’000 Lifestyle wear Sportswear and outdoor apparel Denim Intimate Sweater Total Revenue
%
743,895 598,963 539,964 466,260 292,097
28.2% 22.7% 20.4% 17.7% 11.0%
694,237 554,603 518,920 434,782 267,087
28.1% 22.5% 21.0% 17.6% 10.8%
2,641,179
100.0%
2,469,629
100.0%
Despite the impact of tariff headwinds, the Group’s revenue increased by 6.9% in 2025, driven by resilient sales order demand. The Group’s sales analysed by geographic region based on port of discharge were: For the year ended 31 December 2025 2024 US$’000 % US$’000
%
Asia Pacific (note a) North America Europe (note b) Other countries/regions
1,060,193 988,109 511,744 81,133
40.1% 37.4% 19.4% 3.1%
982,088 942,461 480,265 64,815
39.8% 38.2% 19.4% 2.6%
Total Revenue
2,641,179
100.0%
2,469,629
100.0%
Notes: (a)
Asia Pacific primarily includes Japan, the PRC and South Korea.
(b)
Europe mainly includes the U.K., France, Germany, and the Netherlands.
– 17 –
Gross Profit and Gross Profit Margin For the year ended 31 December 2025 2024 Gross Gross Gross Profit Gross Profit Profit Margin Profit Margin US$’000 % US$’000 % Lifestyle wear Sportswear and outdoor apparel Denim Intimate Sweater
151,390 125,176 90,311 94,416 64,404
20.4% 20.9% 16.7% 20.2% 22.0%
134,591 114,490 85,047 90,473 61,622
19.4% 20.6% 16.4% 20.8% 23.1%
Total Gross Profit
525,697
19.9%
486,223
19.7%
Gross profit margin increased from 19.7% in 2024 to 19.9% in 2025, reflecting efficiency improvements from automation that partially offset the negative impact of tariffs. For Lifestyle wear, increase in gross profit margin was mainly due to improvement in production efficiency. For Sweater, decrease in gross profit margin was mainly due to more conventional sweaters with lower gross margin. Other Expenses and Finance Costs Selling and distribution expenses remained stable at 1.7% in 2025, compared with 1.6% in 2024. Administrative, research and development expenses, and other income remained stable at 7.4% in both 2025 and 2024. The effective borrowing rate for the Group in 2025 ranged from 1.52% to 5.67% compared to 4.61% to 6.65% in 2024. The Group had no fixed-rate borrowings at 31 December 2025. Finance costs amounted to 0.5% of revenue for both years. Net Profit With improvement in the gross profit margin, the Group achieved a net profit of US$225 million for the year ended 31 December 2025. Net profit as a percentage of revenue increased from 8.1% in 2024 to 8.5% in 2025. Capital Management The consolidated financial position of the Group remained sound throughout the year. The positive operating cash flow of US$266 million (2024: US$106 million) contributed to cash balances of US$382 million at 31 December 2025, compared to US$427 million at 31 December 2024. Cash balances were mainly denominated in HK$ and US$. Bank borrowings, mainly denominated in HK$ and US$, have decreased from US$147 million at 31 December 2024 to nil at 31 December 2025. – 18 –
The Group held a positive net cash position of US$382 million at 31 December 2025. The gearing ratio (total interest-bearing bank borrowings, less bank balances and cash, divided by total equity) at 31 December 2025 was nil (31 December 2024: nil). Our conversion cycle has been increased from 71 days in 2024 to 81 days in 2025. With less factoring arrangement for low risk customers, turnover of trade and bills receivables averaged 62 days in 2025, compared with 52 days average turnover throughout 2024. Inventory turnover averaged 52 days in 2025, compared with 48 days throughout 2024. Trade and bills payables turnover averaged 33 days in 2025 compared to 29 days throughout 2024. Capital expenditure incurred, in the main, for the building, equipping and upgrading of production facilities, has been carefully managed. In 2025, capital expenditure amounted to US$183 million, compared to US$160 million in 2024. Capital commitments at 31 December 2025 were US$80 million compared to US$52 million at 31 December 2024. Foreign currency exchange contracts are used to manage foreign currency exposure. The Group’s policy is to monitor its foreign currency exposure and use foreign currency exchange contracts, as appropriate, to minimise its foreign currency risks. Funding and Treasury Policy The Group has adopted a prudent treasury policy and thus maintained a healthy liquidity position throughout the year. The Group strives to reduce credit risk by performing ongoing credit assessments and evaluations of the financial status of its customers. The Group regularly reviews its funding requirements to maintain adequate financial resources in order to support its current business operations as well as its future investments and expansion plans. Pledge of Assets At 31 December 2025, pledge of assets of the Group are set out in note 11 to the consolidated financial statements included at the start of this announcement. Acquisitions and Disposals of Subsidiaries, Associates and Joint Ventures For the year ended 31 December 2025, the Group had no material acquisitions and disposals of subsidiaries, associates and joint ventures. Significant Investment Held For the year ended 31 December 2025, the Group held no significant investments. Material Acquisitions and Future Plans for Major Investment The Group continues to invest in vertical upstream integration. Besides, the Group intends to extend its production facilities into Egypt. The deployment of garment and fabric operational expansion will help disperse geopolitical risks, provide global customers with more flexible and reliable production solutions, and assist the Group in effectively responding to potential changes in trade policies. – 19 –
Contingent Liabilities At 31 December 2025, the Group had no material contingent liability (31 December 2024: nil). Subsequent Events after the Reporting Period On 18 January 2026 (Egypt time), the Group reserved a land parcel located in Egypt at consideration of US$30.4 million. The land acquisition is subject to the approval of the Egyptian local government. The land parcel is located in the New October Industrial Zone in New October City, Egypt. It has a total site area of approximately 800,000 sq.m. For details, please refer to the announcement of the Company dated 20 January 2026. EMPLOYMENT, TRAINING AND DEVELOPMENT The Group employed around 81,000 people at 31 December 2025. Total staff costs, including administrative and management staff, for the year ended 31 December 2025 equated to 24.9% of revenue, compared with 24.1% in 2024. The Group remunerates its staff according to their performance, qualifications, and industry practices, and conducts regular reviews of its remuneration policy. Employees may receive discretionary bonuses and monetary rewards based on their ratings in the annual performance appraisals. The Group also offers rewards or other incentives to motivate the personal growth and career development of its employees, such as ongoing opportunities for training to enhance their technical and product knowledge, as well as their knowledge of industry quality standards. Each new employee of the Group is required to attend an introductory course, and various types of training courses are available to all employees of the Group. OUTLOOK AND PROSPECTS Entering 2026, the Group is placing greater emphasis on improving the capabilities of its unskilled workforce to drive productivity improvement. Consequently, the Group moderated the pace of expansion in Vietnam, prioritising workforce upskilling and efficiency gains. The Group has developed a systematic approach to address its long-term development needs, including acquiring land in Egypt for future expansion. Leveraging Egypt’s geographic advantages, favourable trade policies, and abundant labour resources, the Group aims to accelerate capacity growth and further diversify its production footprint. The Group will continue to deepen vertical integration. The self-built fabric mill in Vietnam is scheduled to commence operations by the end of 2026. This will improve the Group’s fabric supply capabilities for the lifestyle and sports categories, enhancing supply chain responsiveness and creating greater synergy. Capital expenditure in 2026 will continue to focus on automation upgrades, garment capacity expansion, and fabric development. Total capital expenditure for 2026 is expected to be significantly higher than that in 2025, owing largely to the one-off expenditure related to land acquisition and expansion in Egypt.
– 20 –
Since robust operational cash flow generation is expected to sufficiently cover the increased capital expenditure, and in light of its net cash position, the Group is wellpositioned to maintain its longstanding dividend policy and share growth achievements with shareholders. OTHER INFORMATION Final Dividend The Board has resolved to propose a final dividend of HK24.5 cents (approximately US3.1 cents) per ordinary share for the year ended 31 December 2025. The proposed final dividend payment is subject to approval by the shareholders of the Company (“Shareholders”) at the annual general meeting (the “AGM”) to be held on Friday, 29 May 2026. If approved by Shareholders, the proposed final dividend is expected to be paid on Friday, 3 July 2026 to Shareholders whose names appear on the register of members of the Company on Tuesday, 23 June 2026. At the date of this announcement, the Company does not hold any treasury shares (whether in the Central Clearing and Settlement System or otherwise). Closure of Register of Members for Entitlement to Attend and Vote at AGM and to Receive the Final Dividend and Record Date The forthcoming AGM will be held on Friday, 29 May 2026. Notice of the AGM will be made available (and sent, where applicable) to Shareholders in due course. For the purpose of determining Shareholders’ eligibility to attend and vote at the AGM, the register of members of the Company will be closed from Tuesday, 26 May 2026 to Friday, 29 May 2026, both days inclusive, during which period no transfer of shares will be registered. The record date for determining the Shareholders’ eligibility to attend and vote at the AGM is Friday, 29 May 2026. In order to qualify to attend and vote at the AGM, all properly completed transfer forms accompanied by the relevant share certificates must be lodged for registration with the Company’s Hong Kong share registrar, Computershare Hong Kong Investor Services Limited at Shops 1712–1716, 17th Floor, Hopewell Centre, 183 Queen’s Road East, Wanchai, Hong Kong no later than 4:30 p.m. on Friday, 22 May 2026. For the purpose of ascertaining Shareholders’ entitlement to the proposed final dividend, the register of members of the Company will be closed from Thursday, 18 June 2026 to Tuesday, 23 June 2026, both days inclusive, during which period no transfer of shares will be registered. The record date for determining the Shareholders’ entitlement to the final dividend is Tuesday, 23 June 2026. To qualify for the proposed final dividend, all properly completed transfer forms accompanied by the relevant share certificates must be lodged for registration with the Company’s Hong Kong share registrar, Computershare Hong Kong Investor Services Limited at Shops 1712–1716, 17th Floor, Hopewell Centre, 183 Queen’s Road East, Wanchai, Hong Kong no later than 4:30 p.m. on Wednesday, 17 June 2026.
– 21 –
Corporate Governance Practices The Group has complied with the Code Provisions set out in Part 2 of the Corporate Governance Code contained in Appendix C1 to the Rules Governing the Listing of Securities on The Stock Exchange of Hong Kong Limited (the “Listing Rules”) for the year ended 31 December 2025, including both the version effective up to 30 June 2025 and the latest version effective from 1 July 2025 (the “Latest Code”), except for the following deviation: Code provision B.3.5 of the Latest Code provides that issuers should appoint at least one director of a different gender to the nomination committee. Although the nomination committee of the Company (the “Nomination Committee”) currently comprises members of single gender, the Company has put in place the board diversity policy and the workforce diversity policy to promote greater diversity and inclusion (including gender diversity) in its recruitment, and the Nomination Committee also takes into consideration the board diversity policy when reviewing the Board composition, appointing and re-appointing Directors and making recommendations for succession planning to facilitate the development of a diverse talent pipeline. In addition, the Board is satisfied that its overall composition has already reflected strong diversity, with a balanced mix of professional expertise, industry experience and backgrounds, and the inclusion of two female Directors. All members of the Board bring extensive senior management experience, supporting effective governance and strategic oversight. Therefore, the Board considers that the deviation from code provision B.3.5 of the Latest Code is appropriate. The Board will continue to review the composition of the Nomination Committee, and will consider appointing a director of a different gender to the Nomination Committee at a time when it is appropriate and suitable by taking into account the circumstances of the Company. Directors’ Securities Transactions The Group has adopted the Model Code for Securities Transactions by Directors of Listed Issuers (the “Model Code”) set out in Appendix C3 to the Listing Rules as its code of conduct regarding directors’ securities transactions. Upon specific enquiry being made of all Directors, each of them has confirmed their compliance with the required standards set out in the Model Code for the year ended 31 December 2025. Purchase, Sale or Redemption of Listed Securities of the Company Neither the Company nor any of its subsidiaries has purchased, sold or redeemed any of the Company’s listed securities (including sale of treasury shares) for the year ended 31 December 2025.
– 22 –
Scope of Work of Messrs. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu The figures in respect of the Group’s consolidated statement of financial position, consolidated statement of profit or loss and other comprehensive income and the related notes thereto for the year ended 31 December 2025 as set out in the preliminary announcement have been agreed by the Group’s auditor, Messrs. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu, to the amounts set out in the audited consolidated financial statements of the Group for the year as approved by the Board on 19 March 2026. The work performed by Messrs. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu in this respect did not constitute an assurance engagement and consequently no opinion or assurance conclusion has been expressed by Messrs. Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu on the preliminary announcement. Audit Committee and Review of the Annual Results The Audit Committee (the “AC”) has reviewed the Group’s audited consolidated financial statements and reports relating to the year ended 31 December 2025 together with the external auditor satisfying itself as to the extent of work done by the external auditor, the consistent application of the Group’s accounting policies, the appropriateness of financial judgements applied, and compliance with Board approved limits of connected transactions. The AC also reviewed the unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements and reports issued by the Group for the six months ended 30 June 2025. The AC is satisfied with the outcome of its various reviews. PUBLICATION OF INFORMATION ON THE WEBSITE OF THE STOCK EXCHANGE This announcement is published on the website of the Stock Exchange at http://www.hkexnews.hk and the website of the Company at http://www.crystalgroup.com, and the annual report of the Company for the year ended 31 December 2025 will be made available (and dispatched, where applicable) to Shareholders and published on the respective websites of the Stock Exchange and the Company in due course. By Order of the Board Crystal International Group Limited LO Lok Fung Kenneth Chairman Hong Kong, 19 March 2026 At the date of this announcement, the Board of Directors of the Company comprises Mr. LO Lok Fung Kenneth, Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne, Mr. LO Ching Leung Andrew, Mr. WONG Sing Wah and Mr. LO Howard Ching Ho, as executive Directors; Mr. WONG Chi Fai and Mr. LEE Kean Phi Mark, as non-executive Directors; and Mr. CHANG George Ka Ki, Mr. MAK Wing Sum Alvin, Mr. WONG Siu Kee and Mrs. MAK TANG Pik Yee Agnes, as independent non-executive Directors.
– 23 –
Announcement date
19 March 2026
Status
New announcement
Information relating to the dividend Dividend type
Final
Dividend nature
Ordinary
For the financial year end
31 December 2025
Reporting period end for the dividend declared
31 December 2025
Dividend declared
HKD 0.245 per share
Date of shareholders' approval
29 May 2026
Information relating to Hong Kong share register Default currency and amount in which the dividend will be paid
HKD 0.245 per share
Exchange rate
HKD 1 : HKD 1
Ex-dividend date
16 June 2026
Latest time to lodge transfer documents for registration with share registrar for 17 June 2026 16:30 determining entitlement to the dividend Book close period
From 18 June 2026 to 23 June 2026
Record date
23 June 2026
Payment date
03 July 2026 Computershare Hong Kong Investor Services Limited Shops 1712–1716, 17th Floor
Share registrar and its address
Hopewell Centre 183 Queen’s Road East Wanchai Hong Kong
Page 1 of 2
v 1.1.1
EF001 Information relating to withholding tax Details of withholding tax applied to the dividend declared
Not applicable
Information relating to listed warrants / convertible securities issued by the issuer Details of listed warrants / convertible securities issued by the issuer
Not applicable
Other information Other information
Not applicable
Directors of the issuer At the date of this announcement, the board of directors of the Company comprises Mr. LO Lok Fung Kenneth, Mrs. LO CHOY Yuk Ching Yvonne, Mr. LO Ching Leung Andrew, Mr. WONG Sing Wah and Mr. LO Howard Ching Ho, as executive directors; Mr. WONG Chi Fai and Mr. LEE Kean Phi Mark, as non-executive directors; and Mr. CHANG George Ka Ki, Mr. MAK Wing Sum Alvin, Mr. WONG Siu Kee and Mrs. MAK TANG Pik Yee Agnes, as independent non-executive directors.
Page 2 of 2
v 1.1.1
Prompts
Click prompts to add them under the company line, click again to take one out, then copy the result into your AI chat. Shared by Asian Century Stocks and Uncovered Thai Stocks. Thank you.
ETFs Holding Crystal International Group Limited
Exchange-traded funds whose newest published daily portfolio holds one of the company's listings, largest weight first.
| ETF | Weight in ETF | Shares | Market value | As of |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| JSTC | 0.05% | 145,399 | $ 151.407K | Nov 17, 2026 |
| AVDV | 0.03% | 5,962,000 | $ 6.215M | Nov 16, 2026 |
| AVSD | 0.02% | 71,500 | $ 74.537K | Nov 16, 2026 |
| DFIS | 0.02% | 890,000 | $ 916.701K | Nov 12, 2026 |
| AVDS | 0.01% | 47,500 | $ 49.517K | Nov 16, 2026 |
| DFIC | 0.01% | 1,034,500 | $ 1.066M | Nov 12, 2026 |
| DFAX | 0.01% | 605,000 | $ 623.151K | Nov 12, 2026 |
| DFSI | 0.00% | 41,000 | $ 42.23K | Nov 12, 2026 |
| DXIV | 0.00% | 7,000 | $ 7,210.01 | Nov 12, 2026 |
| DFAI | 0.00% | 419,500 | $ 432.086K | Nov 12, 2026 |
| AVDE | 0.00% | 234,000 | $ 243.938K | Nov 16, 2026 |
| AVIV | 0.00% | 26,500 | $ 27.625K | Nov 16, 2026 |