
The bar for packaging that balances sustainability with performance is only getting higher. Trying to meet this balance raises some hard questions.
Can recycled fibers go into food packaging without compromising safety? Are there PFAS-free paper coatings that deliver the barrier protection we need? Is a bio-based glycol any different from a fossil one?
Attendees of a recent Packaging Europe webinar put questions like these directly to material and sustainability experts.
Hosted by Packaging Europe’s Tim Skyes, the panel brought together UPM’s Janne Varvemaa, Ashley Drew and Marinela Crisan to explore how material choices can balance circularity, renewable content and performance.
The Q&A toward the end of the webinar proved extremely popular with attendees. The panel fielded questions on topics ranging from the PPWR’s impact on businesses to the performance of specific types of renewable materials.
Unfortunately, the webinar’s clock ran out before everyone got answers. Below, you’ll find a transcript (edited for length and clarity) of some of the questions Janne, Ashley, and Marinela got to during the session, as well as a few extras that they didn’t have time to address.
How can we incorporate recycled paper content into our food packaging?
Janne: A great question. Thanks for it. I would say it's also kind of... I wouldn't call it a misunderstanding, but in many cases, that's not very easy. The main concern is related to the food safety. The vast majority of today's recycled fibres are not food compatible. The circulation is not clean from mineral oils and other such components that we do not want in direct contact with the food. Therefore, it's very difficult to find a decent recycled fibre for the application.
Janne Varvemaa Director, Products and Technology UPM Specialty Materials
More importantly it’s necessary to understand that this kind of requirement for the recycled materials is stemming from the plastic side where it's actually necessary to create a kind of a market for the recycled plastics. And there hasn't been, traditionally, enough outlets for recycled plastics.
The same is not true for the fibre market or paper-based materials. There's a huge secondary market for recycled fibre, container board being by far the biggest component of that. But there are other grades as well, like tissue or newsprint or some other industrial grades. So actually, incorporating recycled fibres into materials requiring food safety, in my opinion, is not the best way to proceed. There might be some, let's say, exceptions to this rule, especially in the areas where the food contact regulation is perhaps not so tight. Or that you have a very, very special niche recycled fibre that can be used. But as a mainstream, I don't think that would be the right way to go.
How do you see converters and brands starting to prepare their packaging for PPWR?
Ashley: Good question. Now that PPWR is applicable as of last month, we are really seeing our customers and brands preparing their DOCs, (declarations of conformity), which we, as the label supplier, would provide technical documentation for supporting that process.
And then of course this PPWR Article 5, which focuses on substances of concern, including PFAS, which is a big topic, especially for food contact applications.
We're also seeing many questions around the design for recycling criteria. There is a lot of education that's happening around the fact that these DFR criteria have not yet been established and integrated into the legislation. We will see that, of course, come in later, in 2028 with the delegated acts for Article 6. I would say there’s quite a lot of activities ongoing at the moment. But from my point of view, this DOC is the most critical, and these Article 5 points. So that's what we're seeing, at least in our markets.
What is the difference between fossil and bio-glycols?
Marinela: Chemically and functionally there is no difference. The BioMEG from our Leuna biorefinery is designed as a 1-to-1 drop-in replacement for its fossil-based equivalent. The only difference is the origin of the carbon, the production pathway, the associated certification, and the carbon footprint. Once converted into PET, the material can use the same manufacturing and recycling infrastructure. And this doesn't stand only for PET production but everywhere where glycols are used. We will produce two types of glycols in Leuna and both are stand-in replacements for the fossil versions.
Do you see any interest in compostable solutions?
Janne: To some extent, yes, although the recyclability seems to be kind of a global trend and I guess in many areas outside of the EU, EU regulation is followed up pretty closely for potential imports to this area, and also seen as kind of the highest standard that there currently is. But of course, recycling is not always the only solution or a perfect solution from that perspective. Even if the material as such is recyclable, it doesn't mean anything if it's not recycled. The recycled-at-scale targets for Europe are valid. But this would also be needed for other parts of the world where the recycling infrastructure is not in such good condition. And therefore, littering-related issues, or mismanaged or overflowing landfills, plays a role in packaging design. Here I would say compostable, or at least biodegradable, solutions come into play. Brand owners don't typically want to market on the packaging based on biodegradability, because they don't want to have it as a kind of a licence to litter or anything like that. But I would consider it an insurance against leakage into nature. So, to some extent yes, there is a need for these solutions as well.
Which kind of renewable bio-based content are you using in your new materials/mediums (for example, flexible packaging and PSA)?
Ashley: From the perspective of label materials, of course, one is wood-based biomaterials. And then the other notable form is from used cooking oil. And then both of those, of course, would also have ISCC plus chain of custody certification for the traceability.
Janne: And if I just continue briefly on that, of course, the renewability with the paper-based packaging is already there. So, the big majority of our material is of renewable origin and bio-origin. But of course, we do have an R&D pipeline where we are looking into these bio-based opportunities and solutions with our co-creation partners. You just need to follow our launches and innovation news to see that these products are there. Perhaps not yet as a huge mainstream because they often start small from startups and evolve into scale-ups and ultimately then into more regular businesses. But I would say we are on the way. But in many cases, of course, many of these let's say incumbent coatings tend to be fossil-based to start with.
PFAS free paper coatings. Are there good solutions available?
Janne: Matching the performance of PFAS-based concepts is not always easy, as applying the grease resistance mainly via coating solutions is not exactly the same as having the body of the paper made greaseproof through the use of PFAS chemistry. Finding cost-effective, recyclable solutions with adequate performance is doable, although in some cases modifications to packaging design may be helpful to ease the task.
Do you see a market shift coming for either papers or films as a direct result of regulatory changes such as PPWR?
Ashley: If we think about what the overall goal of PPWR is, it's really, to enable recyclability at scale and then improve the market harmonization throughout the EU. Of course, a big piece of this is encouraging the design of packaging that can be effectively recycled. And, that means some of these packaging formats need to be shifted to improve their compatibility.
Ashely Drew Manager, Sustainability, EMEIA UPM Adhesive Materials
Maybe one example of this would be fibre-loss paper-based components that are used on plastic substrates. At least from what we can start to see with the CEN standards that were released earlier this year, the trend is moving toward of course, set in stone, but that may be a look toward the direction that at least the plastics side of things is taking on that.
What are the main regulatory drivers you see at the moment for paper-based packaging?
Janne: Development of and adaptation to PPWR secondary legislation for packaging recyclability continues to be the key topic. Also, dual end of life (recyclability AND compostability/biodegradability) development from a global perspective is gaining momentum.
Circular Renewable Black: Are there differences in processability when replacing carbon black with CRB?
Marinela: UPM Circular Renewable Black is designed to be compatible with the existing manufacturing process, so no fundamental process change is expected. But as with any pigment or master batch change, the exact dosage or dispersion or colour targets, mechanical properties, and application-specific compliance should be still validated. The Sesotec results that we have demonstrate the sortability but it should not be proof of every other processing or end-user property. We don't have any indication that changes in process need to be made. But the final product still needs to be validated.
Marinela Crisan Technical Sales Manager UPM Next Generation Renewables
Can you please share your thoughts about creating a circular and sustainable packaging value chain without compromising food safety?
Janne: There is undoubtedly tension between food safety requirements and use of recycled materials in primary packaging. It’s difficult to guarantee that there are no harmful substances in recycled material collection, and complete elimination of these in sorting and recycling processes is not realistic and economically viable with current technologies.
Also, there is already a huge volume of paper/board products made solely or primarily from recycled fibres, so regulatory actions to create demand for recycled fibre through closed loop recycling for food contact sensitive, high-quality products are not needed. Virgin fibres are also always needed in paper/board recycling to maintain the quality of recycled fibres and products made from these. Compared to e.g. plastics, paper and board recycling is already well-established with the cascaded recycling as the primary means to reduce the use of virgin raw materials.
Related articles
[Story | 9 October 2026 | 6 min
The future of chemicals starts with a new source of carbon
Modern life runs on chemicals. They are in packaging, textiles, tires, cosmetics, electronics, construction materials, and thousands of other...](https://www.upm.com/articles/biochemicals/26/the-future-of-chemicals-starts-with-a-new-source-of-carbon/)
[Story | 7 July 2026 | 6 min
PPWR checklist for manufacturers
Application of the EU Packaging and Packaging Waste Regulation begins in August 2026. Companies will now face distinct, time-sensitive obligations. Meeting those obligations can seem daunting, which is...](https://www.upm.com/articles/circular-economy/26/ppwr-checklist-for-manufacturers/)
[Story | 2 July 2026 | 8 min
DIVERSA: Designing a Premium Performance tequila label through collective creativity
This series explores how leading designers bring their creative vision to life using UPM Raflatac™ Premium...](https://www.upm.com/articles/adhesive-materials/26/diversa-designing-a-premium-performance-tequila-label-through-collective-creativity/)

